Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XVII Rule 3 C.P.C The provisions of Rules 2 and 3 of Order XVII C.P.C
  • 17 Rule 2 and Order 17 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE AMENDMENT ACT
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Order 17 Rule 3 and Order 17 Rule 2
  • provisions of Order 9, viz., rules 9
  • provisions of Order 9 C.P.C
  • rule 6 or rule 8 of Order
  • Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Order IX Rule 9 C.P.C
  • Order IX Rule 8 C.P.C
  • Rule 2 of Order 17
  • Rule 1 of Order 17
  • Order 17 Rule 3(b)
  • present.11. Rule 3
  • Order XVII Rule 2
  • Order 17 Rule 3
  • Order 17 Rule 2
  • Order 9 Rule 13
  • Order 17 Rule
  • rule 8, rule 9
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XVII Rule 3 C.P.C The provisions of Rules 2 and 3 of Order XVII C.P.C
  • 17 Rule 2 and Order 17 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE AMENDMENT ACT
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Order 17 Rule 3 and Order 17 Rule 2
  • provisions of Order 9, viz., rules 9
  • provisions of Order 9 C.P.C
  • rule 6 or rule 8 of Order
  • Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Order IX Rule 9 C.P.C
  • Order IX Rule 8 C.P.C
  • Rule 2 of Order 17
  • Rule 1 of Order 17
  • Order 17 Rule 3(b)
  • present.11. Rule 3
  • Order XVII Rule 2
  • Order 17 Rule 3
  • Order 17 Rule 2
  • Order 9 Rule 13
  • Order 17 Rule
  • rule 8, rule 9
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment delivered by Bhat, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed a civil suit (O.S. 77/80) against the respondents. The suit was dismissed by the trial court on 7-4-1982. The appellant then filed I.A. 465 of 1982 seeking restoration of the suit under Order IX Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C.). The court below dismissed that application on the ground that the dismissal was not under Order IX Rule 8 and therefore could not be restored under Order IX Rule 9. The present judgment is an appeal against that order.

O.S. 77/80 had been tried jointly with another suit, O.S. 17/82; the latter suit's decree and judgment were confirmed on appeal (A.S. No. 65/82, District Court, Thodupuzha). In O.S. 77/80 evidence was being recorded and the case was posted for trial to 1-4-1982. On that date the plaintiff (appellant) did not appear ready; his adjournment application was dismissed. The plaintiff did not give evidence on that day; defendants gave evidence on that day and on succeeding days. Arguments were heard on 5-4-1982 and the suit was dismissed on 7-4-1982. The dismissal purported to be on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dismissal of O.S. 77/80 must be treated as a disposal under Order XVII Rule 2 (and consequently under Order IX modes) or under Order XVII Rule 3.
  2. If the dismissal is a disposal under Order IX, whether restoration of the suit could be sought under Order IX Rule 9.
  3. Whether the "explanation" to Order XVII Rule 2 (i.e., that a court may proceed as if the party were present where a substantial portion of that party's evidence has already been recorded) was attracted in this case.
  4. Whether the appellant established "sufficient cause" for non-appearance (specifically illness) so as to justify restoration of the suit under Order IX Rule 9.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Counsel for the appellant contended that, although the dismissal purported to be on merits, in law it had to be treated as a dismissal under Order XVII Rule 2 and thus could be set aside under Order IX Rule 9 C.P.C.
  • It was further contended that the dismissal was not under Order XVII Rule 3, and that the changes made by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976 affect the operation of Rules 2 and 3 of Order XVII.

Court Below's Position (as recorded in the opinion)

  • The court below dismissed the appellant's restoration application holding that the dismissal of the suit was not under Order IX Rule 8 and hence could not be restored under Order IX Rule 9.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M.V. George v. S.M.S. Traders (1980 K.L.T. 307) Interpreting the post‑1976 amendment distinction between Order XVII Rule 2 and Rule 3; held that a judgment purporting to be on merits will not be treated as a disposal under Rule 3 unless the pre‑requisite (that time had been granted to a party who remained in default) is satisfied; where prerequisites are absent a disposal will be under Rule 2 and Order IX remedies (e.g., Rule 13) remain available. The court relied on this authority to explain that a purported merits disposal may nonetheless amount to a disposal under Order XVII Rule 2 when the conditions for Rule 3 are not satisfied; this supports treating the present dismissal as under Rule 2 rather than Rule 3.
Prakash Chander Manchanda v. Janki Manchanda ((1986) 4 SCC 699) Explained that where a party is absent and no evidence of that party has been recorded, the court must proceed under Order XVII Rule 2 and dispose in a mode prescribed by Order IX; the explanation to Rule 2 (permitting merits disposal despite absence where substantial evidence has been recorded) is limited. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority to support the interpretation that, absent recorded evidence of the plaintiff prior to the adjourned date, the trial court had no option but to treat the disposal as under Rule 2 and dispose in accordance with Order IX.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise manner, applying the amended provisions of Order XVII and the principles from cited authorities:

  1. The court examined whether Order XVII Rule 3 applied. Rule 3 is triggered where a party "to whom time has been granted" fails to produce evidence or perform acts for which time was allowed. The court found Rule 3 inapplicable because the posting of the suit for trial on 1-4-1982 was not at the plaintiff's request or in response to any application for time; it was a posting made by the court of its own accord. Therefore, the pre‑requisite of Rule 3 (that time had been granted and the party was in default) was absent.
  2. Having found Rule 3 inapplicable, the court turned to Order XVII Rule 2. Rule 2 applies when the hearing of the suit has been adjourned and a party fails to appear on the adjourned date; the court may proceed to dispose of the suit in one of the modes directed by Order IX or make such other order as it thinks fit. The court concluded that Rule 2 therefore governed the situation.
  3. The court considered the "explanation" added to Rule 2 by the 1976 amendment, which allows the court, in its discretion, to proceed as if an absent party were present where "the evidence or a substantial portion of the evidence" of that party has already been recorded. The court found the explanation was not attracted here because the plaintiff's evidence or a substantial portion thereof had not been recorded before the plaintiff's failure to appear on 1-4-1982.
  4. Based on the above, the court concluded that the dismissal of the suit was a disposal under Order IX (i.e., in the modes provided by Order IX) rather than an unassailable merits disposal under Rule 3. Consequently, remedies available under Order IX (including restoration under Rule 9, subject to limitation and sufficient cause) were available to the plaintiff.
  5. The court then examined the factual basis for "sufficient cause" for non‑appearance. The plaintiff testified as P.W.1 and relied on Ext. A1, a medical certificate, which was proved by P.W.2. The court found that the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2, together with Ext. A1, clearly established the appellant's inability to attend court on account of illness and thus constituted sufficient cause for non‑appearance.
  6. Because the appellant had established sufficient cause and because the dismissal was properly characterized as a disposal under Order IX (Rule 2 scenario without the explanation), the court concluded that the lower court erred in rejecting I.A. 465 of 1982 and that the application ought to have been allowed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The order of the court below is set aside and I.A. 465 of 1982 is allowed. The trial court is directed to restore O.S. 77/80 to the file and proceed to dispose of the suit in accordance with law. The appeal is allowed without costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The appellant's restoration application succeeds; O.S. 77/80 is to be restored and re‑listed for disposal according to law.
  • Legal consequence emphasized by the court: Where the pre‑requisites of Order XVII Rule 3 are not satisfied (i.e., time was not granted and the party was not in default in the sense contemplated by Rule 3), a purported merits dismissal may nevertheless be a disposal under Order XVII Rule 2 and thus fall within the remedial scope of Order IX (including Rule 9 restoration, subject to sufficient cause and limitation). The explanation to Rule 2 operates only when substantial evidence of the absent party has already been recorded.
  • Broader precedent: The court applied existing authorities (including M.V. George v. S.M.S. Traders and Prakash Chander Manchanda v. Janki Manchanda) to interpret the amended Rules; the judgment resolves the application of those rules to the facts of this case but does not state that it creates any new legal principle beyond applying established interpretations to the facts before it.

    Sankara Pillai v. Balakrishnan Nair

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Bhat, J.:— Appellant herein filed the suit against the respondents. The suit was dismissed on 7-4-1982. Appellant filed I.A 465 of 1982 to restore the suit under Order IX Rule 9 C.P.C The court; below dismissed the application holding that the dismissal of the suit was not under Order IX Rule 8 C.P.C and hence it could not be restored under Order IX Role 9 C.P.C This judgment is now challenged.

    2. It appears the suit OS. 77/80 concerned in this case and soother suit, O.S 17/82, were tried jontly and purportedly disposed of on merits. The decree and judgment in O.S 17/82 have been confirmed in A.S No 65/82 of the District Court, Thodupuzha.

    3. Evidence was being recorded in O.S 77/80. The case was posted for trial to 1-4-1982 On that day plaintiff was not ready. Adjournment application filed on behalf of (he plaintiff was dismissed. Plaintiff did not adduce evidence on that day. Evidence on behalf of the defendants was adduced on that day and succeeding days. Arguments were heard on 5-4-1982 and suit dismissed on 7-4-1982 There is no doubt that the dismissal purports to be on merits. Learned counsel for the appellant would contend that even though the dismissal purported to be on merits, in law it has to be treated as dismissal under Order XVII Rule 2 andean be set aside under Order IX Rule 9 C.P.C Learned counsel would further contend that the dismissal was not under Order XVII Rule 3 C.P.C The provisions of Rules 2 and 3 of Order XVII C.P.C have undergone change by virtue of the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976. The rules in the present from read as follows:

    “2. Procedure if parties fail to appear on day fixed—

    Where, on any day to which the hearing of the suit is adjourned, the parties or any of them fail to appear, the court may proceed to dispose of the suit in one of the modes directed in that behalf by Order IX to make such other order as it thinks fit,

    Explanation—Where the evidence or a substantial portion of the evidence of any party has already been recorded and such party fails to appear on any day to which the bearing of the suit is adjourned, the court may, in its discretion, proceed with the case as if such party were present.

    4. Court may proceed notwithstanding either party fails to produce evidence, etc.

    5. Where any party to a suit to shorn time has been granted fails to produce his evidence-or to cause the attendance of his witnesses, or to perform any other act necessary to the further progress of the suit, for which time has been allowed, the court may, notwithstanding such default,—

    (a) if the parties are present, proceed to decide the suit forthwith; or

    (b) if the parlies are, or any of them is, absent, proceed under rule 2”.

    6. A division bench of this court bed occasion to interpret this rule in M.V George v. S.M.S Traders (1980 K.L.T 307), The court observed:

    “Order 17 Rule 2 and Order 17 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure as they stand after the Civil Procedure Code Amendment Act, 104 of 1976 are materially different from the corresponding provisions as they stood prior to the amendment. Order 17 Rule 3 contemplated a judgment on the merits. But a judgment does not become a judgment on the merits falling under Order 17 Rule 3 merely because’ the judgment purports to be on the merits. The court may have, in the judgment discussed the issues in the case, considered the evidence and decided the case on the merits. But neverthless it will not be a disposal under Order 17 Rule 3 if the pre-requisite for application of therule is not satisfied. The party towhom time has been granted must be in default. If the case comes up not after grant of such time to the party. Order 17 Rule 3 will have no application. The disposal will then be under Order 17 Rule 2 though it purports to be one on the merits. In such a case a defendant notwithstanding the purported disposal on the merits could seek to reopen the decree by an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the C.P.C”.

    7. The court noticed the explanation added to Order 17 Rule 2 as well as the changes in rule 3 and observed:

    “Prior to the amendment the court, notwithstanding the default of party, was entitled to proceed with the suit. But after the amendment it could decide to proceed with the suit under the rule only if the parties are present. If the parties are or any of them is absent the court would proceed only under rule 2.

    The above said amendment makes the earlier decisions on the distinction between Order 17 Rule 3 and Order 17 Rule 2 inapplicable after the amendment. The power of the court to proceed to decide the suit under Order 17 Role 3 is restricted now to cases where the parties are present. If the parties are or any of them is absent the court would proceed only under rule 2.

    There is another important change in the provisions which have been noticed. It is not in all cases coming under Rule 2 of Order 17 that the court could proceed to dispose of the suit in the mode prescribed under 0.9 of the C.P.C If the explanation is attracted the court would proceed to dispose of the suit as if the parties were present. The explanation would be attracted to a case where the evidence or substantial portion of the evidence of any party has already been recorded and such party fails to appear on any day to which hearing of the suit is adjourned. the court has then a discretion to proceed with the case as if the party was present. It may in its discretion decide to proceed ex parte. In a case where invoking the explanation, the court proceeds to deal with the case on the merits on finding that the conditions to attract the explanation are present, the disposal is not under Order 9. In such a case there is no question of reopening the decree by resort to Order 9 of C.P.C In other words though the right to proceed to decide on the merits in case of default of appearance of party has been taken out of Order 17 Rule 3 it has been conferred in restricted cases by the explanation to Order 17 Rule 2. Where the court has chosen to proceed to decide on the merits under the explanation Older 9 cannot be invoked.”

    8. The Supreme Court had occasion to consider the above provisions in Prakash Chander Manchanda v. Janki Manchanda ((1986) 4 SCC 699). The court observed:

    “It is clear that in cases where a party is absent the only course as mentioned in Order 17 Rule 3(b) is to proceed under Rule 2. It is therefore clear that in absence of the defendant, the court had no option but to proceed under Rule 2. Similarly the language of rule 2 as it now stands also clearly lays down that if any one of the parties fails to appear, the court has to proceed to dispose of the suit in one of the modes directed under Order 9. The explanation to Rule 2 gives a discretion to the court to proceed under Rule 3 even if a party is absent but that discretion is limited only in cases where a party which is absent has led some evidence or has examined substantial part of their evidence. It is therefore clear that if on a date fixed, one of the parties remain absent, and for that party no evidence has been examined up to that date the court has no option but to proceed to dispose of the matter in accordance with Order 17 Rule 2 in any one of the modes prescribed under Order 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.”

    9. Order 9 C.P.C deals with appearance of parties and consequence of non-appearance. Rule 1 requires the parties to appear on the day fixed in summons for defendant to appear and answer. The suit shall then be heard unless the hearing is adjourned to a future day fixed by the court. According to Rule 3, where neither party appears when the suit is called on for hearing, the court may make an order that the suit be dismissed. Where the suit is so dismissed, Rule 4 provides that the plaintiff may, subject to the law of limitation, bring a fresh suit, or he may apply for an order to set the dismissal aside and in appropriate cases, the court shall make an order setting aside the dismissal. Rule 8 deals with procedure where defendant only appears. When the plaintiff dees not appear when the suit is called on for hearing the court shell make an order that the suit be dismissed, unless the defendant admits the claim, or part thereof, in which case the court shall pass a decree against the defendant upon such admission and dismiss the suit so far as it relates to the remainder. Where a suit is wholly or partly dismissed under rule 8, rule 9 precludes the plaintiff from bringing a fresh suit in respect of the same cause of action. But he may apply for an order to set the dismissal aside and in appropriate cases the court is empowered to set aside the dismissal. These are the provisions relating to appearance and non appearance of parties of first hearing.

    10. The provisions of Order 17 deal with subsequent stages of the litigation. Rule 1 of Order 17 enables she court for sufficient cause at any stage of the suit to adjourn the hearing of the suit. Where the court declines to great adjournment of hearing of the suit the court has to proceed under rule 2 or rule 3. These two rules deal with different situations. Rule 2 deals with case of failure of parties to appear on any day for which hearing of the suit is adjourned, i.e, evidently adjourned under rule 1. The court may proceed to dispose of the suit in any one of the modes prescribed in that behalf or make such other order as it thinks fit. In other words where rule 2 applies the court is enabled to dispose of the suit either under rule 6 or rule 8 of Order 9. Where the suit is so disposed of the party whose failure to appear led to the disposal has remedies in accordance with the corresponding provisions of Order 9, viz., rules 9 or 13. As indicated above where rule 2 applies ordinarily dismissal must be under Order 9. The explanation inserted by the amending Act of 1976 vests a discretion in the court to dispose of the suit on merits only in one contingency, viz., that the evidence or substantial portion of the evidence has already been recorded and such party fails, to appear on any day to which the hearing of the suit is adjourned. In such a case the court in its discretion may proceed with the case as if such parties are present.

    11. Rule 3 applies to a case where any party to a suit to whom time has been granted fails (a) to produce his evidence, or (b) to cause the attendance of the witnesses or (c) to perform any other act necessary to the further progress of the suit, for which time has been allowed. In such contingencies, the court may notwithstanding the default proceed in one of the two ways, that is, (a) if the parties are present, proceed to decide the suit forthwith or (b) if the parties are, or any of them is, absent, proceed under Rule 2. Even where conditions requisite under Rule 3 are satisfied the court can proceed to decide the suit only when the parties are present. If the parties are or any one of them is absent the court cannot dispose of the suit on merits. It can proceed only under Rule 2. Under the main part of Rule 2, disposal is to be under Order 9. Where the conditions contemplated in the explanation under Rule 2 exist the court has discretion to decide the suit on merits. Where the disposal purports to be on merits, if the conditions requisite for disposal on merits are absent, disposal in the eyes of law is only under Order 9 C.P.C In such a case, remedies under Order 9, C.P.C would be available to parties.

    12. In the present case Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C is not attracted. This is not a case where the plaintiff failed to produce his evidence though time was granted to him or failed to cause attendance of witnesses though time was granted to him or failed to perform any other act necessary to the further progress of the suit for which time was granted. Posting of the suit for trial on 1-4-1982 was not in response to & request or application made by the plaintiff. It was a posting given by the court of its own accord. Therefore Rule 3 cannot apply. Rule 2 will apply because the suit came up for trial on 1-4-1982 on adjournment of the hearing as contemplated under Rule 2. If that be so disposal can only be under Order 9, subject of course to the operation of explanation. The explanation is not attracted in the instant case because evidence or substantial portion of the evidence of the plaintiff had not been recorded and the failure of the plaintiff to appear was not preceded by recording of such evidence. We are therefore of the opinion that disposal in the instant case was a disposal under Order 9 C.P.C Plaintiff is therefore entitled, to seek restoration of tag suit, subject to tile existence of good ground, under the provisions of Order 9 C.P.C According to the plaintiff he could not be present in court for the trial of the suit because he was ill and laid up in Mount Sinai Hospital for treatment. Plaintiff examined as P.W 1 spoke to his case. He relied on Ext. A 1 medical certificate issued and proved by P.W 2. The evidence of P.Ws 1 and 2 in the light of Ext. A 1 clearly establishes his case of inability to attend court for trial on account of illness. We are therefore satisfied that plaintiff has established sufficient cause for his non appearance at the time of trial. The court below erred in rejecting the petition. The petition ought to have been allowed.

    13. In the result, we set aside the order of the court below and allow I.A 465 of 1982. The court below will restore O.S 77/82 to the file and proceed to dispose of the same in accordance with law.

    14. Appeal is thus allowed, but without costs.

    15. Allowed.

    Order 17 Rule 2

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sankara Pillai v. Balakrishnan Nair
    (Feb 4, 1988)