Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners obtained the privilege to sell arrack in five shops of the Poocjar range for the year 1984–85 by being the highest bidders at a public auction. They were joint bidders and agreed to pay Rs. 7,00,000/- in ten equal monthly instalments. Licences were issued accordingly, and the petitioners conducted the trade throughout the contract period. The auction terms specified the quantity of arrack to be supplied to each shop, with a clause allowing the Assistant Excise Commissioner to allot additional quantities if available. The petitioners claimed, for the first time in this writ petition after the contract period ended, that the Department failed to supply the requisite quantity of arrack, causing them losses and rendering them not liable to pay the balance amount due under the contract.

The petitioners admitted paying Rs. 5,60,000/- of the Rs. 7,00,000/- liability but contended the remaining balance was not payable due to the Department’s failure to supply extra quantities beyond the stipulated amount.

The Government, through the learned Government Pleader, expressed willingness to accept the balance amount in ten monthly instalments, provided the petitioners pay Rs. 50,000/- in a lump sum within a reasonable time.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners are liable to pay the balance amount under the contract despite the Department’s alleged failure to supply extra quantities of arrack beyond the stipulated amount.
  2. Whether the contract terms are unconscionable or unenforceable due to unequal bargaining power between the State and the petitioners.
  3. Whether the petitioners can resist enforcement of the contract liability on grounds of failure to supply quantities beyond those stipulated in the agreement.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • They were unable to trade profitably due to the Department's failure to supply the requisite quantity of arrack.
  • This failure caused them losses, thus they are not liable to pay the balance amount due under the contracts.
  • The State had a monopoly and was in a domineering position, so the parties did not have equal bargaining power, rendering the contract terms unfair and unconscionable.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The terms and conditions of the auction and contract were published in advance and known to all bidders.
  • The contract stipulated supply of a specified quantity of arrack, with only a discretionary clause allowing the Assistant Excise Commissioner to allot extra quantities if available.
  • The petitioners have no case that the stipulated quantity was not supplied.
  • The petitioners participated in a public auction with knowledge of the terms and conditions and cannot now resist enforcement of liabilities on grounds of unconscionability or failure to supply extra quantities.
  • The Department is willing to accept the balance amount in instalments subject to an initial lump sum payment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Central Inland Water Transport Corporation v. Brojo Nath Ganguly, (1986) 3 SCC 156 Test of reasonableness or fairness of a contract clause depends on whether parties had equal bargaining power; unconscionable contract terms in employment context violate Article 14. The court distinguished the present case from this precedent, noting that unlike employment contracts, the auction terms were published in advance and known to petitioners, who had equal opportunity to bid; thus, the contract was not unconscionable.
Issac v. Asst Excise Commissioner, 1984 KLT 88 Failure of Department to supply extra quantity of arrack may affect recoverability of balance amount. The court found the terms and conditions in that case different from the present case and held that no obligation existed here to supply arrack beyond stipulated quantity; hence, this precedent did not support petitioners' claim.
Krishnan v. State Of Kerala & Others, 1985 KLT 1159 Alteration of terms and conditions of contract as per Government Order (G.O (MS) 31084.TD dated 22nd February 1984). The court noted that the agreements in the present case were in the altered form as per this G.O., which did not obligate the State to supply arrack beyond stipulated quantities, undermining petitioners' argument.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the petitioners' claim that failure to supply extra quantities of arrack excused them from paying the balance amount under the contract. It noted that the auction terms, published in advance, clearly stipulated the quantity of arrack to be supplied, with only a discretionary clause allowing additional allotment if stock was available. The petitioners did not allege that the stipulated quantity was not supplied.

The Court rejected the argument that the State’s monopoly created unequal bargaining power rendering the contract unconscionable, distinguishing the cited Supreme Court precedent relating to employment contracts where an employee had no choice but to accept unfair terms. Here, the petitioners voluntarily participated in a public auction with known terms.

The Court also distinguished the petitioners' reliance on a prior Division Bench decision, holding that the altered terms of the present contracts did not impose an obligation on the State to supply arrack beyond the stipulated quantity. Consequently, failure to supply extra quantities did not excuse payment of the balance amount.

In light of the Government Pleader's submission, the Court directed that no coercive steps be taken for recovery if the petitioners paid Rs. 50,000/- by a specified date and the balance in monthly instalments, providing a reasonable arrangement for payment.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the writ petition, holding that the petitioners are liable to pay the balance amount due under the contract as the Department fulfilled its obligation to supply the stipulated quantity of arrack. The petitioners’ contention that failure to supply extra quantities excused payment was rejected.

The Court ordered that no coercive recovery action shall be taken provided the petitioners pay Rs. 50,000/- in lump sum by 30th November 1986 and the balance in ten equal monthly instalments thereafter. On default, the respondents may recover the entire amount in one lump sum.

No broader legal precedent was established; the decision directly affects the parties by enforcing contractual liabilities as per the agreed terms.

    Devassya v. Asst. Excise Commr.

    1. The petitioners had obtained the privilege for sale of arrack in five arrack shops of the Poocjar range for the year 1934–85 being the highest bidders at a public auction held in that behalf. The petitioners were joint bidders and the price at which the privilege was conferred on them was for Rs. 7,00,000/- payable in ten equal monthly instalments. The requisite licences were issued to the petitioners and they carried on the trade in arrack for the entire period. The conditions of the auction clearly specified the quantity of arrack to be supplied for each of the shops. There was also a clause empowering the Assistant Excise Commissioner to allot larger quantity of arrack over and above the stipulated quantity. It is the petitioners’ case that for failure of the Department to supply the requisite quantity of arrack, they had not been able to carry on the irade profitably, they hod, in fact, sustained loss, and for that reason they are not liable to pay the balance amount due as per the terms of the agreements entered into on their bids having been accepted by the department. This contention is raised for the first time in this writ petition after the contracts had been performed and the period of the contract is over.

    2. According to the petitioners they have paid a sum of Rs. 5,60,000/- towards their liability for Rs. 7,00,000/- and the balance, even though due, is net payable for the failure of the department to supply the extra quantity of arrack, over and above the stipulated quantity.

    3. Counsel for the petitioners relies on the decision of the Supreme Court in Central Inland Water Transport Corpon. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly, (1986) 3 SCC 156 in support of the proposition that the test of reasonableness or fairness of a clause in a contract would depend on the question whether the parties to the contract had equal bargaining power. According to the learned counsel, the State having a monopoly in regard to the manufacture and sale of liquor was in a domineering position and it cannot be said that the State and the petitioners had equal bargaining power. I do not see any force in this contention.

    4. The decision of the Supreme Court referred to above related to the case of a contract of labour where the employee had no choice except to accept the employment on the terms offered by the employer. One of the terms of the employment for termination of the services of the employee was found to be unconscionable and not enforceable against him. It was also held that under the circumstances such a term of the contract of employ men tissued in the form of a rule was also opposed to Article 14 of the Constitution. In the present case the terms and conditions of the auction were published in advance and every bidder participating at the auction knows the terms and conditions upon which the auction is held. He should, at any rate, be presu med to know such terms and conditions under which the auction is held. One of the terms which is also incorporated in the agreement between the parties is for supply of arrack to each of the shops at the stipulated quantity. It is open to the Assistant Excise Commissioner to allot a larger quantity over and above the stipulated quantity if sufficient stock of arrack is available at the depots of the Government. As per these terms and conditions the petitioners are not entitled to get any extra quantity. They have no case that the stipulated quantity had not been supplied. Counsel relies on the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Issac v. Asst Excise Commissioner (1984 KLT 88) and contends thai for the failure of the Department to supply extra quantity of arrack, the balance amount due as per the con tracts between the petitioners and the Government is not recoverable. The terms and con ditions of the agreement dealt with in that case are different from the terms and conditions of the agreements between the parties in the present case. As was noticed in Krishnan v. State Of Kerala & Others (1985 KLT. 1159), the terms and conditions had been altered as per G.O (MS) 31084.TD dated 22nd February 1984 and the agreemants between the parties in the present case are in the altered form. There is no term of the contract that obligates the State to supply arrack in excess of the stipulated quantity. The mere fact that a clause in the contract authorises the Assistant Excise Commissioner to allot a larger quantity than the quantity stipulated for supply to each of these arrack shops does not entitle the petitioners to demand for more and for failure of supply of the extra quantity to desist payment of the instalments due under the respective agreements. I do not also see any force in the submission that the State was in a domineering position and the petitioners did not have an equal bargaining power. They had participated along with others in the public auctions held for sale of the privilege of vending arrack in the shops concerned as licensees of the Government. The terms and conditions of the auction were published well in advance and the agreements entered into between the parties are in conformity with those published terms. Having participated at such a public auction on such terms and conditions, it is not open to the petitioners now to contend after the period of the contract and after the contract itself had been performed that it was an unconscionable contract to resist enforcement of the liability arising therefrom. I see no merit in this writ petition.

    5. When the writ petition came up for admission yesterday, the learned Government Pleader taking notice on behalf of the respondents took time till today for instructions. The learned Government Pleader submits that the Department is willing to accept the balance amount due as per the notices of demand Exts. P 1 and P 2 in ten monthly instalments provided the petitioners are willing to pay atleast a sum of Rs. 50,000/- in one lump within a reasonable time. In view of this submission made by the learned Government Pleader on behalf of the respondents, there will be a direction that no coercive steps will be taken against the petitioners for recovery of the balance amount due as specified in Exts. P 1 and P 2 on condition that the petitioners pay to the 1st respondent a sum of Rs. 50,000.on or before the 30th of November, 1986 and the balance amount in ten equal monthly instalments payable on the 30th of every English Calendar month thereafter. On default of payment as aforesaid, it is open to the respondents to recover the entire amount in one lump.

    6. The O.P is disposed of as above. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Devassya v. Asst. Excise Commr.
    (Aug 25, 1986)