Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Food Inspector of Tellicherry Municipality (complainant in S.T.C. No. 297 of 1978 before the Additional Judicial First Class Magistrate, Tellicherry) purchased a 675 ml sample of toned milk from the Jubilee Dairy (licence No. 9.G 10) on 16-12-1976. The second accused was the licence-holder and the first accused was a salesman at the dairy. The Food Inspector split the purchased sample into three portions, added formalin, sealed them in the presence of witnesses, prepared a mahazar (Ext. P3), sent one portion to the Public Analyst with Form No. VII and specimen seal, and retained or forwarded the remaining portions to the Local (Health) Authority as per procedure.

The Public Analyst issued a certificate in Form No. III (Ext. P6) reporting the result of analysis. Based on that report, a complaint was filed against both accused. At trial both accused were convicted under provisions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act (specifically S. 2(i-a)(m), 7(i) and (v) read with S. 16(1)(a)(i)) and each was sentenced to six months' simple imprisonment and fined Rs. 1,000 (with one month simple imprisonment in default). The two accused appealed (Criminal Appeal No. 90 of 1979); the Sessions Judge upheld the conviction and sentence against the first accused but set aside the conviction and sentence as against the second accused.

The first accused filed Criminal Revision Petition No. 429 of 1979 challenging his conviction; the Food Inspector, as complainant, is the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 444 of 1979. The matter before the Court included a challenge to the regularity of sample-handling formalities and the contents of the Public Analyst's certificate (Ext. P6).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Food Inspector failed to follow the formalities prescribed under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act and its rules (specifically rules 7 and 17) in the taking, sealing and dispatch of the sample, and whether any such failure vitiated the prosecution.
  2. Whether the omission in the Public Analyst's certificate (Ext. P6) of an explicit statement that the seal fixed on the outer cover was compared with the specimen impression (as later required by Form No. III) amounted to a material irregularity that invalidated the certificate and thereby the conviction.
  3. Whether any alleged non-compliance with Section 13(2) of the Act affected the validity of the prosecution (raised but ultimately not determinative given the finding on the Form No. III omission).

Arguments of the Parties

First Accused / Petitioner (Revision Petitioner)

  • Contended that the Food Inspector did not follow the formalities prescribed under the Act and the relevant rules (notably rules 7 and 17), and that omissions in procedure prejudiced the accused.
  • Specifically relied on the omission in Ext. P6 (Public Analyst's certificate) which did not state that the seal fixed on the outer cover had been compared with the specimen impression sent by the Food Inspector; argued this omission was an irregularity vitiating the proceedings and conviction.

Second Accused (at trial)

  • Raised a factual contention that the second accused was not running the business (the implication being that he should not have been held responsible), a contention which the trial Court did not accept — the trial Court found him guilty though the Sessions Judge later set aside his conviction on appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Subbayyan v. State, A.I.R. 1968 Kerala 330 Form No. III as then constituted did not require the Public Analyst to specifically state that he compared the specimen impression with the seal; non-mention of that fact was not necessarily an irregularity. The Court noted that this view had been taken by this Court when Form No. III originally lacked the explicit clause about comparison of seals.
K.K. Pookunju v. K.K. Ramakrishna Pillai, 1969 K.L.T. 50 (Supreme Court consideration noted) Affirmed the presumption that official acts (such as the Public Analyst comparing seals) are regularly performed; the High Court's reliance on that presumption was held to be without error. The opinion records the Supreme Court's observation approving the presumption of regularity when Form No. III did not explicitly mention comparison of seals.
Jose v. Food Inspector, 1981 K.L.T. 859 (Khalid, J.) Held that non-compliance with the provision requiring mention of comparison of seals in Form No. III taints the prosecution with illegality. The Court expressly agreed with the reasoning in Jose, holding that after the amendments the clause became mandatory and non-compliance vitiated the conviction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded step-by-step from the facts and the statutory / regulatory framework:

  1. Evidence of purchase and the making of the sample (mahazar, sealing, sending one portion to the Public Analyst and forwarding other portions appropriately) was accepted by both the trial and appellate courts: the purchase and initial procedures were amply proved by Pw-1 (the Food Inspector) and Pw-2 (an attestor).
  2. The petitioner challenged the conviction on the ground of procedural irregularities under the Act and its rules, specifically non-compliance with rules 7 and 17. Rule 17 prescribes the manner and timing for despatching sample containers and the memorandum; Rule 7 prescribes duties of the Public Analyst, including comparing seals on the container and outer cover with the specimen impression and reporting within 45 days in Form No. III.
  3. The Public Analyst's certificate in this case (Ext. P6) contained a certification that the container seal was intact and that the seal on the container tallied with the specimen impression; however Ext. P6 omitted an explicit statement that the seal fixed on the outer cover tallied with the specimen impression. The petitioner relied on this omission as a material irregularity.
  4. The Court reviewed the legislative and rule history: originally Form No. III did not explicitly require mention of comparison with the specimen impression; there was divergence among High Courts on the effect of non-mention. This Court had earlier in Subbayyan held non-mention was not necessarily irregular; the Supreme Court in K.K. Pookunju had endorsed a presumption that official acts were regularly performed in that context.
  5. Subsequent amendments to Form No. III (8-7-1968 and further on 2-10-1976) added explicit language that the seal fixed on the container and the outer cover must tally with the specimen impression. The Court placed these changes against important procedural modifications effected by Act 34 of 1976 (notably the discontinuance of returning one portion of the sample to the person from whom it was taken and a shift to the Local (Health) Authority retaining two specimens).
  6. Given the procedural changes and the fact that the Public Analyst's certificate may be the sole evidence (in the absence of direct evidence from the Public Analyst himself), the Court concluded the certificate must conform strictly to statutory requirements. The addition in Form No. III of the clause concerning comparison of the seals (including the outer cover) was intended to be mandatory; therefore strict compliance should be insisted upon.
  7. The Court agreed with the view expressed by Khalid J. in Jose v. Food Inspector (1981 K.L.T. 859) that non-compliance with the provision relating to comparison of seals taints the prosecution with illegality. Applying that principle, the Court held that Ext. P6's omission regarding the outer cover seal rendered the certificate non-conforming to the requirements of law and that no conviction could be founded on such a certificate.
  8. Because of this conclusion on Ext. P6, the Court did not find it necessary to fully adjudicate the separate contention regarding non-compliance of Section 13(2); however, the Court observed that Ext. P7 (notices) and Ext. P8 (acknowledgements) indicated compliance with Section 13(2) in any event.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The conviction and sentence of the first accused (petitioner in Crl. R.P. No. 429 of 1979) are set aside and he is acquitted.

Direct consequences and immediate effects:

  • The Court allowed Criminal Revision Petition No. 429 of 1979 and acquitted the first accused because Ext. P6 (the Public Analyst's certificate) did not conform to the statutory requirement to state that the seal on the outer cover was compared with the specimen impression.
  • Because the first accused's conviction was set aside, the Court found no sufficient reason to interfere with the Sessions Judge's order acquitting the second accused; accordingly Criminal Appeal No. 444 of 1979 was dismissed and the appellate court's order acquitting the second accused was left intact.

Broader legal implication stated by the Court (as reflected in the opinion): after the amendments to Form No. III and the procedural changes in the Act, courts should insist on strict compliance with the requirement that the Public Analyst's certificate expressly state that the seals (including the outer cover) were compared with the specimen impression — non-compliance with that mandatory requirement taints the prosecution.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond its application of the amended Form No. III and its agreement with prior authority (including Jose v. Food Inspector); its decision rests on statutory interpretation of the amended certificate requirement and the resulting procedural necessity for strict compliance.

    Azeez v. Food Inspector

    1. The Food Inspector, Tellicherry Municipality, who was the complainant in S.T.C No. 297 of 1978 on the file of the Additional Judicial First Class Magistrate. Tellicherry, is the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 444 of 1979. The first accused in that case is the petitioner in Crl. R.P No. 429 of 1979. The facts of the case are as follows: The second accused is the licensee in respect of the Jubilee Dairy in Jubilee Market, Tellicherry, having licence No. 9.G 10. The first accused was the salesman in that concern during the relevant period. On 16-12-1976 Pw-1 Food Inspector visited the above shop and purchased 675 ml. of toned milk exhibited for sale, after following the formalities prescribed under the Act and on payment of the price thereof. He divided the sample purchased into three equal parts, poured them into three bottles, added formaline and sealed the sample bottles in the presence of witnesses. A mahazar Ext. P3 was prepared. After due packing and sealing one of the sample bottles was sent to the public analyst along with a copy of Form No. VII memorandum and a specimen seal. The remaining two portions of the sample were sent to the Local (Health) Authority. The public analyst issued Ext. P6 certificate in Form No. III. Copies of the certificate were sent to the two accused as prescribed under the rules. Based on the report of the public analyst, a complaint was filed against the two accused.

    2. The complainant examined himself as Pw-1 and also Pw-2 an attestor to the mahazar. Though a case was put forward that the second accused was not running the business the trial Court did not accept the contention. The Court found both the accused guilty, convicted them for offences punishable under S. 2 (i-a)(m) and 7(i) and (v) read with S. 16(1)(a)(i) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act (for short the Act). Both the accused were sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for six months and to pay a fine of R. 1000/-. In default of payment of fine they are to undergo simple imprisonment for one month. The two accused preferred Criminal Appeal No. 90 of 1979 against the conviction and sentence. The Sessions Judge, Tellicherry, upheld the conviction and sentence in respect of the first accused, but set aside the conviction and sentence in respect of the second accused. It is against the order of the appellate judge that the appeal and the revision petition have been filed.

    3. The conviction of the first accused is being challenged in the revision petition on various grounds. If that petition is to be allowed the benefit will automatically be available to the second accused. I shall therefore first dispose of Crl. R.P No. 429 of 1979. The purchase of the sample is amply proved by the evidence of Pws. 1 and 2. Both the trial Court and the appellate Court accepted their testimony. The petitioner would contend that the Food Inspector failed to follow the formalities prescribed under the At, that he has been prejudiced on account of the omission and that therefore his conviction and sentence are liable to be set aside.

    4. In the first place it was contended that there has been non-compliance of rules 7 and 17 of the rules framed under the Act. Rule 17 deals with the manner of despatching containers of samples. It is directed therein that the sealed container of one part of the sample for analysis and the memorandum in Form No. VII should be sent in a sealed packet to the public analyst immediately but not later than to succeeding working day by any suitable means. Rule 7 deals with duties of public analyst. Under sub-rule (1) thereof, on receipt of a package containing a sample for analysis from a Food Inspector or any other person the Public Analyst or an officer authorised by him should compare the seals on the container and the outer cover with specimen impression received separately and should note the condition of the seals thereon. Under sub-rule (3) the public analyst should within a period of forty-five days from the date of receipt of any sample for analysis, deliver to the Local (Health) Authority a report of the result of such analysis in Form No. III. Form No. III includes a statement to the effect that the sample for analysis was properly sealed and fastened and that the seal was found intact and unbroken and also that the seal fixed on the container and the outer cover of the sample tallied with the specimen impression of the seal separately sent by the food inspector and the sample was in a condition fit for analysis.

    5. Ext. P6 in the instant case stated—

    “I hereby certify that I, K.G Mathai, Public Analyst for the Government of Kerala duly appointed under the provisions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954, received on the Eighteenth day of December 1976 from the Food Inspector, Tellicherry Municipality, Tellichery, a sample of Toned Milk, marked No. 483 for analysis, properly sealed and fastened, and that I found the seal intact and unbroken. The seal fixed on the container of the sample tallied with the specimen impression of the seal separately sent by the Food Inspector and the sample was in a condition fit for analysis.

    I further certify that I have caused to be analysed the aforementioned sample, and declare the result of the analysis to be as follows:”

    6. In other words, Ext. P6 did not contain the certificate to the effect that the seal fixed on the outer cover tallied with the specimen seal. This omission is relied upon by the petitioner as an irregularity which has vitiated the proceedings.

    7. It is noted that even though rule 7 directs that the Public Analyst should compare the seals on the container and the outer cover Form No. III did not originally contain the clause relating to comparing of the seal on the container with the specimen seal. It merely referred a statement that the samples were properly sealed and fastened and that the seal was intact and unbroken. There was divergence of views among the High Courts as to whether the certificate of the Public Analyst should state that the seals on the packet and the specimen seal were compared. The view taken by this Court in Subbayyan v. State, A.I.R 1968 Kerala 330, was that since Form No. III as it stood then did not prescribe that the Public Analyst should specifically mention about comparison of seals on the container and the specimen seal, non-mention of that fact in the certificate was not an irregularity. The Supreme Court had to consider this aspect in K.K Pookunju v. K.K Ramakrishna Pillai, 1969 K.L.T 50. The Supreme Court observed:

    “The High Court relied on the principle that official acts must be presumed to have been regularly performed. Under Rule 7 the Public Analyst has to compare the seal on the container and the outer cover with the specimen impression received separately on receipt of the packet containing the sample for the analysis. The High Court considered that it must be presumed that the Public Analyst acted in accordance with the Rules and be must have compared the specimen impression received by him with the seal on the container.

    We do not find any error in the decision of the High Court on the above point.”

    8. While the above controversy was in vogue Form No. III was amended on 8-7-1968 adding a clause that the seal fixed on the container of the sample tallied with the specimen impression of the seal separately sent by the Food Inspector and the sample was in a condition fit for analysis. The form was further amended with effect from 2-10-1976 adding the words “and the outer cover” after the words “container” Form No. III as it stood on the taking of the sample in the present case contained the clause—

    “The seal fixed on the container and the outer cover of the sample tallied with the specimen impression of the seal separately sent by the Food Inspector and the sample was in a condition fit for analysis.”

    9. It has to be noted that important changes have been made under Act 34 of 1976 with regard to the procedure to be followed by the Food Inspector after the sample is taken. The practice of delivery of one portion of the sample to the person from whom the sample is taken has been discontinued. Instead the two specimen samples are to be kept by the Local (Health) Authority. In the circumstances it is highly necessary that the accused should be assured of the regularity of the procedure followed by the Food Inspector in sending the sample. The effect of the changes in Form No. III has to be considered in the background of the amendment of the Act and also the divergence of views that existed among the High Courts as to the contents of Form No. III as it originally stood. It has to be borne in mind that in the absence of the evidence of the Public Analyst the certificate in Form No. III is the sole evidence on which a decision as to whether the article was adulterated should rest. That is a strong indicator to show that the certificate should conform to the provisions of the statute. In the background of the history of the legislation it has to be held that by the addition in Form No. III of the clause relating to comparison of seals on the container as also outer cover the rule making authority intended to make the provision mandatory. In other words the Court should insist on strict compliance of the provision. Khalid. J, has held in Jose v. Food Inspector, 1981 K.L.T 859, that non-compliance of the provision taints the entire prosecution with illegality for reasons already mentioned I respectfully agree with the said view. It follows that no conviction can be entered on the basis of Ext P6 which does not conform to the requirements of law.

    10. In the light of the above conclusion the further contention raised that there has been non-compliance of S. 13(2) does notarise for consideration. I may however state that Ext. P7 notices and Ext. P8 acknowledgements make out that there has been compliance of S. 13(2). However, in the absence of mention in Ext. P6 that the public analyst compared the seals of the outer cover with the specimen seal, the conviction and sentence of the first accused has to be set aside.

    11. I therefore allow Crl. R.P No. 429 of 1979, set aside the conviction and sentence as against the first accused and acquit him. It follows that there are no sufficient reasons for interfering with the order acquitting the second accused. Criminal Appeal No. 444 of 1979 is therefore dismissed.

    12. Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Azeez v. Food Inspector
    (Jan 12, 1982)