Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • s. 12 of the kerala land reforms (amendment) act, 1971, 25 of 1971. Under s. 1 (2)
  • s. 85 of the land reforms act, 1964 (for short the act)
  • (amendment) act, 1969, 35 of 1969, Lands
  • sub - section (4) of s. 1 of act
  • s. 82 (4) of act 1 of 1964.
  • act 35 of 1969, S. 82 (4)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • s. 12 of the kerala land reforms (amendment) act, 1971, 25 of 1971. Under s. 1 (2)
  • s. 85 of the land reforms act, 1964 (for short the act)
  • (amendment) act, 1969, 35 of 1969, Lands
  • sub - section (4) of s. 1 of act
  • s. 82 (4) of act 1 of 1964.
  • act 35 of 1969, S. 82 (4)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two civil revision petitions under challenge arise from orders of the land board under section 85 of the Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1964 (as it stood before amendment by Act 17 of 1972).

- C.R.P. No. 1130 of 1972: petitioners are three partners (husband, wife and daughter) of a firm; land involved is approximately 4,600 acres.

- C.R.P. No. 1146 of 1972: petitioners are the husband and wife who were the first and second petitioners in C.R.P. No. 1130; land involved is approximately 300 acres.

In both petitions the first petitioner filed statements before the land board as required by s.85(1) read with s.85(2A)(c) and (d), claiming that substantial tracts were exempt lands because they are plantations. The land board held that land converted into plantations after 1-4-1964 are not eligible for exemption. That decision is the principal subject of challenge in these revision petitions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether section 82(4) of the Act applies to land converted into plantations, and whether it applies to conversion occurring before or after particular dates of commencement/amendment.
  2. How the dates on which various provisions of the Act (notably sections 82(4), 83 and 85) came into force should be understood and whether the phrase "after the commencement of this Act" in s.82(4) refers to the Act as a whole or to the coming into force of the particular provision.
  3. Whether land converted into plantations prior to 1-1-1970 (the date on which some provisions such as ss.83 and 85 came into force) falls outside the scope of s.82(4) and/or outside the operation of Chapter III of the Act.
  4. Whether the land board's orders properly identify the specific portions of survey numbers (parcels) that are to be surrendered, in compliance with the Act and the Kerala Land Reforms (Ceiling) Rules, 1970.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioners' Arguments

  • Section 82(4), as substituted by s.12 of the Kerala Land Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1971 (Act 25 of 1971), came into force only on 1-1-1970 (deemed by s.1(2) of the amending Act). The substituted text contains the words "or into a plantation" which were absent from the earlier text.
  • Therefore s.82(4) (containing "or into a plantation") should not apply to conversions into plantations that occurred before 1-1-1970.
  • Since ss.83 and 85 (which make obligatory the surrender of excess lands) only came into force on 1-1-1970, conversions into plantations before that date are outside the ambit of s.82(4) as the "extent of excess land" is to be determined with reference to the operative commencement of ss.83 and 85.
  • The land board's orders do not properly identify the specific land to be surrendered (example: Survey No. 53/1A where 132.50 acres are fixed as excess out of a total of 700+ acres, without specification of the particular portion), failing rules that require description sufficient to identify the land.

Respondent / Government Pleader's Arguments

  • The words "after the commencement of this Act" in s.82(4) are plain and refer to the commencement of the Act as per s.1; the Act (s.1) came into force on 14-1-1964 when published in the Gazette.
  • The Act contains an appointed-day clause (s.1(3)) allowing different provisions to come into force on different dates, and the proviso requires that references in a provision to "the commencement of this Act" be construed as references to the coming into force of that provision.
  • Notifications made by government appointed particular dates: s.82(4) came into force on 1-4-1964; remaining provisions including ss.83 and 85 were appointed to come into force on 1-1-1970. Given the interpretation clause, the words "after the commencement of this Act" in s.82(4) must be read as "after the coming into force of s.82(4)" (i.e., 1-4-1964).
  • The land board has exempted lands falling within s.81; those exempted areas have not been taken into account in determining ceiling area and excess land (government pleader pointed to Part B attached to the board's order showing exempted acreages).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C.R.P. Nos. 1200 etc. of 1972 (decision of Krishnamoorthy Iyer J.) Held that, to attract s.82(4), the subject land must be a class specified in Schedule II and the conversion must be to another class specified in that Schedule or into a plantation; s.82(4) is concerned with calculating extent of land for ascertaining ceiling area under s.83; and conversions of land exempted from operation of Chapter III (e.g., private forest under s.81) do not fall within s.82(4). The court in this opinion treated that decision as distinguishable on facts (this case does not concern private forests converted to plantation). The opinion noted that the cited passage about s.82(3) did not assist the revision petitioners in the present context because the prior decision had specifically confined s.82(4) to land not exempted under Chapter III.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a textual and legislative-history analysis of section 82(4) and related provisions:

  1. The court reproduced the current text of s.82(4) (post-substitution) and noted petitioners' contention that the added phrase "or into a plantation" was introduced by the 1971 amendment (Act 25 of 1971) deemed to come into force on 1-1-1970.
  2. The court examined the earlier version(s) of s.82(4) and the contents of Schedule II as they stood prior to the amendments: originally various plantations were specifically listed in Schedule II (classes 5 to 10), and s.82(4) (in earlier formulations) aimed to prevent certain conversions specified in Schedule II from being taken into account when determining the extent of land liable to be surrendered.
  3. The court explained the effect of the 1969 amendment (Act 35 of 1969), which substituted the original Schedule II (and came into force on 1-1-1970). After that substitution, plantations were no longer specified in the new Schedule II available from 1-1-1970, creating an apparent gap as regards conversion into plantations.
  4. To remedy that omission, s.82(4) was substituted by Act 25 of 1971 to expressly include conversions "into a plantation" with retrospective effect from 1-1-1970. The court concluded that, as a result of the sequence of amendments, conversions of land into plantations should not be taken into account in determining the extent of land liable to be surrendered both prior to and after 1-1-1970 (i.e., the petitioners' contention that s.82(4) did not apply to conversions into plantations before 1-1-1970 was unsustainable).
  5. The court then addressed the argument that ss.83 and 85 came into force only on 1-1-1970 and therefore conversions prior to that date could not be within the ambit of s.82(4). The court analyzed s.1(3) (the appointed-day clause) and its proviso, which provides that references in provisions brought into force by notification to "the commencement of this Act" must be construed as references to the coming into force of that provision.
  6. The court reviewed the government notifications: notification SRO.75/1964 (appointing 1-4-1964 for sections including s.82), and notifications SRO.2/70 and SRO.5/70 (appointing 1-1-1970 for remaining provisions and the operation of the ceiling restrictions). Applying the proviso in s.1(3), the court concluded that "after the commencement of this Act" in s.82(4) must be read as "after the coming into force of s.82(4)," i.e., from 1-4-1964.
  7. Therefore, even though ss.83 and 85 came into force only on 1-1-1970, s.82(4) itself applied to conversions "after the commencement" of s.82(4) (1-4-1964). The court rejected the narrower temporal reading urged by petitioners.
  8. The court considered the cited decision of Krishnamoorthy Iyer J. and found it distinguishable on facts (that decision dealt with conversions of private forest — an exempt category under s.81 — which does not attract s.82(4)). The court noted the government pleader's position that lands falling within s.81 had already been exempted by the land board and not counted in determining ceiling/excess; petitioners disputed this and urged additional lands should be treated as exempt.
  9. Addressing procedural compliance, the court found that the land board's orders did not adequately identify the particular portions of survey numbers to be surrendered (example given of Survey No. 53/1A where 132.50 acres were fixed as excess out of 700+ acres without specific identification). The court reviewed relevant rules (Kerala Land Reforms (Ceiling) Rules, 1970), noting r.13 (enquiry and determination of extent and identity), r.17 (notice in Form 9 after determination, with a schedule requiring "extent with description sufficient to identify the land"), and observed that the board had not satisfied the requirement of definite and exact determination of identity before issuing notices.
  10. The court also noted uncertainty whether petitioners had indicated lands proposed to be surrendered under s.85 subsections; under s.85(6) the board must determine identity accepting the choice indicated. If petitioners had not indicated, the board must give an opportunity to do so and then determine identity.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The civil revision petitions are disposed of by remitting the matters to the land board for limited purposes.

The court ordered that the land board:

  • Identify, with definite and exact description, the lands to be surrendered (including specific identification of portions within survey numbers), in accordance with the Act and the Kerala Land Reforms (Ceiling) Rules, 1970 (including r.13 and r.17 and related provisions).
  • Re-examine and decide claims by the petitioners that additional lands fall within the exemption provided by s.81 of the Act; the board shall accept and determine choices indicated under s.85 subsections where applicable, and give petitioners opportunity to indicate lands to be surrendered if not already done.
  • Amend or modify its earlier orders under revision in accordance with the Act, the Rules and the directions contained in this judgment.

Practical consequences and implications:

  • The court interpreted s.82(4) to apply to conversions into plantations occurring after s.82(4) came into force (1-4-1964), and the subsequent substitution to include "into a plantation" (with effect from 1-1-1970) does not exclude conversions into plantations occurring prior to 1-1-1970 from the operation of s.82(4). In short, conversion into plantations after 1-4-1964 cannot be taken into account in determining land liable to be surrendered under s.82(4).
  • The decision requires the land board to correct procedural defects in identification of specific lands to be surrendered and to reassess claims of exemption under s.81 where contested.
  • The court disposed of the revision petitions as above and made no order as to costs.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to facts, arguments, reasoning, citations and orders contained in the provided opinion text. No information has been added that is not present in that text.

    Ramavarma Raja v. The Land Board Of Kerala

    1. These two civil revision petitions arise out of orders passed by the land board under s. 85 of the land reforms act, 1964 (for short the act) as it stood before its amendment by act 17 of 1972. Crp. No. 1130 of 1972 is by the three partners (husband, Wife and their daughter) of a firm, And is in respect of 4600 and odd acres of land. In crp. No. 1146 of 1972 the petitioners are the husband and wife who are the 1st and 2nd petitioners in the other civil revision petition. Therein the land involved is 300 and odd acres.

    2. Common questions of law are raised in both the civil revision petitions regarding the scope and ambit of the provisions in the act relating to restriction on ownership and possession of land in excess of ceiling area and disposal of excess lands which are provided for in chapter iii of the act. The 1st petitioner in both the civil revision petitions filed statements before the land board as required by s. 85 (1) read with s. 85 (2a) (c) and (d). He therein claimed that large tracts of land are exempted lands, Being plantations. The board took the view that land converted into plantation after 1 - 4 - 1964 are not eligible for exemption. It is this decision that is challenged before me.

    3. S. 82 (4) reads:

    " (4) where, After the commencement of this act, Any class of land specified in schedule ii has been converted into any other class of land specified in that schedule or into a plantation, The extent of land liable to be surrendered by a person owning or holding such land shall be determined without taking into consideration such conversion"
    .

    according to the learned counsel for the revision petitioners the sub - section as it stands now came into force only on 1 - 1 - 1970, Being a provision substituted by s. 12 of the kerala land reforms (amendment) act, 1971, 25 of 1971. Under s. 1 (2) of that amending act the substituted provision shall be deemed to have come into force on 1 - 1 - 1970. The learned counsel further submitted that s. 82 (4) as it stood prior to the substitution did not contain the words "or into a plantation" which occurs in the present sub - section. The submission, Therefore, Is that s. 82 (4) is not attracted to cases where the conversion of land 'into a plantation' was prior to 1 - 1 - 1970.

    4. S. 82 (4) as it stood prior to its amendment by act 25 of 1971 was as follows:

    " (4) where, After the commencement of this act, Any class of land specified in schedule ii has been converted into any other class of land specified therein, The extent of land that may be owned or held by a family or adult unmarried person owning or holding such land at the time of the conversion shall be determined without taking into account such conversion."

    plantation is defined in s. 2 (44) of the act as

    "any land used by a person principally for the cultivation of tea, Coffee, Cocoa rubber, Cardamom or cinnamon and includes."

    in part i of schedule ii as it stood prior to its amendment by the kerala land reforms (amendment) act, 1969, 35 of 1969, Lands other than nilams were classified into ten kinds. Classes 5 to 10 (both inclusive) in all the districts were rubber, Tea, Coffee, Cardamom, Cinnamon, And cocoa plantations. S. 82 (4) and the schedule were amended by act 35 of 1969. As amended by act 35 of 1969, S. 82 (4) stood as follows:

    " (4) where, After the commencement of this act, Any class of land specified in schedule ii has been converted into any other class of land specified therein, The extent of land that may be owned or held by a person owning or holding such land at the time of the conversion shall be determined without taking into account such conversion."

    it will be noticed that under s. 82 (4) as it stood prior to and after its amendment by act 35 of 1969, "where any class of land specified in schedule ii

    has been converted into any other class of land specified therein", Such conversion would not be taken into account or consideration in determining the extent (at the time of conversion) of the land of a person who owned or held such land. So long as all kinds of plantations were specified in schedule ii, S. 82 (4) would be attracted to conversion of lands into plantations. But by act 35 of 1969 which came into force on 111970 the original schedule. 11 was substituted by the present schedule ii in which plantations are not specified. It was to remedy this that the present sub - s. (4) of s. 82 was substituted by act 25 of 1971 with effect from 1 1 1970. The result is that both ;prior to 1 - 1 - 1970 as well as after that date "conversion of any class of land specified is scheduleii" into a plantation cannot betaken into account or consideration in determining the extent of the land liable to be surrendered. The argument of the learned counsel for the petitioners that s. 82 (4) is not attracted to cases where the conversion of land into a plantation was before 1 11970 is therefore without any force.

    5. It was next argued by the learned counsel for the petitioners that since s. 83 and 85 of the act came into force only on 1 - 1 - 1970 conversion of land into plantation prior to that date is outside the ambit of s. 82 (4). The argument is that it is by these provisions (ss. 83 and 85) that it was made obligatory on the part of a person not to own, Hold or possess land in excess of the ceiling area, And to surrender excess land. According to the learned counsel the extent of excess land is to be determined with reference to 1 11970 whereafter alone a person is prohibited to own, Hold or possess more land than ceiling area, And is directed to surrender land in excess of ceiling area. The learned counsel further submitted that therefore the words "after the commencement of this act" in s. 82 (4) is to be construed as meaning'after all the provisions in the act have come into force' or in any event'after s. 83 and 85 came into force'. The learned government pleader, On the other band, Submitted that there is no warrant for such an interpretation, That the words are clear and unambiguous, That the word "act" in s. 82 (4) means "act" and nothing else, And so understood the act came into force on 14 - 1 - 1964 when s. 1 came into force as per s. 1 (3) of the act.

    6. The act has been brought into operation piecemeal. There is an "appointed day" clause in the act, Viz., S. 1 (3) which is as follows:

    " (3) the provisions of this act, Except this section which shall come into force at once, Shall come into force on such date as the government may, By notification in the gazette, Appoint:

    provided that different dates may be appointed for different provisions of this act. And any reference in any such provision to the commencement of this act, Shall be construed as a reference to the coming into force of that provision. "

    under s. 1 (3) read with s. 3 of the interpretation and general clauses act. 1125 and s. 5 of the madras general clauses act, 1891, S. 1 of the act came into force on 14 - 1 - 1964 when the act was published in the gazette. By virtue of the power conferred by the "appointed day" clause the government as per notification sro. 75 of 1964 dated 25 - 3 - 1964 appointed 1 - 4 - 1964 as the date on which s. 2 to 71 (both inclusive), 73 to 82 (both inclusive), 84, 99 to 108 (both inclusive) and 110 to 132 (both inclusive) shall come into force; and by notification sro. 2/70 dated 1 - 1 - 1970 government appointed 1 - 1 - 1970 as the date on which the remaining provisions of the act shall come into force. By another notification sro. 5/70 dated 1 - 1 - 1970 government fixed 1 - 1 - 1970 as the date with effect from which no person shall be entitled to own, Hold or possess under a mortgage lands in excess of the ceiling area. The latter part of the proviso to s. 1 (3) is an interpretation clause. Under that part of the proviso 'any reference in any such provision', (provisions which are to be brought into force by notification) 'to the commencement of this act' is to be construed as a reference to the 'coming into force of that provision'. But for this provision there would have been some force in the submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioners. Ia view of the aforesaid provision, The arguments advanced by the counsel on both sides need not be examined any further, For the words "after the commencement of this act" in s. 82 (4) means construed in the light of the proviso "after the commencement of this section", Viz., S. 82 (4). S. 82 (4), As already pointed out came into force on 1 - 4 - 1964. Though s. 83 and 85 came into force only later, By force of s. 82 (4) conversion of any class of land specified in schedule ii into plantation after 1 - 4 - 1964 cannot be taken into account or consideration in determining the extent of land liable to be surrendered

    7. The learned counsel for the revision petitioners brought to my notice a decision of krishnamoorthy iyer j. In c. R. P. Nos. 1200 etc. Of 1972. In those cases the question now before me did not arise at all. There the question was whether conversion of lands which were private forests (and therefore exempt under s. 81 (d) of the act) into plantations subsequent to the coming into force of act 1 of 1964 but prior to 1 - 1 - 1970 on which date s. 83 came into force, Is hit by s. 82 (4). The petitioners therein claimed that those plantations are exempted lands under s. 81 (1). The learned judge held:

    "to attract s. 82 (4), It must be a class of land specified in schedule ii and the conversion of the same should have been to some other class of land specified in that schedule or into a plantation. I do not think that the respondent can derive any assistance in this caw from s. 82 (4) of act 1 of 1964. That section is concerned only with the question of calculating the extent of land for the purpose of ascertaining the ceiling area under s. 83. In order to attract s. 82 (4), There must be a land which is not exempted from the operation of chapter iii of act i of 1964. Private forest is an item exempted from the provisions of chapter iii by virtue of s. 81 of act i of 1964. When private forests are converted into any other type of land, It is not a conversion of any land included in schedule ii of the act. If so, There is no scope for applying s. 82 (4)"
    .

    the learned government pleader rightly pointed out that that is not the case here. According to him all such lands which come within the purview of s. 81 of the land reforms act have been exempted by the land board and those lands have not been taken into account in determining the ceiling area and the excess land to be surrendered. Mr. Vyasan poti on behalf of the revision petitioners disputes this statement. The learned government pleader has pointed out to me part b attached to the order which gives the details of the land exempted under s. 81 (i) and (3). That area in c. R. P. No. 1130 of 1972 is 1530 acres; and in c. R. P. No. 1146 of 1972 the area of exempted lands is 63 and odd acres. Mr. Poti submits there are some more lands which are exempted lands under s. 81.

    8. The learned counsel for the revision petitioners invited my attention to another passage in the decision of krishnamoorthy iyer j. That passage is as follows:

    "the words 'after the commencement of the act' in s. 82 (3) will have to be interpreted in the light of the proviso to sub - section (4) of s. 1 of act i of 1964. If so done the words 'after the commencement of the act' will only mean after 1 - 1 - 1970 when that provision came into force"
    .

    i do not think that the above passage in any way supports the revision petitioners in that it is with reference to s. 82 (3) and in view of the fact that earlier in the judgment the learned judge has specifically adverted to s. 82 (4) and held that in order to attract that sub - section there must be land which is not exempted from the operation of chapter iii of act 1 of 1964.

    9. Another submission made by the learned counsel for the revision petitioners is that the land board has not by the orders under revision identified the lands to be surrendered. As as instance mr. Poti pointed out to me part d attached to the order of the board in c. R. P. No. 1130 of 1972. He particularly drew my attention to the fact that the land to be surrendered in sy. No. 53/1a is 132. 50 acres. He then referred me to the opening portion of the order itself wherein the board has stated that sy. No. 53/1a has a total area of 700 and odd acres. The submission is, Without anything more 132. 50 acres of land which the civil revision petitioners are to surrender from out of r. S. No. 53/1a is not identifiable. It appears to me that this submission is correct. There is no identification as to wherefrom or from which portion of the survey number the area fixed as excess land is to be carved out. The learned counsel's submission is that such is the position with reference to other survey numbers also and that appears to me to be prima facie correct. Rules have been framed for working out the provisions of chapter iii, Namely, Kerala land reforms (ceiling) rules, 1970. Under r. 13 an enquiry has to be held and thereafter the land board has to determine the extent and identity of the land to be surrendered. R. 17 provides that notice in form 9 shall be issued after the determination of the extent and identity of land that is to be surrendered. By the notice in form 9 the person to whom that notice is issued is directed to surrender 'the lands mentioned in the subjoined schedule'. The third column in the schedule to the notice is 'extent with description sufficient to identify the land'. This presupposes that before the issue of notice and in pursuance of the enquiry under r. 13 the land to be surrendered has to be determined definitely and exactly. R. 19 and 22 to 24 referred to by the learned government pleader relate to a stage after the determination of the extent and identity of the land to be surrendered under r. 13. It is also not clear whether the petitioners have in the statements filed under s. 85 indicated the lands proposed to be surrendered as provided in s. 85 (2), Or s. 85 (3a) read with s. 85 (2). Under s. 85 (6) the board has to determine the identity of land to be surrendered accepting the choice indicated under subsections (2) and (3a) of s. 85. If the petitioners have not already indicated the lands proposed to be surrendered, The board will give them an opportunity to so indicate, And determine the identity of the land which is to be surrendered.

    10. In these circumstances it is necessary to send back the cases to the land board for the limited purposes of identifying the lands that are to be surrendered and also to look into the claims of the revision petitioners that some more land will come within the purview of s. 81 and i hereby do so. The board will look into and decide these matters in accordance with the provisions of the act and the rules, And in the light of what is stated in this judgment, And amend or modify the orders under revision accordingly.

    11. The revision petitions are disposed of as above. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramavarma Raja v. The Land Board Of Kerala
    (Aug 3, 1973)