Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Satyapalan v. Deputy Director Of Education

    1. Both the petitioners in this case had temporary service under rule 9(a)(i) on advice through Employment Exchange, as High School Assistants (HSA). Their services were terminated on the expiry of their provisional appointments. Later, both of them were recruited through Public Service Commission as Primary Departmental Teachers, a post lower than to that of High School Assistant (H.S.A) on 28 January 1977 and 21 February 1977 respectively. They continued in the post as per orders in force. They were promoted on regular basis as H.S.As as per Exhibits P1 and P2, dated 23 September 1977 and 7 January 1978, respectively. Thus, they became H.S.As Taking the temporary service that they had put in even much prior to the regular appointment in the lower post of Primary Departmental Teacher, the increment due to the petitioners in the promoted post of H.S.A was sanctioned. Later the error in reckoning the temporary service as HSA. which the petitioners had put in before their entry in service in the lower category of P.D teacher on regular basis, for the purpose of granting increment after promotion as H.S.As from the lower post was detected and Exhibits P3 and P4 were issued directing refixation of increment and pay without reckoning that temporary service. It was also directed that the excess pay drawn by the petitioners from 1978 or 1979 onwards by reason of the added increment on the strength of the said temporary service, shall be got refunded to the department. The petitioners aggrieved by Exhibits P3 and P4, submitted representations before Government. Those representations were disposed of by Exhibits P13 and P14 upholding Exhibits P3 and P4 on the reason that in terms of Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R the petitioners are not entitled to count their earlier temporary service before regular entry in the department in a lower post, for sanctioning increment in a higher post after promotion from such lower post.

    2. Assailing Exhibits P3, P4, P13 and P14, the petitioners submit that they are entitled to increment in terms of the Government decision which reads as follows:

    “Provisional service on regularisation with or without break in the same category of post will be treated as officiating service ab initio for the limited purpose of granting increments. Provisional service followed by a regular appointment with or without break in the same category of post will also be treating as officiating service ab initio for the limited purpose of granting of increments. The term ‘same category’ of post for the purpose of denotes posts satisfying the following conditions:

    (i) The posts should carry the same or identically scale of pay.

    (ii) The qualification and method of appointment should be the same and

    (iii) The post should fall in the same service.

    (emphasis supplied.)

    3. In order to attract the application of the first part of the said statutory provision, the provisional service put in by the incumbent concerned shall be later regularised. The specific word in the Government decision is “provisional service or regularisation” will be counted for granting increment. The petitioners have no case that the provisional service put in by them before 1977 had, as any time, been regularised. Therefore, the first part of the Government decision does not apply in their case. The second part of the Government decision postulates that provisional service shall be followed by a regular appointment in the same category whether with or without breaks. After termination of the provisional service as H.S.A, what followed was their regular service as PD. teachers and not as H.S.As Therefore, what followed was not regular appointment “in the same category of post”. Therefore, second part also does not apply to them.

    4. There is an added reason also in the second paragraph of the said Government decision. The term “same category” is further defined by that part of the Government decision that the post should carry the same or identical scale of pay and qualification, and method of appointment should be the same. The post of H.S.A and the post of P.D teacher, regular appointment to which the petitioners obtained after their provisional appointment did not carry and even now do not carry the same sake of pay, because P.D teacher is a lower post than H.S.A qualifications are also different P.D teachers are expected to take Classes in primary school, whereas H.S.As are expected to take classes in High Schools. Therefore, the conditions in the second paragraph is not satisfied in the petitioners' case.

    5. It is further submitted by the petitioners that the Government decision No. 2 does not stipulates that regular appointment as H.S.A need not be without an intervening appointment in another category, in the petitioners' case — In the category of P.D teachers. That also does not apply according to me because increment is expected to be granted taking into account the service put in by the incumbent in a particular scale of pay. Government decision No. 2 is a concession to a person who is officiating in a post on regular basis to count the period put in by him in the same post on temporary basis provided the method of appointment is one and the same as mentioned in condition No. 2 Para. 2 of the Government decision extracted above. That does not take in a far subsequent promotion to a post once upon a time an incumbent had occupied on a temporary basis. Even if the petitioners' contention is accepted, the petitioners will not come within the second condition in the second paragraph, because temporary appointment in their case was by direct recruitment through Employment Exchange. That appointment was terminated. The petitioners voluntarily applied for appointment as P.D teacher through P.S.C They obtained that appointment on selection. Later they became ripe enough to be promoted as H.S.A and they were promoted from the post of P.D teacher. So, the earlier temporary appointment as H.S.A was through direct recruitment; whereas the regular appointment as H.S.A was on promotion. So, the method of appointment did differ. So, even if the petitioners contention is accepted, that condition contained in Government decision No. 2 extracted above is not satisfied. Therefore, the challenge against Exhibits P3, P4, P13 and P14 shall fail. The petitioners cannot be granted increment granting the temporary service put in by them.

    6. The petitioners were granted increment on promotion as H.S.A by the department, taking into account, the temporary service which ought not to have been counted for increment. It is far later that, based on an audit objection, Exhibits P3 and P4 were issued to cancel the grant of increment and for consequent pay fixation. The petitioners were not at fault in granting the increment, it is the administrative authority which granted the increment counting the period which could not have been counted. Therefore, it is arbitrary to mulct the petitioners with the liability to refund the amount which they obtained by reason of a wrong fixation of pay made by the administrative authority for the period up to 1984. Therefore, that part of Exhibits P3 and P4 directing refund of the alleged excess amount drawn, as confirmed in Exhibits P13 and P14, is quashed It is further made clear that the petitioners are not entitled to the increment counting the temporary service; but the excess pay cannot be directed to be refunded until the date of Exhibits P13 and P14. The respondents are liable to refix the pay of the petitioners without any liability for refund up to the date of Exhibits P13 and P14.

    7. Original petition is disposed of as above. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Satyapalan v. Deputy Director Of Education
    (Jan 9, 1998)