Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 30 of the University of Rajputana Act, 1946,
  • provisions in the University of Bihar Act, 1959
  • sec. 21 of the University of Rajasthan Act.
  • sec. 20 of the University of Bihar Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 30 of the University of Rajputana Act, 1946,
  • provisions in the University of Bihar Act, 1959
  • sec. 21 of the University of Rajasthan Act.
  • sec. 20 of the University of Bihar Act
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Writ Petition under Articles 226 & 227 (Bhandari, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a writ petition under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution filed by Shri Kanhaiyalal, a registered graduate of the University of Rajasthan. The petitioner challenged the conferment of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D) on Shri Madan Lal Sharma (Respondent No. 4). The University of Rajasthan passed Resolutions Nos. 24 and 21 dated 28 January 1958 and 8 January 1959 respectively, awarding the Ph.D degree to Respondent No. 4.

The petitioner alleged that Respondent No. 4 procured the resolutions by exerting influence on Syndicate members, that Respondent No. 4 had not applied for a Ph.D (only for the degree of 'Vachaspati'), and that Ord. No. 124 (under sec. 30 of the University of Rajputana Act, 1946) required a candidate for Ph.D to hold an M.A., M.Sc., M.Com., M.Ed or M. Pharm — degrees which Respondent No. 4 allegedly did not hold. The petitioner also asserted that any research conducted by Respondent No. 4 was for 'Vachaspati' (not equivalent to Ph.D) and that the petitioner himself could not be awarded 'Vachaspati' because his thesis was submitted in Hindi rather than Sanskrit.

Respondents (the University, its Syndicate and Registrar) contested the petition, denying collusion, asserting that Respondent No. 4 held the degree of Acharya (equivalent to M.A. in Sanskrit), that Ordinance No. 329 made the Ph.D. provisions applicable to 'Vachaspati', that the Oriental Faculty was defunct and the thesis had been refereed with a majority recommendation, and that the University was an autonomous body and the sole judge of conferring degrees. Respondent No. 4 raised similar defences and urged that the petitioner had an alternative remedy before the University.

The court framed the preliminary point of whether the petitioner had a right to institute the present writ (in particular mandamus) and proceeded to decide the petition. The writ petition was ultimately dismissed with costs (one set).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner has the legal right or locus standi to maintain a writ petition (in particular a writ of mandamus) under Articles 226 & 227 challenging the conferment of a university degree.
  2. Whether the conferment of the Ph.D degree on Respondent No. 4 complied with the statutory or ordinance requirements cited by the petitioner (specifically Ordinance No. 124 under sec. 30 of the University of Rajputana Act, 1946, and the application of Ordinance No. 329 to 'Vachaspati').

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner alleged that Respondent No. 4 secured the Syndicate resolutions by exercising influence on some Syndicate members (collusion).
  • Respondent No. 4 had not applied for a Ph.D but only for the degree of 'Vachaspati'.
  • Under Ordinance No. 124 (sec. 30, University of Rajputana Act, 1946), a Ph.D candidate must hold an M.A., M.Sc., M.Com., M.Ed or M. Pharm; Respondent No. 4 did not hold any of these degrees and thus could not be awarded a Ph.D under that provision.
  • The research done by Respondent No. 4 was for 'Vachaspati', which the petitioner contends is not equivalent to Ph.D; the petitioner also asserted he could not obtain 'Vachaspati' because his thesis was in Hindi rather than Sanskrit.
  • The petitioner claimed the right to bring the petition as a registered graduate interested in the affairs and good name of the University.

Respondents' Arguments (University, Syndicate, Registrar and Respondent No. 4)

  • The University and its authorities denied collusion or bad motive in conferring the Ph.D degree.
  • Respondent No. 4 held the degree of Acharya (equivalent to M.A. in Sanskrit) and had applied to carry out research for 'Vachaspati', which (by Ordinance No. 329) was governed by the same Ordinance and statutes as the Ph.D degree.
  • The Oriental Faculty was defunct; the thesis was sent to examiners and a majority of referees recommended conferment; the Syndicate thereupon conferred the Ph.D degree.
  • The University is an autonomous body and the sole judge of whether a particular degree should be conferred; no legal right of the petitioner was violated; therefore the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 could not be invoked to question the University's discretion.
  • Respondent No. 4 asserted that the petitioner had an alternative remedy before the University.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pratapmal v. The Income-Tax Officer, Jodhpur (Division Bench) Art. 226 is generally available to persons whose fundamental right has been infringed; generally only the person affected can approach the Court for writs of mandamus, prohibition and certiorari (quoted in the opinion). The court relied on this authority as part of the discussion on locus standi and the limitation of Art. 226 to persons with a personal right affected.
Municipal Corporation for the City of Bombay v. Govid Laxman Savant

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Narendra Nath Chakravariy v. Corporation of Calcutta

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Jatindra Mohan Sen Gupta in Re

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

General Secretary, Eastern Zone Insurance Employees' Association v. Zonal Manager, Eastern Zone, Life Insurance Corporation

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Indian Sugar Mills Association through its President Shri Hari Raj Swamp v. Secretary to Government, Uttar Pradesh Labour Department

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

In re P. Rama-moorthi

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Satya Prakash v. Commissioner, Land Reforms and Jagirs, M.B

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Sita Vidyalya Nagpur v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Nagpur

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Sri Durga Glass Works Ltd. Association through Ram Singh Kotwal v. State of U.P

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Prem Narain Tandon v. State of U.P & Co.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

The State of Orissa v. Madan Gopat Rungta

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Vice-Chancellor, Utkal University v. S.K. Ghosh & Co.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Chiranjit Lal's case

This information was not directly stated in the provided opinion; it was referenced in an article cited by the parties.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Director of Endowment Government, Hyderabad v. Akram Ali

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Kalyan Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh "A right to maintain such a petition (a petition under Art. 226) ... postulates a subsisting personal right in the claim which the petitioner makes and in the protection of which he is personally interested." (quoted at para. 14) The court treated this decision as authoritative on the necessity of a subsisting personal right for maintainability of a writ under Art. 226.
Dr. Rai Shivendra Bahadur v. Governing Body of the Nalanda College, Bihar Shariff Mandamus will issue only if statutes impose a legal duty that the applicant has a right to enforce; absence of any statutory right to appointment means the petitioner cannot seek mandamus (quoted at length). The court applied the principle that to obtain mandamus the petitioner must show a legal right to the performance of a statutory duty; used this to conclude the petitioner's lack of enforceable personal right.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court identified the primary preliminary question as whether the petitioner had a right to file the present petition for a writ of mandamus. It examined the petitioner's status (a registered graduate of the University of Rajasthan who could vote for Senate members) and the alleged grievances concerning the conferment of the Ph.D degree on Respondent No. 4.

On the legal standard for maintainability, the court relied on authorities — notably the Division Bench decision in Pratapmal and later decisions of the Supreme Court (Kalyan Singh and Dr. Rai Shivendra Bahadur) — to extract the governing principle: a petition under Article 226 requires a subsisting personal right or a present legal interest in the claimant, i.e., the petitioner must show that his personal right has been infringed by the act challenged. The court quoted the Supreme Court's observation that the right to maintain an Art. 226 petition "postulates a subsisting personal right" and the passage from the Nalanda College case that mandamus requires the petitioner to demonstrate that statutes impose a legal duty which the petitioner has a statutory right to enforce.

Applying these principles to the facts before it, the court concluded that the petitioner had not demonstrated any personal right that was affected by the conferment of the Ph.D on Respondent No. 4. The petitioner was unable to show that he was an "aggrieved person" in the sense required by the authorities; his status as a registered graduate and his general interest in the University's affairs did not suffice to create a subsisting personal right to challenge the University's action by mandamus. The court expressly stated that, given the Supreme Court pronouncements, it was unnecessary to survey or decide all other authorities cited by the parties.

Because the petitioner's lack of a demonstrable personal right was dispositive, the court did not proceed to decide in detail the merits of the petitioner's substantive statutory contentions about Ordinance No. 124, the equivalence of degrees, or the precise procedural regularity of the Syndicate's action.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was held to be not maintainable and was dismissed. The court ordered the petition dismissed with costs (only one set of costs allowed).

Implications: The direct consequence of the decision is that the petitioner may not, on the facts presented, invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 to obtain mandamus to set aside the University's conferment of the Ph.D degree because he failed to establish a subsisting personal right or legal interest affected by that act. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal principle beyond the existing authorities it relied upon; the decision applied established locus standi requirements and disposed of the petition on that ground.

    Kanhaiyalal v. The University Of Rajasthan

    Bhandari, J.:— This is a writ petition under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution.

    2. The petitioner Shri Kanhaiyalal is a registered graduate of the University of Rajasthan.

    3. By Resolutions Nos. 24 and 21, dated the 28th of January, 1958 and 8th of January 1959 respectively, the University of Rajasthan, which is Respondent No. 1 in this Writ Petition, decided to award the degree of the Doctor of Philosophy to Respondent No. 4 Shri Madan Lal Sharma, who was a Lecturer in the Maharaja's Sanskrit College, Jaipur, and the said degree was conferred on him. According to the petitioner, Respondent No. 4 managed to get the aforesaid resolutions passed at the meetings of the Syndicate by exercising his influence on some members of the Syndicate. The contention of petitioner is that Respondent No. 4 had never applied for being awarded the degree of Doctor of Philosophy but had applied only for the degree of ‘Vachaspati’ that for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy under Ordinance No. 124, made under sec. 30 of the University of Rajputana Act, 1946, ‘a candidate for the degree of Ph.D must be an M.A, M.Sc M.Com, M.Ed, or M. Pharm and respondent No. 4 did not hold any of these degrees, and as such, could not be awarded the degree of Doctor of Philosophy under the aforesaid Act, that the petitioner pursued no research for being awarded the degree of Philosophy, that the petitioner carried on research, if any, for being awarded the degree of ‘Vachaspati’ which was not equivalent to the degree of Ph.D and that the petitioner could not be awarded even the degree of ‘Vachaspati’ as he had not submitted his thesis in Sanskrit but had submitted it in Hindi. The petitioner has claimed the right to file this writ petition on the ground that he was a registered graduate of the University of Rajasthan and was keenly interested in the affairs and good name of the University. To this writ the Syndicate and the Registrar of the aforesaid University were also made parties and are respondents Nos. 3 and 4 respectively. The petitioner has prayed that any appropriate writ, direction, or order be issued against the University of Rajasthan, or the Syndicate of the aforesaid University, and the Registrar by which they my be directed to withdraw the degree of the Doctor of Philosophy awarded to respondent No. 4. This writ petition was contested and by the University of Rajasthan and its authority and though Respondent No. 4 appeared at a late stage, yet we have permitted him to submit his reply. Respondents Nos. 1 to 3 submitted that there was no collusion with respondent No. 4 or bad motive in conferring the degree of Doctor of Philosophy on him on their part. Respondent No. 4 had the degree of Acharya which degree was equivalent to M.A in Sanskrit and had applied to carry on research for the conferment of the degree of ‘Vachaspati’, which degree was equivalent to the degree of Doctor of Philosophy as under Ordinance No. 329 the Ordinance and statutes which provided for conferment of the degree of Ph.D were applicable to cases for conferment of the degree of ‘Vachaspati’. The Oriental Faculty of the University became defunct and the thesis submitted by respondent No. 4 was sent to the examiners for conferment of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. The majority of the referees recommended that the said degree be conferred on him. It was under these circumstances that the said degree was conferred on the petitioner. It is also submitted on behalf of the University that it was an autonomous body and it was the sole judge of the fact as to whether a particular degree should be conferred on a particular person or not. It is also urged that no legal right of the petitioner was violated and he could not invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court for challenging the propriety of an act of an University in conferring the Ph.D degree on respondent No. 4. Respondent No. 4 has also taken the same defence. Page: 55It is urged on his behalf that the petitioner had an alternative remedy as he could have moved the University.

    4. The first point that arises for consideration is whether the petitioner has a right to file the present petition for the grant of writ of mandamus which, in our opinion, is the appropriate writ to be issued in case we agree with the contentions urged on behalf of the petitioner. As already mentioned, the petitioner is a registered graduate of the University of Rajasthan. He stated that under the provisions of the Act, he can elect members to the Senate who in their turn can elect members of the Syndicate which is the executive body of the University under sec. 21 of the University of Rajasthan Act. The petitioner is, however, not in a position to say that his personal right is in any way affected by the conferment of the degree on respondent No. 4. A Division Bench of this Court in Pratapmal v. The Income-Tax Officer, Jodhpur, Jodhpur Division (1), has observed, as follows:

    “Art. 226 is the counter-part of Art. 32, so far as the High Courts are concerned, and the trend of authorities in India also is that generally speaking it is only the person whose fundamental right has been infringed who can approach the court for relief. There is a well-known exception in the case of the writ of habeas corpus, and it may be that a similar exception might be made in the case of a writ of quo warranto. But so far as the writs of mandamus, prohibition, and certiorari are concerned, the authorities seem to lay down that only the person affected can approach the Court for relief.”

    5. Learned counsel for the petitioner has urged that the observations in the case were made in a case in which a writ of prohibition was prayed for and that those observations must be read with the facts of that case and should not be applied to a case like the present where the petitioner is challenging the act of the University which is clearly in disregard of the statute which the University was bound to obey. A number of decisions have been brought to our notice by the learned counsel for the parties. Learned counsel for the petitioner has cited the Municipal Corporation for the City of Bombay v. Govid Laxman Savant (2), Narendra Nath Chakravariy v. Corporation of Calcutta (3), while the learned counsel for the respondents has relied on Jatindra Mohan Sen Gupta in Re, (4), General Secretary, Eastern Zone Insurance Employees' Association v. Zonal Manager, Eastern Zone, Life Insurance Corporation (5), Indian Sugar Mills Association through its President Shri Hari Raj Swamp v. Secretary to Government, Uttar Pradesh Labour Department (6), In re. P. Rama-moorthi (7), Satya Prakash v. Commissioner, Land Reforms and Jagirs, M.B (8), Sita Vidyalya Nagpur v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Nagpur (9), Sri Durga Glass Works Ltd. Association through Ram Singh Kotwal v. State of U.P (10), Prem Narain Tandon v. State of U.P & Co. (11). The State of Orissa v. Madan Gopat Rungta (12) and Vice-Chancellor, Utkal University v. S.K Ghosh & Co. (13). We may also refer to the article entitled “Legal interest required to challenge the validity of Administrative action: (a Prel minary survey), by A.T Markose, Director of Research, Indian Law Institute Vol. I, No. 2, Page 273, After referring to Chiranjit Lal's case (14) and the Director of Endowment Government, Hyderabad v. Akram Ali (15), the learned author has observed that the Supreme Court has made out two propositions on the subject the first is that the interest of the applicant should be direct and the second is that the applicant should have a present interst.”

    6. After the arguments were heard in this case, two decisions of their Lordships of the Supreme Court also came to our notice. They are Kalyan Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (16), Dr. Rai Shivendra Bahadur v. Governing Body of the Nalanda College, Bihar Sha riff (17). In the first case it was observed at page 1188, para 14, that “a right to maintain such a petition (a petition under Art. 226), the words within brackets are ours, postulates a subsisting personal right in the claim which the petitioner makes and in the protection of which he is personalty interested.” In the second case, the petitioner Mr. D.P Srivastava was appointed the Principal of Nalanda College in March, 1953 which had been affiliated to the Bihar University in 1951 but the Government withdrew him on February 4, 1958 as he was a Government servant. The petitioner's appointment was terminated by the Governing Body of the College and respondent No. 4 in that writ petition was appointed the Principal. Mr. D.P Srivastava thereafter filed the writ petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution challenging the Page: 56validity of appointment of respondent No. 4 as Principal, on the ground that his appointment was never terminated and if there was any resolution to that effect, it was illegal and was void because of certain provisions in the University of Bihar Act, 1959 which had the force of law. Their Lordships dismissed the appeal filed against the order of the High Court dismissing the writ petition with the following observations:—

    “A great deal of controversy was raised before us as to whether the statutes framed by the University under sec. 20 of the University of Bihar Act have or have not the force of law and whether a writ under Art. 226 of the Constitution can issue against the Governing Body of the College, i.e whether the appellant has a legal right to the performance of a legal duty by the respondents. In order that other mandamus may issue to compel the respondents to do something it must be shown that the statutes impose a legal duty and the appellant has a legal right under the statutes to enforce its performance. It is, however, wholly unnecessary to go into or decide this question or to decide whether the statutes impose on the Governing Body of the College a duty which can be enforced by a writ of mandamus because assuming that the contention of the appellant is right that the College is a public body and it has to perform a public duty in the appointment of a Principal, it has not been shown that there is any right in the appellant which can be enforced by mandamns. According to the Statutes all appointments of teachers and staff have to be made by the Governing Body and no person can be appointed, removed or demo-tedexcept in accordance with Rules but the appellant has not shown that he has any right entitling him to get an order for appointment or reinstatement. Our attention has not been drawn to any Article in the Statutes by which the appellant has a right to be appointed or re-instated and if he has not that right he cannot come to Court and ask for a writ to issue. It is therefore not necessary to go into any other question.”

    7. The aforesaid observations clearly show that in order to maintain a writ for grant of mandamus the petitioner must show that there resides in him a right entitling him to compel the opposite party to act in a particular manner or to forbear from acting in a particular manner. In the absence of any such right the petition for the grant of mandamus cannot be allowed. In the case before us it cannot be said that the petitioner is an aggrieved person or has a right to compel the University to act in a particular manner. Giving him the credit that he is acting with the best of motives it cannot be said that the personal right of the petitioner is in any way affected by conferment of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy on Respondent No. 4. In our opinion, these two decisions of their Lordships of the Supreme Court clearly make it necessary that a petitioner who has filed a writ petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution, must show that his personal right has in any way been infringed by the act of the opposite parties. In view of these pronouncements of their Lordships of the Supreme Court, it is not necessary for us to enter into any further discussion on this point, or to survey all the authorities cited by the parties. We are, therefore, of the opinion that this writ petition is not maintainable.

    8. The writ petition, therefore, fails and it is therefore dismissed with costs. Only one set of costs is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kanhaiyalal v. The University Of Rajasthan
    (Sep 24, 1964)