Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging two orders: one dated 28.2.2012 by the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No. 2, Mandi, H.P. in CMA No. 13-VI/2012, and another dated 2.1.2014 by the Additional District Judge (II), Mandi, H.P. in Civil Misc. Appeal No. 10 of 2012. The petitioners contend that the respondent sold the land to them on 18.9.1996 by executing a registered sale deed and handing over possession. Despite this, after 16 years, the respondent obtained an interim injunction restraining the petitioners from raising construction on the land, on the ground that the suit land is in joint ownership and possession. The petitioners claim exclusive possession and that they have raised construction only on their half share. The respondent had filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction along with an application under Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC. The trial court and the appellate court granted injunction restraining the petitioners from raising construction as partition had not been carried out, and these orders are challenged before this court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a co-owner in joint possession can raise construction on the joint property without partition or consent of other co-owners.
  2. Whether the injunction restraining the petitioners from raising construction on the land was rightly granted and affirmed by the lower courts.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The respondent sold the land to them in 1996 through a registered sale deed and handed over possession.
  • They have exclusive possession of the purchased land since 1996.
  • They have only raised construction on their half share of the purchased land.
  • The respondent obtained an injunction after 16 years without filing any partition proceeding.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The suit land is in joint ownership and possession of both parties.
  • The injunction was sought to prevent the petitioners from raising construction on jointly owned land without partition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nagesh Kumar versus Kewal Krishan, AIR 2000 Himachal Pradesh 118 A co-sharer is entitled to injunction when another co-sharer threatens to appropriate joint land exclusively by construction. The court relied on this to affirm that a co-sharer cannot continue construction on joint property without consent or partition.
Shiv Chand versus Manghru & Ors., 2007 (1) SLJ (H.P) 641 A co-owner in joint possession cannot change the nature of the property without partition or consent of other co-owners. The court used this precedent to reject the argument that construction could be raised on a portion of joint property without partition.
Brij Lal versus Puran Chand, 2011 (1) Him.L.R. 80 Without partition or consent, a co-owner cannot raise construction on joint land; pending partition proceedings do not confer such right. The court cited this to emphasize the necessity of partition or consent before altering joint property by construction.
Sant Ram Nagina Ram Vs. Daya Ram Nagina Ram, AIR 1961 Punjab 528 Co-owners must not alter joint property without agreement or partition. Relied upon by the District Judge and affirmed by this court in dismissing appeal.
Prithi Singh Vs. Bachitar Singh, 1969 DLT 583 Supports the principle that co-owners cannot unilaterally change joint property. Used to support the dismissal of appeal against injunction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged the admitted fact that the parties are co-owners of the land. It reiterated the settled legal principle that each co-owner has rights over the entire property and possession by one co-owner is deemed possession by all. Consequently, one co-owner cannot alter the nature of the joint property to the detriment of others without partition or consent. The court relied on consistent precedents from this court and other authorities that affirm the entitlement of a co-owner to seek injunction against unauthorized construction by another co-owner on joint property. The court found no reason to deviate from these established principles. It held that the injunction granted by the trial court and affirmed by the appellate court was legally sound and justified, as no partition had been effected and no consent was given for construction by the petitioners. The court thus dismissed the petition, leaving parties to bear their own costs.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed.

The direct effect is that the injunction restraining the petitioners from raising construction on the jointly owned land without partition or consent is upheld. The decision does not set any new precedent but reinforces the established legal position regarding joint ownership and possession. The parties remain bound by the injunction, and the matter of partition remains to be addressed separately.

    Prabhu Nath & Anr. Petitioners v. Sushma

    Tarlok Singh Chauhan, J.

    1. The petitioners, by way of present petition, under article 227 of the Constitution of India, have prayed for the following relief:-

    That the impugned order dated 28.2.2012 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No. 2, Mandi, H.P. in CMA No. 13-VI/2012 (Annexure P-4) as well as order dated 2.1.2014 passed by the learned Additional District Judge (II), Mandi, H.P. in Civil Misc. Appeal No. 10 of 2012 (Annexure P-5), may very kindly be quashed and set-aside in view of the fact that the respondent on 18.9.1996 sold the land to the petitioners and handed-over the ownership and possession by executing a registered sale deed and spot map and now after lapse of 16 years, the respondent has obtained the interim injunction without filing any proceeding for partition on the ground that the suit land is in joint ownership and possession of the respondent as well as petitioners, whereas the petitioners are in exclusive possession from 18.9.1996 of the purchased land and they have raised construction only on half share of the purchased land.

    2. The petitioners are the defendants. The plaintiff-respondent filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction. Alongwith the same, an application, under order 39 rules 1 & 2 cpc for grant of injunction was also filed. Admittedly the parties are co-owners. The defendants-petitioners had purchased the suit land from the plaintiff and became joint owners in possession of the suit land. The defendants were restrained by an order of injunction from raising any construction as partition had not been carried out. It is this order of injunction granted by the trial court and as affirmed by the learned lower appellate court, that is in question before this court.

    3. Admittedly the parties are co-owners and it is settled that every co-owner has every right over each inch of land. The possession of one co-sharer is possession of all, and therefore, the co-sharer cannot change the nature of the suit land to the detriment of another co-owner unless the land is partitioned or can do so with the consent of other co-sharers. This view has been consistently followed in a number of judgments by this court.

    4. In Nagesh Kumar versus Kewal Krishan, AIR 2000 Himachal Pradesh 118, this court has held as under:-

    16. A co-sharer is entitled to claim injunction when another co-sharer threatens to exclusively appropriate joint land to himself to the detriment of other co-sharers by constructing a structure thereon.

    18. In a cause when a co-sharer has sued for permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the other co-sharer from raising any construction over the land jointly owned by them, it is not just and proper to permit the co-sharer against when the relief of injunction has been claimed, to continue/complete on construction of a house/structure on such land.

    5. In Shiv Chand versus Manghru & Ors., 2007 (1) SLJ (H.P) 641, this court has held as follows:-

    7. The view taken by the first appellate court that one of the persons in joint possession can raise construction on a portion of the joint property provided the area sought to be covered does not exceed his share, is contrary to the proposition of law. The law is very clear that a person in joint possession of immovable property cannot change the nature of the suit property unless the property is partitioned or the other persons in joint possession consent to such change in the nature of the property.

    6. In Brij Lal versus Puran chand 2011 (1) Him.L.R. 80, it has been held as under:-

    8. The partition proceedings are pending before the competent authority. Though the defendant as DW-1 has made reference about some family partition, however, he has neither given any date nor month or year when the family partition took place. He has admitted that the suit land measuring 11-12 bighas was joint of the parties. In his written statement, he has claimed not only that he was in exclusive possession, but also exclusive title to suit land to the exclusion of plaintiff and other co-sharers. Since the land in question has not been partitioned, the defendant could not be permitted to raise any construction thereon without working out any arrangement or with consent of the co-owners. If he wanted to raise any construction, he ought to have sought consent of the other co-owners since the land was joint. The learned District Judge has rightly relied upon Sant Ram Nagina Ram Vs. Daya Ram Nagina Ram, AIR 1961, Punjab, 528 and the judgment rendered by this Court in Prithi Singh Vs. Bachitar Singh, 1969 DLT 583 while dismissing the appeal.

    7. The aforesaid being the consistent view of this court, I see no reason to differ with the same and therefore, in view of the ratio laid down in these cases, no case for interference is made out and accordingly the present petition is dismissed leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

    _______________

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prabhu Nath & Anr. Petitioners v. Sushma
    (Jun 16, 2014)