AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, Jaimal Singh and his son Balwant Singh, were tenants occupying premises that formed part of an evacuee house as allottees under the Custodian. The house was sold by public auction and purchased by Shrimati Gini Devi; the sale was confirmed on 23-11-1957 and a sale certificate was subsequently issued on 30-05-1961. Gini Devi instituted ejectment proceedings against the petitioners on the ground of personal necessity by an application filed on 18-06-1960. The Rent Controller granted ejectment in favour of the purchaser and the Appellate Authority confirmed that order. The tenants raised, for the first time before the Appellate Authority, the defence that the house was evacuee property and that they were protected under Section 29 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act (a two-year protection against ejectment from the date of transfer). The Appellate Authority did not allow those points to be agitated because additional evidence would have been required. A revision petition was filed in this Court; a learned Single Judge (Falshaw, C.J.) referred the matter to a Division Bench because of conflicting views in earlier single-judge decisions as to when title passes to an auction-purchaser of evacuee property (date of confirmation of sale vs. date of issue of sale certificate). The Division Bench (P. C. Pandit, J., delivering the opinion) decided the matter on the admitted facts and dismissed the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. In an auction sale of evacuee property, when does title pass to the auction-purchaser: (a) from the date of confirmation of the sale in favour of the auction-purchaser, or (b) from the date of the issue of the sale certificate?
  2. Consequently, from which date does the two-year protection against ejectment under Section 29 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act run — from the confirmation date or from the date of issue of the sale certificate?
  3. Relatedly, from which date may an auction-purchaser recover rent from the tenant: from confirmation of sale or from the date of issue of the sale certificate (unless the Department authorises recovery from a later date)?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Tenants') Arguments

  • The tenants contended that the premises were part of evacuee property and that Shrimati Gini Devi was not the owner on the date she filed the ejectment application because the sale certificate had not yet been issued to her.
  • They further pleaded that they were protected by Section 29 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, which prohibits ejectment of occupants of evacuee property for a period of two years from the date of the transfer.

Respondent's (Purchaser / Landlord) Position

  • Smt. Gini Devi had purchased the house at public auction; the sale was confirmed on 23-11-1957 and the sale certificate was later issued on 30-05-1961. She instituted ejectment proceedings on grounds including personal necessity (the personal necessity ground was relied upon and not challenged before this Court by the tenants' counsel).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in this Opinion
Ranjit Singh v. Anup Singh, Civil Revision No. 524 of 1959 (D/- 3-8-1960) Held that title passes only on the issue of the sale certificate and that the two-year protection under Section 29 starts from that date. Noted as representing the contrary view (title passes on sale-certificate date); the Division Bench distinguished and declined to follow this approach, explaining the Supreme Court authority relied upon there did not decide that point.
Mohar Singh v. Mool Chand, 1963-65 Pun LR 253 Expressed the view that the sale certificate dates back to the date when sale was confirmed and that an auction-purchaser can sue to eject a tenant two years after the date of confirmation. Referred to as an authority taking the view that title (and the running of Section 29) is dated from confirmation of sale; the Division Bench accepted this line of reasoning and held title passes on confirmation.
Bishan Paul v. Mothu Ram, 1961-63 Pun LR 470 Khosla, C.J. held that title in evacuee property sold at auction passed when the sale was confirmed; sale certificate dated back to confirmation date; auction-purchaser recognised as owner from confirmation. The Division Bench cited and expressly agreed with this authority, adopting the principle that title passes on confirmation of sale and that the sale certificate relates back to that date.
Harkishan Lal v. Banstlal, 1952-54 Pun LR 55 Held that once the sale certificate was granted, the title to the auction-purchaser dated back to the date of confirmation of sale. Cited as supporting the view that confirmation date governs the title and protections; treated as consistent with the Division Bench's conclusion.
Harbans Singh v. Sohan Singh, 1962-64 Pun LR 834 Followed Bishan Paul and the view that sale certificate dates back to confirmation of sale. Expressly noted as following the confirmation-date approach; aligns with the Division Bench's view.
Bombay Salt and Chemical Industries v. L. J. Johnson, AIR 1958 SC 289 (Supreme Court) Supreme Court considered an appeal where sale certificate had not yet been issued; the Court accepted the position that until a sale certificate is granted nothing with effect from any date takes place; however, the Court did not decide the precise point whether issuance of sale certificate, when later given, operates retrospectively as of the auction date. The Division Bench examined these observations and concluded they do not support the view that title passes only on the date of issue of the sale certificate; relied on the distinction that the Supreme Court had not decided the precise retrospective-effect question.
Manohar Lal v. Rent Control and Eviction Officer, Bareilly, AIR 1959 All 388 Used in support (in other cases) of the proposition that sale is not complete until sale certificate under Rule 90 is issued; relied upon in some decisions reaching the sale-certificate date view. Noted as part of authorities adopting the sale-certificate-date view; the Division Bench did not find these authorities persuasive on the facts and reasoning applicable to the present case.
Hira Lal Khanna v. Gurcharan Singh, Civil Revision No. 461 of 1960 (D/- 30-3-1961) Held the two-year protection under Section 29 should be counted from the date of issue of the sale certificate. Recognised as taking the sale-certificate-date approach; the Division Bench discussed and disagreed with this view on the present facts and reasoning.
Motandas v. Gopaidas Basarmal, AIR 1962 Madh Pra 307 Held that the two-year period under Section 29 commences from the date on which the sale certificate was issued and not from the date of auction (citing Supreme Court authority in support in that decision). Noted as an authority adopting the sale-certificate-date approach; the Division Bench distinguished such authorities where no sale certificate had been issued or where the factual record differed.
Deputylal v. Collector of Nigris, AIR 1959 Mad 460 Relied upon in some decisions to support the sale-certificate-date view (as discussed in other judgments cited in the opinion). Cited in the course of surveying conflicting authorities; the Division Bench found the Supreme Court observations did not authoritatively decide the retrospective-effect issue relied upon by those cases.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Division Bench proceeded on the admitted factual matrix: auction in favour of the respondent on 26-12-1956, sale confirmed on 23-11-1957, sale certificate issued on 30-05-1961, and ejectment application filed on 18-06-1960. The court framed the central question as: when does title pass to the auction-purchaser — on confirmation of sale or on the issue of the sale certificate?

The court examined the statutory procedure in Rule 90 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Rules, 1955 and Appendix XXII (form of sale certificate). Rule 90 sets out the auction procedure: proclamation of sale, deposit by the highest bidder, approval of the bid by the Settlement Commissioner or an appointed officer, intimation to the bidder, and subsequent requirement to pay the balance within a specified period, failing which the deposit may be forfeited. Appendix XXII is a certificate form that declares the purchaser to be the purchaser "with effect from" a particular date mentioned in the certificate — the date on which the bid was accepted and the value paid (or adjusted).

From these provisions and the form, the court inferred that an auction-purchaser is declared to be the purchaser of the property as from the date specified in the sale certificate — a date which, in practice and in earlier decisions, has been treated as the date of confirmation of sale. The Division Bench noted that the sale certificate's form itself shows a declared effective date (in this case 23-11-1957).

The court surveyed conflicting case law. Several decisions (Bishan Paul, Harkishan Lal, Harbans Singh, and Mohar Singh) had held that title passes when the sale is confirmed and that the sale certificate, when issued, dates back to the confirmation date; these decisions supported the proposition that the two-year protection under Section 29 runs from the confirmation date. Other decisions (including Ranjit Singh and certain Allahabad, Madras and Madhya Pradesh decisions) had held that title passes only on the issue of the sale certificate and that the two-year protection commences from that later issuance date, some relying upon observations in the Supreme Court's Bombay Salt decision.

The Division Bench closely examined the Supreme Court observations in Bombay Salt and concluded that the Supreme Court had not decided the precise retrospective-effect question (i.e., whether, once actually issued, a sale certificate necessarily relates back to the date of auction/confirmation). The Bench held that the Supreme Court's observations did not support the proposition that title passes only on the issuance date of the sale certificate.

Concluding from the Rules, Appendix XXII, and the weight of authorities interpreting those provisions, the Division Bench held that the auction-purchaser becomes the recognised owner from the date on which the sale is confirmed (the date mentioned in the sale certificate), that the sale certificate ordinarily is issued later as a formal matter and dates back to that confirmation date, and that the protection afforded tenants under Section 29 therefore runs from the confirmation date. The court also explained the consequence for rent recovery: ordinarily, the landlord would be entitled to recover rent from the confirmation date, unless the Department authorises recovery from a later date, in which event recovery would begin from that authorised date.

The court also noted procedural points: the tenants had not raised these contentions before the Rent Controller (so additional evidence would have been required), but the Single Judge permitted them to raise the points in revision; the Division Bench decided the question on the admitted facts.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Division Bench concluded that title to evacuee property sold by public auction passes to the auction-purchaser from the date on which the sale is confirmed in his favour (the date stated in the sale certificate), and not merely from the later date of physical issuance of the sale certificate. Accordingly, the two-year protection against ejectment under Section 29 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act runs from the date of confirmation of sale.

DISPOSITION: The petition is dismissed and the ejectment order confirmed; the court ordered that the parties shall bear their own costs in this Court.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The ejectment order in favour of the auction-purchaser (Shrimati Gini Devi) was upheld because the ejectment application was filed after the two-year period counted from the confirmation date; the petitioners' challenge failed.
  • On rent recovery: Ordinarily, an auction-purchaser may recover rent from the date of confirmation of sale (subject to Departmental direction allowing a different commencement date).
  • On precedent and legal clarity: The Division Bench adopted and applied the line of authority that treats confirmation of sale as the operative date for transfer and Section 29 protection, and rejected, on the reasoning given, the view that title passes only on the date of issuance of the sale certificate. The opinion expressly analyzed and distinguished contrary single-judge decisions and the Supreme Court observations relied upon by them.

Disposition

Petition dismissed. Parties to bear their own costs in this Court.

    Jaimal Singh And Anothers, v. Gini Devi Alias Gini Bal .

    Judgement

    OF REFERENCE

    D. FALSHAW, C.J. :- The petitioners in this case Jaimal Singh and his son Balwant Singh are tenants against whom an order for ejectment passed by the Rent Controller in favour of the landlord Shrimati Gini Devi was upheld by the Appellate Authority.

    2. The premises in suit form part of a house which was evacuee property in which the tenants reside as allottees wider the Custodian. The house was sold by public auction and purchased by Shrimati Gini Devi, the sale in her favour being confirmed on the 23rd of November 1957 and the sale certificate confirming, her ownership as from that date being issued to her on the 10th of May 1961. She instituted proceedings against the present petitioners and other tenants on the ground of personal requirement on the 18th of June 1960.

    3. It seems that it was for the first time before the learned Appellate Authority that the tenants sought to raise the defence that the house was evacuee property and that the landlord was not the owner since the sale certificate had not yet been issued to her. As a matter of fact it had not on the date when the appeal was decided, it was also pleaded for the first time that the tenants were protected by Section 29 of the Displaced persons (Compensation and Re-habilitation) Act which prohibits the ejectment of occupants of evacuee property for a period of two years from me date of the transfer. Although wide powers are given to the Appellate Authority by Section 15(3) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act for holding further enquiry, it necessary, the learned Appellate Authority in this case did not allow these points to be agitated.

    4. These matters are of considerable importance as the points arise in a large number of cases between land-lords and tenants. There appears to be some contact between decisions of learned Single Judges of this Court on the question when a landlord who has purchased an-evacuee property can take steps to recover rent from or evict a tenant who was in occupation as an allottee under the Custodian. In Ranjit Singh v. Anup Singh, Civil Revn. S. No. 524 of 1959, D/-3-8-1960 (Punj) D.K. Manajan, J. has held that the title in the property only passes on the issue or the sale certificate and that the two years protection given under Section 29 of the Displaced Persons (compensation and Rehabilitation) Act only starts from that date, but the view has teen expressed in other cases that in an auction sale of evacuee property even, when a sale certificate is issued later it dates back to the date when the sale was confirmed in favour of the auction-purchaser and that an auction-purchaser can sue to eject tenant two years after the date of the confirmation of the sale. One such decision is Mohar Singh v. Mool Chand, 1963-65 Pun LR 253 where I nave taken that view. It is obviously desirable that these points should be settled, by a larger Bench and accordingly order that this case be laid before a Division Bench.

    JUDGMENT OF DIVISION BENCH

    5. P. C. PANDIT, J. :- This is a tenants petition against the order 01 the Appellate Authority confirming the decision of the Hem Controller ejecting them from the premises in Dispute.

    6. Smt. Gini Devi purchased these premises, which formed part of an evacuee house, in which the petitioners resided as allottees under the Custodian. The house was sold by public auction on 26-12-1956. The sale was confirmed on 23-11-1957 and the sale certificate was issued on 30-5-1961. In the meantime, on 18-5-1960 she filed an application for the ejectment of these petitioners under the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act on the grounds or personal necessity and some other grounds, which were not pressed Before the Appellate Authority.

    7. Both the Rent controller and the Appellate Authority have decided the case in her favour.

    8. Before the Appellate Authority, the petitioners, for the first time, sought to raise the defence that the house, of which the premises in dispute formed a part, was evacuee property and Smt. Gini Devi was not the owner thereof on the date when she filed the application for ejectment, because the sale certificate was issued to her on 30-5-1961. It was also pleaded that they were protected by the provisions of Section 29 of the Displaced Persons (compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954 (Hereinafter referred to as the Act), which prohibited their ejectment for a period of two years from the date of the transfer of the property in favour of Smt. Gini Devi. The Appellate Authority, However, did not allow them to agitate these grounos.

    9. The tenants then filed a revision in this court, which came up for hearing before Falshaw, C.J. The learned Judge was of the opinion that there was some contact between the decisions of learned Single judges of this Court on the question as to when could a landlord, who had purchased an evacuee property, take steps to recover rent from or evict a tenant, who was in occupation as an allottee under the Custodian. Mahajan, J. in Civil Revn. No. 524 of 1959, D/-3-8-1960 (Punj), held that the title in the property passed only on the issue of the sale certificate and the two years protection given under Section 29 of the Act only started from that date. On the other liana, there were decisions which took the view that in an auction-sale or evacuee property, the auction-purchaser could file an application for ejectment two years after the date of the conformation of sale in his favour, even though the sale certificate was issued to him some time later, because the sale certificate dates back to the date when the sale was commend. Reference in this connection was made to the learned Judges own decision in 1963-65 Pun LR 253. In view of this conflict, the case was referred to a Division Bench for decision. That is how, this revision has been placed before us.

    10. I may mention that the learned counsel for the petitioners did not argue the point regarding personal necessity and did not challenge the finding of the Appellate Authority regarding the same. The only point that was taken by me learned counsel was the one which has been mentioned in the referring order.

    11. It is noteworthy that the point on the basis or which the learned Single Judge has referred this case was not taken by the petitioners before the Rent controller the same had been agitated there, all the relevant facts would have come on the record. It is true that this point was raised before the Appellate Authority but he refused to go into this matter, because it could not be decided without taking additional evidence. The petitioners had neither challenged in the written statement the status of the respondent as the landlord of the premises nor had they raised the plea that they were protected under the provisions of Section 29 of the Act, but since the learned Single Judge in this Court in revision permitted them to raise this point, we will decide this case on the facts which are admitted by the counsel for both the parties, namely, that the auction in favour of the respondent took place on 26-12-1956 the sale was confirmed on 23-11-1957, the sale certificate was issued on 30-5-1961, and the application for ejectment had been filed on 18-6-1960.

    12. The main point for decision is that in such a case when does the title in the property pass to the auction-purchaser ? Is it from the date of the issue of the sale certificate or is it from the confirmation of the sale in favour of the auction-purchaser ? I may at once state that the expression "confirmation of sale" does not occur in the Displaced Persons (compensation and Reanimation) Rules, 1955 (Hereinafter referred to as the Rules), the procedure with regard to the sale of the property by public auction is given in Rule 90. Briefly, it is that first of an a proclamation of sale is issued, wherein various particulars of the property to be sold are mentioned. At the time of the sale, the person giving the highest bid has to deposit a sum not exceeding 10 per cent of the amount of his bid, mis bid is subject to the approval of the Settlement commissioner or an officer appointed by them for this purpose. Intimation of the approval of the bid or its rejection has to be given to the highest bidder by registered post and where the bid has been accepted, he is required within 15 days in the receipt of that intimation to produce before the settlement Commissioner or any other officer appointed by him for this purpose, a treasury Chelan in respect of the deposit of the balance of the purchase money. This period of is days can in suitable cases be extended, it may be mentioned that the balance of the purchase money can also be adjusted against the compensation, if any, payable to the auction-purchaser or against the compensation payable to any other person holding a verified claim, who is wining to associate himself with the auction-purchaser in the purchase of the property, it the auction-purchaser does not deposit the balance of the purchase money within the specified period, then the initial deposit made by him is liable to forfeiture and he shall not have any claim to the property. On the other hand, in a case, where the purchase price has been realised in full from the auction-purchaser, the Managing Officer shall issue to him a sale certificate in the form specified in appendix XXII or XXIII of the Rules, as the case may be. It the auction-purchaser is a displaced person and has associated with himself other displaced persons for purchasing this property, the sale certificate shall be made jointly in the name of all such persons am it shall also specify the extent of interest of each of them in the property. Appendix XXII is the form of the certificate or sale with regard to freehold properties. It is as follows :

    "APPENDIX XXII

    certificate of sale,

    Freehold properties

    Rule 90 (15).

    This is to certify that -------- having given the highest bid at a sale by public auction held in pursuance of the powers conferred upon me under Section 20 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954 (44 of 1954) on the ----------day of ----- 195___, of the property described in schedule and his bid having been accepted and the value thereof having been paid by him in cash/by adjustment of compensation due on his associates claims has been declared the purchaser of the said property with effect fron the --------pay of --------195 .

    The property, the compensation of which has been adjusted against the value of this property was mortgagee with Shri -----------son of ---------- in West Pakistan and or Shri --------- the purchaser had obtained a debt of Rs.-----of shri ------- S/o -------- in west Pakistan, the said mortgagee/ creditor has obtained a decree for Rs. -------from the Tribunal constituted under the Displaced Persons (Depts Adjustment) Act, 1951, the intimation of which has been received by the Chief Settlement commissioner from the Tribunal concerned. The mortgagee/creditor would, therefore, have a lien over this property to the extent of mortgage charge/debt or Rs. ------ according to me provisions of the above Act, until the mortgage charge/debt is satisfied or is redeemed by the mortgagor/debtor.

    Given under my hand and seat of my office, this-------------- day -------------- of -------.

    SCHEDULE

    Signature

    Name

    Designation of the Officer."

    13. This Rule and the form, Appendix XXII, would indicate that the auction-purchaser is declared the purchaser of the property after his bid has been accepted and the value thereof has been paid by him either in cash or by adjustment of compensation. That date is mentioned in the sale certificate. The Form clearly prescribes that with effect from that particular date, the auction-purchaser is declared to be the purchaser of the said property, in this present case, this date is 23-11-1957. Learned counsel for me petitioners however, submitted that this date was the date of the approval of the bid and, as such, the landlord could not fie deemed to be the owner of the property on us date. It was only on the issue of the sale certificate, namely, 30-5-1961, that she became the owner thereof thus, scoring to the learned counsel for the petitioners, the confirmation of the sale in favour of the auction-purchaser merely means the approval of the bid given by her. It is common, ground that 23-11-1957 is the date mentioned in the sale certificate, with effect from which Smt. Gini Devi has been declared to be the purchaser of the property in dispute. Since this point, as already mentioned above, was not raised by the petitioners before the Rent Controller, it cannot be positively decided as to from which date the Department declares the auction-purchaser to be the owner of the property. Presumably, it is the date after he has laid the balance of the price on the bid having been approved by the officer concerned. This date has been generally taken to be the date of confirmation of sale in the various decisions of this Court. In my view, this is the date from which the auction-purchaser is said to have become the owner of the property. The sale certificate may be issued later on, but effect to the sale would have to be given from this date, It follows, therefore, that such an auction-purchaser can file an application for the eviction of a tenant after this date and the protection to the tenant from eviction under Section 29 of the Act for a period of two years is also from this very date, in other words, me order of eviction will be passed against the tenant only after the expiry of two years from this date, though the auction-purchaser may tile an application for ejectment after this date.

    14. So far as the recovery of rent is concerned, ordinarily, the landlord would be entitled to recover rent from this very date, but if in any particular case the Department authorises him to receive the same from an earner elate, inert it is from that date that he would be able to recover the same.

    15. In Bishan Paul v. Mothu Ram, 1961-63 Pun LR 470 G.D. Khosla, C.J. held that the title in evacuee property put to auction by a competent officer passed when the sale was confirmed, because it was that date on Which the auction-purchaser was recognised officially as the owner and was entitled to obtain possession of the property. When a sale certificate was issued, it dated back to the date when the sale was confirmed, therefore, failure of the tenant to pay rent to the auction purchaser from the date of confirmation rendered him liable to ejectment, similarly in Harkishan Lal v. Banstlal, 1952-54 Pun LR 55, the same learned Judge held that once the sale certificate was granted, the title to the auction-purcheser dated back to the date of the confirmation of the sale. This authority was followed by Shamsher Bahadur, J. in Harbans Singh v. Sohan Singh, 1962-64 Pun LR 834. Bishan Pauls case, 1961-63 Pun LR. 470 was followed by Falshaw, C.J. in 1953-65 Pun LR 253, where it was observed that in an auction-sale of evacuee property even when a sale certificate was issued later, it dated back to the date when the sale was confirmed in favour of the auction-purchaser and he could sue to eject the tenant two years after the date of continuation of sale.

    16. A contrary view was however, taken by Manajan, J. in Civil Revn. No. 524 of 1959 D/-3-8-1960 (Punj), where the learned Judge relying on Bombay salt and Chemical industries v. L.J. Johnson, AIR 1958 SC 289, held that title to the property passed to the auction-purchaser on the date when the sale certificate was issued in his favour and not before, it may be mentioned that the Supreme Court decision was considered by Khosla, C.J. in Bishan Pauls case, 1961-63 Pun, LR 470 and it was observed as under -

    "In that case some evacuee property was in possession of the Bombay Salt and Chemical industries. The property was put up to sale and was purchased by Parvatibai wadhumal and Kakanbai Tulsimal who were respondents in the proceedings before the Supreme Court. Before the sale certificate could be issued, the Managing Officer of because Property took steps to evict the occupiers. He actually ejected them and put the auction purchasers into possession. The previous occupiers then filed an appeal to the supreme Court from the order of the Chief settlement commissioner evicting them and putting the auction purchasers into possession. The argument raised before the Supreme Court was that since no sale certificate had been issued in favour of the auction-purchasers, title had not passed to them and the right to evict the occupiers vested with Managing officer. This argument was accepted and the appeal of the aggrieved tenants was rejected. In the concluding portion of their judgment, their Lordships observed.

    Mr. Purshotam Trikamdas contended that the certificate will in any event be granted and that once it is granted, as the form of this certificate snows, the transfer will relate back to the date of the auction. It is enough to say in answer to this contention that assuming it to be right, a point which is by no means obvious and which we do not decide, till it is granted, no transfer with effect from any date whatsoever takes place and none has yet been granted.

    Two things are quite clear from these observations, (1) that their Lordships had not before them the question of whether title passes only on the date when the sale certificate is granted because in that case the sale certificate had not yet been granted. In the second place, their Lordships quite clearly and unequivocally stated that they were not deciding the point raised by counsel before them. There is, therefore, nothing whatsoever in the observations of their Lordships of the Supreme Court to support the view that when a sale certificate is actually issued, it is the date of Issue which is the date on which title passes to the auction-purchaser. In my view, title passes when the sale is confirmed, because it is that date on which the auction-purchaser is recognised officially as the owner and is entitled to obtain possession of the property, the issue of the sale certificate is invariably delayed because certain routine formalities have to be complied with and it is in very rare cases that an office can be so prompt as to issue the sale certificate on the very day the sale is confirmed. But when a sale certificate is issued, it dates back to the date when the sale was confirmed."

    17. I am in respectful agreement with the view by the learned Chief Justice and, therefore, this authority does not support the view that the title in the property passes to the auction-purchaser on the date of the issue of the sale certificate only and not from the date of the confirmation of sale in his favour, Besidies, in Kanjit Singhs case, Civil Revn. No. 524 of 1959 D/-3-8-1960 (Punj) this precise point was not before the learned Judge, because there on one date, that is, 22-11-1956, the sale was confirmed as well as the sale certificate was issued in favour of the auction-purchaser. In Hira Lal Khanna v. Gurcharan Singh, Civil Revn. No. 461 of 1960, D/- 30-3-1961 (punj), Gosain, J. also took the view that it was from the date or the issue of the sale certificate that two years had to be counted under Section 29 of the Act for giving protection to the tenant. This view was based on. the Supreme Court ruling mentioned above and Manohar Lal v. Rent control and Eviction Officer, Bareilly, AIR 1959 All 388. For the reasons stated above, the Supreme Court decision does not Help the present petitioners case. In the Allahabad case, J.K. Tondon, J. had field that the sale did not become complete until The sale certificate under Rule 90 of the Rules was issued. In that case, the sale certificate had not been issued and only the bid made by the auction-purchaser was accepted. Moreover, there was no date mentioned on which the auction-purchaser had been declared to be the purchaser of the property. The learned Judge was only considering the date of the auction and the date with effect from which the Department had asked the tenants to attorn to the auction-purchaser. As against these two dates, the learned Judge held that the date of the issue of the sale certificate was the correct date from which two years protection to the tenant within the meaning of section 29 or the act should start.

    18. In Motandas v. Gopaidas Basarmal, AIR 1962 Madh Pra 307 it was held by S.B. Sen, J. that the period of two yeans, to which the displaced persons were entitled under Section 29 of the Act, started from the date on which the sale certificate was issued and not from the date of auction. In this case, again, reliance was placed en the Supreme Court decision, which has already been discussed above, and Deptylal v. Collector of Nigris, AIR 1959 Mad 460. In the Madras authority, Balakrisnna Ayyar, J. had also placed reliance on this very Supreme court ruling. Moreover, in that case, no sale certificate had at all been issued.

    19. In the present case, as already mentioned above, the Department had declared the landlord to be the purchaser of the property with effect from 23-11-1957 and the application for ejectment, having been filed on 18-6-1960, was in order.

    20. The result is that this petition tails and is dismissed. In the circumstances of this case, however, I will leave the parties to bear their own costs in this court.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jaimal Singh And Anothers, v. Gini Devi Alias Gini Bal .
    (Sep 26, 1963)