Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 302, under section 304,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 302, under section 304,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (M.L. Koul, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 7-12-1988 at about 2:30 P.M., in Main Bazar, Balispaur, the deceased Baljit Singh alias Hukam Chand (age 21) tore a newspaper in the shop of the appellant/accused Pawan Kumar. This provoked the accused, who slapped and punched the deceased and then, picking up a knife from his shop counter, inflicted a knife blow on the left side of the deceased's chest. The deceased fell; Jai Pal (PW-10, the complainant) and Raj Kumar (PW-11) and others brought him to hospital. PW-6 (Ram Karan), PW-7 (Ram Piara) and PW-8 (Dharam Pal) were attracted to the scene by noise and were also injured by the accused with the knife. The accused later produced the knife during investigation, and the police took it into possession.

On completion of investigation both accused (Pawan Kumar and Om Prakash) were challaned. At trial: - Pawan Kumar was convicted under Sections 302 and 324 IPC and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life under Section 302 and six months under Section 324, both sentences to run concurrently. - The trial court did not proceed with trial under the relevant provision of the Arms Act because there was no sanction under Section 27 of the Arms Act. - Om Prakash was acquitted of the charges.

The matter came before the court on appeal; counsel for the appellant was Mr. R. S. Ghai, Senior Advocate, and the respondent-State was represented by Mr. N. K. Sanghi, Deputy Advocate General, Haryana.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant's conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC was sustainable, or whether the facts and circumstances of the case fell within Exception IV to Section 300 IPC thereby attracting conviction under Section 304, Part II IPC.
  2. Whether the required elements for Clause (thirdly) of Section 300 IPC (i.e., intention to cause bodily injury which is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death) were proved so as to justify conviction under Section 300(3) rather than a lesser offence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)

  • Counsel for the accused (Mr. Ghai) contended that two important eyewitnesses, PW-10 (Jai Pal, the complainant) and PW-11 (Raj Kumar), who were said to have witnessed the occurrence, turned hostile and stated that in their presence no crime was committed by the accused. This, it was argued, undermined the prosecution case.
  • The defence further argued that because PW-10, PW-11 and the three injured witnesses were present at the scene, they could have overpowered the accused and prevented him from inflicting injuries on PW-6 to PW-8; the implication being that the accused could not have caused the injuries as alleged or that the sequence of events was inconsistent with the prosecution story.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent-State's legal arguments beyond the representation of counsel being present.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the evidence and proceeded through the following analytical steps, as set out in the opinion:

  1. Credibility and corroboration of witnesses: The court acknowledged that PW-10 and PW-11 had turned hostile on some points, but found that even they broadly corroborated key elements of the prosecution story — that the deceased had torn a newspaper, that an FIR was lodged by PW-10, and that the deceased was brought to hospital. The court treated their partial hostility as not negating their presence at the scene or the truth of the core events.
  2. Testimony of injured witnesses: PW-6, PW-7 and PW-8 (Ram Karan, Ram Piara, Dharam Pal) consistently stated that they were attracted by the noise and sustained knife injuries while attempting to apprehend the accused. Their medical examinations and injury reports supported these claims.
  3. Forensic/medical evidence: The post-mortem and medical evidence (notably Dr. Naveen Sabarwal, PW-4) described a penetrating wound on the left side of the chest that traversed into the left ventricle and communicated with the pleural cavity; this injury was ante-mortem and sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. Dr. J. R. Bansal (PW-5) proved the injuries on the other three injured persons.
  4. Recovery of weapon and disclosure: The accused made a disclosure during investigation and produced the knife, which was taken into possession by police. The weapon corresponded to the wounds.
  5. Assessment of intention and legal classification of homicide: The court examined whether the act fell under clause (thirdly) of Section 300 IPC (requiring intention to cause a bodily injury that is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death) or whether Exception IV to Section 300 applied (sudden and grave provocation, heat of passion). The court explained the legal elements that prosecution must prove to bring the case within clause (thirdly).
  6. Application of facts to legal standards: Considering the trivial provocation (tearing of a newspaper), the absence of premeditation or ill-will, the single knife blow, and the spontaneous nature of the altercation, the court concluded that the accused acted on the spur of the moment in heat of passion. Although the accused knew that his act was likely to cause death, he did not possess the specific intention required for clause (thirdly) of Section 300.
  7. Conclusion of analysis: On this factual matrix, the court held that Exception IV to Section 300 applied, bringing the conduct within the ambit of Section 304 Part II IPC rather than murder under Section 302. The court therefore found it appropriate to modify the conviction and sentence accordingly. The separate conviction and sentence under Section 324 IPC for injuries to other persons remained intact.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court modified the conviction: the accused's conviction under Section 302 IPC was changed to a conviction under Section 304, Part II IPC, with the sentence altered to rigorous imprisonment for 10 years for that offence. The concurrent sentence under Section 324 IPC (six months) was left unmodified.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The appellant's conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC was reduced to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part II IPC; the substantive punishment was reduced to 10 years' rigorous imprisonment for that count. The sentence under Section 324 IPC remains in force. The appeal otherwise failed and was dismissed.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent; it applied existing legal principles regarding sudden provocation, heat of passion, and the distinctions between clauses of Section 300 and Exception IV to that section to the facts of this case. The judgment modifies the conviction and sentence in light of that application.

Final Order (as recorded in the opinion): Except for the modification substituting conviction under Section 304, Part II IPC in place of Section 302 IPC (with the attendant sentence of rigorous imprisonment for 10 years), the appeal fails and is dismissed.

    Pawan Kumar v. State Of Haryana

    M.L.Koul, J.:-

    (1) Unfortunately on a trifle issue one youth of 21 years, lost his life when the while reading a newspaper on the watch and cycle shop of the appellant (hereinafter referred to as the accused) pawan kumar, at main bazar, balispaur, by chance tore it out which caused annoyance to the accused who gave slaps and fists to the deceased baljit singh alias hukam chand at 2. 30 p. M. On 7 - 12 - 1988. He not being satisfied with that and not ready to receive the cost of the paper gave a knife blow on the left side of his chest which was picked up by him from the counter of his shop. His father also reached on the spot and while giving beating to the deceased instigated the accused to commit the crime saying that "mar de dekha jagia" on receipt of such a knife blow the deceased could fall down but p. Ws. 10 and 11 jai pal (the complainant) and raj kumar held him up and brought him to the hospital. On hearing noise pws. 6, 7 and 8 namely ram karan, ram piara and dharam pal respectively were attracted on the spot and these all the three persons also got injured by the accused with the knife. These three people were also medically examined and the post mortem on the dead body of the deceased was conducted and the inquest report was prepared by the police. During the investigation, the accused pawan kumar produced the knife which was taken into possession by the police.

    (2) On completion of the investigation both the accused were challaned. Accused pawan kumar on trial was convicted for the offences under sections 302 and 324 of the indian penal code and was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life under section 302 and ri for six months under sections 324 of the indian penal code. Both these sentences were ordered to run concurrently. As there was no sanction for his trial under section 27 of the arms act, therefore, the trial court did not proceed with the trial of the accused and left it open to be tried by a competent court of law. The other accused om prakash who too was charged for the offences under sections 302 and 324 of the indian penal code was acquitted of the charge.

    (3) Heard mr. R. S. Ghai, sr. Advocate, for the appellant and mr. N. K. Sanghi, deputy advocate general haryana for the respondent - state also bestowed our thoughtful consideration over the record on the file.

    (4) At the out set it is not out of place to mention here that no acquittal appeal has been preferred by the prosecution against the other accused om prakash, rightly so because there was no evidence which established that he in any manner was an accomplice or abetted the commission of crime of murder by his son pawan kumar.

    (5) Mr. Ghai, representating the accused argued that the two important eye witnesses pws 10 and 11 jai pal (complainant) and raj kumar who as per the prosecution witnessed the occurrence with their own eyes turned hostile and stated that in their presence no crime was committed by the accused. This argument of mr. Ghai is belied simply on the ground that even these two witnesses have corroborated the prosecution story about the correctness of the occurrence in which a young man (the deceased) was done away whose only fault was that he tore out some newspaper while reading it by chance and was ready to pay its cost to the accused. On the evidence of the prosecution it is found that the accused pawan kumar who is a short tempered man was unable to control his emotion on a trifle issue, abused the deceased, went out of control and being not satisfied with the beating of the deceased struck him with a knife blow which caused his death after - wards. After the occurrence he tried to run away. Pws 6 to 8 namely ram karan, ram piara and dharam pal tried to catch hold of him but he caused injuries to them as well. Thereafter, the deceased and the above said injured were brought to the hospital and on medical examination it was found that they had sustained injuries with a knife. Also the knife blow caused on the body of the deceased in the ordinary course of nature was sufficient to cause his death. All the three witnesses have deposed that while trying to catch hold of the accused, he caused injuries on their persons also.

    (6) The contention of the learned counsel for the accused is that as the complainant pw 10, the other witness pw 11 and the three injured witnesses were present on the spot, they could easily over - power him as a result of which disable him to cause injuries on pws. 6 to 8. This argument of the learned counsel for the accused is out of context for the fact that even the hostile witnesses stated that pws 6 to 8 sustained injuries in theincident in which the deceased was injured. It implies and is found that this witness and the complainant were present on the spot and they have witnessed the occurrence with their eyes. Once these three injured people by co - incidence on noise were attracted on the spot they were not supposed to be armed with any weapon and that was the reason that they could not over power the accused who being armed with a knife caused injuries on their persons as well.

    (7) In every criminal case the statements of prosecution witnesses suffer from contradictions but once the court is satisfied that the occurrence has taken place, the witnesses are truthful, their evidence is without motive and they speak without any prejudice against the accused their veracity is to be given full credence or weightage in favour of the prosecution.

    (8) In the present case it is found that the occurrence has taken place in which the deceased lost his life at the hands of the accused that too at the spur of the moment on a paltry object that a newspaper was torn out by him belonging to the accused while he was reading it. There is the disclosure statement of the accused proved in the case whereby the weapon of offence has been recovered from his possession which in the opinion of the doctor was sufficient to cause injuries on the person of the deceased. The injury no. 1 is reproduced as under : -

    "penetrating wound 2. 5 cms x 0. 7 cms x probe passing very deep on the left side of chest in third inter costal stage 5 cm lateral to mid line. On dissection the wound was penetrating into inter costal muscles cutting the upper lobe of the lung in its lower part on medial size passing through the pericardium and penetrating into left ventricle crossing it on posterior side cutting the pericardium posteriorly and communicating with the plural cavity. The corresponding hole was present on the clothes."

    This injury as per the statement of dr. Naveen sabarwal pw 4, was ante mortem in nature and was sufficient to cause death of the deceased in the ordinary course of nature. Accordingly pw 5 dr. J. R. Bansal has proved the injuries sustained by the other three victims in the incident.

    (9) Again the argument of mr. Ghai that pw 10 who turned hostile did not support the prosecution story, is not sustainable for the fact that although this witness turned hostile but broadly admitted that the first information report was lodged by him with the police and he was told on the spot by raj kumar that the accused had given knife injury on the deceased. He admitted that the said deceased was brought to the hospital by him and raj kumar pw 11 and made the report with the police as well. Although he tried to save the accused saying that he did not witness the occurrence with his own eyes but admitted the factum of the occurrence that the accused had run away from the spot after committing the crime. It indicates that the witness was present on the spot and the report made by him with the police is correct in letter and spirit. Thus, there is no delay in lodging the report with the police and no ground is made up for the defence to claim that the first information report was lodged by the prosecution after due deliberation and consultation and the accused was falsely involved when he had not committed the crime.

    (10) There is no defence led by the accused that he did not commit the murder. His denial is simpliciter in nature and in no manner can absolve himself of the liability of having committed the murder of the deceased. On all fours it is found that the accused who is very emotional and stiffy in nature on a non - existent matter got infuriated on the action of the deceased who by chance tore out his newspaper while reading it, hurled abuses on him and gave a blow with a knife on his chest which resulted into his death. As he became afraid that he would be over - powered by the other persons present on the spot, he ran away and while on run who - so - ever came in his way he inflicted injuries on him, as a result of which three people got injured and he ran away from the spot. Ultimately, during the investigation good sense prevailed upon him, he produced the weapon of offence before the police and on trial was found that he committed the murder of the deceased and as such was convicted and sentenced for offences under sections 302 and 324 of the indian penal code for having caused injuries to the deceased and to the other persons as well, which were grievous in nature.

    (11) In the peculiar circumstances of the case it is to be seen whether the case of the accused would be covered under exception iv to section 300 or under clause thirdly of the said section. The essential elements to be proved by theprosecution to prove the case under clause thirdly of section 300 are that : (1) that the act which causes the death was done with the intention of causing a bodily injury; and (ii) that the injury intended to be inflicted is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. Otherwise, the offence could be culpable homicide not amounting to murder. There are catena of rulings from the apex court on the subject that where the evidence clearly establishes that the whole incident was a sudden development and the accused had acted on the spur of the moment and without any pre - meditation, there had been no ill - will or enmity between the two, the case cannot be covered under clause thirdly of section 300 of i. P. C.

    (12) Looking at the totality of the evidence it would not be possible to come to the conclusion that when the accused struck the deceased with the knife he intended to cause such bodily injury as was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause his death. A casual dispute which arose with regard to the turning out a newspaper by the deceased provoked the accused and some altercation ensued which culminated into stabbing with knife. The accused used the knife only once and did not act in any cruel manner. It was a sudden quarrel in heat of passion that the accused inflicted injury on the person of the deceased without any intention to cause death but having knowledge that such act was likely to cause the death of the deceased. In such circumstances the act of the accused falls under exception iv to section 300, ipc and the accused is liable to be convicted only under section 304, part ii, ipc and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years. With regard to the other sentence awarded to him under section 324 of the indian penal code, there is no modification.

    (13) Except for the above modification with regard to the change of conviction and sentence upon the accused instead of section 302, under section 304, part ii, ipc the appeal fails and is dismissed. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pawan Kumar v. State Of Haryana
    (Mar 20, 1997)