AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 120 of the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd. (Staff) Rules, 1980, Rule 24 of the Assam Services (Disciplinary and Appeals) Rules, 1964
  • provisions of the Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 1949.
  • sub-rule (2) Rule 10 of Order 1 CPC
  • provisions of Order 1 Rule 10
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • Rule 9 of the Govt. Rules,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 120 of the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd. (Staff) Rules, 1980, Rule 24 of the Assam Services (Disciplinary and Appeals) Rules, 1964
  • provisions of the Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 1949.
  • sub-rule (2) Rule 10 of Order 1 CPC
  • provisions of Order 1 Rule 10
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • Rule 9 of the Govt. Rules,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal was filed by the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd., a banking society registered under the provisions of the Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 1949. The respondent (an employee of the Bank) filed a title suit, TS No. 96 of 1986, before the Munsiff No. 1, Goalpara. The trial Court dismissed the suit. The defendant (respondent in this appeal) had originally sued the Chairman, Administrative Council and Board of Directors of the Bank, the Managing Director and the Branch Manager (defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 respectively), but the Bank itself was not made a party in the suit.

Facts relevant to the dispute: the respondent was appointed as an Office Assistant in 1958, promoted to Sub Accountant in 1977, transferred in 1979 to be in charge of Abhayapuri Branch, and placed under suspension on 16.9.1980. A departmental enquiry on six charges was conducted; the respondent and another employee were found guilty of charges Nos. 1, 3 and 4. The disciplinary authority (the Managing Director) accepted the enquiry findings and imposed the punishment of reversion of rank from Sub Accountant to Assistant. The respondent challenged the orders (dated 9.11.81 and 17.3.86) as void and illegal and sought a declaration that he continued in service as Sub Accountant.

The trial Court framed three issues (cause of action; whether the demotion was illegal; entitlement to relief) and after evidence dismissed the suit. The lower appellate Court (District Judge, Goalpara) set aside the trial Court and decreed the suit (TA No. 32 of 1988). The Bank has preferred this second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of a necessary party (the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd.) when the Chairman, Managing Director and Branch Manager were impleaded but the Bank itself was not.
  2. Whether a body corporate (the Bank) that is not a party to the suit can nevertheless prefer an appeal (i.e., maintainability of the present appeal by the Bank) because it will be prejudicially affected by the decree.
  3. Whether the disciplinary order of reversion of rank (reduction from Sub Accountant to Assistant) was illegal — specifically whether there was violation of principles of natural justice or malafide in the departmental enquiry and award of punishment.
  4. Whether the punishment imposed was disproportionate to the charges proved (i.e., the appellate Court's assessment of proportionality and the correctness of that assessment).
  5. Whether any delay in disposal of the internal appeal (the appellate authority's decision after approximately three years) rendered the reduction of rank illegal, and if so which rules apply (the Bank's staff rules vs. Government service rules).

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • Urged that because the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd. was not a party before either the trial Court or the lower appellate Court, the present appeal was not maintainable; other defendants had not been impleaded as appellants or proforma respondents.
  • Contended it was the duty of the plaintiff to select the proper parties, but also argued that a duty was cast on the Court and on defendants to make necessary parties; cited High Court decisions (AIR 1985 NOC 204 (Cal), AIR 1977 NOC 340 (MP)) to support the procedural point.
  • Relied on authorities (including a Patna High Court decision, AIR 1981 Patna 77 — Smt. Phulpati Devi v. Parameswar Rai) that a suit cannot continue without necessary parties.
  • Raised that Rule 120 of the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank (Staff) Rules, 1980 and Rule 24 of the Assam Services (Disciplinary and Appeals) Rules, 1964 would require the appellate authority to decide within three months and noted the appellate decision had been taken after about three years (arguing prejudicial delay).

Appellant's (Bank's) Arguments

  • Contended (and the Court considered) that although the Bank was not impleaded in the original suit, the Bank as a body corporate would be prejudicially affected by any decree and thus could prefer an appeal with leave of the appellate Court — relying on Supreme Court precedents establishing that a non-party adversely affected may be allowed to appeal.
  • Maintained that the lower appellate Court's judgment was deficient because it recorded submissions for the respondent without discussing evidence or giving its own proper findings; the lower appellate Court's conclusion that the disciplinary authority disagreed with the enquiry officer was said to be perverse in light of the documentary order (Exhibit 'Chaa') showing agreement.
  • Argued that even if there was delay in disposal of the internal appeal, delay alone did not make the reversion order illegal; and that on the Bank's own staff rules the matter was governed by Rule 46 rather than the Government Rule cited by the respondent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Kerala vs. General Manager, Southern Railways, AIR 1976 SC 2538 Where a public authority (owner) is the real party in interest, merely impleading an official (e.g., General Manager) is not sufficient; the owner must be impleaded. The Court applied this principle by holding that the Bank, as a body corporate, could not be adequately represented solely by impleading office-holders (Chairman, MD); non-joinder of the Bank made the suit bad.
Kankarathammal vs. VSL Madaliar, AIR 1965 SC 271 (with reference to Naba Kumar Hazra vs. R. Mahish, AIR 1931 PC 229) Scope of sub-rule (2) of Rule 10 of Order 1 CPC: the step of impleading a party must be taken at the trial stage; Order 1 Rule 10 cannot be applied at appeal stage when non-joinder was brought to notice at the outset. The Court relied on this to conclude that failure to implead the Bank at trial could not be cured at the appellate stage and supported the conclusion that the suit was bad for non-joinder.
M/s Indo Swiss Time Limited vs. Umrao & others, AIR 1981 P & H 213 Consideration of whether a company was a necessary party (context: Land Acquisition Act, 1894). The Court noted this Full Bench decision was not relevant to the present matter because it related to a Land Acquisition Act dispute; it did not change the Court's view on necessary-party requirements here.
Smt. Phulpati Devi vs. Parameswar Rai & others, AIR 1981 Patna 77 Authority for the proposition that a suit cannot continue without necessary parties. The Court cited this decision to reinforce the conclusion that the Bank was a necessary party and that its non-joinder rendered the suit untenable.
Smti Jatan Kanwar Golcha vs. Golcha Properties, AIR 1971 SC 374 Established that a person who is not a party to the suit may prefer an appeal with the leave of the appellate Court if he would be prejudicially affected by the judgment. The Court applied this authority to hold that the Bank could maintain the present appeal because it would ultimately have to implement any decree and therefore would be prejudicially affected.
State of Punjab vs. Amar Singh, AIR 1974 SC 994 Affirms that ordinarily only parties may appeal, but a non-party adversely affected may appeal with leave; reference to applicability of res judicata under Explanation 6 to Section 11 in certain contexts. The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that the Bank could file the appeal with leave because it would be prejudicially affected by the decree.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in two broad stages: first addressing the preliminary procedural question of non-joinder and maintainability, and then considering the merits of the lower appellate Court's decision.

  1. Non-joinder and necessary-party analysis:
    • The Court observed that the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank is a registered society and, by Section 85 of the Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 1949, is a body corporate with a separate legal entity, perpetual succession and the capacity to sue and be sued.
    • Given the Bank's separate legal personality and the fact that the Bank would ultimately have to implement any decree, the Court concluded the Bank was a necessary party whose non-joinder rendered the suit bad. The Court rejected the contention that impleading office-holders (Chairman and Managing Director) was sufficient to represent the corporate bank.
    • The Court relied on State of Kerala v. General Manager, Southern Railways to underline that impleading an official is not a substitute for impleading the owner/entity, and on Kankarathammal (and the underlying ratio in Naba Kumar Hazra) to emphasize that the opportunity to implead such necessary parties must be taken at trial and cannot be postponed to the appeal stage once the non-joinder was pointed out at the outset.
    • Other authorities relied upon by the respondent (e.g., Full Bench in Indo Swiss and decisions of various High Courts) were considered; the Court found the Indo Swiss decision inapposite because it dealt with the Land Acquisition Act context, while other High Court authorities supported the non-joinder principle.
  2. Maintainability of the appeal by the Bank (non-party seeking to appeal):
    • The Court reconciled the procedural defect (suit bad for non-joinder) with the Bank's ability to bring the present appeal by applying Supreme Court authorities (Smti Jatan Kanwar Golcha; State of Punjab v. Amar Singh) which permit a non-party to prefer an appeal with leave if the non-party would be prejudicially affected by the judgment. The Court concluded the Bank could file the present appeal because it would have to implement any decree.
  3. Merits review of the appellate Court's decision:
    • The Court criticized the lower appellate Court for merely recording the respondent's submissions without discussing evidence or giving its own findings. The appellate Court's finding that the disciplinary authority did not agree with the enquiry officer was held to be perverse.
    • The Court examined the documentary order of the disciplinary authority (Exhibit 'Chaa') and noted that the disciplinary authority expressly agreed with the enquiry officer's findings; this undermined the lower appellate Court's stated basis for setting aside the disciplinary order.
    • The Court addressed the proportionality argument: two of the proved charges (Charges Nos. 1 and 3 quoted in the record) involved alleged fraudulent manipulation and misappropriation of branch account balances and were described by the Court as serious in nature. The Court concluded the lower appellate Court's conclusion that the punishment was disproportionate was not supported by the evidence on record.
    • On the point of delay in the appellate process (respondent argued the appeal before the Bank's appellate authority was decided only after three years): the Court observed that even if there was delay, delay alone did not render the reduction illegal. The Court found that the proper rule to govern the Bank's internal appeal was Rule 46 of the Bank's staff rules rather than the Government rule relied upon by the respondent, and therefore delay did not invalidate the disciplinary order.
    • In view of the respondent's imminent superannuation, the Court exercised remedial discretion: it indicated that if the respondent submitted a representation to the appellate-Bank, it should be considered favourably and disposed of within three months and that the respondent "may be promoted to the post of Sub-Accountant."

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court allowed the second appeal by the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd. and set aside the impugned judgment and decree passed by the learned District Judge, Goalpara in TA No. 32 of 1988. The Court found merit in the appeal and ordered that parties shall bear their own costs.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The Court held that the original suit was bad for non-joinder of a necessary party (the Bank), reinforcing the principle that a corporate entity must be impleaded and cannot be effectively represented merely by impleading office-holders.
  • Despite the procedural defect, the Court accepted that the Bank — being prejudicially affected by any decree — could prefer the present appeal in the appellate Court's discretion, relying on Supreme Court authorities allowing non-parties to appeal with leave when prejudicially affected.
  • On the merits, the Court found the lower appellate Court's reversal of the disciplinary order unsustainable: the disciplinary authority had agreed with the enquiry findings and the proved charges were serious; proportionality and natural justice grounds raised in the lower Court were not established on the record.
  • Remedial direction: The Court invited the respondent to make a representation to the appellate authority of the Bank, directing that such representation be considered and disposed of favourably within three months; the Court indicated that the respondent may be promoted back to Sub-Accountant in the circumstances.
  • No novel legal principle or new precedent was set by this decision; the Court applied established principles on necessary parties, the competence of non-parties to seek leave to appeal, and routine appellate review of evidence and legal conclusions. The decision's direct effect is to set aside the decree in TA No. 32 of 1988 and to remit a remedial opportunity to the relevant internal authority of the Bank.

Costs: each party to bear its own costs (as stated by the Court).

    Assam Co-Operative Apex Bank Limited. v. Tarun Kumar Chakravarty

    This appeal has been filed by the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd. which is a banking society registered under the provisions of the Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 1949. The respondent who is an employee of the above Bank filed the title suit in question, namely TS No. 96 of 1986, before the Munsiff No, 1, Goalpara. The second appeal is preferred against the judgment and decree of the learned District Judge, Goalpara, in TA No. 32 of 1988 by which the judgment and decree of the learned Munsiff No. 1, Goalpara (TS No. 96 of 1985) was set aside. It may be stated that the learned trial Court dismissed the suit but the learned lower appellate Court decreed it.

    2. The respondent herein as plaintiff filed the title suit against the Chairman, Administrative Council and Board of Directors of the Assam Co-operative Apex Band Ltd., Managing Director of the Bank and Branch Manager of Goalpara Branch of the Bank namely; defendent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 respectively. The Bank which is the sole appellant in this case was not made a party.

    3. The plaintiff respondent was initially appointed as an Office 'Assistant of the Bank at Gaolpara Branch in the year 1958 and subsequently promoted to the post of Sub Accountant in the year 1977. After serving two years he was transferred to a new branch at Abhayapuri in the same district of Goalpara in the year 1979 and he was put in-charge of the said Branch and working along with two other persons. On 16.9.80 the plaintiff was placed under suspension and departmental proceeding was drawn up in respect of six charges and enquiry was duly conducted. The plaintiff and one Shri Ramesh Das, an Assistant of the said branch were found guilty of charge Nos. 1, 3 and 4 and they were not found guilty in respect of other three charges. The disciplinary authority namely, Managing Director, accepted: the finding of the Enquiry Officer and imposed the punishment of reversion of rank of the plaintiff-respondent from Sub Accountant to an Assistant. Hence, the present suit.

    4. The plaintiff-respondent averred that the order dated 9.11.81 passed by the Managing Director of the Bank (defendant No. 2) reducing the rank of the plaintiff and the order dated 17.3.86 passed by the Chairman of the Administrative Council and Board of Directors, Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd. (defendant No. 1) rejecting the appeal against the above order is void and illegal and for further declaring that the plaintiff is still continuing in service in the post of Sub Accountant.

    5. On behalf of all the defendants one written statement was filed. It was specifically pleaded that the suit was bad in law for non-joinder of the parties it cannot proceed against the defendant without impleading the Bank as party It was also mentioned.in the written 'statement the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank is a body corporate and as the said " Bank has not been made a party tke suit is not maintainable. It was pleaded that the plaintiff was negligent in discharging his duties and he was' found' guilty after due enquiry. According to the defendants there was no violation of principles of natural justice,no malafide or vindictive action hr conducting the departmental enquiry and in passing the impugned order.

    6. The learned trial Court framed three issues namely,(1) whether there is a cause of action for the plaintiff suit; (2) whether the plaintiff was illegally demoted to a lower post; and (3) whether the plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs prayed for.

    7. The parties adduced evidence both oral and documentary and thereafter the trial Court dismissed the suit, but decreed by the" lower appellate Court. Hence, this present second appeal.

    8. Before I take into consideration the contentions of the learned counsel, Mr. Sarma, on behalf of the appellant, let me first consider a preliminary point raise J by Mr. Choudhury, learned counsel for the respondent. Mr. Choudhury has urged that as the Bank was not a party either before the trial Court or before the lower appellate Court, the present appeal is not at all maintainable inasmuch as the other defendents have not been jmpleaded either as appellants Or proforma respondents. There is no dispute that the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank is a banking society registered-trader the provisions of the Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 1949. Section 85 of the said Act, inter alia, provides that every registered society shall be deemed to be a body corporate by the name under which is registered with perpetual succession and a common seal, and with power to hold property, to enter into contracts, institute and defend suits and other legal proceedings and to do all things necessary for the purpose for which it was constituted.

    9. Being a body corporate, Bank has a separate legal entity and its functions through the subordinate staff; such as, Managing Director, Branch Manager etc. If the decree is upheld ultimately the Bank with suffer and the Bank shall have to implement the decree of the Court, rift other words, to decide the dispute effectively and completely it is necessary to implead the Bank as a party.

    10. Mr. Choudhury, learned counsel for the respondent-plaintiff has urged that as the Chairman and Managing Dkector was impleaded as defendants it would be sumcient to hold that the the Bank was before the Court. I am unable to accept the contention of Mr. Choudhury, learned counsel for the respondent, as the Bank being a body corporate has a seperate legal entity and it has to be impleaded as party.

    11. In this connection, I refer to the decision of the Apex Court in the State of Kerala vs. General Manager, Southern Railways, Madras, AIR 1976 SC 2538. In that case there was a dispute between State of Kerala and Railways and the suit was filed without impleading the Union or India, lie Apex Court held that the Union of India being the owner of the Railways; merely because the General Manager was impleaded iit would not be sufficient compliance of law and in the absence of the owner of the Railways, namely; Union of India the suit cannot proceed. Similarly, in the case in hand, merely because the chairman and the Managing Director have been impleaded it would not be sufficient compliance with the provisions of law and not by impleading the Bank as a party, the provisions of the proviso of order 1 Rule9 CPC would be attracted. In other words the suit is bad for non-joinder of parties.

    12 According to Mr. Choudhury, it is not only the duty of the plaintiff to select the parties and a duty is cast on the Court and as well as on the defendants in making parties to a suit. In support of the same the learned counsel has placed reliance on the decisions of the Calcutta an4 Madhya Pradesh High Courts reported in AIR 1985 NOC 204 (Cal) and AIR 1977 NOC 340 (MP). In the case in hand, a specific plea was taken in written statement that Bank was a necessary party but the plaintiff did not taken any step for impleading the Bank. Now the plaintiff can not turn round and say that was the duty of the defendants or the Court to implead the Bank. Therefore,the contention of Mr.Sarma is not at all acceptable.

    13. In this connection, I refer-to the decision of the Apex Court in Kankarathantmmal vs. VSL Madaliar, AIR 1965 SC 271. In paragraph 15 of the judgment the Court considered the scope of sub-rule (2) Rule 10 of Order 1 CPC and held that such step of impleading the party has be done in trial stage, applying the ratio laid down in Naba Kumar Hazra vs. R.Mahish,AIR 1931 PC 229, their Lordships held that the provisions of Order 1 Rule 10 cannot be applied at the stage of appeal when at the very outset of the proceedings non-joinder of party has been brought to the notice of the plaintiff.

    14. Mr. Choudhury, learned counsel for the respondent has placed reliaoce in the Full Bench decision of Punjab and Haryana High Court in M/s Indo Swiss Time Limited vs. Umrao & others, AIR 1981 P & H 213, but the said case is not relevant for the present purpose as that dispute was in respect of Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and the question whether the company has been impleaded as a party or not was considered. Mr. Choudhury, learned counsel has also placed reliance on the decision of the Patna High Court in Smt. Phulpati Devi vs. Parameswar Rai & others, AIR 1981 Patna 77, wherein the Court, held that without necessary parties a suit cannot continue.n "there is no dispute on tnat point and in the case in hand, as the' Bank is'a riecesiary party the suit cannot continue.

    15. Situated thus, I am of the opinion that the suit is bad for non-joinder of parties as urged by Mr. Sarma, learned counsel for the appellant. Ceding back to the question as to whether the present appeal can be maintained in this Court. I may now examine the decisions of the Apex Court as referred to by the learned counsel, Mr. Sarma.

    16. In Smti Jatan Kanwar Golcha vs. Golcha Properties, AIR 1971 SC 374, the Apex Court held that it is well settled that a person who is not a party to the suit may prefer an appeal with the leave of the appellate Court and such leave should be granted if he would be prejudicially affected by the judgment.

    17. In State of Punjab vs. Amar Singh reported in AIR 1974 SC 994 at paragraph 29, the Apex Court held that the ordinary rule is that only a party to a suit adversely affected by the decree or any of his representatives in interest may file an appeal and under such circumstances, a person who is not a party may prefer an appeal with the leave of the appellate Court

    "if he would be prejudicially affected by the judgment and if it would be binding on him as res judicata under Explanation 6 to Section 11."

    18. In view of the above law laid down by the Apex Court the Bank can file the present appeal as ultimately the Bank shall have to implement the decree.

    19. In the impugned judgment the lower appellate Court only recorded the submission made on behalf of the respondents but did not discuss the evidence or gave its own finding. Suddendly the Court came to the finding that the impugned order is improper on the ground stated in paragraph 7 of the judgment. There is no finding of the Court that there was violation of principles of natural justice or violation of any provisions of any rule. '

    20. I have perused the evidence on record and though the learned lower appellate Court held that the Managing Director namely, disciplinary authority did not agree with the finding of the Enquiry Officer but this finding is perverse inasmuch as the disciplinary authority namely, the Managing Director agreed with the finding of the Enquiry Officer and thereafter passed the impugned order. Exhibit 'Chaa' is the order of the disciplinary authority and the relevant portion of the said order is quoted below:

    "I agree with the finding of the Enquiry Officer and I consider the irregularities committed by Shri Tarun Kumar Chakraborty to be of serious nature. Shri Chakraborty had committed serious malpractices in the maintenance of accounts of the Branch..."

    21. The learned lower appellate Court also held that the punishment Imposed was disproportionate to the charges proved.The three charges, which were found to be proved, are as follows :-

    Charge No. I:

    "That while you were in charge of Abhayapuri Branch of the Bank wef 16.1.79 to 27.9.80, you fraudulently manipulated the balance of S/B Account No. 213 of Shri Dhiren and allowed overdrawal of Rs.2,639.60 on 7.3.80 without approval of HO."

    Charge No.3 : That you fraudulently altered the date of opening of S/B Account No. 398 and 399 of Shri Kamala Kanta Sarma and Smti Kamala Devi respectiyely from the, actual date of deposits i.e, 31.3,80 to 11 5.80 and thereby temporarily misappropriated the balance from 31.3,80 to 11.5.80.

    22. It is not relevant to quote the charge No. 4. The above two charges proved are of serious nature. Therefore, the finding of the learned appellate Court -that the punishment was disproportionate is not based on evidence on record. As staled above there is also no finding that there was any, violation of principles of natural justice.

    23. Mr. Choudhury has urged that in view of Rule 120 of the Assam Co-operative Apex Bank Ltd. (Staff) Rules, 1980, Rule 24 of the Assam Services (Disciplinary and Appeals) Rules, 1964 would apply and the appeal preferred before the appellate authority ought to have been decided within 3 months but in the present case the appeal was decided after 3 years. Even if there was a delay in disposal of the appeal, it cannot be held that the order of reduction of rank is illegal. The learned lower appellate Court has referred to the submission of the the learned counsel for the respondents regarding application of Rule 9 of the Govt. Rules, but from reading the rule framed for the staff by the appellant Bank, it is absolutely clear that the present case is covered under Rule 46 of the above Rules framed by the Bank.

    24. Admittedly the plaintiff-respondent is going to retire on superannuation shortly. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I am of opinion that now the plaintiff respondent may be promoted to the post of Sub-Accountant. If the plaintiff respondent submits any representation before the appellate-Bank it may be considered and disposed of favourably within three months from the date of such submission.

    25. For what has been stated above, I find merit in the present appeal and accordingly I allow the appeal and set aside the impugned judgment and decree passed by the learned District Judge, Goalpara in TA No. 32 of 1988. Parties will bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Assam Co-Operative Apex Bank Limited. v. Tarun Kumar Chakravarty
    (Jan 20, 1993)