Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion (Second Appeal) — Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The present matter is a second appeal by the defendant against concurrent judgments and decrees of the two lower Courts which had decreed the plaintiff's suit for specific performance.

According to the plaint, the defendant entered into an agreement to sell dated 28.5.1993 for a residential house (No.70/4, Krishna Colony, Bhiwani) for a consideration of Rs.60,000/-, and received Rs.25,000/- as earnest money. The date fixed for execution of the sale deed was 30.4.1994. On that date the Sub-Registrar's office was closed (Saturday); the plaintiff waited with the balance consideration but the defendant did not appear. The plaintiff obtained affidavits marking his presence from the Executive Magistrate and the Office of the Sub-Registrar. On 2.5.1994 the plaintiff again went to the Sub-Registrar's office; the defendant again did not appear. The plaintiff requested the defendant to accept the balance consideration and execute the sale deed; the defendant refused and the suit was filed.

The defendant, in the written statement, denied the agreement and asserted the property was worth approximately Rs.3,00,000/-, arguing there was no occasion to enter into an agreement for Rs.60,000/-. After replication, ten issues were framed on 19.11.1996 (listed below in the Legal Issues section). After evidence and trial, both lower Courts found that the agreement was executed and that the plaintiff had shown readiness and willingness to perform; they decreed specific performance. The defendant appealed to this Court in a second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of specific performance of the contract as prayed for on the ground alleged in the plaint? (OPP)
  2. Whether the defendant had entered into an agreement with the plaintiff? (OPP)
  3. Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present suit? (OPD)
  4. Whether no cause of action accrued to the plaintiff to file the present suit? (OPD)
  5. Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form? (OPD)
  6. Whether the suit is time barred? (OPD)
  7. Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purposes of court fees and jurisdiction? (OPD)
  8. Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purposes of court fees and jurisdiction? (OPD) [duplicate issue as recorded]
  9. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder and misjoinder of necessary parties? (OPD)
  10. Relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Defendant's) Arguments

  • The agreement (Ex.P1) was misread by the Courts below as an agreement to sell; its true and dominant purpose was a loan transaction.
  • Ex.P1 provided that Rs.25,000/- was received as earnest and Rs.35,000/- was to be paid at registration on 30.4.1994; during the period the seller would return Rs.25,000/- with interest @ 2% per month to the purchaser, failing which the seller would execute the sale deed. This arrangement, the appellant argued, showed the real intent was a loan repayable with interest, not an outright sale.
  • Accordingly, the relief should have been limited to recovery of the money (refund with interest), not specific performance by execution of sale deed.
  • The appellant relied on several precedents (Supreme Court and High Court decisions) supporting the proposition that where the real transaction is a loan, specific performance is not the appropriate remedy.

Respondent's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The document Ex.P1 must be read as an agreement to sell: the defendant categorically agreed to execute the sale deed in case of non-refund of the earnest money with interest.
  • Since the defendant failed both to refund the earnest money and to execute the sale deed, specific performance through the Court was appropriate.
  • The defendant has been dishonest: he consistently denied execution of the agreement though the Courts below concurrently found the agreement proved and found plaintiff's readiness and willingness. The defendant himself, as DW1, stated, “I have not borrowed any money from Sunil Kumar on interest.”
  • The defendant never offered to repay the amount he now claims was a loan; the loan contention was not raised before the lower Courts and therefore cannot be raised for the first time in the second appeal.
  • The respondent relied on a decision of this Court (Krishan Kumar Verma Vs. Narender Prabhakar) to support the proposition that a party who dishonestly denies execution and then re-characterises the document is not entitled to succeed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S. Rangaraju Naidu Vs. S. Thiruvarakkarasu, 1995(3) RRR 298 Where an agreement to sell is collateral to a promissory note and the predominant object is recovery of money, the agreement may be treated as intended to secure repayment (i.e., not a bona fide sale). The Court distinguished this authority: it observed that in Rangaraju Naidu the agreement was collateral to a promissory note and there was no consensus ad idem to sell; that factual matrix does not exist here because the defendant denied execution and denied borrowing on interest, so the precedent was held inapplicable.
Gurbax Singh Vs. Labhu Ram, 1996(1) RRR 509 Where the Court below finds a document executed in the shape of agreement to sell is in fact meant for advancement of loan, the agreement will be treated as a loan transaction. The Court noted the case but found it factually distinct: in the present matter the defendant had denied execution and denied borrowing; thus the factual finding in Gurbax Singh did not apply.
Prem Singh Vs. Mangu Ram, 2004(3) LJR 241 If a Court finds that a document was executed only to secure a loan and ensure repayment, it is a money transaction without intention to sell/purchase land. The Court recognized the principle but held it inapplicable on the facts because the defendant here denied both execution of the document and borrowing; therefore the Court did not accept the recharacterisation urged by the appellant.
Lonkaran Kishorilal Paliwal Vs. Bhaskar Rambhau Ghive and another, 1994(1) LJR 152 Specific performance of an agreement to sell is ordinarily to be granted unless it is shown that damages would constitute an adequate relief; pleadings asserting the agreement was security for a loan were examined in that case. The Court observed the principle but found the case distinguishable on facts and did not apply it to defeat specific performance in the present matter.
Krishan Kumar Verma Vs. Narender Prabhakar, 2009(4) LAW HERALD (P&H) 2814 : 2009(4) PLR 109 Authority addressing dishonesty in denying execution of an agreement, re-characterisation of documents and related credibility findings. The Court accepted and relied upon this authority to support the conclusion that the defendant was dishonest in denying execution and then trying to re-characterise the agreement as a loan transaction; this supported dismissing the appeal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the core dispute: the nature of document Ex.P1 — whether it is an agreement to sell (plaintiff's case) or a loan/security document (defendant's case). Both lower Courts had found Ex.P1 proved and held that the plaintiff had been ready and willing to perform his part of the contract.

The appellant advanced a new case in this Court that Ex.P1 was essentially a loan transaction because it contained a provision for repayment of Rs.25,000/- with interest @ 2% per month during the intervening period, and provided that failure to repay would entitle the purchaser to insist on execution of the sale deed. The appellant relied on several authorities to support the proposition that where the dominant purpose of a document is to secure a loan, specific performance is inappropriate and relief should be confined to recovery.

The Court analysed that none of those authorities were applicable on the facts here for several reasons expressly stated in the opinion:

  • The defendant had consistently denied execution of Ex.P1 throughout the proceedings; nevertheless both lower Courts concurrently found that the agreement was executed. That factual conclusion underpins the Court's analysis.
  • The defendant, in his own testimony as DW1, stated: “I have not borrowed any money from Sunil Kumar on interest.” If the defendant's positive case under oath is that he never borrowed money from the plaintiff on interest, he cannot plausibly contend that the agreement (which he had denied) was a loan transaction.
  • The defendant never offered to repay the amount which he now claims was a loan; the absence of an offer to repay undermines the loan-character contention.
  • The Court noted that the contention that the document was a loan transaction was not raised before the Courts below; it held that raising such a new point for the first time in a second appeal was impermissible.
  • Where the appellant tried to rely on precedents holding recharacterisation is appropriate, the Court distinguished those precedents on their facts (for example, Rangaraju Naidu involved a promissory note and collateral agreement; Gurbax Singh and Prem Singh involved factual findings that the document was a loan/security). On the present record those factual matrices did not exist.
  • The Court found support in Krishan Kumar Verma for the proposition that a party who denies execution and later seeks to re-characterise a document may be held dishonest; that reasoning was applied against the appellant.

On that combined factual and legal analysis, the Court concluded that the appellant's new contention that the agreement was a loan transaction lacked merit and was barred from being raised at this stage; therefore the lower Courts' concurrent findings stood.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The Court wrote the operative result as: DISMISSED though specifically noting the dismissal is "without any order as to costs."

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The decree for specific performance awarded to the plaintiff by the Courts below remains undisturbed by this second appeal; the defendant's attempt to have the transaction recharacterised as a loan and to obtain monetary relief instead has failed.
  • On precedent and broader law: The opinion distinguishes and applies existing authorities on the circumstances in which an agreement may be treated as a loan versus a sale. The Court explicitly found the cited precedents inapplicable on the facts. The judgment does not purport to announce a new legal principle beyond application of established law to the facts here.

Order: The appeal is dismissed; there is no order as to costs.

    Ram Lal v. Sunil Kumar

    Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.:-

    The defendant is in second appeal against the judgment and decree of both the Courts below whereby suit of the plaintiff for specific performance has been decreed.

    2. Plaintiff's case is that defendant entered into an agreement to sell dated 28.5.1993 for sale of a residential House No.70/4, Krishna Colony, Bhiwani for a consideration of Rs.60,000/- and received an amount of Rs.25,000/- as earnest money. The date for execution of sale deed was settled as 30.4.1994 but on that day the office of sub Registrar was closed due to Saturday so the plaintiff waited for the defendant in front of the office of Sub-Registrar along with remaining sale consideration but defendant did not turn up. The plaintiff got his presence marked on an affidavit from Executive Magistrate, Bhiwani. On next working day i.e. 2.5.1994, plaintiff again went to the office of Sub Registrar but the defendant did not turn up. He again got his presence marked on an affidavit from the office of Sub Registrar. He thereafter, requested the defendant to accept the balance sale consideration and get the sale deed executed but on his refusal, the suit was filed. The defendant in the written statement totally denied the agreement. It was alleged that the disputed property was worth Rs.3 lacs or so, therefore, there was no occasion for him to enter into agreement for a mere sum of Rs.60,000/-. After filing of the replication, following issues were framed on 19.11.1996:

    (i) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of specific performance of the contract as prayed for on the ground alleged in the plaint? OPP.

    (ii) Whether the defendant had entered into an agreement with the plaintiff? OPP.

    (iii) Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present suit? OPD.

    (iv) Whether no cause of action accrued to the plaintiff to file the present suit? OPD.

    (v) Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form? OPD.

    (vi) Whether the suit is time barred? OPD.

    (vii) Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purposes of court fees and jurisdiction? OPD.

    (viii) Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purposes of court fees and jurisdiction? OPD.

    (ix) Whether the suit is bad for non joinder and misjoinder of necessary parties? OPD.

    (x) Relief.

    3. After appreciation of the evidence available on record, both the Courts have concurrently upheld the execution of the agreement between the parties and the readiness and willingness on the part of the plaintiff to perform his part of the contract.

    4. In the present appeal, two legal points have been raised by the counsel for the appellant, firstly, the agreement has been misread as a document of sale which was rather meant for loan transaction and secondly, the Court below should not have granted the decree keeping in view hardship of the defendant. In this regard, counsel for the appellant has read over agreement to sell (Ex.P/1) in which it is provided that the appellant/seller has received Rs.25,000/- as earnest money and remaining amount Rs.35,000/- would be received at the time of registration of sale deed on 30.4.1994. During this period, the appellant/seller would return the amount of Rs.25,000/- with interest @ 2% per month to the purchaser otherwise he would execute the sale deed in favour of the purchaser/respondent after receiving the balance sale consideration. In case, he would refuse to execute the sale deed, the purchaser would get the sale deed executed through the process of Court and in that circumstances, the seller would pay the entire expenses incurred in the legal proceedings. Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the dominant purpose of the agreement wherein it was agreed that he would return Rs.25,000/- with interest before the date fixed for execution of sale deed, tantamounts to an agreement of loan and not of sale. Thus, the Court below should not have decreed the suit for specific performance by execution of sale deed rather should have decreed the suit for recovery. In this regard, he has relied upon decision of the Supreme Court in the case of S.Rangaraju Naidu Vs. S.Thiruvarakkarasu 1995(3) RRR 298, decision of this Court in the case of Gurbax Singh Vs. Labhu Ram 1996(1) RRR 509 and Prem Singh Vs. Mangu Ram 2004(3) LJR 241 and a decision of Bombay High Court in the case of Lonkaran Kishorilal Paliwal Vs. Bhaskar Rambhau Ghive and another 1994(1) LJR 152.

    5. On the other hand, counsel for the respondent has vehemently argued that document Ex.P1 could not be read as a document for raising loan rather it is a document in which defendant has categorically agreed to execute the sale deed in case of non refund of the earnest money with interest and since he failed to refund the earnest money and also failed to execute the sale deed, therefore, the same has been rightly ordered to be executed through the process of Court. He further submits that appellant is a dishonest person as he had been throughout denying the execution of agreement and now when both the Courts have given a concurrent finding of fact that agreement has been duly executed and the defendant has been always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract, he has tried to take shelter of the law laid down by the Supreme Court without its applicability to the facts of the present case. He also relies upon a decision of this Court in the case of Krishan Kumar Verma Vs. Narender Prabhakar [2009(4) LAW HERALD (P&H) 2814] : 2009(4) PLR 109. Learned counsel for the respondent has also very categorically read the statement of the defendant which clinches the dispute between the parties. The defendant appeared as his own witness as DW1 and in his examination-in-chief he has categorically stated “I have not borrowed any money from Sunil Kumar on interest.” It is submitted that if it is the positive case of the appellant on oath that he had never borrowed any money from the respondent, then he had no cheek to say that agreement was meant for taking loan and not for selling the property. It is also submitted that this point was never raised by the appellant before both the Court below, therefore, it could not raised for the first time before this Court.

    6. I have heard both the counsel for the parties and have perused the record with their assistance.

    7. The dispute in this case has started with the execution of document Ex.P1 which according to the plaintiff/respondent is an agreement to sell and according to the defendant/appellant is a document meant for raising loan. Interestingly, the defendant has been throughout denying the execution of document Ex.P1 which has been concurrently proved before both the Courts below besides the readiness and willingness on the part of the plaintiff/respondent for the purpose of execution of the sale deed. Taking advantage of the conditions enumerated in agreement Ex.P1, defendant/appellant has now tried to set up a new case that the agreement was meant for loan, therefore, plaintiff was entitled to alternative relief of refund with simple interest and not for execution of the sale deed. The judgment relied upon by the appellant, namely, in the case of S.Rangaraju Naidu Vs. S.Thiruvarakkarasu (supra) is not applicable because it was a case for recovery of Rs.15,500/- for which a promissory note was executed on 30.12.1977. On the same day, appellant executed an agreement of sale for the discharge of the very same promissory note debt, and since he was not in a position to pay the same, he agreed to sell three plots of land to an extent of 7,500 sq.feet for the same consideration. As he did not execute the sale deed, a civil suit was filed against him for specific performance of the agreement which was decreed and was confirmed upto to the stage of second appeal. However, the Supreme Court held that agreement to sell was only collateral to the promissory note and there was no consensus of ad idem to sell the land under the agreement, therefore, pre dominant object was recovery of the dues with interest and not the intention to sell the land. In the case of Gurbax Singh Vs. Labhu Ram (supra) finding of fact was recorded by the Court below that document which was executed in the shape of agreement to sell was in fact a document meant for advancement of loan. This Court upheld the decision by dismissing the Regular Second Appeal. In the case of Prem Singh Vs. Mangu Ram (supra), it has been held that if the Court comes to the finding that document was executed only to secure loan and ensure its repayment, it is only a money transaction without any intention to sale and purchase the land. In the case of Lonkaran Kishorilal Paliwal Vs. Bhaskar Rambhau Ghive and another (supra), it was held that specific performance of an agreement to sell is ordinarily to be granted unless it is shown that damages would constitute adequate relief. In that case also, plea was that the agreement was a security for a loan transaction but he agreed to sell his property under pressure for a consideration, which was inadequate.

    8. To my mind, all the judgments relied upon by the counsel for the appellant are not applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case for the reason that defendant has been altogether denying execution of the agreement to sell and had even stated as DW1 that he had never secured or borrowed any money from the plaintiff on interest. If the stand of the defendant is that he had never borrowed any money on interest from the plaintiff then it could not be said that the agreement which he has been denying throughout was meant for raising loan on interest. Moreover, the defendant has never offered to repay the said amount which he has now claimed as loan. He has been throughout denying the agreement. Therefore, I fully agree with the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent in the case of Krishan Kumar Verma Vs. Narender Prabhakar (supra) in which it has been held that defendant/appellant was not honest. He denied the execution of the agreement and claimed it to be forged and fabricated document though he himself was signatory to the agreement and then alleging it to be a loan transaction. There is another aspect of the matter that the question which has now been raised before this Court, was never raised before the Courts below, therefore, the same could not be raised for the first time in second appeal.

    In view of the aforesaid discussion, I do not find any merit in the present appeal and as such, the same is hereby dismissed though without any order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Lal v. Sunil Kumar
    (May 21, 2010)