Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 25 (1-5) of the Arms Act, 120A/ 121/122IPC read with section 13 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, under section 394/302 IPC read with section 3/4 tADA (P) Act.
  • provisions of Article 22 (5) of the Constitution and the provisions of the COFEPOSA Act and the PIT NDPS Act
  • section 3 (2) of the National Security act, 1980, hereinafter referred to as the Act,
  • 3/97 U/s 25 (1-5) Arms Act and 10/97 U/s 120A/121/122IPC R/W section 13 UA (P) Act
  • UNLAWFUL ACTIVITIES PREVENTION ACT 1967
  • 240/91 U/s 394/302 IPC R/W section 3/4 TADA (P) Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 25 (1-5) of the Arms Act, 120A/ 121/122IPC read with section 13 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, under section 394/302 IPC read with section 3/4 tADA (P) Act.
  • provisions of Article 22 (5) of the Constitution and the provisions of the COFEPOSA Act and the PIT NDPS Act
  • section 3 (2) of the National Security act, 1980, hereinafter referred to as the Act,
  • 3/97 U/s 25 (1-5) Arms Act and 10/97 U/s 120A/121/122IPC R/W section 13 UA (P) Act
  • UNLAWFUL ACTIVITIES PREVENTION ACT 1967
  • 240/91 U/s 394/302 IPC R/W section 3/4 TADA (P) Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution was filed by the detenu challenging a detention order dated 12.9.1997 passed by the District Magistrate, Bongaigaon, under section 3(2) of the National Security Act, 1980. The detention order (Annexure A) was supported by grounds of detention contained in Annexure B. The detenu is Sri Binod Bihari Nath (also described as Binod Nath @ Ananda Jogi @ Partha Pratim Nath). The grounds alleged that the detenu had been an active member of the banned organisation ULFA since 1989, had attended ULFA meetings and training, had held organisational roles, had been involved in violent incidents and criminal cases (including cases under the Arms Act and provisions of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act), and had been found in possession of arms and incriminating materials on 10.1.1997.

Procedurally, the respondents filed an affidavit-in-opposition on 22.5.1998 attaching the detention order and a letter addressed to the detenu. The detenu challenged the detention on multiple grounds, prominently alleging failure to inform him of his right to make a representation to the Central Government, non-application of mind, and non-furnishing of basic facts and materials constituting the grounds of detention. The Court examined these contentions, applied existing authority, and decided the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the detention order under the National Security Act is vitiated by non-compliance with procedural safeguards, specifically non-apprisal of the detenu's right to make a representation to the Central Government.
  2. Whether the grounds of detention supplied to the detenu are relevant, germane and proximate in time to justify continued detention under the Act.
  3. Whether other alleged procedural infirmities such as non-application of mind and non-furnishing of basic facts and materials invalidate the detention order (as raised by the detenu).

Arguments of the Parties

Detenu's Arguments

  • The detenu alleged several grounds for challenging detention, including that he was not apprised of his right to make a representation before the Central Government.
  • He also contended there was non-application of mind by the detaining authority and that basic facts and materials constituting the grounds of detention were not furnished to him.

Respondents' Position

  • The respondents filed an affidavit denying the detenu's allegations and produced the detention order and a letter addressed to the detenu. The letter informed the detenu that "you may submit representation if so felt, against the order of detention through the Superintendent of Jail in which you are detained to the State Govt."
  • However, the grounds of detention as supplied to the detenu did not contain any reference to his right to make a representation to the Central Government, and there was no mention of such a right even to the State Government in the grounds (the letter conveying the right to represent to the State Government was provided four days after the detention order).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kamaleshkumar Ishwardas Patel v. Union of India & others, (1995) 4 SCC 51 Interpreting Article 22(5) and related statutory regimes: a person detained has a right to make a representation not only to the Advisory Board but also to the detaining authority (the authority that made the detention order) and to any other authority competent to revoke the detention; the detained person must be informed of this right when served with the grounds of detention. The Court relied on this authority to hold that failure to inform the detenu of his right to make a representation to the authority competent to revoke the order (including the Central Government) results in denial of that right and vitiates the detention.
Nutan J. Patel v. SP Prasad, (1994) 2 SCC 315 Application of the principle that lack of intimation of the right to make representation can vitiate detention; the Supreme Court refused to accept a contention that mere knowledge of the right by the detenu cures non-intimation. The Court cited this decision to support the conclusion that detention cannot be sustained where the right to make representation was not properly communicated, even where it was argued the detenu knew of the right.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in two main strands: (1) factual assessment of the grounds of detention and (2) procedural compliance with Article 22(5) and related jurisprudence concerning the right to make representations.

On factual grounds, the Court examined the reproduced grounds of detention and observed that they alleged active and continuing involvement of the detenu with ULFA (a banned organisation), membership since 1989, organisation-building activities, attendance at ULFA meetings including one in Bangladesh, political and arms training, participation in publication and publicity activities, and involvement in criminal cases including possession of a .32 revolver and ammunition and registration of cases under the Arms Act and Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. The Court expressly found these grounds to be "relevant and germane" and proximate in time to the object sought to be achieved by the detention order.

On procedural grounds, the Court focused on the detenu's specific objection that he had not been apprised of his right to make a representation to the Central Government. The available papers included the detention order and grounds (which did not mention the right) and a letter informing the detenu of a right to represent to the State Government through the jail superintendent; that letter was dated four days after the detention order and was endorsed as received by the detenu on 16.9.1997. The Court found there was no statement in the grounds of detention apprising the detenu of his right to make a representation to the Central Government, nor was there any mention of such a right even to the State Government in the grounds when they were furnished to him.

The Court relied on Kamaleshkumar (supra) for the settled principle that Article 22(5) gives a detained person the right to make a representation against detention to the detaining authority and other competent authorities (including the Central Government where appropriate) and that the authority making the detention order must inform the person of that right at the time the grounds are served. The Court also referred to Nutan J. Patel (supra) where the Supreme Court quashed detention despite arguments regarding the detenu's knowledge of the right, reinforcing that absence of proper intimation cannot be cured by asserted awareness.

Applying those principles to the present facts, the Court concluded that the failure to inform the detenu of his right to make a representation to the Central Government amounted to a denial of the right conferred by Article 22(5). That procedural defect "vitiates the continued detention" despite the factual grounds otherwise being relevant and proximate. The Court therefore did not need to adjudicate in detail the other grounds raised by the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition was allowed and the detention order was quashed. The Court's core ruling can be stated as:

DETENTION ORDER QUASHED; PETITION ALLOWED.

Consequences and implications:

  • The detenu was ordered to be set at liberty forthwith unless he was otherwise wanted in connection with any other case or cases.
  • The Court made no order as to costs.
  • The decision rests on the procedural defect of non-apprisal of the detenu's right to make a representation to the Central Government under Article 22(5) as explained in the cited precedents; the opinion does not purport to lay down any broader new principle beyond application of those authorities to the facts of this case.

This summary reproduces and synthesizes only information expressly contained in the provided opinion.

    Hemanta Nath v. State Of Assam And Ors.

    V. Dutta Gyani, C. J. (Acting)--

    By this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution the petitioner seeks to challenge the detention order dated 12.9.97 passed by District Magistrate, Bongaigaon in exercise of powers under section 3 (2) of the National Security act, 1980, hereinafter referred to as the Act, filed as Annexure A to the petition.

    The impugned order of detention based on grounds as contained in Annexure B, they are reproduced hereunder:

    "1. SriBinod Nath @ Ananda Jogi @ Partha Pratim Nath is an active member of banned 'Union Liberation Front of Asom' (ULFA) since 1989.

    2. The person has the following associates :

    (a) Sanjib Singh @ Mech S/o Surendra Mohan Singh, TR Phulom Road, Bongaigaon town PS & Dist. Bongaigaon.

    (b) Pradeep Chakraborty @ Chiko @ Samiran Baruah, S/o Nityananda Chakraborty of Barpeta, Gossaipara, Bongaigaon town, PS & Dist Bongaigaon.

    (c)'Parashmoni Roy @ Dilip Das @ Janmoni Roy S/o Nirmal Ch. Das of Village Chakihali. PS Manikpur, Dist. Bongaigaon {Chief Secretary/Parichalak Birjhora Anchalik, ULFA).

    (d) Jamuna Sastri @ Bippin Sastri @ Bikash Patowary @ Abhoy Singha, S/o late Chintaharan Sastri of Borobazar, Bongaigaon town, PS & Dist. Bongaigaon (Finance Secretary/Parichalak Birjhora Anchalik ULFA).

    (e) Binoy Kumar Das @ Prabhakar Mili Rudra Baruah @ Bimal Das, S/o Rajani Kt Das of Patiladha, Jakuapara, PS Manikpur, Dist Bongaigaon (ex Finance Secy Bongaigaon Dist ULFA).

    (f) Utshav Das @ Ashim Singha, S/O Ratneswar Das of Jhaubari, PS Manikpur, Dist. Bongaigaon (ex Commander Bngg Dist ULFA).

    (g) Bijoy Boro, President, ULFA, West Bongaigaon, ULFA) (h) Idrajit Rava, Organising Secy Western Range.

    3. The persons has joined ULFA in the year 1989 at the instance of Sri Biswajit Singha, hardcore ULFA activist of Bongaigaon. ULFA organisation has been declared unlawful association by Govt of India vide notification No. SO. 915 (E) dated 27.11.90 under the provision of Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.

    4. The person has framed an unit ULFA at Abhayapuri in September, 1989 along with his associates and took over charge of Parichalak.

    5. The person underwent political training in November, 1989 at different places like Kaljirapara under Patacharkuchi PS under Barpeta District. Asanta Bagh Phukan imparted the political training on the aim, objective, ideology etc of ULFA. The person also took arms training at Goalpara in July, 1991.

    6. The person was appointed by Bijoy Bora as Organising Secretary of undivided Goalpara Dist in 1991. Thereafter the person was appointed as Organisation Secretary of Bongaigaon Dist. During his Organising Secretariship he formed a good numbers of ULFA sub unit in Bongaigaon Dist such as Patiladaha, Dewangaon, Bashbari etc.

    These are all prejudicial activities of the person.

    7. The person was also associated in the incident of killing of Dhurbajyoti Adhikary, a Congress (I) worker of Abhayapuri town on 6.11.91 the day when the Hon'ble Chief Minister, Assam Hiteswas Saikia visited Abhayapuri. This refer A. Pun PS Case No. 240/91 U/s 394/302 IPC R/W section 3/4 TADA (P) Act.

    8. In July, 1992 the person attended the General Council meeting of ULFA held in Bangladesh which was attended by Arabinda Rajkhowa, Chairman of ULFA, Pradeep Gogoi, Vice Chairman, ULFA, Anup Chetia, Secretary ULFA and Paresh Barua C-in-C, ULFA among others. After his return from the meeting he was arrested by Police on 31.7.92 but subsequently released on bail. After getting release on bail the person has again gone underground and continued his prejudicial activities.

    9. In March, 1996 the person took over charge of Publicity Secy of Birjhora Anchalik Parisad under West Zone. As Publicity Secretary, the person published a Souvenir 'Smaranika' on 27th July, 1996 in connection with their Swahid Divas. The Souvenir contains the life histories of some ULFA members and their prejudicial activities were also incorporated therein.

    10. The person was arrested on 10.1.97 with one .32 revolver with 9 rounds of ammunition. One Yashica camera loaded with film, some incriminating documents related to ULFA and cash of Rs.2,638.50. Two cases vide Bijni PS Case No. 3/97 U/s 25 (1-5) Arms Act and 10/97 U/s 120A/121/122IPC R/W section 13 UA (P) Act were registered against him and investigated into. The loaded film was developed and seen that the person was with some other ULFA activists. The person was seen with dressed generally used by Indian Army. This clearly indicative that the person with other ULFA activists have been fighting for the cause of ULFA viz liberation of Assam from Indian Union through arms struggle."

    2. Going through the same, it becomes abundantly clear that the detenu, Sri Binod Bihari Nath @ Ananda Jogi @ Partha Pratim Nath is actively involved with the unlawful activities of waging a war against the Union of India, the organisation ULFA is a banned organisation, he has been taken active part and his activities are against the security of State. Apart from this, he has been involved in two criminal cases registered under section 25 (1-5) of the Arms Act, 120A/ 121/122IPC read with section 13 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, under section 394/302 IPC read with section 3/4 tADA (P) Act. Going through these grounds of detention, we do not have a slightest hesitation in holding that these grounds are relevant and germane to, having a nexus with the object sought to be achieved by passing the impugned order of detention, they are proximate in time as well.

    3. The detenu has challenged his detention on several grounds including non-compliance of the inbuilt procedural safeguards not apprising him of his right to make a representation before the Central Govt, non application of mind and non-furnishing of basic facts and materials constituting the grounds of detention. The respondents in their affidavit have denied the allegations made by the detenu.

    4. We first deal with the detenu's objection as regards non apprising him of his right to make a representation before the Centra! Govt which is evident from both Annexure A and B. There is no reference to the detenu's right of making representaion. The detaining authority along with his affidavit-in-opposition filed on 22.5.98 has also filed the detention order. Annexure A and annexed hereto also a letter addressed to the detenu. At the end of the aforesaid letter, it is stated that

    "you may submit representation if so felt, against the order of detention through the Superintendent of Jail in which you are detained to the State Govt."
    Learned counsel appearing for the detenu placed before us a copy of the grounds of detention which does not contain any such reference. This letter, Annexure A has attached to the affidavit-in-opposition as filed and sworn by the detaining authority on 22.5.98. There is an endorsement by the detenu as a token of having received the same on 16.9.97 ie 4 days after passing of the detention order. It is quite in time so far as section 8 is concerned, but the fact remains that the grounds of detention as supplied to the detenu does not contain any such statements of facts apprising the detenu of his right to make a representation. May be it has been subsequently corrected, but despite this correction made by the respondents, the detenu has not been apprised about his right to make the representation to the Central Govt. Undoubtedly, it cannot be disputed that the Central Govt has the power to revoke any order of detention passed or confirmed by the State Govt under section 14 of the Act and this power is quite independent of the power of the State Govt to confirm or revoke the order of detention passed by District Magistrate. It does not depend on the report of the Advisory Board which may be eventually submitted. The Supreme Court in Kamaleshkumar Ishwardas Patel vs. Union of India & others, (1995) 4 SCC 51 has observed as follows :

    "Having regard to the provisions of Article 22 (5) of the Constitution and the provisions of the COFEPOSA Act and the PIT NDPS Act the question posed is thus answered :

    Where the detention order has been made under section 3 of the cofeposa act and the pit ndps act by an officer specially empowered for that purpose either by the Central Govt or the State Govt the person detained has a right to make a representation to the said officer and the said officer is obliged to consider the said representation and the failure on his part to do so results in denial of the right conferred on the person detained to make a representation against the order of detention. This right of the detenu is in addition to his right to make the representation to the State Govt where the detention order has been made by an officer specially authorised by a State Govt and to the Central Govt where the detention order has been made by an officer specially empowered by the Central Govt, and to have the same duly considered. This right to make a representation necessarily implies that the person detained must be informed of his right to make a representation to the authority that has made the order of detention at the time when he served with the grounds of detention so as to enable him to make such a representation and the failure to do so results in denial of the right of the person detained to make a representation."

    5. It is an admitted position that the detenu has not been apprised of his right to make a representation to the Central Govt so much so as per detention order and grounds of detention as supplied to the detenu. There is no mention of his right to make a representation even to the State Govt, although subsequently, just within four days of passing the detention order, he was informed through a letter that he could make such representation to the State Govt. But there again is no information so far as the Central Govt is concerned. This denial of opportunity to make a representation to the Central Govt vitiates the continued detention of the detenu.

    6. Dealing with clause (5) of Article 22 of the Constitution where from the right to make a representation flows, the Supreme Court, in Kamlesh Kumar (supra) interpreting this Article has held:

    "Article 22 (5) must, therefore, be construed to mean that the person detained has a right to make a representation against the order of detention which can be made not only to the Advisory Board but also to the detaining authority, i.e. the authority that has made the order of detention or the order for continuance of such detention, which is competent to give immediate relief by revoking the said order as well as to any other authority which is competent under law to revoke the order for detention and thereby given relief to the person detained. 'The right to make a representation carried within it a corresponding obligation on the authority making the order of detention to inform the person detained of his right to make a representation against the order of detention to the authorities who are required to consider such a representation."

    7. In Nutan J. Patel vs. SP Prasad, (1994) 2 SCC 315, the Supreme Court had occasion to consider such a contention. A Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissed a writ petition on the ground that the detenu had known that he had a right to make representation but he did not exercise that right and, therefore, the order of detention was not vitiated on the ground of non-intimation of the right to make representation to the specified officer. Of course it was a case under COFEPOSA Act, but the Supreme Court relying on the Kamlesh Kumar (supra) allowed the appeal and quashed the detention, even though the period of detention had already undergone by the detenu and the question had become one of academic interest. The Supreme Court refused to accede to the contention.

    8. In View of the foregoing discussion, this petition, even on this short ground alone, without adverting to other grounds as taken by the petitioner deserves to be allowed, U is accordingly allowed. The impugned order of detention is Mashed. He beset at liberty forthwith, unless otherwise wanted in connection with any other case or cases

    We make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hemanta Nath v. State Of Assam And Ors.
    (Jun 1, 1998)