Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sections 420, 423, 467, 468, 471 and 506, Indian Penal Code,
  • section 249 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1860
  • Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.2.
  • section 95 of the Indian Penal Code,
  • SECTION 249 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • (section 420, Indian Penal Code)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sections 420, 423, 467, 468, 471 and 506, Indian Penal Code,
  • section 249 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1860
  • Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.2.
  • section 95 of the Indian Penal Code,
  • SECTION 249 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • (section 420, Indian Penal Code)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Chhabila filed a criminal complaint under sections 420, 423, 467, 468, 471, and 506 of the Indian Penal Code against Major Jagir Singh, alleging fraud in a land exchange transaction. The complainant's sons owned 20 Kanals of land exchanged by the petitioner, who was not the owner of the land delivered in exchange due to a prior consent decree. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Hissar, after preliminary evidence, ordered summoning of the accused. This order was challenged and set aside by the Additional Sessions Judge, who remanded the case for a fresh speaking order. Meanwhile, the complaint was dismissed for non-appearance of the complainant but later restored by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, who also ordered summoning of the accused again. Two petitions—Criminal Revision No. 115 of 1987 and Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 684-M of 1987—were filed challenging the summoning order and the restoration of the complaint, respectively.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Magistrate was justified in summoning the accused without passing a speaking order applying his mind to the evidence produced by the complainant.
  2. Whether the trial Magistrate had jurisdiction to recall the order dismissing the criminal complaint in the absence of the complainant and restore the complaint.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The dismissal of the complaint due to the complainant's absence could not be recalled by the Judicial Magistrate.
  • Reliance on the Supreme Court decision in Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. Kali Singh which held that Magistrates have no jurisdiction to recall or review orders dismissing complaints for non-appearance.
  • The trial Magistrate failed to apply his mind to the evidence before summoning the accused, contrary to the directions of the Additional Sessions Judge.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • Distinguished the cited Supreme Court case on the basis that the present case involves a non-cognizable offence (section 420 IPC) where the complaint could not be dismissed for non-appearance of the complainant.
  • Relied on section 249 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1860, which allows the Magistrate discretion to discharge the accused in cases of non-appearance of the complainant before framing of charge.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Inder Kahari v. Shri Mahesh Kumar Mehra, 1977 Chandigarh Law Reporter 17 Order summoning the accused must be a speaking order showing application of mind and prima facie opinion on evidence. The Court held the trial Magistrate ignored this principle and set aside the summoning order.
Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. Kali Singh, (1977) 1 SCC 57 : AIR 1977 SC 2432 Magistrates have no jurisdiction to recall or review an order dismissing a complaint for non-appearance of the complainant. The Court applied this ratio to hold the Magistrate had no jurisdiction to restore the complaint dismissed for non-appearance.
Babu Ram v. Ramji Lal, 1964 PLR 196 Dismissing criminal complaint for non-appearance cannot be restored and accused cannot be summoned on the same complaint. Supported the Court's conclusion that restoration of dismissed complaint was without jurisdiction.
Bhagwan Singh v. Gurnam Kaur, 1966 PLR 127 Same principle as above regarding dismissal and restoration of complaints. Reinforced the Court’s stance on jurisdictional limits of Magistrates.
Gurbhajan Kaur v. Yaspal Singh, 1974 PLJ (Cr.) 326 Criminal complaint dismissed for non-appearance cannot be restored. Further supported the Court's decision to quash the restoration order.
Mata Din v. Ram Babu, 1986 (1) RCR 584 : 1986 (1) CLR 208 Magistrate competent to restore complaint dismissed in default; discharge of accused without jurisdiction. The Court rejected reliance on this decision as contrary to Supreme Court precedent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the summoning order and found that the trial Magistrate failed to comply with the Additional Sessions Judge’s direction to pass a speaking order applying mind to the evidence before summoning the accused. The Court relied on the precedent of Smt. Inder Kahari v. Shri Mahesh Kumar Mehra to underscore the necessity of a speaking order showing prima facie opinion. Regarding the restoration of the complaint dismissed for non-appearance of the complainant, the Court examined the Supreme Court ruling in Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. Kali Singh, which held that Magistrates have no jurisdiction to recall or review such dismissal orders. The Court found the respondent's reliance on section 249 CrPC and the Delhi High Court decision in Mata Din v. Ram Babu unpersuasive and contrary to binding Supreme Court authority. Consequently, the Court concluded that the Magistrate lacked jurisdiction to restore the complaint and proceed further on that basis.

Holding and Implications

The petition is accepted and the impugned order dated September 6, 1986 (Annexure P. 4), which recalled the order dismissing the complaint for non-appearance of the complainant, along with subsequent proceedings summoning the accused, are quashed.

The direct effect is that the complaint dismissed for non-appearance remains dismissed and no further proceedings can be taken on it. No new precedent is established beyond the reaffirmation of existing Supreme Court and High Court principles regarding Magistrate jurisdiction and procedural safeguards in summoning accused persons.

    Major Jagir Singh v. Chhabila .

    A.L Bahri, J.:— Vide this order, Cr. R. 115 of 1987 and Crl. M. No. 684-M of 1987 are being disposed of together as the facts are common. One of the orders under challenge is the same. Facts are given from criminal miscllaneous petition filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

    2. Chhabila filed a criminal complaint under sections 420, 423, 467, 468, 471 and 506, Indian Penal Code, against Major Jagir Singh, the present petitioner. Copy of the complaint is Annexure P. 1. Sarwan Singh and Rajinder, sons of Chhabila owned 20 Kanals of land. On October 7, 1981, this land was got in exchange by the petitioner Major Jagir Singh. The petitioner was not owner of the land delivered in exchange since he had suffered a consent decree with respect to land measuring 111 Kanals 4 Marlas in favour of his daughter. In this way, it was alleged that Major Jagir Singh defrauded Chhabila.

    3. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Hissar on the complaint passed an order, Annexure P. 2, on February 8, 1984 after preliminary evidence was recorded that Major Jagir Singh accused be summoned for March 19, 1984. This order was challenged in a revision petition before the Additional Sessions Judge. The order was set aside. The case was remanded to the trial Magistrate for deciding afresh by passing a speaking order, copy of the order of the Additional Sessions Judge dated October 3, 1985 is Annexure P. 3. In the meantime on July 3, 1986, the complainant did not put in appearance before the Magistrate and the complaint was dismissed. Chhabila complainant filed an application for restoration of the complaint dismissed in default which was allowed by Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate vide order dated September 6, 1986, copy Annexure P. 4. On the same day, Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate passed a separate order on the complaint noticing that the complaint had been restored and that the accused be summoned for October 14, 1986, copy of this order is Annexure Page: 363P. 5. Against this order, Criminal Revision No. 115 of 1987 has been filed in this Court on the solitary ground that the trial Magistrate did not apply his mind to the evidence produced in order to come to a conclusion that there were sufficient grounds for proceedings against the accused before summoning him. It was on this very ground that the Additional Sessions Judge had accepted the revision petition and remanded the case to the trial Magistrate. Criminal Miscllaneous Application No. 684-M of 1987 has been filed for quashing the proceedings on the ground inter alia that the trial Magistrate had no jurisdiction to recall the order dismissing the criminal complaint in the absence of the complainant vide order dated September 6, 1986, copy Annexure P. 4, and subsequent proceedings taken on the criminal complaint are also liable to be quashed on that ground.

    4. As far as order, Annexure P. 5, passed on the criminal complaint summoning the accused is concerned, there is no dispute that it is to be see aside as the trial Magistrate ignored the directions of the Additional Sessions Judge while passing this order. The trial Magistrate was required to go through the evidence produced by the complainant and then to come to a conclusion that there were sufficient grounds for proceedings with a complaint and to order summoning of the accused. The Additional Sessions Judge relied upon a decision of this Court in Smt. Inder Kahari v. Shri Mahesh Kumar Mehra, 1977 Chandigarh Law Reporter 17. It was held in this case that the order summoning the accused has to be a speaking order showing the application of the mind by the Judicial Magistrate and the prima facie opinion formed by him on the evidence produced by the complainant.

    5. Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that dismissal of the complaint on account of the absence of the complainant could not be recalled by the Judicial Magistrate. In support of this contention, reliance has been placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. Kali Singh., (1977) 1 SCC 57 : AIR 1977 Supreme Court 2432. That was a case relating to a petty nature and trivial offence, notice of which could not be taken in view of section 95 of the Indian Penal Code, as observed by the Supreme Court. The only allegation was that the appellant had got a copy which was meant for the complainant by signing his name. The complainant had also got his own copy a few days later. The said complaint was dismissed on account of the absence of the complainant. In para 4 of the judgment, the Supreme Court observed that there was no provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (which applied to the case) empowering the Magistrate to review or recall an order passed by him. The Code of Criminal Procedure containing provision for inherent powers under section 561-A conferred powers on the High Court alone. Thus, it was held that the Magistrate had absolutely no jurisdiction to recall the order dismissing the complaint. The learned counsel for the respondent has sought to distinguish the above case on the ground that the present case related to an offence which is non-cognizable (section 420, Indian Penal Code) and the complaint could not be dismissed for non-appearance of the complainant, Reliance has been placed on section 249 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1860 which reads as under:—

    “Section 249. Absence of complainant.—When the proceedings, have been instituted upon complaint, and on any day fixed for the hearing of the case, the complainant is absent, and the offence may be lawfully compounded or is not a cognizable offence, the Magistrate may, in his discretion, notwithstanding anything hereinbefore contained, at any time before the charge has been framed, discharge the accused.”

    6. There is no force in this contention. A perusal of section 249, Criminal Procedure Code, as reproduced above, makes it abundantly clear Page: 364that this section applies to complaints of offences which can be compounded as well as to complaints of non-cognizable offences. The ratio of the decision of the Supreme Court (supra) would be applicable to the case in hand. Reference may also be made to several decisions of this Court. Babu Ram v. Ramji Lal, 1964 PLR 196, Bhagwan Singh v. Gurnam Kaur, 1966 PLR 127, and Gurbhajan Kaur v. Yaspal Singh, 1974 PLJ (Cr.) 326. In the aforesaid case, it was held that criminal complaint dismissed for non-appearance of the complainant could not be restored and the accused could not be summoned on the same complaint. The Magistrate had no jurisdiction to recall or review of order of dismissing complaint for non-appearance of the complainant. Learned counsel for the respondent referred to the decision of the Delhi High Court in Mata Din v. Ram Babu, (1986 (1) Recent Criminal Reports 584) : 1986 (1) Chandigarh Law Reporter 208, wherein it was held that the Magistrate was competent to restore the complaint dismissed in default. Discharge of the accused was without jurisdiction. This judgment is contrary to the ratio of the Supreme Court decision, as referred to above. It cannot be relied upon.

    7. For the reasons recorded above, this petition is accepted and the impugned order dated September 6, 1986 (Annexure P. 4) recalling of order of dismissing complaint for non-appearance of the complainant and further proceedings on the complaint summoning the accused are quashed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Major Jagir Singh v. Chhabila .
    (Aug 8, 1988)