Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 13(1)(a) (b) (c) (d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 read with Sections 406, 409, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code,
  • Sections 13(1) (a) (b) (c) (d) and Sub-section 2 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Section 438, Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 13(1)(a) (b) (c) (d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 read with Sections 406, 409, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code,
  • Sections 13(1) (a) (b) (c) (d) and Sub-section 2 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Section 438, Cr.P.C
Smart Summary

Case Summary — Anticipatory Bail Petition (K.B. Sharma)

Factual and Procedural Background

The prosecution arose from Income Tax raids conducted on 20/21 November 1997 at premises including those of K.K. Jerath, Chief Engineer, Chandigarh Administration. Documents seized during those raids included two diaries which the Income Tax Department forwarded to the Vigilance Cell of Chandigarh in the first week of January 1998. The diaries were decoded and, based on information obtained, a First Information Report was registered on 3 February 1998 under Sections 13(1)(a),(b),(c),(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, read with Sections 406, 409, 420 and 120-B IPC.

Initially three persons were accused: K.K. Jerath, Mr. Vashishat (P.A. to Jerath) and Hiramani (peon). Subsequent decoding of the diaries identified middlemen and additional persons, including Suresh Sharma, Dinesh Sharma and Sunil Kalia (the author of entries). Interrogation indicated the name of the petitioner, K.B. Sharma, then Superintending Engineer, as one who allegedly received secret commissions while effecting purchases for the Government. The Vigilance Cell sought his arrest.

The petitioner applied for anticipatory bail before the Special Judge, Chandigarh, which was rejected by order dated 24.6.1998. The petitioner filed the present petition. An interim anticipatory bail was earlier granted by the court's predecessor on condition that the petitioner would join investigation; the State disputes whether the petitioner properly cooperated during interrogation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether anticipatory bail under Section 438, Cr.P.C. should be granted to the petitioner (K.B. Sharma) in the circumstances of the case.
  2. Whether custodial interrogation of the petitioner is justified and necessary in view of the decoded diary entries and other investigative material.
  3. Whether the arrest of the petitioner would be without basis or motivated by an oblique motive.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Entries in the diaries cannot be treated as books of account and the entries alone cannot be used to fix criminal liability on the petitioner.
  • There is no requirement to effect any recovery by arresting the petitioner.
  • No one has stated that secret commission amounts were actually paid to the petitioner.
  • The petitioner’s role was limited to considering quantities to be ordered; evidence shows quantities were reduced by 50–70% in many cases, which undermines the prosecution's theory that he sought commissions.
  • Communications bearing the petitioner’s signature do not name firms; approval of supplier names is done by the Government of India as 'Approved Suppliers' and the petitioner had no role in selecting firm names.
  • The petitioner had complied with joining the investigation (per the interim bail condition); the Investigating Officer allegedly refused to issue a written certificate of such joining, prompting the petitioner to approach the Judicial Magistrate who observed the petitioner's contention regarding cooperation was not refuted.

State's Arguments

  • Scrutiny and decoding of diaries reveal entries naming the petitioner as a recipient of secret commissions.
  • Custodial interrogation is necessary for effective investigation.
  • The State relied on the decision in State v. Anil Sharma (1997 SCC (Cri.) 1039) to support custodial interrogation in large public-fund-related matters.
  • Co-accused K.K. Jerath had his anticipatory bail rejected by the High Court and the Supreme Court (K.K. Jerath v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, 1998 SCC (Cri.) 809); the State argued the petitioner is similarly situated to Jerath.
  • The petitioner did not properly cooperate in investigation, allegedly declining to reply to interrogation and implicating others in writing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State v. Anil Sharma, 1997 SCC (Cri.) 1039 Support for custodial interrogation in cases involving large sums of public funds (as observed by the court in this opinion). The court relied on the observations in Anil Sharma to justify custodial interrogation where large public funds (secret commissions) were involved.
K.K. Jerath v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, 1998 SCC (Cri.) 809 Denial of anticipatory bail to a co-accused prosecuted under the same provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act; example of treatment of similarly placed accused. The court regarded Jerath's unsuccessful anticipatory bail applications in the High Court and Supreme Court as an indication that the position of the present petitioner was not materially different and used this to support refusal of anticipatory bail.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first explained the object and historical purpose of Section 438, Cr.P.C. — introduced to meet situations where influential persons might be falsely implicated for oblique or political motives — and noted that the provision was aimed at preventing unjustified pre-trial detention. It observed that the criteria for grant of anticipatory bail differ from those applied when considering regular bail after arrest and reiterated that anticipatory bail should be granted where detention appears unjustified or motivated by oblique considerations.

The court then considered the petitioner's specific contentions and the State's counter-material. It held that many of the petitioner's contentions (for example, on the evidentiary weight of the diaries and on disputed issues such as which Superintending Engineer an entry referred to) are matters for trial or for later bail consideration and could not be determinatively addressed at the anticipatory bail stage.

The court noted investigative developments: some middlemen and authors of diary entries are accused, and one accused (Mr. Sachdeva) had become an approver (order dated 2.5.1998), whose evidence might shape the prosecution's case. The prosecution had produced photocopies of entries showing the petitioner named as "K.B. Sharma" with payments indicated to a Superintending Engineer. While the petitioner argued ambiguity (two Superintending Engineers existed), the court found that these materials provided a basis for arrest and investigation.

The court placed weight on the magnitude of alleged secret commissions: initial investigation indicated approximately Rs. 43 lakhs, later said to have nearly doubled. Citing the guidance in Anil Sharma and the outcome of Jerath's anticipatory bail applications, the court concluded that custodial interrogation was justified in a matter involving substantial public funds and potential disproportionate assets.

The court acknowledged a factual dispute about whether the petitioner cooperated with investigation (the petitioner said he joined; the State said he refused to answer). However, the court regarded this dispute as not determinative in light of the other reasons for refusing anticipatory bail.

On balance, the court concluded that it could not hold that the petitioner was being taken into custody without any basis or that arrest was motivated by an oblique purpose. Consequently, the court refused anticipatory bail and set procedural safeguards concerning arrest and remand.

Holding and Implications

Petition dismissed.

Direct consequences and directions resulting from the dismissal:

  • The petition for anticipatory bail is dismissed and the petitioner is not granted anticipatory bail.
  • The authority effecting arrest must immediately inform in writing a near relation of the petitioner of the date and time when the petitioner will be produced before the concerned Magistrate for remand proceedings.
  • The Magistrate granting either police custody or judicial custody remand shall ascertain from the petitioner whether he has any grievance regarding physical torture.
  • If necessary, the Magistrate shall send the petitioner immediately to the nearest hospital/dispensary for medical examination and treatment.
  • The Magistrate must consider the case diary to determine the necessity and propriety of any further police remand.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities (as cited) and does not discuss broader legal implications beyond the direct procedural and investigational consequences set out above.

Order: Petition dismissed.

    K.B Sharma v. State Of U.T Chandigarh .

    S.C Malte, J.:— Petitioner seeks anticipatory bail in a case registered under Sections 13(1)(a) (b) (c) (d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 read with Sections 406, 409, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, registered at Police Station Vigilance Cell, Chandigarh.

    2. The circumstances giving rise to the registration of the case can be briefly summarised as follows:

    3. On 20/21.11.1997, Income Tax authorities conducted raid on the residential premises of certain persons including one Mr. K.K Jerath, who was Chief Engineer, Chandigarh Administration. In the course of those raids certain documents including two diaries came to be attached by the Income Tax Department. The Income Tax Department then thought it proper to apprise the Vigilance Cell of Chandigarh Administration regarding the outcome of raids conducted by it. Consequently, the diaries which were seized during raids by the Income Tax Department, were forwarded to the Vigilance Cell of Chandigarh Police. These diaries were thus received by the Vigilance Cell in the first week of January 1998. The contents of these diaries were then got decoded. With the help of information thus collected a First Information Report in respect of the offences mentioned above came to be registered on 3.2.1998 Initially, these were only three accused namely K.K Jerath (Chief Engineer), Mr. Vashishat (P.A to Mr. Jerath) and one Hiramani (Peon to Mr. Jerath). Mr. K.K Jerath had also sought anticipatory bail which was ultimately rejected by this Court and also by the Supreme Court. At later stage, that aspect would also figure while disposing of the present petition.

    4. Further examination of those diaries indicated that while effecting certain purchases for the Department, other persons besides the accused mentioned above, had also pocketed huge amount of secret commission. The diaries also brought to light the middlemen who had acted as conduits for passing such money. They are Suresh Sharma, Dinesh Sharma and Sunil Kalia. Said Sunil Kalia is said to be the author of entries in the diaries. Interrogation of these persons brought to light further information. On interpretation of the entries in the diaries certain names were found to have been mentioned by showing initials only. Briefly stated, the name of the present petitioner Mr. K.B Sharma also figured as one of the persons who, while functioning as Superintending Engineer at the relevant time, appears to have pocketed secret commission while effecting purchases of stores for the use of Government. The Vigilance Cell of the police, therefore, wants to arrest him for the offences mentioned above.

    5. Apprehending his arrest, the petitioner moved the Special Judge, Chandigarh for the grant of anticipatory bail. The Special Judge, Chandigarh, vide order dated 24.6.1998 rejected the anticipatory bail. Petitioner, thereupon, filed the present petition. During pendency of this petition my learned predecessor had granted ad interim anticipatory bail on condition that petitioner shall join the investigation as and when called by the Investigating Officer. On behalf of the petitioner, it was contended that petitioner had accordingly joined the investigation. This claim is, however, disputed by the State by raising a contention that petitioner has not properly co-operated during his interrogation. At later stage, I will consider this aspect also.

    6. Learned counsel for the petitioner mainly raised five points. It was contended that diaries on which the prosecution placed reliance cannot be considered as books of account and any entry in such diaries cannot be fastened on the petitioner to hold him guilty. The second point raised was that no recovery is to be made by arresting the petitioner. It was further contended that nobody says that the amount has been paid to the petitioner by way of secret commission. It was also contended that role of the petitioner while effecting the purchases is only to consider the quantity to be ordered; and there was material to show that quantity of the stores indented was considerably reduced to the extent of 50 to 70 per cent of the requirement which militates the claim by the prosecution that he was interested in getting secret commission. It was contended that had he been interested in getting the commission, he would not have scaled down the requisitions of stores as put forth by the Executive Engineers. It was further contended that in none of the communications on which the petitioner has signed for getting stores, there is any mention of names of the firms. It was contended Page: 781that names of the firms is approved by the Government of India as the ‘Approved Suppliers’ and the petitioner has nothing to do regarding the names of the suppliers. On these grounds it was submitted that there was absolutely no need to detain the petitioner in custody for interrogation. Moreover, according to the learned counsel, the petitioner had joined the investigation but the Investigating Officer declined to issue him a certificate in writing to the effect that petitioner has thus made himself available for interrogation. It was submitted that on finding that the Investigating Officer has declined to give such certificate regarding joining the interrogation, the petitioner was constrained to move the Court of Judicial Magistrate and the Magistrate has also made an observation regarding joining of investigation by the petitioner.

    7. Learned counsel for the State on the other hand submitted that scrutiny of the diaries and decoding of entries have now revealed that petitioner has been shown by name as the person who has received secret commission from the suppliers. It was submitted that in order to have effective interrogation, custody of the petitioner would be necessary. To substantiate that point, the learned counsel for the State relied upon the case of State v. Anil Sharma, 1997 Supreme Court Cases (Cri.) 1039, It was further submitted that the other accused Mr. K.K Jerath who was involved in this very case had also lost in the High Court and the Supreme Court and consequently, his application for anticipatory bail stood rejected. That case was reported as K.K Jerath v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, 1998 Supreme Court Cases (Cri.) 809. On this premises, it was vehemently contended that position of the present petitioner is not materially different from the position of Mr. Jerath who also (is) one of the co-accused in this very case and is similarly situated. It was further contended that the petitioner has not co-operated properly in the investigation inasmuch as he declined to reply interrogation.

    8. In my opinion, the criteria for grant of anticipatory bail is materially different from the criteria while considering the regular bail after arrest. In order to appreciate this aspect, it would be worthwhile to note the object for which the provision of anticipatory bail under Section 438, Cr.P.C was introduced. Prior to that there was conflict of judicial opinions about the powers of Court to grant anticipatory bail. It had, however, come to notice that necessity to grant anticipatory bail arose mainly because sometimes influential persons try to implicate their rivals in false cases with a view to disgrace them or for the purpose of some political or oblique motives. It was also noticed that political rivalry has given rise to the tendency of falsely implicating other persons to malign their image. The introduction of Section 438, Cr.P.C, for the grant of anticipatory bail was primarily with that object. In the course of application of that provision the Courts have by various rulings laid down certain principles governing the grant of anticipatory bail. The basic idea, however, was to see that a person is not put behind bars without any justification because such detention in custody adversely affects on the persons which cannot be replenished at any time later. Liberty of persons was valued in the light of Constitutional safeguards and Courts were inclined to grant anticipatory bail in all those cases where there appears that detention of a person is either not justifiable on merits or there is element of some oblique motive for the arrest of a person.

    9. The points raised by learned counsel for the petitioner, as referred above, may be good points for determination of bail at later stage. The question as to the evidentiary weight and value of the diaries in which name of the petitioner figure, is a question to be determined at later stage. Some of the middlemen and author to the said entries in the diaries are also mentioned in the list of accused. It may be noted that one of the accused namely Mr. Sachdeva has become approver as per order dated 2.5.1998 passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate. It is yet to be ascertained what material would come in the deposition of Mr. Sachdeva as an approver. The prosecution case would also take shape after evidence of the approver. Learned counsel for the State has placed before this Court photo copies of certain entries in which name of the petitioner was mentioned as K.B Sharma, against which payment of certain amount was shown. I find that these entries would be different from the entries in the diaries in which only initials were given. These entries also pertain to payment of certain amounts to the Superintending Engineer. It was contended by the petitioner that there were two Superintending Engineers and, therefore, reference to Superintending Engineer cannot be said to be to the petitioner. That aspect can be sorted out after further interrogation.

    Page: 78210. The question regarding the proof of fact that certain amounts were received by way of secret commission would be a matter for appreciation during trial. At present, only question to be considered is whether the petitioner is being taken into custody without any justification. Presently, I find that name of petitioner figures as one of the recipients of commission as indicated in the diaries and account books which came to be recovered during the course of investigation, and it cannot be said that he is sought to be arrested without any basis. It also cannot be said that arrest is motivated by some oblique motive. In the context, it may be recalled that Mr. Jerath who was one of the accused in this very case was denied anticipatory bail by the High Court and by the Supreme Court also. The position of the present petitioner is not different from Mr. Jerath. It was contended by learned counsel for the petitioner that case of Mr. Jerath can be distinguished on the ground that he was being interrogated for ascertaining some hidden assets in the light of huge wealth recovered from him during the Income Tax Department raids in respect of which he was not able to show any legal source of acquisition. I find, that might be one of the objects to take Mr. Jerath into custody. The case of K.K Jerath v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, 1998 SCC (Cri.) 809 indicates that he was also being prosecuted for the offences under Sections 13(1) (a) (b) (c) (d) and Sub-section 2 of the Prevention of Corruption Act. It may be noted that the present petition is also being prosecuted under the same Sections. Learned counsel for the State has contended that effective interrogation of the petitioner would be necessary in order to ascertain whether he holds property disproportionate to his known sources of income. Besides that, effective interrogation would also reveal if there are other kickbacks while purchasing the stores for the Government.

    11. It was submitted that effective interrogation could have been done without taking the petitioner into custody. It was submitted that petitioner had made himself available for interrogation on various dates but the Investigating Officer had not cared to put any question, and even declined to issue a certificate for joining the investigation. In that respect my attention was invited to the petition submitted by the petitioner in the Court of Judicial Magistrate. The Magistrate has observed that the contention raised by the petitioner in that petition in respect of co-operation of the petitioner for investigation has not been refuted by the other side and, therefore, should be taken as accepted. On the other hand, an affidavit filed by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance Cell, Chandigarh, indicates that petitioner declined to reply the interrogation made to him and even gave in writing thereby implicating three persons responsible for ruining the career of the petitioner. It, therefore, appears that the fact regarding co-operation of the petitioner to join investigation is a matter of controversy between the two sides. That aspect, however, loses its bearing in view of reasons for which I am going to pass order in this case. At any rate, I would say in the light of observations made by Hon'ble the Supreme Court in the cases of Anil Sharma and K.K Jerath (supra) that Courts leaned in favour of custodial interrogation in cases where huge public funds were involved. In this case the initial investigation indicated that the amount of commission secretly obtained was to the tune of Rs. 43 lacs. Further investigation is said to have raised that figure to almost the double. Under these circumstances, in my opinion, there is no justification to grant anticipatory bail.

    12. In the result, this petition stands dismissed. However, it is directed that the authority arresting the petitioner shall immediately intimate in writing to the near relation of the petitioner, the date and time when the petitioner would be produced before the concerned Magistrate for further remand. The Magistrate while granting either the police custody remand or the judicial custody remand shall ascertain from the petitioner as to whether he has any grievance regarding his physical torture.

    13. If it becomes necessary, the Magistrate shall immediately send the petitioner to the nearest hospital/dispensary for his medical examination and treatment. The Magistrate shall also take into consideration the case diary in order to ascertain the necessity and propriety of extending further police remand of the petitioner.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.B Sharma v. State Of U.T Chandigarh .
    (Jul 27, 1998)