Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — R.L. Anand, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion disposes of two criminal appeals, Nos. 870-SB of 1998 and 1067-SB of 1998, arising from the same judgment in a prosecution under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (the Act). The appeals were filed separately due to the appellant engaging two different lawyers.

The prosecution's case, as narrated in the trial court record, was that on 22.5.1997 police received secret information that three persons (Satnam, Nimma/Nimma Ram and Tilak/Tilak Raj) at village Padiala were seeking transport to carry eight gunny bags of poppy husk. A police party reached the location, saw the three accused with eight bags, and on suspicion apprehended them and the bags. The Investigating Officer informed the accused of their right under Section 50 of the Act to have a search conducted in the presence of a Magistrate or a Gazetted Police Officer. A joint consent memo (Ex. PD) was recorded, the DSP Ashwani Kapoor (a Gazetted Officer) was summoned and the bags were searched in his presence; poppy husk was found. Samples (250 grams from each bag) and the remaining poppy husk (weighed in the record) were sealed; other memos and site plan were prepared, and currency notes were seized pursuant to supplementary search. Samples were submitted to the Chemical Examiner, who reported the contents as poppy heads (report Ex. PK).

The accused were charged under Section 15 of the Act (alleged possession of 280 kgs of poppy husk without licence). At trial the prosecution called several police witnesses (including the Investigating Officer, DSP, ASIs, HC and others) and tendered the Chemical Examiner's report. The accused were examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., denied the incriminating circumstances and did not lead defence evidence. The Special Judge, Ropar convicted the appellants under Section 15, sentenced each to 10 years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh (with two years RI in default). The appellants appealed to the High Court; this opinion relates to those appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the purported compliance with Section 50 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act — specifically the recording of a joint consent to search (Ex. PD) by multiple accused together — satisfied the statutory requirement that each accused be individually offered the choice of search in the presence of a Magistrate or a Gazetted Police Officer?
  2. If Section 50 was not complied with lawfully, whether the resultant search and seizure of contraband (poppy husk) must be treated as illegal and the conviction based on such seizure set aside?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The primary contention advanced on behalf of the appellants was that the compliance with Section 50 of the Act was improper because the trial record showed a joint consent statement (Ex. PD) recorded by the Investigating Officer for all three accused together. Counsel submitted that Section 50 requires that the offer be made to each accused individually and that a joint offer or joint acceptance is not valid. The counsel relied on the decision in Paramjit Singh v. State of Punjab, 1997 (1) Recent C.R. 293 to support the proposition that an offer under Section 50 must be individually given and that a joint offer/answer undermines compliance.

The opinion does not set out any detailed counter-arguments advanced on behalf of the State in the trial court or in the High Court; the AAG appeared for the State but the opinion records no specific State submissions in response.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Paramjit Singh v. State of Punjab, 1997 (1) Recent C.R. 293 Establishes that the offer under Section 50 (to be searched before a Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer) must be given to each accused individually and that a joint offer/response is not acceptable as genuine compliance. The court relied on paragraph 9 of Paramjit Singh to conclude that the joint consent memo (Ex. PD) in the present case was not a permissible mode of compliance with Section 50. The decision supported the conclusion that the "joint" recording was unreliable and did not constitute lawful compliance.
State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh, 1994 (1) Recent C.R. 736 Recognises the settled proposition that non-compliance with the statutory procedure in Section 50 renders search and seizure illegal and inadmissible. The court invoked this decision to hold that, since Section 50 was not complied with as required, the search and seizure of the contraband in the present case must be treated as illegal, undermining the prosecution's case and warranting acquittal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning followed these main steps, based on the material on record:

  1. Examination of the documentary and testimonial record showed that the consent memo (Ex. PD) was a joint consent statement reportedly signed by Nimma Ram, Tilak Raj and Satnam Singh together. The Investigating Officer (Inspector Surjit Singh, PW 4) explicitly stated that a consent memo was prepared and signed by the accused and attested by police and the independent witness.
  2. The court found it implausible and legally insufficient that all three accused could validly and individually exercise the statutory right in unison such that a single, joint statement would satisfy Section 50. The court observed that it was "not believable" that all three appellants "unanimously and with one voice and at the same time" made the requisite individual choice.
  3. The court relied on Paramjit Singh to emphasise the existing authority requiring that the offer under Section 50 be made to each accused individually; a joint assertion undermines the genuineness of the offer and its acceptance.
  4. Because the police action in this case followed secret information (making the Section 50 compliance mandatory), the court concluded that the improper, joint mode of recording the consent amounted to non-compliance with Section 50 as a matter of law.
  5. Invoking State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh, the court treated the search and seizure connected to the defective Section 50 compliance as illegal. On that basis the prosecution's primary evidence of possession (the seized contraband) could not sustain the conviction.
  6. Given these conclusions, the court allowed the appeals, set aside the trial court's conviction and order, and acquitted the appellants of the charges framed under Section 15 of the Act.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS ALLOWED — Convictions set aside; appellants acquitted.

Direct consequences and orders recorded in the opinion:

  • The High Court allowed the appeals and set aside the judgment and order of conviction dated 27.8.1998 passed by the Special Judge, Ropar.
  • The appellants (Nimma Ram, Tilak Ram and Satnam Singh) were acquitted of the charge under Section 15 of the Act.
  • The case property (contraband) stands confiscated to the State of Punjab and is to be destroyed according to rules.
  • The Court directed that intimation regarding acceptance of the appeals be sent to the Superintendent, District Jail, Ludhiana so that the appellants may be set at liberty forthwith if not otherwise required to be detained or convicted in other matters.

No broader or novel legal principle was announced beyond application of the cited precedents: the court applied existing authority on Section 50 compliance and the consequence of non-compliance. The opinion therefore effects the direct result for these parties (acquittal and destruction/confiscation of seized property) and does not purport to lay down a new precedent.

Appeals allowed.

    Nimma Ram v. State Of Punjab .

    R.L Anand, J. (Oral):— By this judgment I dispose of two criminal appeals, Nos. 870-SB of 1998 and 1067-SB of 1998, titled Nimma Ram… v. State Of Punjab….. I may clarify that both these appeals have arisen from one judgment but have been filed by separate lawyers under some misconception as the appellant engaged two separate lawyers at different points of time in order to file their appeals.

    2. These appeals are directed against the judgment and order dated 27.8.1998 passed by the court of Special Judge, Ropar, who convicted appellants Nimma Ram, Tilak Ram and Satnam Singh under Section 15 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (hereinafter referred to ‘the Act’) and sentenced each one of them to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of 10 years and to pay a fine of Rs. 1 lac. In default of payment of fine, each one of the appellants was directed to further undergo rigorous imprisonment for two years.

    3. The brief facts of the case are that on 22.5.1997 Surjit Singh, SHO, Police Station Kurali received secret information that three persons in the area of village Padiala namely Satnam, Nimma and Tilak Raj were looking for transport to carry eight bags of poppy husk. Inspector Surjit Singh recorded F.I.R and the police party consisting of Surjit Singh, SHO, ASI Kulbir Singh, ASI Karnail Singh, HC Kuldip Singh and other police officials including independent witness Yash Pal headed for the disclosed place. On reaching T point in the revenue estate of village Padiala on main Kurali-Kharar road, all the accused were seen present along with eight bags. On seeing the police party they tried to slip away On the basis of suspision, accused along with the gunny bags were apprehended. Inspector Surjit Singh told the accused that he wanted to search the gunny bags and whether the latter wanted to be searched in the presence of a Magistrate or a Gazetted Police Officer. The accused stated that the wanted to be searched in the presence of a Gazetted Officer of the police department. Consent memo Ex. PD to this regard was prepared which was signed by the accused and attested by ASI Kulbir Singh, ASI Karnail Singh and independent witness Yash Pal. Accordingly, a wireless message was flashed and Ashwani Kapoor, DSP, Kharar was summoned to the spot. On reaching the spot, the DSP disclosed his identity and further offered whether the accused wanted to be searched in his presence. On approval of the accused, the Investigating Officer conducted search of the gunny bags in the presence of DSP and it was found that the gunny bags were containing poppy husk. A sample of 250 grams each was taken out from all the eight bags. On weighment the remaining poppy husk in each bag was Page: 450found to be 34 kgs. 750 grams. The remaining poppy husk was put back into the same bags and was prepared in the form of parcels. The parcels and samples were sealed with the seal of the Investigating Officer and that of DSP bearing impressions ‘SS’ and ‘AK’ respectively. The seal of the Investigating Officer was handed over to ASI Karnail Singh after its use, whereas the DSP kept his seal with him. The entire case property was taken into possession vide memo Ex. PB which was attested by DSP Ashwani Kapoor, ASI Kulbir Singh and independent witness Yash Pal. On supplementary search, currency notes of Rs. 80/-, Rs. 65/- and Rs. 52/- were recovered from accused Satnam Singh, Nimma Ram and Tilak Raj respectively, which were taken into possession vide memos Ex. PE, PF and PG. Rough site plan of the place of recovery Ex. PH was prepared and statements of the witnesses were recorded. On reaching police station, the case property was deposited with the MHC Bawa Singh. Samples and sample seals were also deposited with him. On 23.5.1997, the case property along with the accused was produced before Illaqa Magistrate by ASI Kulbir Singh and on return to the police station, the same was deposited with the MHC.

    4. The samples of the poppy husk were sent to the office of Chemical Examiner, who vide his report Ex. PK declared the contents as poppy heads and on completion of investigation, the accused were challaned under Section 15 of the Act in the court in Illaqa Magistrate, who supplied the copies of the documents to the accused and vide commitment order dated 1.8.1997 committed the accused to the Court of Session in order to face the trial.

    5. Vide orders dated, 14.8.1997 all the three accused were charge sheeted under Section 15 of the Act on the allegations that on 22.5.1997 in the area of village Padiala they were found in possession of 280 kgs. of poppy husk without any licence or permit and thereby committed the offence punishable under Section 15 of the Act. The charge was read over and explained to the accused to which they pleaded, not guilty and claimed a trial.

    6. In order to prove the charge, the prosecution tendered into evidence affidavit Ex. PA of Constable Prabjot Singh, who appeared as PW 1. Constable Manjit Singh appeared as PW 2 and stated that on 22.5.1997 Inspector Surjit Singh entrusted to him the special reports for delivering the same to the Illaqa Magistrate and SSP, Ropar. He accordingly delivered the same to the Illaqa Magistrate first and then to S.S.P, Ropar, DSP Ashwani Kumar appeared as PW 3 and Inspector Surjit Singh, the Investigating Officer, appeared as PW 4. HC Bawa Singh appeared as PW 5 and ASI Karnail Singh appeared as PW 6. ASI Kulbir Singh gave his statement by appearing as PW 7. PW Yash Pal was given up by the prosecution as having been won over by the accused. Finally, the prosecution tendered into evidence the report Ex. PK of the Chemical Examiner and closed the case.

    7. Statements of the accused were recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C and all the incriminating circumstances appearing in the prosecution evidence were put to them. They denied those circumstances and stated that they have been falsely implicated in this case.

    8. In defence the accused did not lead any evidence and closed the case.

    9. The trial Court relied the story of prosecution and rejected the defence version, convicted and sentenced the appellants in the manner as stated above and aggrieved by their conviction and sentence, the present appeal.

    10. I have heard Mr. R.S Ghumman, Advocate on behalf of the appellants, Mr. Vikas Cuccuria, AAG on behalf of the State and with their assistance I have also gone through the records of this case.

    11. The frontal argument which was raised by the learned Counsel for the appellants in this case is that the so-called compliance of Section 50 of the Act is not in accordance with the Act. The counsel submitted that the record of the trial Court would show that a joint consent statement under Section 50 of the appellants had been recorded by the Investigating Officer and this mode is not permissible according to law. He further submitted that the mandate of law is that the offer of section 50 should be given to each individual accused and joint offer is no offer in the eyes of law. In support of his contention, the learned Counsel for the appellants relies upon Paramjit Singh v. State of Punjab, 1997 (1) Recent C.R 293. In para No. 9 of the judgment the Hon'ble Lordship was pleased to hold as follows:—

    “Not only no independent witness was present but it is difficult to believe that offer was given jointly and the answer also given in a similar manner. Necessarily, the offer must Page: 451be given to each of the accused individually that if he likes the services of a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate can be procured. It has not been done. It makes one conclude that the said assertion of the prosecution was make-belief rather than genuine. It is, therefore, difficult to hold that there was compliance of the provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 50 of the Act.”

    12. Let us see what evidence has been led by the prosecution in the present case. The consent statement is Ex. PD on the record. A reading of the same would show that it is a joint consent statement made by Nimma Ram, Tilak Raj and Satnam Singh. It is not believable that all the three appellants unanimously and with one voice and at the same time will make the statement before the Investigating Officer that they (would) like to give the search in the presence of a Gazetted Police Officer. The Investigating Officer, Inspector Surjit Singh appeared as PW 4 in this case and his substantive statement is as follows:—

    “I then stated to the accused that I had suspicion that they were having poppy husk in the gunny bags and that their search was to be conducted. I further apprised the accused of their legal right to offer their search before a Magistrate or a Gazetted Police Officer, or myself. The accused stated that they would offer their search before a Police Gazetted Officer. Accordingly consent memo was prepared which is Ex. PD, which was signed by the accused and attested by ASI Kulbir Singh, ASI Karnail Singh and Yash Pal.”

    13. Thus the above would conclusively establish that a joint consent statement was recorded by the Investigating Officer which is not permissible according to law. In this case the compliance of Section 50 was mandatory because the police had received a secret information against the appellants that they were in possession of the poppy husk. Once it is established that Section 50 in this case has not been complied with according to law, the search and seizure of the contraband would become illegal in view of the settled proposition of law as given by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the famous case of State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh, 1994 (1) Recent C.R 736.

    14. In the light of above, I allow these appeals, set aside the judgment and order of the trial Court and acquit the appellants of the charge framed against them.

    15. The case property stands confiscated to the State of Punjab and shall be destroyed according to rules.

    16. Let the intimation about the acceptance of these appeals be sent to the Superintendent, District Jail, Ludhiana so that the appellants may be set at liberty forthwith, if not wanted or convicted in my other case.

    Appeals allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nimma Ram v. State Of Punjab .
    (Mar 31, 1999)