AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rule 8(4) of the Punjab Employment Departments (State Service Class III) Rules, 1964, (hereinafter called the Rules).
  • Rule 8 of the Rules,
  • rule 8(4).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rule 8(4) of the Punjab Employment Departments (State Service Class III) Rules, 1964, (hereinafter called the Rules).
  • Rule 8 of the Rules,
  • rule 8(4).

    Salig Ram Kumar v. Secretary Haryana Public Service Commission, Etc.

    Bal Raj Tuli, J. - The petitioner joined service in the Employment Department of the erstwhile State of Punjab in May, 1958, as a Clerk in the grade of Rs. 60-4-80/5-120/5-175, and was confirmed in that post with effect from April 1, 1966. From October 18, 1961 to August 22, 1968, he worked as a Clerk in the Statistical Section of the Directorate of Employment Exchange, first in the State of Punjab and then, after its reorganisation, in the State of Haryana. While working in the Statistical Section, the petitioner gained experience in collection, scrutiny and interpretation of statistical data in Department of the Government, viz., the Employment Department. The petitioner, during his service, improved his academic qualifications. He passed his B.A. examination in April, 1967, with English, Hindi and Political Science as his subjects. In 1968, he passed Economics as an additional subject and this acquired the academic qualification B.A. with Economics. In January, 1969, at the instance of the Directorate of Employment, Haryana, the Haryana Public Service Commission, through advertisement in the papers, invited applications for the post of one Statistical Assistant for the Employment Department in the scale of Rs. 150-10-300. The qualifications mentioned in the advertisement were the same as are contained in rule 8(4) of the Punjab Employment Departments (State Service Class III) Rules, 1964, (hereinafter called the Rules). According to this rule and the advertisement, the petitioner held the minimum educational qualification, that is, Graduate with Economics. He also claimed that he possessed at least three years' experience in collection, scrutiny and interpretation of statistical data in Government office. He applied for the post but was informed by the Haryana Public Service Commission, by letter dated May 27, 1969, that it has not been possible to select him for interview because he did not possess the qualifications experience as Field Investigator. The petitioner then applied to the Director of Employment and Training for a certificate that he possessed the qualifications and necessary experience as mentioned in rule 8(4). The Director informed the Public Service Commission by letter that the petitioner did possess the qualifications with regard to experience. The result was that the petitioner was called for interview. At the interview, he was told that since he had acquired the experience in collection, scrutiny and interpretation of statistical data before he acquired the minimum educational qualification, he was not eligible for the post and could not be considered for the same. In the opinion of the Commission, the experience in collection, scrutiny and interpretation of statistical data had to be acquired after the acquisition of minimum academic qualifications. This decision of the Haryana Public Service Commission has been challenged in this petition to which written statement has been filed by the Secretary of the Public Service Commission reiterating the views stated above. 2. Rule 8 of the Rules, the interpretation of which is called for in this petition, reads as under :- "8. No person shall be requited to the service by direct appointment, unless he possess educational qualifications in both Hindi and Punjabi upto Matriculation Standard of its equivalent and also the following educational and other qualifications mentioned against each :- Serial No. Post Minimum educational qualifications Other qualifications 1. X X X X X 2. X X X X X 3. X X X X X 4. Statistical Assistant (i) X X, (ii) X X, (iii) Graduate with mathematics A or B course or economics; or At least 3 years experience in collection, scrutiny and interpretation of statistical date in a Government office of a business concern of repute". 3. The language of this rule clearly shows that at the time a person applies for the post, he must possess the minimum educational qualification and other qualifications mentioned in the rule. It is not the requirement of this rule that one qualification should have been acquired before the other. The Commission was therefore, not right in holding that the experience in collection, scrutiny and interpretation of statistical data in a Government office should have been acquired by the petitioner after he became graduate with economics. The petitioner has asserted in the petition that the departmental representatives, at the interview, held by the Public Commission for the selection of the Statistical Assistant, did not agree with the view of the Public Service Commission that this experience in collection, scrutiny and interpretation of statistical data in Government office had to be acquired after the candidate acquired the minimum academic qualifications, to which there is no denial. 4. The learned counsel for the respondents has shown me the requisition sent by the Director of Employment, Haryana to the Public Service Commission, where in item No. 14 in so far as relevant reads as under :- "14. Qualifications required :- (a) Academic (b) Training. as given in Annexure B. (c) (i) Experience (ii) State clearly whether the experience gained by a candidate after acquiring the minimum basic qualification(s) prescribed against clause (a) above is to be taken into consideration. Note :- If no reply is given to c(ii) above the experience gained by a candidate after acquiring the minimum basic qualification(s) prescribed against (a) will only be counted by the Commission". Annexure 'B' with the requisition only gives the qualifications stated in rule 8(4) does not indicate whether one qualification had to be acquired before the other. The Commission inferred from the note to item No. 14, that since nothing had been indicated by the Director of Employment against column C(ii), the experience gained before acquiring the minimum academic qualification had not to be taken into consideration. In my opinion, the commission was not right in striking to this interpretation, especially after the Director of Employment had written to the Commission that the petitioner possessed the necessary qualifications both the academic and as regards the experience. It was not open to the Public Service Commission to go against the opinion of the Director of Employment, who was the appointing authority. The Commission had only to recommend whether the petitioner was suitable for the post, assuming that he had the minimum necessary academic and experience qualifications. 5. For the reasons given above, this petition is accepted with costs and it is held that the petitioner possessed the necessary qualifications mentioned in rule 8(4) and was eligible for the post of Statistical Assistant and had been wrongly ignored while making the selection. A direction is issued to the respondents that the petitioner should be considered for the post of Statistical Assistant, if any, is lying vacant at present. If not, he should be considered for such a post whenever it falls vacant in the future. The costs shall be paid by respondent No. 1. Counsel's fee Rs. 100/-. Petition accepted.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Salig Ram Kumar v. Secretary Haryana Public Service Commission, Etc.
    (Oct 13, 1972)