AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXIII, rule 3
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXIII, rule 3
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition arises from a suit for specific performance. The plaintiff's case included that he had paid Rs. 40,000 as earnest money for the property. On March 27, 1982, at the stage of arguments, counsel for the parties recorded a statement before the trial court that the parties had compromised: the defendants would pay Rs. 22,000 to the plaintiff and deposit that sum in Court by 15.6.1982, failing which they would be liable to pay Rs. 40,000. The trial court, in the presence of counsel, passed an order on 27.3.1982 decreeing the suit to the effect that the defendants shall pay Rs. 22,000 and deposit it in Court by 15.6.1982, with the contingency that failure to deposit would entitle the plaintiff to Rs. 40,000.

The defendants filed a revision petition against that order; a Division Bench of this Court dismissed the revision petition by order dated May 3, 1983 (reported as Manohar Lal v. Surjan Singh, 1983, Punjab Law Journal 402). The defendants obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, which, by order dated July 29, 1988, granted special leave, set aside the High Court's order and remitted the matter back to the High Court for reconsideration in light of the Supreme Court's observations in Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel (1987)(2) SCALE 1338. Following that remand, the present revision petition came up for hearing in this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a compromise recorded by counsel in Court, without a written and signed agreement reducing the terms of the compromise, satisfies the requirements of Order XXIII, rule 3.
  2. Whether the plaintiff's claim was in fact satisfied (by payment or other acceptable proof) such that the recording of the compromise should be treated as a binding satisfaction under Order XXIII, rule 3.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manohar Lal v. Surjan Singh, 1983, Punjab Law Journal 402. The Division Bench's earlier construction of Order XXIII, rule 3 as treating the two parts disjunctively (first part as lawful agreement/compromise arrived at out of Court; second part where defendant satisfies plaintiff). The Court observed that the view expressed in this earlier decision was not correct in light of the Supreme Court's later ruling; accordingly, that earlier view did not stand and the revision petition should be allowed on the basis of the correct legal principle.
Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel. (1987)(2) SCALE 1338 Interprets Order XXIII, rule 3: the word "satisfies" denotes satisfaction of the plaintiff's claim wholly or in part; such satisfaction need not rest on a written agreement and may be proved by a receipt, bank payment or other evidence; the Court must decide upon evidence whether there has in fact been such satisfaction and pass decree under Order XXIII, rule 3. The Supreme Court's observations in this case were treated as authoritative and controlling; the High Court was directed to reconsider the matter in light of these observations, which led this Court to require a written signed compromise or proof of satisfaction before treating the recorded statement as a valid compromise.
Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel., 1988 Punjab Law Journal 118 Same Supreme Court exposition of the meaning and application of Order XXIII, rule 3, as reported in the Punjab Law Journal. The Court relied on the reported paragraph to conclude that the earlier Division Bench view was incorrect and to hold that the trial court must insist on reduction of compromise terms in writing signed by the parties or on proof of satisfaction of the plaintiff's claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court followed the Supreme Court's exposition in Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel that the proper approach to Order XXIII, rule 3 is not the restrictive, disjunctive construction earlier adopted by the Division Bench in Manohar Lal. The Supreme Court clarified that "satisfies" under the rule denotes satisfaction of the claim wholly or in part and may be established by receipts, bank payments or other evidence; the court must decide, on evidence or affidavits, whether such satisfaction has in fact taken place and then pass a decree under Order XXIII, rule 3.

Applying that principle, this Court noted that there was no evidence that the Rs. 22,000, as agreed before the court, was ever paid by the defendants to the plaintiff, and that neither party filed any written compromise nor did either party make a statement in writing reducing the terms of any compromise. As a result, the plaintiff's claim was not shown to have been satisfied and the requirements identified by the Supreme Court were not met. Therefore the impugned order, which had been founded on the oral statement of counsel alone, could not stand.

Holding and Implications

Revision petition accepted and the impugned order set aside.

Consequences for the parties:

  • The impugned order of 27.3.1982 is set aside.
  • The parties are directed to appear in the trial Court on August 2, 1990 for further proceedings in the suit.
  • There will be no order as to costs.

The opinion does not purport to create a new precedent beyond applying the Supreme Court's interpretation in Gurpreet Singh; its direct effect is to invalidate the trial court's order based on an oral compromise where no payment or written signed compromise was shown.

    Shri Manohar Lal And Another Petitioners, v. Surjan Singh And Another

    J.V Gupta, C.J — This revision petition has arisen out of a suit for specific performance.

    2. The case of the plaintiff-respondent herein was that he had paid Rs. 40,000/- by way of earnest money for the purchase of the property. When the suit had reached the stage of arguments, the learned counsel for the parties on March 27, 1982, made the following statement before the Court, which was duly recorded on the said date;

    “Statement of counsel for the parties, the parties have compromised. The defendants shall pay Rs. 22,000/- to the plaintiff. The suit of the plaintiff may accordingly be decreed and rest of his claim may be dismissed. The defendants shall deposit the money in Court on 15.6.1982 In case he fails to deposit the money in the Court on 15.6.1982, then he would be liable to pay Rs. 40,000/- to the plaintiff. RO & AC.

    Dated 27.3.1982

    Sd./- Addl. Senior Sub-Judge, Ferozepur.”

    In view of the aforesaid statement, the Court on that date, in the presence of the counsel for the parties, passed the impugned order, which reads as follows;

    Present; Counsel for the parties. The present suit was filed by the plaintiff against the defendants for specific performance. The case was fixed for evidence of the defendants when on 27.3.1982 the parties effected a compromise. In view of the compromise between the parties the suit is decreed to the effect that the defendant shall pay Rs. 22,000/- to the plaintiff. The said amount shall be deposited in the Court on or before 15.6.1982 In case they fail to deposit the said amount by the said date the plaintiff would be entitled to Rs. 40,000/-. Parties are, left to bear their own costs of the suit in view of compromise. Decree-sheet be drawn accordingly. File be consigned to the record room.

    Page: 287Dated: 27.3.1982

    Sd./- Addl. Senior Sub-Judge, Ferozepur.”

    Against the above-said order, thedefendant filed the present revision petition which was ultimately dismissed by a Division Bench of this Court on reference, vide order dated May 3, 1983. The said judgment is now reported as Manohar Lal v. Surjan Singh, 1983, Punjab Law Journal 402. Aggrieved against the said judgment of the Division Bench the defendants went to the Supreme Court by way of special leave petition which was allowed vide order dated July 29, 1988, which reads as under:

    “Special leave granted and the appeal is disposed of by order herein. Having considered the facts and circumstances of the case, in our opinion, the appropriate order would be to set aside the order of the High Court and remit the matter back to the High Court for re-consideration of the matter in the light of the observations of this Court in Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel. (1987)(2) SCALE 1338. The appeal is disposed of accordingly. There will be no order as to costs.”

    Now, this revision petition has come up for hearing in view of the remand order passed by the Supreme Court.

    3. In Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel., 1988 Punjab Law Journal 118, the Supreme Court has specifically considered Manohar Lai's case (supra) in paragraph 11 of the report, which reads as under;

    “In our considered opinion, the view to the contrary expressed by the High Court in Manohar Lal and another v. Surjan Singh and another, 1983 Punjab Law Journal 402, that the first part relates to a lawful agreement or compromise arrived at by the parties out of Court, does not seem to be correct. Sandhawalia, C. J., speaking for himself and Tewatia J., observes that the word ‘or’ makes the two parts disjunctive and they visualise two distinct and separate classes of compromise. According to the learned Judges, the first part relates to a lawful agreement or compromise arrived at by the parties out of Court, while the second is applicable where the defendant satisfies the plaintiff in respect of the whole or any part of the subject matter of the suit. Such a restricted construction is not warranted by the language used in rule 3. The word ‘satisfies’ denotes satisfaction of the claim of the plaintiff wholly or in part, and for this there need not be an agreement in writing signed by the parties. It is open to the defendant to prove such satisfaction by the production of a receipt or payment through bank or otherwise. The satisfaction of the claim could also be established by tendering of evidence. It is for the Court to decide the question upon taking evidence or by affidavits as to whether there has in fact been such satisfaction of the claim and pass a decree in accordance with Order XXIII, rule 3 of the Code.”

    It is, therefore, evident that the view taken by this Court earlier in this case while deciding the revision petition vide order dated May 3, 1983, was not held to be correct. That being so, the revision petition is liable to be accepted in view of the aforesaid Supreme Court judgment wherein it has been held that the Court must insist upon the parties to reduce the terms of the compromise in writing. It should be signed by the parties and it should be a complete agreement.

    4. It is not the case of either of the parties that a sum of Rs. 22,000/- as agreed by the learned counsel for the parties, was ever paid by the defendants to the plaintiff. Thus, the claim of the plaintiff was never satisfied as such. Apart from the above, neither of the parties as such made any statement, nor any compromise, in writing, was filed in Court.

    5. Under the circumstances, the revision petition succeeds. The impugned order is set aside and the parties are directed to appear in the trial Court on August 2, 1990, for further proceedings in the suit. However, there will be no order as to costs.

    Petition accepted.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Manohar Lal And Another Petitioners, v. Surjan Singh And Another
    (Jul 17, 1990)