Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 6 of the land acquisition act, 1894
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 6 of the land acquisition act, 1894
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Three writ petitions challenging the same acquisition and the declaration issued under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (and G.O. Ms. No. 2171, Adi Dravidar and Tribal Welfare, dated 20.11.1989) were heard together. The petitions seek quashing of the declaration in respect of specific survey numbers.

The petitioners are:

  • W.P. No. 14595 of 1990 — petitioners claimed to be sons of the late Ramasamy Moopanar, son of Muthusamy Moopanar, the original owner of survey no. 138/12b.
  • W.P. No. 15225 of 1990 — petitioner claimed to be owner of survey no. 138/13b.
  • W.P. No. 15226 of 1990 — petitioner claimed to be owner of survey no. 138/10, claiming title under a will dated 6.7.1963 executed by Poonjolai Ammal, the alleged original owner.

Procedurally, notices of motion were ordered (10.9.1990 for W.P. No.14595; 18.9.1990 for the other two), and interim stay of dispossession was granted with liberty to proceed. Notices were served and respondents entered appearance and filed a counter-affidavit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the declaration under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (and the related government order) in respect of the petitioners' lands should be quashed.
  2. Whether there was valid personal service of notices for the enquiry under section 5-A of the Act on the petitioners (or their legally entitled representatives).
  3. Whether the declaration under section 6 was made beyond the period of one year from the date of notification under section 4 of the Act, thereby violating the proviso to section 6.
  4. Whether the absence of simultaneous publication of the substance of the section 4 notification vitiates the acquisition proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • No personal service of notices for the enquiry under section 5-A of the Act was effected on the petitioners.
  • The declaration under section 6 was issued after the expiry of one year from the date of notification under section 4, thereby contravening the proviso to section 6.
  • There was no simultaneous publication of the substance of the notification, which vitiates the acquisition proceedings.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The acquisition covered approximately 0.99.0 hectares in S.F. Nos. 138/10, 138/12b, 138/13b and 138/14b for providing house-sites to 40 houseless Adi-Dravidar families.
  • The section 4(1) notification was issued in G.O. Ms. No. 334 (ADTW) dated 1.11.1988 and published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette on 16.11.1988; it was published in Tamil dailies on 17.11.1988.
  • The substance of the section 4 notification was published at local convenient places on 9.12.1988 and published in Form 3 at collector and relevant local offices on 20.12.1988; individual notices in Form 3-A for the section 5-A enquiry were served on 25.1.1989.
  • Where the original pattadar was dead (for S.F. No. 138/12b), notice was served on a person (Ramasamy, s/o. Arunachala Moopanar) who claimed possession by oral agreement (son-in-law); that person participated in the enquiry. Similarly, in relation to W.P. No. 15225 the person served participated; in W.P. No. 15226 notice was served by affixture after refusal to receive it and the petitioner participated.
  • With regard to the proviso to section 6, the declaration (G.O. Ms. No. 2171 dated 20.11.1989; published in Gazette on 27.11.1989) was within one year from the last of the various publications of the section 4 notification (the respondents relied on a precedent to support computation from the last publication).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Government of Tamil Nadu v. S. Jarayaman, 1992 Writ L.R. 332 Authority for computing the one-year period in the proviso to section 6 with reference to the date of the last of the different categories of publication contemplated under section 4. The court relied on the principle to hold that the declaration under section 6 was made within one year measured from the date of the last relevant publication (20.12.1988), and therefore the proviso to section 6 was not violated by the respondents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the three writ petitions together because they relate to the same acquisition and the parties' counsel made common submissions.

The court examined the factual averments in the respondents' counter-affidavit concerning publication dates, service of notices and participation in the section 5-A enquiry. The court took the following analytical steps:

  • For W.P. Nos. 15225 and 15226, the court accepted the respondents' account that notices were either served personally (and the recipients participated) or, in the case of refusal, were served by affixture and the petitioner nevertheless participated in the enquiry. On that factual basis the court held that the plea of absence of personal notice could not be countenanced as invalidating the proceedings.
  • On the point of simultaneous publication, the court noted that the petitioner’s counsel conceded from the counter-affidavit materials that publication of the substance had been effected within 25 days. The court concluded that publication within that period did not constitute a legal infirmity and could legitimately be treated as simultaneous publication for the statutory purpose.
  • Regarding the proviso to section 6, the court relied on the authority cited (Government of Tamil Nadu v. S. Jarayaman) and the factual dates of publication. The court treated the one-year period as to be computed from the date of the last of the different kinds of publication envisaged under section 4. On that computation the declaration (G.O. Ms. No. 2171 dated 20.11.1989; Gazetted 27.11.1989) fell within one year of the last publication (20.12.1988) and thus did not contravene the proviso.
  • However, with respect to W.P. No. 14595 (S.F. No. 138/12b), the court found a distinct and decisive factual and procedural failing. The respondents knew that the recorded original owner (Ramasamy Moopanar) had died long before, yet the declaration under section 6 still bore the name of the deceased. The respondents accepted notice served on a person claiming to be a son-in-law with an oral claim of mutual arrangement without adequately verifying the heirs or entitlement of the deceased pattadar. The court held that statutory authorities should have made due enquiries to ascertain heirs and could not accept such unverified oral claims from a claimant who asserted to be son-in-law. These lapses and irregularities in verification prejudiced the petitioners and vitiated the acquisition proceedings insofar as S.F. No. 138/12b is concerned.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling:

W.P. No. 14595 of 1990 is ALLOWED insofar as it relates to the lands of the petitioners (S.F. No. 138/12b). W.P. Nos. 15225 and 15226 of 1990 FAIL and are DISMISSED.

Consequences and implications:

  • Direct effect: The impugned land acquisition proceedings and the declaration under section 6 are quashed in so far as they relate to S.F. No. 138/12b (the lands claimed in W.P. No. 14595/1990). The other two petitions challenging acquisition in respect of their lands were dismissed.
  • The court identified and condemned procedural lapses by the authorities in verifying legal heirs and ownership where the recorded owner was dead; such failure can vitiate acquisition insofar as affected lands. This decision rests on the particular facts proved concerning S.F. No. 138/12b.
  • The opinion applies the accepted approach (as cited) that the one-year period in the proviso to section 6 is computed from the date of the last of the assorted publications under section 4; on the facts before the court the proviso was not breached.
  • No broader novel legal principle or new precedent is stated in the opinion beyond application of the cited authority and the factual conclusion that inadequate verification of heirs can invalidate proceedings in relation to particular lands. The opinion does not elaborate further-reaching implications beyond the direct effect on the parties.
  • Costs: There is no order as to costs.

This summary is confined strictly to the findings, facts and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.

    Muthuswamy And Others v. The State Of Tamil Nadu Represented By Secretary To Government Adi-Dravidar And Tribal Welfare Department, Madras And Another

    These three writ petitions can be considered, and disposed of together since they relate to the same acquisition and declaration under sec. 6 of the land acquisition act, 1894 and the learned counsel appearing on either side also made submissions in common.

    2. The above writ petitions have been filed seeking for quashing the declaration issued under sec. 6 of the act and in g. O. Ms. No. 2171, adi dravidar and tribal welfare, dated 20. 11. 1989 in so far as the lands of the respective writ petitioners are concerned. The petitioners in w. P. No. 14595 of 1990 claimed to be the sons of late ramasamy moopanar, s/o. Muthusamy moopanar, the original owner of survey no. 138/12b. The petitioner in w. P. No. 15225 of 1990 claims to be the owner of the property in survey no. L38/13b. W. P. No. 15226 of 1990 has been filed by a person claiming to be the owner of survey no. 138/10 and he claims title under a will said to have been executed on 6. 7. 1963 by his aunt by name poonjolai ammal, stated to be the original owner of the said item of land.

    3. Notice of motion has been ordered by this court in w. P. No. 14595 of 1990 on 10. 9. 1990 and the other two writ petitions on 18. 9. 1990 and at that time, interim stay of dispossession alone was granted with liberty to proceed with further proceedings. Notices have been served and the respondents have entered appearance. A counter - affidavit has also been filed for the respondents.

    4. Mr. V. Nicholas, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in all these cases contended in common for all the writ petitions, that (a) no personal service of notices for the enquiry under sec. 5 - a of the act has been served on the petitioners; (b) that the declaration under sec. 6 of the act came to be made beyond a period of one year from the date of notification under sec. 4 of the act in contravention of the proviso to sec. 6 of the act; and (c) there was no simultaneous publication of the substance of the notification and that this infirmity vitiates the acquisition proceedings.

    5. While meeting the above contentions, learned counsel for the respondents points out from the averments contained in the counter filed that the acquisition in question relating to dry lands measuring about 0. 99. 0 hectares in s. F. Nos. 138/10, 138/12b, 138/13b and 138/14b of nattarmanga - lam village, perambalur taluk, trichy district was for the purpose of providing house sites to 40 houseless adi - dravidar families, that the notification under sec. 4 (l) of the act was issued in g. O. Ms. No. 334 (adtw) , dated 1. 11. 1988 and published on 16. 11. 1988 in the tamil nadu government gazette that the same was published in the tamil daily newspapers on 17. 11. 1988, that the substance of the notification under sec. 4 (l) of the act was published at the convenient places in the locality on 9. 12. 1988 as required under the act and that the substance of the notification was also published in form 3 under the act at the collector s office, trichy taluk office, perambalur sub registrar s office, chettikulam and police station at padalur on 20. 12. 1988 and that individual notices for enquiry under sec. 5 - aof the act in the prescribed form. 3 - a were served on the land owners and interested persons in the lands on 25. 1. 1989. While elaborating the above submission regarding the personal service of notice, it is pointed out for the respondents that so far as the owner in respect of survey no. L38/12b is concerned, the pattadar was said to have died long before and that one ramasamy, s/o. Arunachala moopanar claiming to be the son - in - law of the deceased represented that the lands were given to him by oral agreement and mutual understanding and that he has been served with notice in respect of the said survey number treating to him to be the owner and enjoyer. In respect of the land which is the subject matter of w. P. No. 15225 of 1990 it is claimed that ramasamy, s/o. Arunachala moopanar who claimed to be also the son - in - law of the owner of the land which is the subject matter of w. P. No. 14595 of 1990 has been served with notice and that he did also appear for the enquiry by participating in it. So far as the owner of the land which is the subject matter of w. P. No. 15226 of 1990 is concerned, it is claimed that on the refusal of the petitioner to receive the notice the same was served by affixure and that the petitioner also participated in the enquiry under sec. 5 - a of the act and, therefore, no valid objection could be taken on behalf of the said writ petitioner making a grievance of absence of personal service. It is admitted that so far as the writ petitioners in w. P. No. 14595 of 1990 is concerned, no notices have been served on them and that they have not also participated in the enquiry under sec. 5 - a of the act.

    6. So far as the contention based on the alleged violation of the proviso to sec. 6 of the act is concerned, it is pointed out for the respondents that the declaration under sec,6 of the act came to be made in g. O. Ms. No. 2171, adtw, dated 20. 11. 1989 and published in the tamil nadu government gazette on 27. 11. 1989 and having regard to the date of the last of the different kinds of publication of the notification under sec. 4 (l) of the act referred to already the proviso to sec. 6 of the act could not be said to have been violated and that the declaration was made well within the period of one year from the date of the last of such publication viz. 20. 12. 1988 (vide: government of tamil nadu v. S. Jarayaman, 1992 writ l. R. 332).

    7. So far as the ground and grievance made on the absence of simultaneous publication, the learned counsel for the petitioner himself fairly stated on going through the materials and details frunished in the counter - affidvit that the publication has been effected within 25 days. The same could not be said to suffer any infirmity in law.

    8. I have carefully considered the arguments of the learned counsel appearing on either side. So far as the petitioners in w. P. Nos. 15225 and 15226 of 1990 are concerned, the plea of absence of personal notice cannot be countenanced in the light of the details furnished in the counter - affidavit which has been referred to supra. The writ petitioner in w. P. No. 15225 of 1990 has been served and he has participated in the enquiry too. Though the writ petitioner in w. P. No. 15226 of 1990 has not been personally served, it was only due to the refusal of the petitioner to receive the notice and in the wake of such refusal it is claimed for the respondents that the notice has been served by affixture. The procedure adopted cannot be said to be bad in law particularly when the said person actually participated in the enquiry under sec. 5 - a of the act. So far as the said writ petitioners are concerned, the grievance projected on the ground of alleged absence of personal service of notice has to fail in the light of the facts stated and my conclusions referred to above.

    9. So far as the ground relating to the absence of simultaneous publication is concerned, the details furnished in the counter - affidavit to which a reference has been already made would be lie the claim of the petitioners and the publication with in 25 days of the notification cannot be said to bean infirmity in law or that it cannot be legitimately said to be not a simultaneous publication. This ground of challenge also does not merit acceptance. Equally untenable is the ground of challenge based on the proviso to sec. 6 of the act. Factually the details disclosed would show that the declaration has been made and issued under the act within the stipulated period of one year from the date of the publication of the notification, having regard to the fact that as held by a division bench of this court the period of one year has to be computed with reference to the date of the last of the category of various kinds of publications contemplated under sec. 4 of the notification.

    10. So far as the absence of personal service of notice on the petitioners in w. P. No. 14595 of 1990 is concerned, the only answer of the respondent is that the son - in - law of the erstwhile owner represented that the lands have been given to him on a mutual arrangement and that therefore notice was served on such persons, that he has participated in the enquiry under sec. 5 - a of the act and that therefore no objection could be taken to the enquiry conducted or the absence of personal notice to the petitioners. The stand taken by the respondents in this regard cannot be countenanced in law. Admittedly, the respondents were aware of the fact that the original owner of the lands comprised in s. F. N0. 138/12b by name ramasamy moopanar, s/o. Muthusamy moopanar died long before. In spite of the said factual position, it is surprising that even in the declaration under sec. 6 of the act the name of the erstwhile owner whose death was known to the respondents is found published. On this ground alone, the impugned order in so far as it seriously relates to s. F. No. 138/ 12b deserves to be quashed. That apart, it is beyond comprehension as to how the responsible authorities discharging statutory functions under the act were very much indifferent in making due enquiries to ascertain about the heirs of the deceased owner and were so gullible to readily accept a claim by someone that the lands have been given to him by mutual and oral understanding. The person who made such a claim claimed to be the son - in - law of the erstwhile owner. Such contentions coming from responsible statutory functionaries cannot be either justified or sustained in a court of law. The authorities, in my view have miserably failed to verify properly about the heirs of the deceased pattadar and the fact that such heirs have not themselves come on record cannot be a valid plea in a case of the nature involving the death of the only owner of the land or justify the issue of a notification or a declaration in the name of a dead person. The procedure adopted by the respondents cannot be approved by a court of law. On account of the irregularities and lapses committed on the part of the respondents in properly verifying about the ownership or the legal heirship in respect of s. F. No. 138/12b, the petitioners have been seriously prejudiced. This vitiates the impugned land acquisition proceedings in so far as it relates to s. F. No. L38/12b. The grievance made on the absence of notice as well as the manner of issue of notification and the declaration under sec. 6 of the act in so far as it relates to the land of the petitioners in w. P. No. 14595 of 1990 deserves to be sustained.

    11. For all the reasons stated above, w. P. No. 14595 of 1990 shall stand allowed as prayed for in so far as it relates to the lands of the petitioners are concerned, they fail and shall stand dismissed. But, in the circumstances, there is no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Muthuswamy And Others v. The State Of Tamil N...
    (Aug 27, 1992)