Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion: First Appeal arising from Motor Accident Claim

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal challenges the Judgment and Award dated 15/05/2003 passed by the Presiding Officer, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, South Goa, Margao, in Claim Petition No. 206/2001 filed by the present appellants (heirs of the deceased). The appellants are the heirs of late Domnic Barretto who, according to the claim petition, died from injuries sustained in a road accident that occurred on 05.01.2001 at Karmalghat, Quepem. The deceased was riding a motorcycle which was allegedly struck by a pick-up vehicle bearing registration No. KA-30-4143 driven by Respondent No.1, owned by Respondent No.2 and insured with Respondent No.3 (the Insurance Company). The claim alleged rash and negligent driving by the pick-up and sought Rs. 5,00,000/- in compensation, asserting that Domnic was the sole earning member of the family.

All respondents were served in the claim petition but did not appear, and the Tribunal proceeded ex parte. The Tribunal found Issue No. 3 (reproduced below) proved in favor of the applicants, but it refused to fasten liability on Respondent No.3 because the Tribunal was not satisfied that the Insurance Policy produced at trial established the policy's validity on the date of the accident. The appellants filed Civil Application No. 197/2003 in the First Appeal to place a xerox copy of the original Insurance Policy on record; that application was allowed by order dated 04.09.2003. On perusal, the appellate court found the Policy to be a comprehensive policy covering vehicle KA-30-4143 with validity from 14.03.2001 to 13.03.2002 and concluded it was valid on the date of the accident as stated in the appeal record. The impugned Award was modified accordingly.

(The Tribunal had framed Issue No. 3 as: “Do the applicants prove that they are entitled to claim the compensation?”)

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicants proved that they were entitled to claim compensation (Issue No. 3 as framed by the Claims Tribunal)?
  2. Whether Respondent No.3 (the Insurance Company) should be fastened with liability for the compensation awarded by the Tribunal, given the evidence as to the Insurance Policy's validity?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court followed a discrete, fact-focused line of analysis:

  1. The Tribunal had already found Issue No. 3 proved — i.e., it accepted that the applicants were entitled to compensation — but declined to fasten liability on the insurer because the material then before it did not establish the Insurance Policy's validity on the date of the accident.
  2. On appeal, the appellants sought leave to place a true xerox copy of the original Insurance Policy on record by way of Civil Application No. 197/2003; that application was allowed by order dated 04.09.2003, and the policy copy was placed on record in the First Appeal.
  3. The Insurance Policy produced on appeal showed that vehicle No. KA-30-4143 was covered under a comprehensive policy valid from 14.03.2001 to 13.03.2002. On that basis the court concluded that the policy was valid on the date of the accident as recorded in the appeal (the opinion states the date of accident in this context as 05.06.2001 when referring to policy validity).
  4. The learned counsel for Respondent No.3 did not dispute the position that the policy, as produced on appeal, showed coverage including the date in question.
  5. Given (a) the Tribunal's finding that the applicants were entitled to compensation and (b) the production on appeal of an Insurance Policy that, on its face, covered the relevant vehicle during the period that included the date of the accident, the appellate court held that liability should be fastened on Respondent No.3 (the insurer) and the impugned Award required modification to reflect that.

Holding and Implications

The First Appeal was allowed to the extent of modifying the impugned Award so that Respondent No.3 (the Insurance Company) is held liable to pay the compensation and costs ordered by the Tribunal, as modified below.

The court's modification of the Award ordered that:

  • Respondent No.3 shall pay Rs. 6,18,715/- to the appellants (the applicants before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal).
  • Simple interest at the rate of 8% per annum shall be payable by Respondent No.3 from 16.08.2001 until final payment.
  • The applicants are awarded costs of Rs. 2,000/-, recoverable from Respondent No.3.

Consequences for the parties: The direct effect is that the insurer (Respondent No.3) must satisfy the monetary award with interest and pay the stated costs; Respondent Nos.1 and 2 remain respondents but the financial liability for the award is allocated to Respondent No.3. The opinion does not discuss or purport to establish any broader legal principle or precedent beyond the disposition in this case.

Judge: R. M. Savant, J.

    Fatima Barreto v. Balsu Ullhas Xetkar

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    The above Appeal arises out of the Judgment and Award dated 15/05/2003, passed by the learned Presiding Officer, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, South Goa, Margao, in Claim Petition no. 206/2001, filed by the Appellants herein. The said Award is challenged solely on the ground that the Respondent no. 3-Insurance Company, has not been made liable and the Respondent nos. 1 and 2 have been directed to pay the said amount.

    2. The facts in brief can be stated thus :

    The Appellants herein are the heirs of late Domnic Barretto, who expired in consequence of the injuries sustained by him in a road accident which took place on 05.01.2001 at Karmalghat, Quepem. The motorcycle driven by the deceased Domnic was given a dash by a Pick-up vehicle bearing no. KA-30-4143, which was driven by the Respondent no. 1 and which was owned by the Respondent no. 2 and insured with the Respondent no. 3. It was the case of the Appellants that the said Pick up vehicle was driven in a rash and negligent manner resulting in the accident which led to the death of late Dominic Barretto. It was their case that the said Domnic was the only earning member of the family and, therefore, they claimed an amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- as compensation under various heads. Though the Respondents were served in the said Claim Petition, none of the Respondents appeared and, therefore, the matter proceeded exparte against them. In so far as the present Appeal is concerned, issue no. 3 of the issues framed by the Claim's Tribunal, is material and is re-produced herein under :

    “Issue no. 3 : Do the applicants prove that they are entitled to claim the compensation ?

    3. The said issue was held to be proved by the Claims Tribunal, however, the Claims Tribunal has refused to make the Respondent no. 3-Insurance Company liable as details of the Insurance Policy in the matter of its validity etc. were not produced and what was produced was the Policy of the year 2000 and there was no material on record that the Policy was valid on the date of the accident i.e 05.06.2001 The Tribunal was of the view that merely because the Insurance Certificate was produced, the liability could not be fastened on Respondent no. 3 in the absence of their being material to show the validity of the Insurance Policy on the day of the accident.

    4. In the above Appeal, at the time of admission, Civil Application no. 197/2003 came to be filed by the Appellants above named to place the Insurance Policy on record. To the said Civil Application, a true xerox copy of the original Insurance Policy was appended. The same Civil Application came to be allowed by Order dated 04.09.2003, as a result of which, the Insurance Policy was allowed to be produced on record.

    5. A perusal of the Insurance Policy discloses that the vehicle bearing no. KA-30-4143 is covered and that the said Policy is a comprehensive Policy and the validity of the said Policy is from 14.03.2001 to 13.03.2002 and, therefore, the said Policy was valid on the day the accident took place i.e 05.06.2001 The learned Counsel for the Respondent no. 3 does not dispute the aforesaid position.

    6. In the light of the Insurance Policy which has been placed on record in the above First Appeal, the impugned Award would have to be modified. The liability would have to be fastened on the Respondent no. 3-Insurance Company. The impugned Award is, therefore, modified as under :

    “The Appellants herein i.e the Applicants before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, South Goa, Margao, are ordered to be paid the amount of Rs. 6,18,715/- by the Respondent no. 3 along with Simple Interest at the rate of 8% per annum from 16.08.2001 till the final payment. The applicants are also awarded costs of Rs. 2,000/- recoverable from the Respondent no. 3.”

    7. The First Appeal is accordingly allowed to the above extent.

    R. M. SAVANT, J

    arp/*

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Fatima Barreto v. Balsu Ullhas Xetkar
    (Mar 4, 2010)