AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302/328 read with Section 34 and 120-B IPC.
  • Section 302 read with Section 120-B IPC,
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC
  • Section 302, 328/34, 120-B, IPC.
  • Section 378 (3) Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 174 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302/328 read with Section 34 and 120-B IPC.
  • Section 302 read with Section 120-B IPC,
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC
  • Section 302, 328/34, 120-B, IPC.
  • Section 378 (3) Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 174 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Section 378(3) Cr.P.C. was filed by the State of Haryana challenging the acquittal by the Additional Sessions Judge, Faridabad, of four accused who had been tried for offences including Section 302 and related provisions (302/328 read with 34 and 120-B IPC). The prosecution case arose from events of the night intervening 5-6 September 2000: a complaint (Ex.PJ) was lodged on 6.9.2000 by Major General B.S. Dagar reporting the suspicious death of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary and alleging foul play and motive linked to property disputes. An FIR (Ex.PJ/1) was recorded on 6.9.2000 and post mortem proceedings under Section 174 Cr.P.C. were undertaken. Post mortem report Ex.PD and chemical examination report Ex.PF were part of the record. Accused Ved Pal and Smt. Amrindu were charged under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and Section 328/34 IPC; Mehar Chand and Karan Dalal were charged under Section 302 read with Section 120-B IPC. The trial court acquitted all accused by judgment dated 18.11.2003. Aggrieved, the State sought leave to appeal against the acquittal in this Court. The trial court record was requisitioned and notice issued to the accused. After hearing counsel and perusal of the record, the Court reserved decision on whether leave to appeal should be granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether leave to appeal against the acquittal should be granted to the State under Section 378(3) Cr.P.C.?
  2. Whether the prosecution proved that the cause of death of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary was aluminium phosphide poisoning (i.e., whether the chemical analysis and post mortem evidence establish death by poisoning)?
  3. Whether there was sufficient evidence on record of motive or conspiracy to sustain criminal convictions under the charges framed?

Arguments of the Parties

State of Haryana (Applicant)

  • The trial court erred in law in acquitting the accused; leave to appeal should be granted.
  • There was no delay in lodging the FIR; any alleged delay had been satisfactorily explained.
  • The cause of death was proved to be aluminium phosphide poisoning and the trial court was wrong to hold the death as natural.
  • There was sufficient evidence of motive for the accused to commit murder (property grab allegations), making this a fit case to grant leave and convict the accused.

Accused Respondents

  • The cause of death by aluminium phosphide poisoning was not proved; the chemical examiner's report could not be relied upon because samples sent for chemical analysis had been tampered with.
  • The record did not show that a part of the brain was sent for analysis, yet the Chemical Examiner's report referred to brain material — suggesting some other viscera might have been tested.
  • There was ongoing civil litigation between parties; accused had no motive to commit the crime and there was no evidence of conspiracy on the file.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the trial court's analysis and the records (including post mortem report Ex.PD, chemical report Ex.PF, various police and medical endorsements and the testimony of witnesses). The reasoning proceeded as follows:

  1. Examination of the post mortem report (Ex.PD): The post mortem dated 6.9.2000 showed scalp, skull, vertebrae, membranes, brain and spinal cord described as healthy; lungs, liver, spleen, kidneys and intestines were described and parts of many organs were specifically recorded as taken and sent for chemical examination. The post mortem expressly recorded what viscera were placed in sealed jars and did not mention removal of any part of the brain.
  2. Discrepancy regarding brain material: The Chemical Examiner's report (Ex.PF) and later endorsements suggested analysis included brain. However, there was no mention in Ex.PD that the skull was opened or brain removed. The Court found that the endorsement Ex.PE/1 (dated 19.11.2000) by Dr. Jagmohan Mittal and others, asserting that brain was taken and sent, could not be relied upon because it was made long after the post mortem and without supporting material in the post mortem record.
  3. Forwarding letter (Ex.PF/1) deemed inconclusive: The forwarding letter was a printed form stating what a jar "would" contain (including the word "brain"). The Court held that if the brain had not been taken but the printed line was not struck through, the mere presence of the printed word could not be taken as proof that brain material was actually sent.
  4. Admissions by medical witnesses supported the gap: The Chemical Examiner (P.W.6) admitted the skull must be opened to take brain; P.W.4 (Dr. Jagmohan Mittal) likewise stated skull-opening would be recorded. Neither the opening of the skull nor removal of the brain was recorded in Ex.PD. P.W.29 (SI Bani Singh) stated he did not see any injury on the head when the body was handed over after post mortem. These facts reinforced the conclusion that brain was not taken.
  5. Consequence for reliance on chemical report: Because the viscera reportedly analysed included brain (which was not shown to have been taken from this body), the Court concluded the Chemical Examiner's analysis could not be reliably tied to the viscera of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary. Therefore Ex.PF could not be relied upon to prove aluminium phosphide poisoning in this deceased's body.
  6. Defence evidence of antecedent illness: The Court noted defence witnesses (including D.W.1 Dr. G.L. Bansal and the testimony of P.W.4 about prior treatment by Dr. B.L. Chimpa) that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary was treated for diarrhoea and vomiting on 4.9.2000 and 5.9.2000. Prescription Ex.DL and medical opinion Ex.DE were part of this evidentiary showing. The post mortem itself recorded congestion of the small bowel (cherry red appearance), which could be attributable to causes other than poisoning.
  7. Trial court's view and standard of interference: The Court found the trial court had taken a possible view based on the record (paras 11–12 of the trial judgment) that poisoning was not proved and that a natural death due to illness could not be ruled out. Given the evidentiary deficiencies identified, the appellate Court concluded there was no basis to interfere with the acquittal or to grant leave to appeal.

Holding and Implications

Decision: The petition for leave to appeal is dismissed; leave to appeal against the acquittal is declined and the acquittal of the accused by the Additional Sessions Judge is left undisturbed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The accused respondents remain acquitted of the charges; the State's application for leave to appeal under Section 378(3) Cr.P.C. has been refused and the petition dismissed.
  • No broader legal principle was declared as establishing a new precedent in the opinion; the Court emphasized that the trial court had taken a possible view supported by the record, and there was insufficient evidence to prove death by aluminium phosphide poisoning or establish guilt under the charged sections.

    State Of Haryana v. Mehar Chand Son Of Sanwal Singh & Others

    V.M. Jain, J. - This petition under Section 378 (3) Cr.P.C., has been filed by the State of Haryana, Challenging the acquittal of the accused respondents by the Additional Sessions Judge, Faridabad, in a case under Section 302/328 read with Section 34 and 120-B IPC.

    2. The prosecution case in brief is that on 6.9.2000, at 7 p.m. Major General B.S. Dagar, complainant submitted complaint Ex.PJ to ASI Ram Rattan, SHO PS City, Palwal. By way of said complaint, Ex.PJ, the complainant sought registration of suspected murder case in respect of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased, alleging therein that his wife Smt. Suresh Dagar got a telephonic message from Faridabad and Amarpur that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased had died during the night intervening 5-6.9.2000 and suspected foul play in the matter. His wife, her sister Mrs. Hitesh Kharab and Major General R.M. Kharab had left for palwal to report the matter to the local police at Palwal. It was alleged that they suspected foul play as Mehar Chand and his son wanted to grab the property belonging to late Lt. Col. Narbir Singh by showing Smt. Amrendu (wife of Ved Pal son of Dharam Chand) as the daughter of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased. It was further alleged that he (Major General B.S. Dagar) also reached Palwal in the afternoon and there he learnt from local enquiries that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary had been murdered by Mehar Chand son of late Sawan Singh, Ved Pal and Smt. Amrindu to claim the property rights in respect of Smt. Sumtira Chaudhary, deceased. It was accordingly requested that a case be registered under Section 302 and suitable action be taken against the culprits. On the basis of the said complaint Ex. PJ, formal FIR Ex.PJ/l was recorded in PS City Palwal at 7.30 p.m. on 6.9.2000 and special report had reached the Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Palwal on the same day at 9.40 p.m., as per endorsement Ex. PJ/2 on the said FIR Ex. PJ/1.

    3. Earlier thereto, at 11.15 a.m., on 6.9.2000, entry at Sr. No. 15 was made in Daily Diary Register dated 6.9.2000 of PS City Palwal, copy Ex. PAE, on the basis of written application Ex.PS from Mrs. Suresh Dagar wife of Major General B.S. Dagar, Mrs. Hitesh Kharab wife of Major General R.N. Kharab and Mrs. Lalita chaudhary. In the said application Ex.PS also it was alleged that they suspected foul play in the death of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary. It was alleged that they (Suresh, Hitesh and Lalita) were sisters inter se and that they were daughters of late Lt. Col. Narbir Singh and that they were his only legal heirs and that they had learnt that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased had died on the night intervening 5-6.9.2000 under very suspicious circumstances. It was alleged that she used to live with their late father Col. Narbir Singh in their house at Palwal and they suspected that Mehar Chand, his son Ved Pal and his wife Smt. Amrindu were involved in the foul play resulting in her death under the patronage of Karan Dalai, MLA. It was alleged that this had been done with a view to grab their property, of which they were the only heirs. It was requested that a thorough post mortem of her body be carried out to ascertain the real cause of her death and her cremation be stopped immediately. It was also requested that necessary blood and other requisite samples be, collected from D.N.A. test as Mehar Chand and his son Ved Pal were likely to stake a false claim that Smt. Amrindu wife of Ved Pal is the daughter of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary, which in fact she was not. It was alleged that immediate action was requested and that the entire property of their father be handed over to them as they were his only legal heirs. On receipt of the aforesaid application Ex.PS, it was found that proceedings under Section 174 Cr.P.C., were being held and on receipt of the post mortem report further necessary action shall be taken and accordingly contents of the said application Ex.PS were entered in the Daily Diary Register, as per police proceedings Ex.PS/l.

    4. Sub Inspector Bani Singh, to whom the application PS was submitted and who had made endorsement Ex.PS/l for entering the same in the Daily Diary Register, had visited the spot and arranged for a Photographer and took the photographs of the dead body. Thereafter, he carried out the inquest proceedings and prepared the inquest report Ex.PAH. He had noticed some blood, red coloured liquid coming out of the mouth of the dead body, the drops of which had fallen on her clothes. In the inquest proceedings he had recorded the statements of Ved Pal and Smt. Amrindu. He sent the dead body for post mortem examination alongwith police Constable Naresh Kumar and Ved Pal had accompanied the dead body. Police application Ex.PD/1 for conducting post mortem examination and for DNA test was also moved. The post mortem examination was conducted by a Board of Doctors and they submitted post mortem report Ex.PD. After post mortem examination the dead body was handed over to Ved Pal. On the next day i.e. on 7.9.2000, the Doctor who had conducted the post mortem examination had handed over two sealed parcels to him; one containing viscera for chemical examination and the other containing part of viscera for sending the same to Pathology Department. However, he had not prepared any recovery memo in this regard. The Doctor had also handed over two other envelopes to him alongwith the sealed parcels. He deposited the said parcels with the M.H.C. on the same day. On 9.9.2000, SI Bani singh had moved application Ex. PAI to the Medical Officer seeking opinion regarding the admission of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary in the hospital, who made his endorsement Ex.PAI/1 thereon.

    5. Sub Inspector Ravi Dutt, who was entrusted with the investigation of this case on 6.9.2000, had visited the spot and had prepared the rough site plan Ex.PAK. On 10.9.2000, he made application Ex.PAL to Barisal Nursing Home, qua the admission of smt. Sumitra Chaudhary, deceased. On 13.9.2000, SI Ravi Dutt moved application Ex. PL before the Illaqa Magistrate for recording the statement of Major General B.S. Dagar. On 8.11.2000, SI Ravi Dutt moved application Ex.PH to the Medical Officer to ascertain the cause of death of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary. After completion of investigation, challan was submitted in the Court.

    6. Accused Ved Pal and Smt. Amrindu were charged under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC as also under Section 328/34, IPC whereas accused Mehar Chand and Karan Dalal were charged under Section 302 read with Section 120-B IPC, to which charges all the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. The prosecution produced evidence in support of its case. Statements of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C., were recorded in which they denied the prosecution allegations against them and stated that they were innocent and had been falsely implicated in this case. It was alleged that they had strained relations with Sh. Om Parkash Chautala, Chief Minister, Haryana and on that account they had been falsely implicated in this case. In their defence the accused examined various witnesses.

    7. After hearing both sides and perusing the record the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Faridabad acquitted all the four accused of the various charges framed against them, vide judgment dated 18.11.2003. Aggrieved against the same, Sate of Haryana filed the present petition in this Court for the grant of leave to appeal against acquittal.

    8. The trial Court record was requisitioned. Notice was also issued to the accused respondents to show cause as to why leave to appeal be not granted.

    9. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the record carefully.

    10. The learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the State of Haryana submitted before us that the learned Additional Sessions Judge had erred in law in acquitting the accused respondents of the various charges framed against them. It was submitted that there was no delay in lodging the FIR and that the delay, if any, had been satisfactorily explained. It was further submitted that the cause of death in this case was proved to be due to aluminium phosphide poisoning and the learned trial Court had erred in law in holding that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased had died a natural death. It was further submitted that there was sufficient evidence on the record to show that the accused respondents had the motive to commit the murder of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary. It was submitted that it was a fit case where leave to appeal against acquittal be granted and the accused respondents be held guilty for the charges framed against them.

    11. On the other hand the learned counsel appearing for the accused respondents submitted before us that in the present case the cause of death due to aluminium phosphide poisoning was not proved on the record. It was submitted that no reliance, whatsoever, could be placed on the report submitted by the Chemical Examiner in this regard considering that the samples which were sent for chemical analysis had been tampered with. It was submitted that there was nothing on the record to show that brain or part of the brain was sent alongwith other parts of the body while sending the viscera for chemical examination but the Chemical Examiner had also found the brain alongwith the other viscera, which would clearly show that some other viscera was tested. It was further submitted that civil litigation was already going on between the parties but the accused respondents had no motive to commit the crime. It was submitted that in any case there was no evidence regarding the conspiracy, available on the file.

    12. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties and perusing the record, in our opinion, no case for interfering with the judgment of acquittal passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge is made out and as such no case is made out for granting leave to appeal against acquittal, to the State of Haryana.

    13. The learned Additional Sessions Judge while acquitting the accused respondents considered various factors in paras 11 and 12 of the judgment in coming to the conclusion that it was not a case of death by poisoning of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary, deceased. It was found that even though the case set up by the prosecution was that the cause of death of Smt. Sumitra chaudhary was due to administering aluminium phosphide, which was ante mortem in nature and sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course, it was not proved that any part of the brain of the deceased was taken for analysis. It was also found that in the post mortem report Ex.PD, scalp, skull, vertebrae, membrane and spinal cord were found healthy and similarly intestines and their contents were taken for chemical examination. It was found that liver, spleen and kidneys were also found to be healthy and part of the same were sent for chemical examination. It was found that if any part of the skull or brain had been taken then this fact would certainly be mentioned in the report Ex.PD but admittedly this fact was not mentioned therein. It was found that PW20 SI Bani Singh, to whom the dead body of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary was handed over after post mortem examination, admitted that he had not seen any injury on the head of the deceased when the dead body was handed over to him after post mortem examination. It was found that under these circumstances, the statement of PW6 Dr. S.S. Dalal that a part of brain was received in jar alongwith forwarding letter Ex.PF/1 could not be believed. It was further found that if the deceased had been administered aluminium phosphide then the same would affect all the organs of the body and the same could not be healthy as shown in the post mortem report Ex.PD. It was also found that the report Ex.PS/l submitted by the Doctors to show that a part of the brain was also taken out from the body of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary and sent to the Chemical Examiner, was obtained after the bail application was decided by the High Court. It was further found that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary was admittedly suffering from Diarrhoea and vomiting and was taking treatment from the doctors and on that account she expired on the night intervening 5-6.9.2000. It was found that since the daughters of Late Lt. Colonel Narbir Singh and Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary were having a number of litigations, in order to stop the line of succession the accused were got falsely implicated in this case. Taking all these facts into consideration, it was found that the prosecution had failed to prove that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary had died of poisoning.

    14. After going through the entire record, in our opinion, the finding given by the learned trial Court regarding the cause of death is based on evidence available on the record and no fault could be found with the same. Ex.PD is the post mortem report pertaining to Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary. As per the said post mortem report, scalp, skull and vertebrae were found to be healthy and similar was the position with regard to membranes, brain and spinal cord, which were also found to be healthy. Similarly the right lung and the left lung were found to be healthy. However, the parts of botn the lungs were taken and sent for chemical examination. Similarly, stomach and its contents and large intestines and their contents were also found to be healthy and parts thereof were also taken out and sent for chemical examination. Liver, spleen and kidneys were also found to be healthy and parts thereof were taken and sent for chemical examination. All other organs of the body were also found to be healthy, except small intestine and their contests regarding which it was found that the small bowel was highly congested and was having cherry red appearance and a part thereof was taken and sent for chemical examination and also for Histopathological examination, separately. It was further mentioned in the post mortem report that while handing over the dead body after post mortem examination alongwith a copy of the post mortem report, a sealed box bearing 10 seals containing sealed jar No. 1 containing stomach with contents, parts of small and large intestines, another sealed jar No. 2 containing parts of lungs, kidneys, liver and spleen and another sealed jar No. 3 containing sample preservative (saline) and another sealed vial containing blood, was handed over to the police besides sealed envelope bearing five seals and containing forwarding letter and copy of the post mortem report and also police papers duly initialed by the doctors and another sealed envelope containing forwarding letter to the Head of Department of Pathology, Medical College Hospital, Rohtak alongwith sample seals. As referred to above, in the post mortem report Ex. PD, it was nowhere mentioned that any part of the brain was taken out or was sent for chemical examination. This fact was not mentioned either in the column where scalp, skull and vertebrae have been mentioned and shown to be healthy nor this fact was mentioned in the contents of the various jars containing the viscera which were sent for chemical examination. On the other hand, the fact that left and right lungs, large intestines, liver, spleen and kidneys were healthy and parts thereof were taken and sent for chemical examination, was specifically mentioned in the requisite column in the post mortem report and this fact was also mentioned showing that the sealed jar containing viscera contained the above organs of the body.

    15. The post-mortem report is dated 6.9.2000. When some of the accused respondents filed application for anticipatory bail in this Court, this point was specifically raised that the Chemical Examiner had not analysed the viscera taken out from the body of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary, deceased, since part of the brain was not sent for chemical examination but the Chemical Examiner had also received parts of the brain besides other organs and analysis was done in respect of those parts including the brain. This would be clear from the copy of the order dated 15.11.2000, Ex.DQ. This order dated 15.11.2000 was passed by this Court in the presence of the counsel for both the sides. It was thereafter that application dated 117.11.2000, Ex.PE was submitted by the SHO to P.W.4 Dr. Jagmohan Mittal, asking him to clarify as to whether brain was also sent for chemical examination alongwith other organs of the body or not. Thereafter, the Doctors including Dr. Jagmohan Mittal gave their endorsement Ex.PE/1 dated 19.11.2000 that part of the brain was actually taken at the time of post-mortem examination and was sent in jar No. 2, even though the factum regarding sending of part of the brain had not been mentioned in the post-mortem report. It was further alleged that this fact was mentioned in the forwarding letter which was sent to the Chemical Examiner.

    16. In our opinion, no reliance whatsoever, could be placed on the endorsement Ex.PE/1 made by P.W.4 Dr. Jagmohan Mittal and other doctors to the effect that the part of the brain was also taken at the time of post-mortem examination and was sent for chemical examination alongwith other organs of the body. As referred to above, the post mortem examination had taken place on 6.9.2000. There is absolutely no mention in the post-mortem report that part of the brain was taken out and sent for chemical examination. Under these circumstances the doctors on 19.11.2000, vide endorsement Ex.PE/1, could not have specified, in the absence of any material or data that in fact part of the brain was actually taken at the time of post-mortem examination and sent for chemical examination alongwith other organs. So far as the forwarding letter Ex.PF/l is concerned, in our opinion, on the basis of the said forwarding letter Ex.PF/l, it cannot be said that in fact a part of the brain was also sent alongwith other organs of the body while sending the viscera for chemical examination. This is especially so when forwarding letter Ex.PF/1 is a printed letter and it is printed therein that one sealed bottle was containing part of right/left lungs, parts of liver, spleen, right/left kidney and part of brain while the other sealed bottle was containing stomach with contents and part of large, small intestines with contents. It in a given case part of the brain was not taken out for sending the same to the Chemical Examiner for analysis and forwarding letter Ex.PF/1 was sent in routine without striking out the word "brain" therefrom, it could not be said that in fact part of the brain was also sent for chemical examination. This is especially so when in the post-mortem report Ex.PD, it was nowhere mentioned that part of the brain was taken out and sent for chemical examination, either in the body of the post mortem report or in the contents of the sealed jars containing the organs of the body.

    17. In our opinion, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, after considering the evidence available on the record, had rightly found that part of the brain was not sent to the Chemical Examiner for chemical examination. Under these circumstances, it cannot definitely be said that the parts of the body including brain, which were chemically analysed by the Chemical Examiner as per report Ex.PF, were in fact that of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary, deceased, since the parts which were analysed by the Chemical Examiner also contained part of the brain which was never sent. Furthermore, as found by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, P.W.29 SI Bani Singh, to whom the dead bony was handed over after post-mortem examination, had specifically stated that he had not seen any injury on the head of the deceased when the dead body was handed over to him after post mortem examination. P.W.6 Dr. S.S. Dalal, Chemical Examiner, had admitted that for taking out part of the brain, the skull is to be opened. He had also admitted that it was nowhere mentioned in the post mortem report Ex.PD that the skull was opened. Even P.W.4 Dr. Jagmohan Mittal had stated that for taking out the brain portion, the skull portion is to be broken open and this fact had not been mentioned in the post mortem report Ex.PD. Thus, there is absolutely no material on the record to show that in fact part of the brain was sent for chemical examination.

    18. Once it is found that the prosecution had failed to prove that the Chemical Examiner had analysed the viscera in respect to the body of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased (since the organs which were chemically examined contained part of the brain and brain was never sent), no reliance, whatsoever, could be placed on the report Ex.PF submitted by the Chemical Examiner showing that the viscera of the deceased contained aluminium phosphide for holding that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary had died of aluminium phosphide poisoning. P.W.4 Dr. Jagmohan Mittal, a member of the Board of Doctors who conducted post-mortem examination, had deposed during cross examination on behalf of the accused that in case the police was suspecting it to be a case of poisoning, normally the police would write in the police request for post mortem examination in this regard. He stated that in the police request Ex.PD/l there was no mention regarding suspected poisoning. He further stated that during post-mortem examination except congestion in the small bowel, there was no other symptom showing poisoning or suspected poisoning. He further stated that congestion in the small bowel may be due to various other reasons. He further stated that their report in respect of cause of death due to poisoning was only on the basis of the examination of the viscera report Ex.PF. Furthermore, P.W.4 Dr. Jagmohan Mittal had deposed that the fact was within his knowledge that on 4.9.2000 and 5.9.2000, Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary was ill and under medical treatment, immediately two days before her death and that treatment was given by Dr. B.L. Chimpa who was a member of the Board of Doctors, conducting post-mortem examination on the dead body of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary. He stated that at the time of post mortem examination on the dead body of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary, he had enquired from the said doctor and he had replied that he had given her treatment in respect of diarrohea, but this fact was not mentioned in the post mortem report Ex.PD. DWI Dr. G.L. Bansal from Bansal Nursing Home Palwal had deposed that he knew Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased as she had been coming to him for treatment. He stated that she had come to him for treatment of diarrohea and vomiting on 4.9.2000 in the evening and had stayed at his Nursing Home for about one hour or so and again she visited his Nursing Home on the same day i.e. 4.9.2000 at about 8-9 p.m. with the same problem. He stated that he gave her adequate and prescribed treatment and thereafter she left his Nursing home. He stated that the symptoms that he notices on the person of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary could have led to vomiting and diarrohoea. He stated that he had seen the record of 4.9.2000 of his Nursing Home which was issued by him on 4.9.2000 and he stated that as per this record he had prescribed certain medicines. He proved the prescription slip Ex.DL. He stated that the ailment of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary was not serious but could have gone serious later on. He stated that in old age this type of ailment could become serious. He further stated that the opinion Ex.DE was in his hand and was seen by him. He stated that on both the occasions when Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary had come to him, Smt. Amrindu accused had accompanied her. He stated that in the prescription, Ex.DL he had not mentioned the time and in the opinion Ex.DE, he had not given the name of Smt. Amrindu.

    19. From the above evidence available on record, in our opinion, it would be clear that on the one hand the prosecution had failed to prove that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary had died of aluminium phosphide poisoning and on the other hand the defence has produced evidence on the record to show that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary was suffering from diarrhoea and vomiting on 4.9.2000 and 5.9.2000 and she was treated not only by D.W.1 Dr. G.L. Bansal of Bansal Nursing Home but was also treated by Government Doctor, Dr. B.L. Chimpa, as deposed by P.W.4 Dr. Jagmohan Mittal. Under these circumstances, the possibility of Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary, having died natural death due to diarrhoea and vomiting cannot be ruled out. In this view of the matter, in our opinion, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, had given his finding regarding cause of death, on the basis of material available on the record.

    20. Once it is found that the prosecution had failed to make out that Smt. Sumitra Chaudhary deceased had died due to aluminum phosphide poisoning, in our opinion, the accused could not be held guilty under Section 302, 328/34, 120-B, IPC.

    21. In view of the detailed discussion above, in our opinion, it would be clear that the Additional Sessions Judge had taken a possible view after considering the evidence available on the record and as such no case for interfering with the judgment of acquittal passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge is made, especially when the prosecution had failed to prove that death of Smt. Sumitra chaudhary, deceased was homicidal or that she had died of aluminium phosphide poisoning. Accordingly, finding no merit in this petition, the leave to appeal is declined and the petition is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Haryana v. Mehar Chand Son Of Sanwal Singh & Others
    (Aug 27, 2004)