Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Central Act, Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1976 (Karnataka Act 81/76), Karnataka Civil Page: 4616Courts (Second Amendment) Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 28/1978), Notification
  • S. 2 of the Amending Act 28/1978, clause (iv) of sub-Sec. (1) of S. 23 of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964 (in Short the Civil Courts Act)
  • Venugopala Gowda, J.:A petition U/S 276 of the Indian Succession Act 1925 (Central Act for short)
  • Sections 4, 5 and 10 of the Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1976 (Karnataka Act 81/76),
  • sub-Sec. (1) of S. 23A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964. (Karnataka Act 28 of 1978),
  • Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1978 (Act 8/78), Ss. 4, 5 and 10 of the Karnataka Act 81/76
  • ARTICLE 254 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 23 KARNATAKA CIVIL COURTS ACT 1964
  • U/S 23-A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act 1964 Notification
  • Indian succession Act, 1925 (Central Act 39 of 1925).(2)
  • Amending Act, Sec. 265 and 388 of the Central Act
  • U/S 23-A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964
  • Amendment) Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 28/1978)
  • s. 388 of the Indian succession Act, 1925,
  • U/S 276 of Indian Succession Act 1925,
  • Central Act and the Civil Courts Act,
  • S. 317 of Part X of the Central Act
  • Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1996,
  • S. 23-A of the Civil Courts Act,
  • S. 30-B of the Civil Courts Act,
  • Indian Succession Act, 1925 (1)
  • U/S 23-A of the 1964 Act. I.A
  • State Amending Act 28/1978,
  • Indian Succession Act 1925,
  • U/S 276 of the Central Act
  • U/S 23-A of the 1964 Act
  • Indian succession Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Central Act, Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1976 (Karnataka Act 81/76), Karnataka Civil Page: 4616Courts (Second Amendment) Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 28/1978), Notification
  • S. 2 of the Amending Act 28/1978, clause (iv) of sub-Sec. (1) of S. 23 of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964 (in Short the Civil Courts Act)
  • Venugopala Gowda, J.:A petition U/S 276 of the Indian Succession Act 1925 (Central Act for short)
  • Sections 4, 5 and 10 of the Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1976 (Karnataka Act 81/76),
  • sub-Sec. (1) of S. 23A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964. (Karnataka Act 28 of 1978),
  • Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1978 (Act 8/78), Ss. 4, 5 and 10 of the Karnataka Act 81/76
  • ARTICLE 254 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 23 KARNATAKA CIVIL COURTS ACT 1964
  • U/S 23-A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act 1964 Notification
  • Indian succession Act, 1925 (Central Act 39 of 1925).(2)
  • Amending Act, Sec. 265 and 388 of the Central Act
  • U/S 23-A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964
  • Amendment) Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 28/1978)
  • s. 388 of the Indian succession Act, 1925,
  • U/S 276 of Indian Succession Act 1925,
  • Central Act and the Civil Courts Act,
  • S. 317 of Part X of the Central Act
  • Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1996,
  • S. 23-A of the Civil Courts Act,
  • S. 30-B of the Civil Courts Act,
  • Indian Succession Act, 1925 (1)
  • U/S 23-A of the 1964 Act. I.A
  • State Amending Act 28/1978,
  • Indian Succession Act 1925,
  • U/S 276 of the Central Act
  • U/S 23-A of the 1964 Act
  • Indian succession Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Venugopala Gowda, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

A petition under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 was filed by the respondents in the District Judge's Court at Madikeri, Kodagu District, impleading the petitioners in this matter. The petition sought to prove a will said to be executed by Ramanna Rai and for grant of probate with effect throughout India in respect of the 'A' schedule property. The respondents opposed the probate petition by filing a statement of objections. Because the petition was contested, it was ordered to be converted into an original suit and issues were framed on 29.6.2001.

Considering an office note on pecuniary and territorial jurisdiction, by order dated 12.12.2003 the District Judge transferred the suit to the Principal Civil Judge (Junior Division), Madikeri for disposal and directed parties to appear on 24.1.2004. The defendants (petitioners before this Court) filed I.A. No. IV under Section 151 CPC in the Civil Judge (Junior Division) asking that the plaint be returned for presentation in the "proper" court (the District Court) or that the record be re-transferred, contending that probate under Section 276 must be tried only by the District Court. The Civil Judge (Junior Division) rejected I.A. No. IV, holding that the District Court's transfer order had attained finality and the plaint could not be returned. That rejection was challenged by the petitioners in this writ petition.

At the hearing before this Court, learned counsel for the petitioners appeared; the respondents, though served, remained unrepresented.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Civil Judge (Junior Division) has jurisdiction to try and dispose of a petition filed under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 which was subsequently converted into a suit?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioners') Arguments

  • The petition under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act (probate) must be tried only by the District Court and subordinate courts have no jurisdiction to try such matters.
  • The District Judge erred in transferring the suit to the Civil Judge (Junior Division), and consequently I.A. No. IV filed under Section 151 CPC asking for return of the plaint to the District Court or re-transfer of the record should have been allowed.
  • By dismissing I.A. No. IV, the trial court committed illegality and the impugned order should be set aside.

Respondents' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments presented by the respondents; it records only that the respondents opposed the petition and filed a statement of objections and that they remained unrepresented before this Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a statutory and contextual analysis focused on the Central Act (Indian Succession Act, 1925), amendments to the Karnataka Civil Courts Act and consequent High Court notification(s). The reasoning proceeded in the following steps:

  1. Identification of central Central Act provisions relevant to probate and administration: Chapter IV provisions concerning granting and revoking probate and letters of administration, specifically noting Section 264 (conferring jurisdiction on District Judge), Section 265 (empowering High Court to appoint delegates for non-contentious cases) and Section 272 (grant of probate/letters by delegate).
  2. Recognition that Part X of the Central Act deals with succession certificates, with Sections 371–374 specifying succession-certificate jurisdiction and procedure, and Section 388 (previously) providing for investiture of inferior courts with District Judge powers in relation to Part X.
  3. Examination of the Karnataka legislative changes: the Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1976 and the subsequent Karnataka Civil Courts (Second Amendment) Act, 1978 (Act 28/1978). By Act 28/1978, clause (iv) of sub-section (1) of Section 23 of the Civil Courts Act was omitted and a new Section 23‑A was inserted.
  4. Analysis of the text of Section 23‑A (as inserted): this section empowers the High Court, by notification, to invest Civil Judges or Munsiffs with such local and pecuniary limits as may be specified, with all or any of the powers of a District Judge under the Indian Succession Act; it provides that such invested Civil Judges or Munsiffs shall have concurrent jurisdiction with the District Judge, and that orders passed by them shall be subject to appeal to a specified forum.
  5. Noted legislative effect: Sections 265 and 388 of the Central Act (which allowed delegation in certain situations) were omitted by the State Amending Act (28/1978), and the new state regime (Section 23‑A and consequent High Court notification) became the operative mechanism for investing subordinate courts.
  6. Consideration of the High Court Notification (No. GOB 460/78) dated 29.3.1979 (and later referenced as dated 12.3.1979 in the record): the High Court purportedly invested officers presiding over courts of Civil Judges and Munsiffs with all or any of the powers of a District Judge under Section 388 of the Indian Succession Act 1925 within their territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction. The Court observed the reference to Section 388 to be an inadvertent error because Section 388 had been omitted; the intention, the opinion states, appears to have been to vest powers in subordinate judges relevant to Part X succession matters (the opinion mentions S.317 of Part X as the intended reference).
  7. Application of constitutional principle: the State amending Act had received the President's assent (22‑11‑1978) and, since wills, intestacy and succession fall within the Concurrent List (Entry 5, Seventh Schedule), Article 254(2) requires the State Act (having presidential assent) to prevail in case of inconsistency with the Central Act.
  8. Factual application: the District Judge's order dated 12.12.2003 transferring the petition (converted into a suit) under Section 276 to the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Madikeri, was made pursuant to consideration of pecuniary and territorial jurisdiction and in conformity with the High Court Notification issued under Section 23‑A of the Civil Courts Act.
  9. Legal consequence: because the State statutory framework and the High Court Notification authorized conferring District Judge powers on Civil Judges within specified limits, I.A. No. IV (seeking return of plaint and arguing lack of subordinate-court jurisdiction) was not maintainable. The trial court's order refusing I.A. No. IV was therefore required to be upheld.
  10. Procedural note ("Order on 'Being Spoken To'"): the Court records that it had earlier (29‑1‑2008) allowed the writ petition and quashed the impugned order, but before signing discovered (after enquiry) the High Court Notification. Having obtained the Notification, the Court recalled its earlier order, posted the matter for being 'spoken to', heard counsel who raised no objection to recall, and then proceeded to rehear and decide the writ petition in light of the Notification and statutory framework.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed and the impugned order is upheld. More specifically, the Court concluded that the transfer by the District Judge of the petition under Section 276 (converted into a suit) to the Civil Judge (Junior Division) was valid under the State legislative scheme and the High Court Notification; accordingly the interlocutory application (I.A. No. IV) seeking return of the plaint or re-transfer was not maintainable.

Core Ruling: The Court upheld the order rejecting I.A. No. IV and dismissed the writ petition.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the Civil Judge (Junior Division) retains jurisdiction to try and dispose of the probate petition (converted into a suit) within its territorial and pecuniary limits; the plaintiffs' request to have the plaint returned to the District Court or the record re-transferred is denied.
  • Legal consequence in broader terms: the opinion rests on the State legislative provision (Section 23‑A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act), the High Court notification issued thereunder, and the constitutional principle (Article 254(2)) that a State Act with Presidential assent can prevail in the concurrent field; the decision applies those statutory instruments to validate the exercise of jurisdiction by subordinate civil courts in succession/probate matters within prescribed limits.
  • No broader precedent beyond application of the cited statutes and notification is explicitly announced by the Court in this opinion; the decision states the direct effect on the parties and does not purport to lay down a novel legal doctrine beyond the statutory interpretation applied.

    B.R Jayanthi And Others v. Radamma And Others

    Venugopala Gowda, J.:—

    A petition U/S 276 of the Indian succession Act 1925 (‘Central Act’ for short) was filed by the respondents herein, in the court of District Judge, Madikeri, Kodagii District, by impleading the petitioners herein. The prayer in the petition was to hold that, the will said to have been executed by one Ramanna Rai, in common form be allowed to be proved and that probate thereon to have effect throughout India may be granted to them, pertaining to the ‘A’ schedule property and for such other relief. The respondents in the Probate Petition have opposed the petition, by filing statement of objections. Since the petition was contested, it was ordered to be converted in to a original suit. Thereafter, issues have been framed on 29.6.2001 Considering the office note with regard to the pecuniary and territorial jurisdiction of the suit property, by an order dated 12.12.2003, the petition which was converted into a suit, was transferred and directed to be considered by the Principal Civil Judge (Junior Division) at Madikeri, by directing the parties to appear in the Court of the Principal Civil Judge (Junior Division), at Madikeri on 24.1.2004 and to take further orders. The defendants, i.e, the petitioners herein, had filed I.A No. IV U/S 151 of CPC with a prayer to return the plaint to the plaintiffs, to present Page: 4614the same in the proper Court, contending that the Civil Judge (Junior Division), has no jurisdiction to issue the probate, in view of the provisions contained under Section 264 of the Act. Said application was opposed by the respondents herein. After hearing the parties, the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Madikeri, has rejected I.A No. IV, holding that, since the District Court has transferred the suit for disposal to it, the plaint cannot be returned, for presentation in the proper court and the earlier order passed by the District Court, transferring the suit to it, having not been questioned by filing an appeal or revision, the order having attained finality, the application was not meritorious. The said order has been questioned in this writ petition.

    2. I have heard Sri. G. Balakrishna Shastry, learned Counsel for the petitioners and perused the records. The respondents though served remained unrepresented.

    3. Sri. G. Balakrishna Shastry, learned Counsel for the petitioners contended that, the probate case U/S 276 of the ‘Central Act’ has to be tried only by the District Court and the subordinate Courts have no jurisdiction to try the suit Learned counsel contended that the District Court had erred in transferring the suit and hence I.A No. IV filed before the Civil Judge (Junior Division) to exercise its inherent power and to return the plaint for presentation to the District Court or to re-transfer the record to the District Court, ought to have been allowed. It is contended by the learned counsel that, in not ordering so and by dismissing I.A No. IV, the court below has committed illegality and hence the impugned order be set aside and the relief prayed in I.A No. IV be granted.

    4. Considering the contentions and the record, the point that arises for consideration is.

    “Whether the Civil Judge (Junior Division), has been conferred with the jurisdiction, to try and dispose of a petition filed U/S 276 of Indian succession Act 1925, which petition was subsequently converted into a suit?”

    5. Provisions relating to granting and revoking of probate and letters of administration, is contained in Chapter IV of the Central Act.

    Sec. 264 confers jurisdiction on the District Judge in granting and revoking probate and letters of administration etc.,

    Section 265 empowers the High Court to appoint such judicial officers within any district as it thinks fit to act for the District judge as delegates for granting and revoking, probate and letters of administration in non-contentious cases within such local limits as it may prescribe.

    Section 272 empowers the grant of probate and letters of administration by delegate.

    6. In order to appreciate the dimensions of the problem and seeking an answer thereto, it is required to examine the relevant provisions contained under the Central Act, Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1976 (Karnataka Act 81/76), Karnataka Civil Page: 4616Courts (Second Amendment) Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 28/1978), Notification issued thereunder, and Article 254 of the Constitution of India.

    7. Part X of the Central Act deals with grant of succession certificate. Section 371 of the Act provides that the District Judge within whose jurisdiction the deceased ordinarily resided, or, if at the time of his death he had no fixed place of residence, the District Judge, within whose jurisdiction any part of the property of the deceased may be found, may grant succession certificate under the Act. Sections 372, 373 and 374 provide the procedure for making an application for grant of succession certificate, its entertainment and the contents of the certificate to be granted. Section 388 has made provision for investiture of inferior Courts, with jurisdiction of District Courts with the power to exercise the function of the District Judge under Part-X i.e in relation to grant of succession certificate.

    8. By Sections 4, 5 and 10 of the Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1976 (Karnataka Act 81/76), The Karnataka State Legislature has made three material amendments concerning Court's jurisdiction and appeal provisions in relation to the proceedings under the Central Act. Subsequently, by Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1978 (Act 8/78), Ss. 4, 5 and 10 of the Karnataka Act 81/76 were omitted by a further exercise, the State legislature has passed Karnataka Civil Courts (Second Amendment) Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 28/1978) for the very same object, though with some material changes.

    9. By S. 2 of the Amending Act 28/1978, clause (iv) of sub-Sec. (1) of S. 23 of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964 (in Short the ‘Civil Courts Act’) was omitted and simultaneously a new S. 23-A was inserted, which read thus:—

    23-A. investiture of sub-ordinate Courts with jurisdiction of District Court under the Indian succession Act, 1925 — (1) The High Court may, by Notification, invest any civil Judge or Munsiff, with such local limits and subject to such pecuniary and other limitations as may be specified in such Notification with all or any of the powers of a District Judge under the Indian succession Act, 1925 (Central Act 39 of 1925).

    (2) Any Civil Judge or Munsiff invested with powers under sub-Section (1) shall have concurrent jurisdiction with the District Judge in the exercise of the powers conferred by the said Act upon the District Judge, and the provisions of the said Act relating to the District Judge shall apply to such Civil Judge or Munsiff, as the case may be, as if he were the District Judge:

    Provided that every order made by the Civil Judge or the Munsiff by virtue of the powers conferred upon him under sub-Sec. (1) shall be subject to appeal.

    (i) to the Court of Civil Judge when the order is passed by the Munsiff;

    (ii) to the District Court where the order is passed by a Civil Judge.

    (3) Every order passed on appeal under the proviso to sub-Sec. (2) shall be subject to appeal to the High Court under the rules contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, applicable to appeals from appellate decree.

    10. By the above Amending Act, Sec. 265 and 388 of the Central Act which had made provisions for delegation of powers of the District Judge in non-contentious cases arising under Chapter IV and in relation to grant of succession certificate under Part X, were omitted.

    11. Pursuant to the above powers conferred on the High Court under the newly inserted S. 23-A of the Civil Courts Act, the High Court has issued a Notification, published in the gazette dt. 29.3.1979 which reads as under.

    “No. GOB 460/78. In exercise of the powers conferred under sub-Sec. (1) of S. 23A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964. (Karnataka Act 28 of 1978), the High Court of Karnataka hereby invests all the Officers Presiding over the Courts of Civil Judges and Munsiffs in the State, with all or any of the powers of a District Judge, under s. 388 of the Indian succession Act, 1925, within the limits of their respective territorial jurisdiction and respective pecuniary jurisdiction.”

    12. Reference to S. 388 of the Central Act in the above Notification appears to be an inadvertent error, since the section had been omitted, by State Amending Act 28/1978, as already noticed above. The intention appears to be to clothe Civil Judge (Sr. Dn) and Page: 4619Civil Judge (Jr. Dn.) with the power of the District Judge under S. 317 of Part X of the Central Act which deals with grant of succession certificate only.

    13. In view of S. 30-B of the Civil Courts Act, as inserted by Karnataka Act 16/1996, the words “Court of Munsiff” and “Court of Civil Judge” as referred to has to be construed as “Court of Civil Judge (Junior Division)” and “Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division)”. S. 30-B reads thus:

    30-B. Construction of references to Civil Judge, Court of the Civil Judge, Munsiff and Munsiffs Court in any judgment and decree, etc.- Unless the context otherwise requires, any reference made to “Civil Judge” “Court of the Civil Judge”, “Munsiff” or “Munsiffs Court” in any judgment, decree, order or other instrument, prior to the date of commencement of the Karnataka Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 1996, shall respectively be construed as reference to “Civil Judge (Senior Division)”, “Civil Judge (Junior Division)” and “Court of the Civil Judge (Junior Division)”.

    14. The State amending Act 28/78 has received the assent of the President on 22-11-1978. Further, the legislative field of Wills, intestacy and succession is in the Concurrent list of the seventh schedule at its Entry 5. Therefore in view of Article 254(2) of the Constitution of India, in case of inconsistency between the Central Act and the Civil Courts Act, the latter having received the assent of the President, has to prevail in the State.

    15. Thus, it is clear that by virtue of powers exercised U/S 23-A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act 1964 Notification has been issued and in pursuance of the said Notification, the District Judge having considered the office note with regard to the pecuniary and territorial jurisdiction of the property, by an order dated 12.12.2003, has transferred the petition filed U/S 276 of the Act, which was converted into a suit, for being tried and disposed of by Civil Judge (Junior Division), Madikeri.

    16. Thus, the power exercised and order passed by the District Judge, is in conformity with the Notification issued by the High Court, which was in pursuance of the power conferred U/S 23-A of the 1964 Act. I.A No. IV filed in the Court of Civil Judge (Junior Division), considering the Notification dated 12.3.1979 referred to supra, issued U/S 23-A of the 1964 Act is clearly not maintainable. Eventhough, the trial Court has not considered the matter in the above background, the order passed holding that I.A No. IV to be not maintainable, is required to be upheld, for the reasons stated herein.

    17. From the examination of the provisions contained in chapter X of the Central Act and Section 23-A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964 it has to be held that, there is provision for delegation and conferring of jurisdiction on the Civil Courts to try matters relating to grant of probate or letters of administration within their pecuniary and territorial jurisdiction. Hence the contentions of the learned counsel for the petitioner, has to be held as untenable and devoid of merit.

    For the foregoing reasons, the Writ Petition is devoid of merit and the impugned order is upheld. Consequently, Writ Petition fails and is hereby dismissed. No costs.

    ORDER ON ‘BEING SPOKEN TO’*

    1. By an order dated 29-1-2008, this writ petition was heard and allowed and the impugned order was quashed. Before the draft of the order could be corrected and order could be signed, having entertained doubt as to whether there is any Notification issued U/S 23-A of the Karnataka Civil Courts Act, 1964 by this Court, investing the jurisdiction of District Court under the Indian succession Act on the subordinate Courts, Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka was requested to look into the old records and make available the Notification, if any, issued.

    2. Registrar General made available to me a Notification No. GOB 460/78, dated 12-3-1979, which shows that High Court of Karnataka has invested all the officers, presiding over the Courts of civil Judges and munsiffs in the State, with all or any of the powers of a District Judge U/S 388 of the Indian succession Act 1925, with-in the limits of their respective territorial jurisdiction and respective pecuniary jurisdiction.

    3. Since the said Notification referred to supra, was not brought to my notice, even after I had made enquiries with the branch dealing with succession matters, on the date writ petition was heard and said order was dictated in the Court, allowing the writ petition, before the draft could be corrected and order could be signed, the doubt was Page: 4622clarified. Hence, the writ petition was ordered to be posted before the Court for “being spoken to”, to reconsider the order dictated in open Court on 29-1-2008.

    4. Heard Sri G. Balakrishna Shastry, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners. In view of the Notification dated 12-3-1979 referred to supra, learned counsel has no objection to recall the order dated 29-1-2008 and to rehear the writ petition. For the foregoing reasons the order dated 29-1-2008 is recalled. Further arguments in the writ petition are heard and a separate order is passed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    B.R Jayanthi And Others v. Radamma And Others
    (Feb 15, 2008)