Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 5 of the Watan Act III of 1874
  • section 5(1)(a) of the Watan Act
  • Bombay Act III of 1874.
  • Bombay Act V of 1886.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 5 of the Watan Act III of 1874
  • section 5(1)(a) of the Watan Act
  • Bombay Act III of 1874.
  • Bombay Act V of 1886.

    Narayan Raghtjnath Kulkarni v. Krishnaji Govind Kulkarni

    Patkar, J.:—

    The question involved in this second appeal is whether a watandar can validly devise his watan property by will in favour of a watandar of the same watan.

    The lands in suit are admittedly Kulkarni watan lands. The Kulkarni service is commuted. Mere commutation of service does not affect the rule as to inalienability embodied in section 5(1)(a) of the Watan Act unless the right of alienation without the sanction of Government is conferred on the watandars by the terms of the settlement or has been acquired by them under the same terms. The property in suit is not alleged to be watan property assigned under section 23 as remuneration of an officiator. section 7 of the watan act will not, therefore, apply. It is common ground that section 5(1)(a) of the Watan Act applies to the property in suit. section 5(1)(a) of the Watan Act says that without the sanction of Government it shall not be competent to a watandar to alienate for a period beyond the term of his natural life any watan to any person who is not a watandar of the same watan. Under section 5(1)(a) of the Watan Act the power of alienation of a watandar is restricted to his lifetime only in case the alienation is to a stranger and not to a watandar of the same watan. An alienation to a watandar of the same watan is not prohibited. In the present case the devise by will is in favour of defenants Nos. 1, 2 and 3 who are watandars of the same watan. The plaintiff claims the property by inheritance along with defendant No. 4.

    The question, therefore, in the case is whether the word “alienate” excludes a devise by will. It is urged on behalf of the appellant that the word “alienate” means to transfer by sale. It is conceded on behalf of the appellant that the watandar can make a gift of the watan property to a watandar of the same watan. If a watandar can alienate the property by gift inter vivos, he would presumably have the right to alienate by will in favour of a watandar of the same watan. The word “alienation” according to Stroud's Judicial Dictionary, Vol. I, p. 65, means “to make a thing another man's.” “Alienate,” according to Wharton's Law Lexicon, means “to transfer property.” Alienation would, therefore, include a devise by gift if the effect of it is to make the property another man's by means of a bequest. It is urged on behalf of the respondents that if the word “alienation” excludes a bequest it would lead to the anomalous result that a bequest in favour of a stranger would not be prohibited by section 5(1)(a) of the Wtatan Act.

    In Bhimappa v. Mariappa it was held that the interest enjoyed by one of a body of coparceners, in possession of land attached by way of emolument to a hereditary office, cannot be bequeathed to one or more of the other coparceners, as the estate held by each sharer is only a life interest, subject to the right of the Collector, under Act XI of 1843, to assign a fit remuneration from the rent and profits for the maintenance of the person appointed to conduct the duties of the office. This decision was prior to the enactment of Bombay Act III of 1874. The original section 5 of the Watan Act III of 1874 ran as follows:—

    “No watandar shall, without the sanction of Government, sell, mortgage, or otherwise alienate or assign any watan or part thereof or interest therein to any person not a watandar of the same watan.”

    The words “otherwise alienate” would include a devise by will, and an alienation in favour of a watandar of the same watan would be valid under the original section and also under the present section substituted by Bombay Act V of 1886. In Bai Devkore v. Amritram Jamiatram a bequest in favour of a stranger was described as an alienation by will, and it was held that the alienation by will of what was a watan held for service in favour of a stranger being in its inception invalid as against the heirs did not become valid because of a change in the tenure of the estate after his life interest had terminated. Though the estate devised comes into existence on the death of the testator under a will, the beneficial interest is created in favour of the devisee in the lifetime of the watandar and stands so long as it is not revoked by the testator during his lifetime. The alienation, therefore, by will by a watandar during his lifetime would be valid beyond the term of his natural life if it is in favour of a watandar of the same watan.

    I think, therefore, that the view taken by both the lower Courts is correct, and this appeal must be dismissed with costs.

    Decree confirmed.
    B.G.R
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narayan Raghtjnath Kulkarni v. Krishnaji Govind Kulkarni
    (Jun 27, 1930)