Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, the son of an adopted son of the late Rajah of Pittapur, sued the defendant, the present Rajah of Pittapur, for maintenance. At the time the suit was filed, the plaintiff's father was alive but died during the pendency of the suit. The Raj of Pittapur is an impartible zemindari, devised by will to the defendant, described therein as the aurasa son of the late Rajah, born three years after the adoption of the plaintiff's father. The plaintiff's father had previously contested the defendant's right to the Raj, alleging the defendant was not the legitimate son of the late Rajah. The Subordinate Judge initially ruled the defendant illegitimate and the Raj inalienable, but this judgment was reversed on appeal, with higher courts holding that the impartible nature of the zemindari precluded the plaintiff's challenge to the will's alienation. In the present case, the defendant resists the maintenance claim on the basis that no legal foundation was alleged, and the plaintiff did not prove any custom or relationship entitling him to maintenance. The Subordinate Court initially granted maintenance to the plaintiff, but this was reversed by the Court of Appeal, which dismissed the case.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff, as the son of an adopted son of the late Rajah of an impartible zemindari, has a right to maintenance out of the Raj's property.
  2. Whether the right to maintenance arises by birth in an impartible zemindari, akin to rights under ordinary joint family coparcenary governed by Mitakshara law.
  3. Whether any custom or personal relationship exists or was proven to support the plaintiff's claim to maintenance.
  4. The legal effect of the impartible nature of the zemindari on co-parcenary rights and maintenance claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff claimed a right to maintenance by birth out of the property constituting the Raj, asserting this right followed the property into the hands of a third party.
  • The plaintiff did not rely on any custom affecting this zemindari nor on a claim based on personal relationship.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant contended there was no legal basis for the claim as no custom or relationship was alleged or proven.
  • The defendant relied on prior decisions holding that in an impartible zemindari there is no co-parcenary, and thus no right to maintenance arises by birth alone.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rani Sartaj Kuari v. Rani Deoraj Kuari (1885) L.R. 15 I.A. 51 Established that in an impartible zemindari there is no right to object to alienation by the holder as there is no co-parcenary. The court relied on this precedent to confirm that the plaintiff had no right to challenge the alienation of the Raj and no co-parcenary rights existed.
Sri Rajah Rao Venkata Surya Mahipati Rama Krishna Rao Bahadur v. Court of Wards (1899) L.R. 26 I.A. 83; 1 Bom. L.R. 277 Confirmed the absence of co-parcenary in impartible zemindaris and the consequent lack of maintenance rights based on birth. The court applied this decision to reject the plaintiff's claim based on coparcenary rights and maintenance.
Bachoo v. Mankorebai (1904) I.L.R. 29 Bom. 51; 6 Bom. L.R. 268 Affirmed that impartible properties do not have co-parcenary rights. The court cited this to support the principle that no co-parcenary exists in impartible zemindaris.
Ilaja Yar-lagadda Mallikarjuna Prasada Nayudu v. Raja Yarlagadda Durga Prasada Nayudu (1900) L.R. 27 I.A. 51; 2 Bom. L.R. 945 Recognized that younger brothers of a zemindar in an impartible estate retain rights to maintenance as junior members. The court distinguished this case, noting that the right to maintenance recognized was tied to junior members of the family and custom, which was not proven here.
Nilmony Singh Deo v. Hingoo Lall Singh Deo (1879) I.L.R. 5 Cal. 256 Held there is no invariable custom allowing maintenance claims beyond the first generation from the last Raja. The court cited this to emphasize the absence of automatic maintenance rights for more remote descendants such as the plaintiff.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by acknowledging the prior decisions that established the impartible zemindari as lacking co-parcenary rights, which traditionally underpin maintenance claims in joint family property under Mitakshara law. The court recognized that in ordinary joint families, junior members have co-parcenary interests entitling them to maintenance, but this is inseparable from the common property nature of the estate. However, the impartible zemindari is a creature of custom, and the Board's binding decisions have settled that no co-parcenary exists in such estates. Consequently, the plaintiff's claim, founded on a birthright to maintenance akin to coparcenary rights, fails. The court further examined the limited categories of persons entitled to maintenance under Mitakshara law, which include those disqualified from inheritance due to personal defects and certain close relatives like widows, parents, and infant children, but not grandsons. The plaintiff did not assert any claim based on personal relationship nor prove any special custom granting him maintenance rights. The court also noted that while some maintenance rights in impartible zemindaris have been repeatedly recognized by custom, no such custom was proven here. The absence of community of interest and the plaintiff's refusal to admit any relationship meant the property was not burdened with his claim. Accordingly, the court concluded that the plaintiff's claim is legally untenable.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed with costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the plaintiff’s claim for maintenance out of the impartible zemindari property is denied due to the absence of co-parcenary rights and failure to establish any custom or personal relationship justifying maintenance. This ruling affirms the settled legal principle that impartible zemindaris do not confer maintenance rights by birth alone beyond recognized classes. No new precedent was set; the decision reinforces existing jurisprudence on the nature of impartible zemindaris and maintenance rights under Mitakshara law.

    Sri Rajah Rama Rao v. Rajah Of Pittapur

    1. The plaintiff is the son of an adopted son of the late Rajah of Pittapur, and he sues the defendant, the present Rajah of Pittapur, for maintenance.At the time that the suit was raised the father of the plaintiff was alive, but pending the suit he died. The Raj of Pittapur is an im-partible zemindari, and was devised by will to the defendant, who was described in the will as the aurasa son of the late Rajah born of one of his wives, three years after the adoption of the plaintiff's father. The plaintiff's father contested the right of the defendant to the Raj, and alleged that he was not the legitimate son of the late Rajah. In that suit the Sub-ordinate Judge decided that the defendant was not legitimate and that the Raj was inalienable The judgment was reversed and the case decided in favour of the defendant by the Court of Appeal and by this Board, who, without deciding as to the legitimacy of the defendant, held that in accordance with what had been laid down by this Board in the case of Rani Sartaj Kuari v. Rani Deoraj Kuari (1885) L.R. 15 I.A. 51 the zemindari of Pittapur, being impartible, there was no right in the plaintiff to quarrel with tha alienation made by the will of the late Rajah.

    2. The defendant in the present case resists the claim on the ground that no legal basis for the claim is alleged. The plaintiff did not attempt to prove that there was any custom affecting this particular zemindari which enjoined the making of grants of maintenance to any persons, nor did he put his case on any claim resting on relationship, a relationship which, following his father's allegation, he did not allow, existed, but he rested his case on what he alleged was the general law, viz that by birth he had a right to maintenance out of the property constituting the Raj, which right followed the property into the hands of a third party. The learned Judge of the Subordinate Court gave judgment in favour of the plaintiff for maintenance and arrears. This judgment was reversed by the Court of Appeal, who dismissed the case. The ground on which the learned Subordinate Judge proceeded was shortly this : He considered that the zemindari was joint family property, only with the peculiar quality that it was impartible. Being joint family property, the right which accrues to every junior member (and a grand-son is such a junior member) in the case of the ordinary joint family under the Mitakshara law exists also in this case. The learned Judges of the Court of Appeal held that after the decisions in Rani Sartaj Kuari v. Rani Deoraj Kuari and Sri Rajah Rao Venkata Surya Mahipati Rama Krishna Rao Bahadur v. Court of Wards (1899) L.R. 26 I.A. 83 : 1 Bom. L.R. 277, it was impossible to base the plaintiff's right to maintenance on any right of coparcenary accruing by birth, and that the case as put was based on no other ground.

    3. It is beyond doubt that the decisions in the Madras Courts prior to the case of Rani Sartaj Kuari v. Rani Deoraj Kuari embodied the theory that there was joint property in an impartible zemindari, which only fell short of coparcenary because, by custom, partition was inadmissible. It is needless to cite or examine the authorities, as their Lordships do not apprehend that there is any doubt as to this statement being correct. It will be sufficient to quoto a fragment of the decision of the Court of Appeal in that case itself:-

    It must be conceded that the complete rights of ordinary copareenary ship in the other members of the family to the extent of joint enjoyment and the capacity to demand partition are merged in-or perhaps, to use a more correct term, subordinated to-the title of the individual member to the incumbency of the estate, but the contingency of survivorship remains along with the right to maintenance in a sufficiently substantial form to preserve for them a kind of dormant co-ownership.

    4. But the decision of the Board which binds their Lordships made that view no longer tenable. It sottled that in an impartible zemindari there is no co-parcenary, and consequently no person existed who as co-parcener could object to alienation of the Whole subject by the de facto and de jure holder. That judgment was followed and applied to this very Raj in the Pittapur case (1899) L.R. 26 I.A. 83 : 1 Bom L.R. 277. The import of these decisions was, in their Lordships' view, correctly stated by Sir Lawrence Jenkins in the case of Bachoo v. Mankorebai (1904) I.L.R. 29 Bom. 51, 58 : 6 Bom. L.R. 268. "It has now been definitely decided,..that in impartible properties there is no co-parcenary.

    5. It was admitted on both sides of the Bar that in an ordinary joint family ruled by the Mitakshara law the junior members, down to three generations from the head of the family, have a co-parcenary interest accruing by birth in the ancestral property; that this co-parcenary interest carries with it the inchoate right to raiso an action of partition and that until partition is de facto accomplished these same persons have a right to maintenance. It seems clear that this right is an inherent quality of the right of co-parcenary-that is, of common property. The individual enjoyment of the common property being ousted by the management of the head of the family, they havo a right till they exercise their right to divide, to be maintained out of the property which is common to them, who are excluded from the management, and to the head of the family who is invested with the manage ment .As it is expressed by the late Mr. Mayne in his work:-

    "Those who would be entitled to share in the bulk of the property are entitled to have all their necessary expenses paid out of its income."
    It follows that the right to maintenance, so far as founded on or inseparable from the right of co-parcenary, begins where co-prcenary begins and ceases where co-parcenary ceases.

    6. There are, however, certain persons who, as is explained by express texts of the Mitakshara, while not entitled to succeed as co-owners, are given rights of maintenance. There is the category of persons who by reason of personal disqualification aro not allowed to inherit. Such are the idiot, the blind from birth, the madman, &c. Such persons aro debarred from the rights of co-parcenary, but are given maintenance in lieu, That this is owing not to a denial of their birth status, but to a personal disqualification preventing enjoyment, is clear by the fact that the children of such porsons, being within the allowed degrees and not themselves stigmatised with the personal defect, got by their birth the full status of coparcenary,

    7. There must also be added another class, eqnally the subject of special texts. The right of this class to maintenance lies in personal relationship, but is limited to the widow, the parent, and the infant child. It does not includo the grand-son. It is obvious that so far as certain individuals are concerned this category overlaps the first. But it is an obligation which is independent of the fact of thero being ancestral or joint family property. It is an obligation attaching to the individual. Those categories exhaust the classes of persons who havo such a right to maintenance under the Mitakshara law.

    8. Their Lordships will now revert to the position of an impartible zemindari as it has been fixed by the decisions before referred to. An impartible zemindari is the creature of custom, and it is of its essence that no co-parcenary exists.

    9. This being so, the basis of the claim is gone, inasmuch as it is founded on the consideration that the plaintiff is a person who, if the zemindari wero not impartible, would be cutitled as of right to maintenance. There is no claim based on personal relationship.

    10. This proposition, it must be noted, does not negative the doctrine that there are members of the family entitled to maintenance in the case of an impartiblo zemindari. Just as the impartility is the creature of custom, so custom may and does affirm a right to maintenance in certain members of the family. No attempt has been, as already stated, made by the plaintiff to provo any special custom ia this zemindari. That by itself in the case of some claims would not be fatal. When a custom or usage, whether in regard to a tenure or a contract or a family right, is repeatedly brought to the notice of the Courts of a country, the Courts may hold that custom or usage to be introduced into the law without the necessity of proof in each individual case. It becomes in the end truly a matter of process and pleading. Analogy may be found in instances in the law merchant or in certain customs in copyhold tenure, In the matter in hand their Lordships do not doubt that the right of sons to maintenance in an impartiblo zemindari has been so often recognised that it would not be necessary to prove the custom in each case. It is this which will explain the reference to rights of maintenance in rases decided sub-sequent to the decision in the case of Rani Sartaj Kuari v. Rani Deoraj Kuari. For example, in the ease of Iiaja Yar-lagadda Mallikarjuna Prasada Nayudu v. Raja Yarlagadda Durga Prasada Nayudu (1900) L.R. 27 I.A. 51, 157 : 2 Bom. L.R. 945, the judgment says:-

    As to the zemindari estate, this Board held that it was impartible, and the consequence is that the plaintiffs, as the younger brothers of the zemindar, retain such right and interest in respect of maintenance as belong to the junior members of a raj or other impartible estate descendible to a single heir.

    11. But their Lordships may agree here with what was said by the Court in the case of Nilmony Singh Deo v. Hingoo Lall Singh Deo (1879) I.L.R. 5 Cal. 256, 259.

    We can find no invariable or certain custom that any below the first generation from the last raja can claim maintenance as of right.

    12. Apart from custom, what is left ? The matter is tersely put by Sankaran Nair, J., in the Court of Appeal:-

    The plaintiff does not advance any claim based on relationship. He refuses to admit any relationship.... As there was no community of interest the property is not burdened with his claim in the hands of a donee.

    13. Their Lordships will humbly advise. His Majesty to dismiss the appeal with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sri Rajah Rama Rao v. Rajah Of Pittapur
    (May 2, 1918)