Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rules of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules, 1953.4.
  • rule 7(1) of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules
  • rule 4 of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules
  • section 15 of the Bihar and Orissa Municipal Act
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • rule 7(1).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rules of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules, 1953.4.
  • rule 7(1) of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules
  • rule 4 of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules
  • section 15 of the Bihar and Orissa Municipal Act
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • rule 7(1).
Smart Summary

Case Summary: Two Writ Applications Relating to Rosera Municipality Elections (R.K. Choudhary, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two writ petitions under Article 226 challenge the election of commissioners of the Rosera Municipality, Darbhanga district. M.J.C. 591 of 1956 was instituted by Raghuni Nayak, who stated he intended to stand as a candidate but was debarred because his name did not appear on the electors' list. M.J.C. 898 of 1956 was instituted by three defeated candidates: Hansi Lal Sahani, Lakhan Nayak and Lakshmi Thakur.

The petitioners sought writs setting aside the election, restraining the returned candidates (opposite party Nos. 3 to 15 in one petition) from functioning as commissioners, and directing the District Magistrate to hold a fresh election. The District Magistrate published a notification fixing 24 July 1956 as the last date for election. The Returning Officer fixed dates for filing nominations (27 June 1956) and scrutiny (29 June 1956).

On 10 April 1956 Raghuni Nayak applied to the District Magistrate seeking preparation of a separate electors' roll, alleging omission of about 700 names from the electoral roll; the District Magistrate rejected the application on 11 April 1956. Polling was held on 24 July 1956, votes were counted on 25 July 1956, and the Returning Officer declared certain candidates elected.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the municipal election was void because the electoral roll used was not prepared in accordance with law (including whether a separate electoral roll should have been prepared under the proviso to rule 4 of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules, 1953).
  2. Whether the petitioners who participated in the election are estopped from challenging the validity of that election after defeat (i.e., whether participation/acquiescence bars a later quo warranto-type challenge).
  3. Whether the election was void because its result was declared after the last date fixed by notification (24 July 1956), and whether the expression “election” or “to elect” includes the declaration of the result such that a post-deadline declaration would invalidate the election.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Raghuni Nayak (M.J.C. 591 of 1956) contended his name and about 700 other qualified persons were omitted from the electoral roll and sought a separate electoral roll under the proviso to rule 4 of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules, 1953.
  • It was submitted that the electoral roll used for the election was therefore inaccurate and the election was void.
  • It was further contended that because the result of the election was not declared by 24 July 1956 (the date fixed by notification), the election was void — the submission being that “election” includes declaration of result and therefore the whole process should have been completed by that date.
  • The petitioners relied on the Bench decision in Parmeshwar Mahasoth v. State of Bihar (1957 BLJR 672 : AIR 1958 Pat 149) in support of their contentions.

Respondents' / Opposing Arguments (as reported)

  • The Standing Counsel for the District Magistrate and Returning Officer opposed the petitions and argued that the petitioners in M.J.C. 898 had participated in the election and were therefore estopped from challenging it after losing.
  • It was contended that the District Magistrate had discretion under the proviso to rule 4 to decide whether a separate electoral roll should be prepared and that the petitioner could not claim such a roll as a matter of right.
  • The opposite party challenged the allegation of omission of 700 names and noted there was nothing to show any of those persons had sought insertion of their names in the roll.
  • It was also pointed out that a separate register of voters (as required under section 15 of the Bihar and Orissa Municipal Act) had been prepared in the present case, making that contention irrelevant here.
  • On the timing point, the respondents relied on the distinction in rule 7(1) and rule 45(1) between the electors' act of voting (which had to be completed by the notified date) and the Returning Officer's function to count votes and declare the result (which may occur after polling and is not an act required of the electors).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Parmeshwar Mahasoth v. State of Bihar, 1957 BLJR 672 : (AIR 1958 Pat 149) (a) Interpreting the proviso to rule 4 — that it is for the District Magistrate to decide whether electoral rolls of an Assembly constituency are suitable for municipal elections and whether a separate municipal roll should be prepared;
(b) The broader treatment of the term “election” (noting that “election” generally includes registration, nomination, voting and declaration).
The Court applied the holding that the District Magistrate has discretion under the proviso to rule 4 and that a petitioner could not claim, as of right, preparation of a separate roll. The Court also noted the earlier case's view of the meaning of “election” in rejecting the contention that a post-deadline declaration of result rendered the election void.
Bindhyachal v. S.C. Mukherji, ILR 33 Pat 905 (B) The principle that petitioners who knowingly participated in or acquiesced to an election may be estopped from later challenging the legality of that election (i.e., such petitioners are not entitled to relief in the nature of quo warranto). The Court found this authority directly applicable to M.J.C. 898 of 1956 and dismissed that petition on the ground of estoppel arising from participation in the election.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court treated the two petitions separately and applied statutory provisions and prior decisions as follows.

M.J.C. 898 of 1956 (petition by defeated candidates)

The learned Standing Counsel argued, and the Court accepted, that petitioners who participated in the election are estopped from challenging it after defeat. The Court relied on the Bench decision in Bindhyachal v. S.C. Mukherji (ILR 33 Pat 905 (B)), which held that petitioners who knew of the illegality but acquiesced could not maintain a quo warranto-like application. The Court examined the petitioners' reliance on Parmeshwar Mahasoth but concluded that that case did not consider the estoppel point nor did its facts establish participation in the same manner; consequently Parmeshwar Mahasoth did not override the Bindhyachal principle. On this ground alone M.J.C. 898 was dismissed.

M.J.C. 591 of 1956 (petition by Raghuni Nayak)

The Court examined three principal contentions raised by the petitioner.

  1. Alleged invalidity of the electoral roll and right to a separate municipal roll: The petitioner had applied to the District Magistrate on 10 April 1956 for preparation of a separate electoral roll (alleging omission of about 700 names). The District Magistrate rejected that application on 11 April 1956. The Court relied on the holding in Parmeshwar Mahasoth that under the proviso to rule 4 it is for the District Magistrate to decide whether an Assembly constituency roll is suitable and whether a separate municipal roll should be prepared. Thus the petitioner had no enforceable right to insist on preparation of a separate roll; the District Magistrate's exercise of discretion against the petitioner ended the matter in that respect.
  2. Requirement under section 15 for a separate register of voters: While acknowledging that section 15 requires a separate register and publication before notification of the election, the Court found that a separate register had in fact been prepared in the present case, removing that contention from the case's merits.
  3. Timing of declaration of result vs. last date fixed for election: The petitioner argued that because the result was not declared by 24 July 1956 (the date fixed by notification), the election was void — on the basis that “election” includes declaration of result. The Court analysed rule 7(1) (which calls upon wards “to elect commissioners ... before such date as may be specified”) and rule 45(1) (which makes declaration of result the duty of the Returning Officer after counting). The Court distinguished “to elect” (which, for electors, meant to cast votes by the last date) from the Returning Officer's procedural duties of counting and declaring. The Court held that the notified date was the last date for electors to cast their votes; counting and declaration by the Returning Officer may lawfully occur after that date. The Court noted that in Parmeshwar Mahasoth a similar situation occurred and was not held to invalidate the election. Accordingly, this contention failed.

Having rejected each of the petitioner's contentions on the above bases — discretionary rejection of the separate roll request, existence of a separate register in the facts, and correct interpretation of the notified last date — the Court concluded no writ lay under Article 226.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court dismissed both applications. Petitions dismissed with costs.

The direct consequences as recorded by the Court are:

  • The petitions under Article 226 were dismissed and no writ was issued to set aside the municipal election.
  • Costs were awarded against the petitioners; the hearing fee of Rs. 100 was ordered in each case.

Broader implications discussed by the Court (limited to what appears in the opinion): the decision applies existing principles that (a) a District Magistrate has discretion under the proviso to rule 4 to decide whether to prepare a separate municipal electoral roll, and (b) petitioners who participated in and acquiesced to an election may be estopped from later challenging its validity. The Court did not purport to lay down any new precedent beyond applying these authorities to the facts before it.

Disposition recorded in the opinion: Petition dismissed. (V. Ramaswami, C.J., concurred.)

    Raghuni Nayak v. Dist. Magistrate

    R.K Choudhary, J.:— These two writ applications under Article 226 of the Constitution of India arise out of the election of commissioners of the Rosera Municipality in the district of Darbhanga. M.J.C 591 of 1956 is by one Raghuni Nayak who states that he intended to stand as a candidate for being elected a commissioner of the above Municipality, but was debarred from doing so as his name did not appear in the electors' list. M.J.C 898 of 1956 is by three defeated candidates, namely, Hansi Lal Sahani, Lakhan Nayak and Lakshmi Thakur.

    2. By these two petitions the petitioners pray for issue of an appropriate writ setting aside the election of the commissioners of the above Municipality, restraining the returned candidates, namely, opposite party Nos. 3 to 15, from functioning as commissioners of the said Municipality and directing the District Magistrate of Darbhanga for holding a fresh election in accordance with law. The short facts are these: On the 11th of April, 1956, a notice by the District Magistrate of Darbhanga, opposite party No. 1, being No. 4303R dated the 29th March, 1956, was published in the Bihar Gazette fixing the 24th of July, 1956, as the last date for election of Municipal Commissioners for the Rosera Municipality. Sri Banarsi Prasad Singh, Magistrate, first class, Samastipur (opposite party No. 2 in M.J.C 591 of 1956 and opposite party No. 3 in M.J.C 898 of 1956), as being the Returning Officer for the said election, fixed the 27th of June, 1956, as the last date for filing nomination paper, the 29th of June, 1956, as the last date for scrutiny thereof and the 24th of July, 1956, for election, if necessary.

    3. On the 10th of April, 1956, the petitioner of M.J.C 591 of 1956, namely, Raghuni Nayak, moved an application before the District Magistrate of Darbhanga alleging that his name as well as the names of about 700 other people qualified to be registered as voters in the Assembly constituency of that area had been omitted from the electoral roll of the said constituency and prayed for a separate electors' roll for the Rosera Municipality to be prepared on the basis of the qualifications prescribed for the electoral roll of an Assembly constituency under the proviso to rules of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules, 1953.

    4. On the 11th of April, 1956, Mr. Jacob, the District Magistrate of Darbhanga, rejected the said application. Subsequently, polls were held on the 24th of July, 1956, votes were counted on the 25th of July, 1956, and opposite party Nos. 3 to 15 of M.J.C 591 of 1956, who are opposite party Nos. 4 to 16 in the other application, were declared elected by the Returning Officer. The Chairman of the Rosera Municipality is opposite party No. 2 in M.J.C 898 of 1956, but he is not a party in the other application.

    5. The petitioners state that the election of the Municipal Commissioners referred to above was void inasmuch as no electoral roll as required by the Municipal Act and the rules framed thereunder had been prepared in the case and also because it was not held within the last date fixed for the purpose. On these two grounds they seek to have the election set aside. Reliance has been placed on their behalf in support of their applications on a Bench decision of this Court in Parmeshwar Mahasoth v. State of Bihar, 1957 BLJR 672 : (AIR 1958 Pat 149) (A), and on certain provisions of the Municipal Act and the rules framed thereunder.

    6. The Standing Counsel opposes the applications on behalf of the District Magistrate and the Returning Officer. Mr. Baldeva Sahay appears for opposite party Nos. 3, 4, 9 to 13 and 15 in M.J.C 591 of 1956 who are opposite party Nos. 4, 5, 10 to 14 and 16 in M.J.C 898 of 1956. Cause has been shown on their behalf opposing the applications by filing counter affidavits in both the cases. The other members of the opposite party do not appear before us.

    7. Mr. Baldeva Sahay has adopted the arguments advanced by the learned Standing Counsel and it will not, therefore, be necessary to refer to his arguments separately.

    8. So far as M.J.C 898 of 1956 is concerned, the learned Standing Counsel has advanced an argument that the petitioners of that case having participated in the election were estopped from challenging the validity of that election after having lost therein. The argument is well founded and is supported by a Bench decision of this Court in Bindhyachal v. S.C Mukherji, ILR 33 Pat 905 (B). In that case the petitioners knowing of the illegality acquiesced or concurred in the election of the Municipal Councillors.

    9. In those circumstances their Lordships, after reviewing the various cases on the point, held that the petitioners were not entitled to information in the nature of quo warranto and an application for a writ at their instance could not be maintained. On behalf of the petitioners, however, Mr. Ghosh has contended that in the case of 1957 BLJR 672 : (AIR 1958 Pat 149) (A), also the petitioners had participated in the election which was quashed at their instance. In that case there were ten petitioners out of whom petitioners 6 to 10 were the defeated candidates and petitioners 1 to 5 were some of the electors residing within the Municipality in question.

    10. The question that has been raised in the present case was not raised in that case and the attention of their Lordships was not drawn to the Bench decision of this Court in ILR 33 Pat 905 (B), referred to above. There was thus no decision in that case on the point raised in the present case. Moreover, the facts of that case do not show that the first five petitioners had participated in the election. For the above reason that case cannot be an authority for holding a view contrary to the proposition laid down in the case of ILR 33 Pat 905 (B). M.J.C 898 of 1956 has, therefore, to be dismissed on this very ground.

    11. I will now deal with the other case, namely, M.J.C 591 of 1956. The first contention raised by Mr. Ghosh is that the election roll was not prepared in accordance with law. It is submitted that an application was made by the petitioner, as already stated, on the 10th of April, 1956, drawing the attention of the District Magistrate about the non-inclusion of the name of the petitioner and of about 700 other people qualified to be registered as voters in the Assembly constituency of that area, but the learned District Magistrate rejected the application with an observation that the petitioner should apply to the Chief Electoral Officer for inclusion of the names in the electoral roll.

    12. It is also submitted that a general revision of the electoral rolls for the Assembly constituency in the district of Darbhanga was under preparation and the names of almost all the 700 persons which had been omitted in the previous electoral roll have now been included in the draft electoral roll prepared with reference to the 1st of March, 1956, as qualifying date.

    13. It is, therefore, submitted that the electoral roll on the basis of which polls were held was not an accurate roll inasmuch as the names of several persons were omitted to be included therein. On behalf of the opposite-party the allegation about the non-inclusion of the names of 700 persons has been challenged and there nothing to show that any of these 700 persons ever made any attempt for insertion of his name in the electoral roll. Be that as it may, one thing is apparent from the own petition of the petitioner that he moved the District Magistrate for preparation of a separate electoral roll under the proviso to rule 4 of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules which runs as follows:

    “Provided that where the District Magistrate is of opinion that electoral roll or rolls of an Assembly constituency are not suitable for purposes of elections of commissioners of the municipality, an electoral roll for that municipality shall be prepared on the basis of such qualification and in such manner as the State Government may, by notification, direct.”

    14. It has been held in the case of 1957 B.L.J.R 672; (AIR 1958 Pat 149) (A) that under the above proviso it is entirely for the District Magistrate to consider whether or not the electoral roll of the Assembly constituency is suitable for the municipal elections. In that view of the law, the petitioner could not claim as of right the preparation of a separate electoral roll under that proviso. The District Magistrate had a discretion to prepare any such roll and he having exercised his discretion against the petitioner by rejecting Iris application, there is an end of the matter in that regard.

    15. It has then been contended by Mr. Ghosh that under section 15 of the Bihar and Orissa Municipal Act a separate register of voters must be prepared and published before the holding of election is notified. The proposition of law is absolutely correct and is borne out by the above decision of 1957 BLJR 672 : (AIR 1958 Pat 149) (A), but in the present case such a separate register had been prepared and, therefore, there is no point in raising; this question in the present case.

    16. The next contention of Mr. Ghosh is that the result of election not having been declared by 24-7-1956, which was the last date for election, it was void. It is submitted that the expression “election” includes the declaration of the elected person, and, as such, when by the notification the election had to be completed by 24-7-1956, the result of the election should also have been declared by that date and not later.

    17. It is true that the expression “election” generally includes registration, nomination, voting and the manner in which votes are to be counted and the result made known. The case of 1957 BLJR 672 : (AIR 1958 Pat 149) (A) also has taken the same view about this expression. It has, therefore, to be seen whether the election is void by reason of its result having been declared subsequent to the last date fixed for election. In this connection rule 7(1) of the Bihar Municipal Elections and Election Petitions Rules is of importance. It runs as follows:

    “For the purpose of constituting the municipality or re-constituting it on the expiration of the term of office of the commissioners or under section 386, the District Magistrate shall, by a notification published in the Official Gazette and in the manner laid down in section 356, call upon all the wards of the municipality to elect commissioners in accordance with the provisions of the Act and these rules before such date as may be specified in the notification.”

    18. The above rules require the District Magistrate to call upon all the wards of the municipality to elect commissioners. In my view, the expression “to elect commissioners” does not exactly convey the same meaning as the expression “election of commissioners.” The expression “to elect” means to pick out or choose, and, in my opinion, where the election has to be made by casting votes, the expression “to elect” so far as the electors are concerned, would mean to pick out or choose by casting their votes. It is in the above sense that the expression “to elect” has been used in the above rule 7(1).

    19. The electors, as the rule envisages, are called upon to elect, or in other words, to cast their votes for the election of the commissioners. Therefore, when in the present case 24-7-1956 was fixed as the last date for the electors to elect commissioners, it was obviously meant that it was the last date by which the voters had to cast their votes. Rule 45(1) of the above rules provides that when the counting of the votes has been completed, the Returning Officer shall forthwith declare the candidate or candidates, as the case may be, to whom the largest number of votes have been given, to be elected. The counting of the votes and the declaration of the result is for the Returning Officer.

    20. The voters are not called upon to do anything in that matter under the notification as provided by rule 7(1). Their business is over after they have given their votes. In 1957 BLJR 672 : (AIR 1958 Pat 149) (A) also the result of the election was declared after the last date fixed for the electors to elect but no argument was advanced that the election was bad on that account. There thus appears to be no merit in this contention also and this application has also to fail.

    21. In the result it is manifest that no case has been made out by the petitioners for issue of any writ under Article 226 of pie Constitution of India and the applications are accordingly dismissed with costs. Hearing fee: Rs. 100 in each of the cases.

    22. V. Ramaswami, C.J:— I agree.

    M.K.S

    23. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raghuni Nayak v. Dist. Magistrate
    (Feb 4, 1958)