Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule. Chapter-I of the said Rules, Rule 3
  • rules.11. Rules 3 and 4 of the Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule 1964
  • provision of Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule 1964
  • Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule, 1964
  • (1) Primary Schools;, (2) Junior High Schools; (3) Higher Secondary Schools; (4) Degree Colleges; (5) Training Colleges.Rule 4: (a)
  • provisions of U.P Contribution Provident-Insurance Pension Rules 1964
  • U.P Contributory Provident Fund Insurance Pension Rules
  • Pension. Rule 4 of the aforesaid Rules
  • clause (b) of Rule 19 of the Rules
  • Rule 3 of the aforesaid Rules
  • Rule 19(b) of Rules 1964
  • sub-Rule (b) of Rule 19,
  • pension.13. Rule 18
  • final.14. Rule 24
  • Rule 17 and 19
  • Rules, Rule 17
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule. Chapter-I of the said Rules, Rule 3
  • rules.11. Rules 3 and 4 of the Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule 1964
  • provision of Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule 1964
  • Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule, 1964
  • (1) Primary Schools;, (2) Junior High Schools; (3) Higher Secondary Schools; (4) Degree Colleges; (5) Training Colleges.Rule 4: (a)
  • provisions of U.P Contribution Provident-Insurance Pension Rules 1964
  • U.P Contributory Provident Fund Insurance Pension Rules
  • Pension. Rule 4 of the aforesaid Rules
  • clause (b) of Rule 19 of the Rules
  • Rule 3 of the aforesaid Rules
  • Rule 19(b) of Rules 1964
  • sub-Rule (b) of Rule 19,
  • pension.13. Rule 18
  • final.14. Rule 24
  • Rule 17 and 19
  • Rules, Rule 17
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion — Structured Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This bunch of Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petitions arises from multiple petitioners seeking relief relating to pension entitlements under the State-aided educational institutions' service rules and various Government Orders. The petitions primarily request (a) permission to deposit the managerial (employer) contribution to the Contributory Provident Fund along with interest so that past unaided service may be clubbed for pension calculation; and (b) directions quashing or modifying certain Government Orders that treat institutions included in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005 as governed by the new pension scheme.

Specific petitions included in this batch are: Civil Misc. Writ Petition Nos. 45217/2012, 45229/2012, 47649/2012, 44742/2012, 47000/2010 and 55778/2010. Reliefs sought varied from permitting one-time deposit of managerial contribution with interest, to quashing parts of Government Orders (notably the Government Order dated 08.04.2009 and the District Basic Education Officer's Government Order dated 24.07.2012), and directions to club unaided service for pension calculation as per various Government Orders (including those dated 27.07.2001, 22.05.2006, 20.07.2006 and 21.01.2009).

The Court reviewed the statutory scheme established by the Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rules, 1964 (the "Rules of 1964") and an extended chronology of Government Orders (including those of 1965, 1978, 1982, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2006, 2009 and 2010) that addressed application of the Rules, clubbing of unaided service, and time-limits for depositing managerial contribution. The Court also considered prior judicial decisions bearing on cut-off dates for deposit and the counting of unaided service as qualifying service for pension.

At the conclusion the Court delivered a mixed final disposition (set out in paragraph 73 of the opinion): Civil Misc. Writ Petition Nos. 45217/2012 and 45229/2012 were dismissed; Nos. 47649/2012 and 44742/2012 were allowed; Nos. 55778/2010 and 47000/2010 were dismissed. Petitioners whose petitions were allowed were permitted to deposit the required contribution with interest within two months, subject to fulfillment of other terms and conditions. No costs were awarded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, as a one-time measure, the State should extend or reopen the time allowed for depositing managerial contribution (with interest) so that employees can have unaided service clubbed for pension calculation under the Rules of 1964 and related Government Orders.
  2. Whether employees appointed prior to 01.04.2005 but whose institutions were included in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005 are entitled, as of right, to be governed by the old (pre-01.04.2005) pension scheme and have their unaided service counted for pension, or whether they are governed by the new pension scheme introduced w.e.f. 01.04.2005.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The scheme in question is benevolent/welfare-oriented; therefore the time frame for depositing managerial contribution together with interest should not bar eligible employees from availing pension benefits.
  • Incumbents appointed prior to 01.04.2005, even if their institutions were included in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005, should have the option to be covered under the old pension scheme rather than being mandatorily placed under the new pension scheme.
  • The Government Order dated 08.04.2009 (which treats institutions included in grant-in-aid after 01.04.2005 as governed by the new scheme) is challenged as per se bad in so far as it denies the option/benefit to such incumbents.

Respondent / State Arguments (Standing Counsel)

  • The time frame for depositing managerial contribution together with interest was fixed and the petitioners (or their institutions) did not comply within the prescribed period; accordingly, benefit of the old pension scheme cannot be extended now.
  • The Rules of 1964 apply only to employees of institutions that are on the grant-in-aid list; the Rules do not apply to unaided institutions until they are included in that list.
  • The State legitimately adopted a policy decision that institutions included in grant-in-aid after 01.04.2005 would be governed by the new pension scheme, and petitioners cannot as a matter of right demand coverage under the old rules once the policy decision has been taken.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Shanti Solanki v. State of U.P. (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 75746 of 2005) Judicial invalidation of a Government Order-imposed cut-off date (31.03.2002) for deposit of managerial contribution. The Court relied on this earlier decision to note that the cut-off date of 31.03.2002 had been struck down as arbitrary; that decision was used to support the argument that time-limits may be susceptible to challenge and that reopening the deposit window is possible in appropriate circumstances.
Chandra Bhushan Bajpai v. Joint Director of Education, Kanpur (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 32132 of 2001, decided 21.08.2008) Interpretation that qualifying service for pension must be determined by reference to the Rules of 1964 and that unaided service is not countable unless Rules provide. Adopted as persuasive authority: the Court noted the view that services rendered in an unaided institution (prior to a grant-in-aid entry) were not to be counted for pension unless rules so provide; the decision supported refusal to count unaided service automatically without compliance with statutory conditions.
D.S. Nakara v. Union of India, (1983) 1 SCC 305 Principle that pension is a right but its grant and modalities are governed strictly by rules. Used to reaffirm that pension entitlement must be determined within the framework of applicable rules (i.e., a person within the rules is entitled, but no entitlement arises outside the rules).
Kunwar Bahadur Sinha v. Director of Education, U.P., Lucknow (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No.13741 of 1990, decided 05.05.1995) Interpretation of Rule 19(b) (continuous temporary or officiating service followed by confirmation counts as qualifying service). Cited to show that sub‑Rule (b) of Rule 19 can have application where confirmation/factual continuity is present; the Court used it to distinguish cases where Rule 19(b) was overlooked by authorities.
Commander HQ v. Capt. Biplavendra Chand, JT 1997 SC 371 : (1997) 1 SCC 208 : AIR 1997 SC 2607 Principle that pension is payable only to those who fall within the ambit of the governing rules. Relied upon to support the proposition that being within the ambit of the rules is a prerequisite for pension entitlement; used to uphold the State's position that policy decisions and rule applicability must be respected.
T.N. Electricity Board v. Veeraswamy, 1999 (2) ESC (SC) 1036 Similar principle that pensionary benefits are governed by rules and applicable only to those within their ambit. Used alongside other Supreme Court authority to reinforce that rules determine entitlement to pension.
Sudhir Kumar Kansal v. Allahabad Bank, 2011 (2) ESC 243 : 2011 (3) ALJ 262 Rule-of-law principle that sympathies cannot override rules and regulations governing pension entitlements. Invoked to justify refusal to allow relief under the old pension scheme where rules do not permit it; the Court cited it to support the conclusion that claimants cannot bypass clearly applicable statutory or policy rules through equitable sympathy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded methodically, first setting out the statutory and administrative framework: the 1964 Rules (the Triple Benefit Scheme: Contributory Provident Fund, Compulsory Life Insurance and Pension), the relevant Rules (notably Rules 3, 4, 17, 18, 19 and 24), and a chronology of Government Orders that addressed clubbing of unaided service and deadlines for deposit of managerial contribution (1965, 1978, 1982, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2006, 2009, 2010 and later).

Key legal propositions established from the text of the Rules and earlier orders were:

  • Rules 3 and 4 confine application of the Rules of 1964 to permanent employees serving in State-aided educational institutions (i.e., only after an institution is recognised for grant-in-aid).
  • Rule 17 and Rule 19 set out eligibility and the conditions under which service counts as qualifying service for pension (including the requirement that service will not count unless the employee holds a substantive post on a permanent establishment, subject to the exception in Rule 19(b)).
  • Government Orders provided mechanisms and deadlines for clubbing unaided service where institutions were later brought on the grant-in-aid list, but those orders also set cut-off dates for depositing managerial contribution with interest.

Applying these propositions, the Court addressed the two categories of claimants separately:

  1. For employees whose appointments were prior to 01.04.2005 and whose institutions were included in the grant-in-aid list prior to 01.04.2005 (or otherwise fell within the Rules' ambit when included), the Court concluded that clubbing of unaided service for pension could be permitted subject to the statutory/administrative condition that the managerial contribution (and interest) be deposited. Noting that a previous decision (Smt. Shanti Solanki) had struck down a specific cut-off date (31.03.2002) as arbitrary, the Court reasoned that, because the scheme is benevolent and the State's fiscal interest is protected by requiring deposit with interest, the State could, as a one‑time measure, allow an extension enabling those appointed prior to 01.04.2005 to deposit the managerial contribution with interest and thereby secure pension benefits under the old scheme. The Court directed the State to undertake the requisite exercise within one month from receipt of certified copy of the order (para 26) and gave two months for deposit for successful petitioners (para 73).
  2. For the second category — employees appointed prior to 01.04.2005 but whose institutions were included in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005 — the Court analysed the policy decision that the new pension scheme (Contributory Pension Scheme) introduced w.e.f. 01.04.2005 applied to grant-in-aid institutions included after that date. The Court emphasised that the Rules of 1964 do not apply to unaided institutions before inclusion in the grant-in-aid list, and therefore the State's decision to subject institutions included after 01.04.2005 to the new scheme (and to treat such employees as governed by the new scheme) was not arbitrary or irrational. The Court relied on settled principles (including D.S. Nakara and other Supreme Court authorities) that pension entitlements depend upon the applicable rules and that rule-based policy decisions are permissible so long as they have a rational basis.

The Court also relied on case-law (e.g., Chandra Bhushan Bajpai) showing that service in an unaided institution, prior to grant-in-aid, is not to be counted for pension unless the Rules or Government Orders provide for it and the statutory conditions (such as deposit of managerial contribution with interest) are met.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition (core ruling):

  • Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 45217 of 2012 — Dismissed.
  • Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 45229 of 2012 — Dismissed.
  • Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 47649 of 2012 — Allowed.
  • Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 44742 of 2012 — Allowed.
  • Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 55778 of 2010 — Dismissed.
  • Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 47000 of 2010 — Dismissed.

Consequential Directions and Immediate Effects:

  • Petitioners whose petitions were allowed are permitted to deposit the managerial contribution with interest within two months from the date of the order; upon such deposit (and subject to fulfillment of other terms and conditions), the respondents shall extend the benefit of the Government Order(s) to them.
  • The State was directed (as stated in the reasons) to consider, as a one‑time measure, giving a last opportunity to teaching and non-teaching staff appointed prior to 01.04.2005 to deposit managerial contribution with interest so that qualifying service (including unaided service) may be clubbed for pension — the requisite exercise to be undertaken within the time frame provided in the opinion.
  • No order as to costs was made by the Court.

Broader legal implication drawn by the Court: the opinion confirms that pension entitlements must be determined according to the applicable statutory rules and administrative policy decisions; employees who fall within the Rules' ambit are entitled to pensionary benefits under those rules, whereas employees or institutions not within the Rules' ambit (e.g., unaided institutions until inclusion in grant-in-aid) cannot claim such benefits except insofar as Government Orders and statutory conditions (such as deposit of managerial contribution with interest) expressly permit. The Court did not purport to lay down a new general precedent overriding the statutory scheme; it applied existing Rules and case-law to the facts and granted limited relief where administratively appropriate.

    Buddhiram v. State Of U.P And Ors.

    1. Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 45217 of 2012 has been filed by petitioner requesting therein to permit the petitioner for depositing the management contribution together with interest thereon and further prayer has been made to command respondent au thorities for clubbing the petitioner service when the institution was unaided for calculation of his pension as per Government Orders dated 27.07.2001, 22.05.2006, 20.07.2006 and 21.01.2009

    2. Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 45229 of 2012 has been filed by the petitioner requesting therein to permit the petitioner for depositing the management contribution together with interest thereon and further prayer has been made to command respondent authorities for clubbing the petitioner service when the institution was unaided for calculation of his pension as per Government Orders dated 27.07.2001, 22.05.2006, 20.07.2006 and 21.01.2009 Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 47649 of 2012 has been filed by the petitioner for directing the respondents to accept managerial contribution for providing the pension and other post retrial benefit to the petitioners so that the petitioners be get the pension, within a period to be specified by this Court

    3. Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 44742 of 2012 has been filed requesting to quash the Government Order dated 24.07.2012 passed by District Basic Education Officer, Allahabad and further to issue a suitable writ order or direction directing the respondents to accept the management contribution from the petitioner with interest and pay pensionery benefits as he was getting prior to Feb. 2008 with arrears of pension from March 2008 onwards and others consequential benefits.

    4. Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 47000 of 2010 has been filed for quashing the last two lines of Government dated 08.04.2009 and further prayer has been made to direct the respondent to count more than 10 years service rendered by the petitioners prior to 01.04.2005 and provided pensionery benefits under the old pension scheme existing prior to 01.04.2005

    5. Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 55778 of 2010 has been filed for quashing the last two lines of Government dated 08.04.2009 and further prayer has been made to direct the respondent to count more than 10 years service rendered by the petitioners prior to 01.04.2005 and provided pensionery benefits under the old pension scheme existing prior to 01.04.2005

    6. Petitioners of this bunch of writ petitions are complaining that scheme in question is beneficiary scheme and once whatever de fault has been there in depositing managerial contribution together with interest, the delay be condoned and requisite relief should be ac corded to deposit managerial contribution with interest so that benefit of pension be extended to them and further request has been made by a group of incumbent by contending that once institution in question has been included in the grant-in-aid list of the State Government after 01.04.2005 but their appointment is prior to 01.04.2005 then they should be given option to be covered under old pension scheme and not under new pension scheme, and accordingly requisite relief be accorded to both the category of incumbents.

    7. Sri Ashok Khare, Senior Advocate, Sri Anil Yadav Advocate, Sri L.K Dwivedi, Advocate and Sri V.K Singh, Advocate made submission in respect of claim mentioned in the writ petitions by submitting that scheme in question is welfare scheme and in view of this time frame provide for depositing managerial contribution together interest should not come in the way for depositing managerial contribution together interest, and benefit of said scheme should be extended to them qua the said category of incumbents and further the institutions which have been included in grant in aid list after 01.04.2005, w.e.f 01.12.2006 incumbent working therein are also entitled for benefit of the old scheme once their appointments have been made prior to 01.04.2005, then said benefit cannot be denied and in view of this clarification which has been made in the Government Order dated 08.04.2009, that institution in question which has been included in the grant in aid list after 01.04.2005 they would be governed by new pension scheme is per se bad.

    8. Learned Standing counsel on the other hand contended that in the present case time frame has been fixed for depositing managerial contribution together interest and well within the said time frame said exercise has not been at all been undertaken as such benefit of the old pension scheme cannot be extended and as far as Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule 1964 is concerned benefit of the same is extendable to such institutions who are in the grant-in-aid list, and once policy decision has been taken that all those institutions who have been included in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005, they would be governed by new pension policy then in such matters petitioners cannot claim as matter of right that they should be governed under old rules and accordingly writ petitions deserve to be dismissed.

    9. After respective arguments have been advanced, the scheme of things are being looked into.

    10. In order to provide teachers serving in the State-aided institution better service conditions committee was constituted and said committee made recommendation that an employee serving in the State-aided educational institutions were enjoying the benefits of Contributory Provident Funds only, and there was no provision of their Life Insurance/Pension etc. and it was considered necessary that these benefits might also be extended to them in order to relieve them of the worries after the retirement and in this background by means of Government Order dated 17.12.1965, Triple Benefit Scheme was introduced which was made effective with effect from 01.10.1964 The benefit occurring to the employees to the said scheme was (i) Contributory Provident Fund (ii) Compulsory Life Insurance (iii) Pension including Family Pension. For making these benefits more effective Rules were made providing therein terms and conditions on which these benefits were extendable. The said Rules were known as “Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule. Chapter-I of the said Rules, Rule 3 provides that benefit of aforesaid Rules shall apply to permanent employees serving in the State of the following categories of institution run either by a Local Body or by a Private Man-agement and recognised by a competent authority as such for purposes of payment of grant-in-aid. The object of said rule is to ensure all three types of service benefits namely Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance and Pension. Rule 4 of the aforesaid Rules provides that these rules are intended to ensure to the employees of the State aided educational institutions, three types of service benefits viz Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance and Pension (Triple Benefit Scheme) the quantum of the benefits and the conditions by which they are governed are described in the succeeding Chapters. Under the said Rules an employee: already in permanent service on the date of enforcement of these Rules shall be given an option to elect these new rules or to continue to be governed by the existing rules applicable to him. Categorical provision has been provided for that no employees shall be allowed option to choose only a part of the scheme except as otherwise specifically provided for in these rules.

    11. Rules 3 and 4 of the Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule 1964 is being quoted below:

    Rule 3: These rules shall apply to permanent employees serving in State aided educational institutions of the following categories run either by a Local Body or by a Private Management and recognised by a competent authority as such for purposes of payment of grant-in-aid: (1) Primary Schools;, (2) Junior High Schools; (3) Higher Secondary Schools; (4) Degree Colleges; (5) Training Colleges.

    Rule 4: (a) These rules are intended to en sure to the employees of the State aided educational institutions, three types of service benefits viz Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance and Pension (Triple Benefit Scheme) the quantum of the benefits and the conditions by which they are governed are described in the succeeding Chapters.

    (b) An employee already in permanent service on the date of enforcement of these Rules shall be given an option to elect these new rules or to continue to be governed by the existing rules applicable to him.

    (c) No employees shall be allowed option to choose only a part of the scheme except as otherwise specifically provided for in these rules.

    12. Chapter II of of the said Rules deals with definition clause. Chapter III of the said Rules deals with Contributory Provident Fund, Chapter IV of the said Rules deals with Life Insurance and Chapter V of the said Rules deals with Pension. Under Chapter V of the said Rules, Rule 17 deals with eligibility for pension of an employee and in respect of entitlement of pension.

    13. Rule 18 deals with amount of pension that may be granted shall be determined by the length of qualifying service and Rule 19 provides that service will not count for pension unless the employee holds a substantive post on a permanent establishment. Rule 17 and 19 being relevant is being extracted below:

    Rule 17: An employee shall be eligible for pension on:

    (i) retirement on attaining the age of superannuation or on the expiry of extension granted beyond the superannuation age;

    (ii) voluntary retirement after completing 25 years of qualifying service;

    (iii) retirement before the age of superannuation under a medical certificate of permanent incapacity for further service; and

    (iv) discharge due to abolition of post of closure of an institution due to withdrawal of recognition or other valid causes.

    Rule 19: (a) Service will not count for pension unless the employees holds a substantive post on a permanent establishment.

    (B) Continuance temporary or officiating service followed without interruption by confirmation in the same or another post shall also count as qualifying service.

    (C) Leave without allowance, suspension allowed to stand as a specific penalty, overstayal of joining time or leave not subsequently regularized, and period of breaks in service shall be reckoned as qualifying service.

    (d) Period of breaks between two periods of service due to termination of service, for no fault of the employee shall not be treated as interruption involving forfeiture of past qualifying service. In other cases breaks due to other causes shall result in forfeiture of past service unless condoned by Government.

    (e) Time passed on earned leave shall fully count as qualifying service, but time passed on other kinds of leave with allowance shall count as qualifying service as follows:—

    (i) If the total service is not less that 13 years, but less than 30 years, one year of such leave shall count as qualifying service;

    (ii) If the total service is not less than 30 years, two years of such leave shall count as qualifying service.

    Notes: (1) The term “Earned Leave” means leave on full average pay.

    (2) In case a married women employee time passed on maternity leave may be allowed to count as qualifying service, provided that the period covered by such leave and also earned leave shall not exceed what would have been admissible had she availed of the whole of the earned leave to which she was entitled under the rule.

    (3) “Total Service” means total service reckoning from the date of commencement of service qualifying for pension and includes periods of leave referred to above.

    (4) The service put in by an employee before he has completed 18 years of age or after attaining the age of superannuation unless extended by competent authority or on re-employment after retirement shall not qualify for pension.

    (5) The entry relating to confirmation of employee in the service book shall be countersigned by the Controlling Authority.

    (6) In cases not covered by these rules qualifying service shall be determined by Government and its decision shall be final.

    14. Rule 24 deals with family pension and as per said Rule 24 family pension not exceeding the amount specified could be granted for a period of 10 years to the family of an employee who dies either while still in service or after retirement, after completion of not less than twenty years of qualifying service. Proviso has been added to the said Rule providing therein that period of payment of family pension shall in no case extend beyond a period of five years from the date on which the deceased employee would have attained the age of superannuation. While this scheme had been subsisting on 08.03.1978 State Government issued Government Order in the background of repeated request being made that pension should be made available to the employee of institution run and managed by Basic Shiksha Parishad, Allahabad in the same way and manner as State Government employees were being paid. State Government conceded to this demand and mentioned mat all the employees of institutions run and managed by Basic Shiksha Parishad who have been retired on 01.03.1977 or thereafter they would be paid their pension in the same way and manner as State Government employees were being paid. However, a rider was attached to the same by mentioning that the said teacher would not at all be entitled for benefit of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity and after death no pension would be made admissible to their family members. In the said Government Order itself it was mentioned in paragraph 2 that each employee will have to give their option as to whether they would opt for pension for in Government Order dated 08.03.1978 or they will continue to be governed by the provisions as contained under Government Order dated 17.12.1965 In paragraph 3 of the said Government Order it was mentioned that all benefits which were extended to the employee who have been superannuated prior to 01.03.1977 same would be made available. In paragraph 5 of the aforesaid Government Order it was mentioned that the benefits extended by means of Government Order dated 17.12.1965 and benefits extended by means of U.P Basic Shiksha Parishad G.P.F Adhiniyam, 1975 be treated as amended to this extent. After the said Government Order had been issued, much hue and cry has been raised by the employees in respect of deprivation of family pension and then State Government in its wisdom on 31.03.1982 mentioned that condition which has been imposed in the Government Order dated 08.03.1978 is being rescinded and subject to the conditions mentioned in the Government Order employees who are covered by the new pension policy they would be extended the same Government employees are getting with effect from 01.10.1981 In this particular Government order in paragraph 4(a) of the same it has been provided for that where while in employment if employee has completed seven years of service, then in that event family pension would be payable from the date of death, in case of his survival, he would have attained the age of 65 years. In paragraph 4(b) it has been provided that if death takes place after superannuation then in that event family pension would be payable to the family pensioner till pensioner would have attained sixty five years of age or for period of seven years, whichever was earlier. Subsequent to this Government Order, another Government Order dated 16.06.1984 has been issued, wherein by way of clarification it has been mentioned that said benefit was extenable to teachers who had died on 01.10.1981 or even prior to the same.

    15. As provision of Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule 1964 has been covering only those institutions and employees who were permanent in the State aided educational institution and as various institutions were being included in the grant-in-aid list of the State Government then issues have been raised qua clubbing the services rendered by incumbents at the point of time when the institution was unaided. In this regard repeated demands were being made from the State Government for extending the benefit of aforesaid service for computing the qualifying service for pension. State Government proceeded to consider the request of said category of teachers and in furtherance of Government Orders dated 10.03.1978 and 31.03.1982 State Government proceeded to issue Government Order dated 23.05.1998 mentioning therein that in continuance of the Government Order dated 10.03.1978 and 31.03.1982, period which has been spent by incumbent in the institution prior to institution being included in grant-in-aid list, said period of service shall also be clubbed but condition was attached therein that who have attained the age of superannuation will have to pay contribution in Contributory Provident Fund along with interest. Said amount in question was required to be deposited in Contributory Provident Fund and further it was mentioned that even incumbents who have died, said benefit in question shall be extended to them also. By means of Government Order dated 23.05.1998 time frame has been provided for upto 31.03.1998 for the said amount in question to be deposited in the Government treasury. Obligation has been cast upon the Management through Principal that in respect of teaching and non-teaching staff after computation being made the managerial contribution along with the interest, be deposited in the office of District Basic Education Officer. It was also mentioned that thereafter entry shall be made in the service book. It was also clarified that for pension/family pension, said service would be computed from the date when he has been lawfully appointed and it was also clarified that this Government Order dated 23.05.1998 shall be applicable to the incumbent who have retired after aforesaid date i.e 23.05.1998

    16. Thereafter said Government Order in question has again been considered in Government Order dated 17.02.1999, wherein period which has been fixed for depositing managerial contribution upto 30.09.1998 same has been extended up to 30.07.1999 and it was also clarified and directed that for availing benefit of aforesaid Government Order, all the institutions should get said contribution deposited in time with the Government Treasury.

    17. State Government again issued Government Order dated 15.07.1999 for fixing salary of teachers and other employee of Junior High School and as per the same it was clearly provided that institutions which are included in the grant-in-aid list at the said point of time, increment shall be admissible from the date when they have been validly appointed in the institution concerned as per the provision as contained under U.P Recognized Basic Schools (JHS) (Recruitment and Conditions of Service of Teachers and other Conditions) Rules 1978 and the way and manner salary was to be fixed has also been provided for. Thereafter it appears that State Government once again issued Government Order dated 26.07.2001 and period for depositing Managements contribution has been extended from 30.06.1999 up to 31.03.2002

    18. By means of Government Order dated 26.07.2001 cut of date for depositing the managerial contribution has been fixed upto 31.03.2002 and at the said point of time, Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 75746 of 2005 (Smt. Shanti Solanki v. State of U.P) has been filed and challenge was made therein that said cut of date as has been fixed to deposit management contribution together with inter est upto 31.03.2002 is arbitrary and unreasonable. This Court on 06.09.2006 has held that said cut of date as 31.03.2002 is wholly arbitrary and has no nexus viz-a-viz the shence mentioned therein. This Court has also proceeded to mention that cut of date as has been mentioned in the Government Order dated 26.07.2001 fixing 31.03.2002 as the last date for deposit of management's contribution has already been struck down and accordingly management's contribution along with inter est is deposited within a period of six weeks from today and if the amount, as directed above, is paid, the respondents shall extend the benefit of aforesaid Government Order to petitioner also subject to fulfillment of other terms and conditions of the scheme. Relevant extract of the said judgment is being extracted below:

    “As the allegations made in the writ petition have not been denied and no justification for fixing the cut— off date as 31.03.2002 has been given, the Court is left with no other option but to quash that part of the Government Order dated 26.07.2001 which fixes 31.03.2002 as the last date for deposit of the management's contribution together with interest.

    Consequently, the writ petition is allowed and in case the petitioner deposits the management contribution together with interest within a period of six weeks, the respondents shall extend the benefit of the said Government Order to the petitioner within a further period of six weeks.”

    19. On 22.05.2006 State Government issued Government Order and therein State Government has proceeded to mention that all those institutions who have been included in grant-in-aid w.e.f 01.01.2004 qua the same demand has been made by Teachers Association whereas it has been specifically mentioned in the Government Order dated 29.05.1999 in paragraph-2, that in respect of institutions which are included in the grant-in-aid, the date on which, institution in question is included in grant-in-aid list within six months managerial contribution should be deposited and accordingly action be taken.

    20. Thereafter another Government Order dated 20.07.2006 has been issued in the direction of clubbing of earlier service rendered when institution was unaided for calculation of pension on the condition of depositing of contributory fund and fulfillment of other terms and condition.

    21. Thereafter State Government had taken the decision to include various institution in the grant-in-aid list and the said institution were to be taken into grant-in-aid list w.e.f 01.12.2006 and accordingly list of institutions have been published, who have been taken in the grant-in-aid on 01.12.2006 Said list forms part of the record in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 45229 of 2012. The Additional Education Director (Basic) Allahabad thereafter wrote a letter on 26.10.2007 and called the guideline for extending the time period depositing the management contribution fund, in pursuance of the Government Order dated 26.07.2001 The Regional Joint Director of Education wrote a letter to all District Basic Education Officer of Uttar Pradesh and Finance and Account Officer in the office of the District Basic Education Officer on 10.02.2009 and called the list of the teachers and non-teaching staff, who have not deposited the management contribution fund. The Chief Secretary Finance U.P Government Lucknow also issued a circular on 16.09.2010 regarding the pension of the employees. The State Government issued a Government Order on 21.01.2009 for the purposes of depositing the management contribution fund (Anshdan) of the employees; which period the institution was not taken in grant-in-aid, regarding considering of the pension of the employees, on the basis of the entire service.

    22. On 08.04.2009 Government Order has been issued and it has been clearly mentioned therein that w.e.f 01.04.2005 new pension scheme namely Contributory Pension Scheme has been introduced and said scheme has been made applicable to all Government aided in-stituation w.e.f 01.04.2005 and all those employees, who have not completed 10 years of service as on 01.04.2005 they can opt for new Pension Scheme and it has also been mentioned therein that all the institutions included in grant-in-aid list on 01.12.2006 after 01.04.2005 they would be covered by new pension scheme.

    23. On the parameter of the aforesaid pro-visions thus, broadly matter has to be examined qua the institutions, who have been brought in grant-in-aid list w.e.f 01.04.2005 and onwards and the institutions who have been brought in the grant-in-aid list of the State Government prior to 01.04.2005

    24. In reference to the institution who have been broght in the grant-in-aid list of the State Government prior to 01.04.2005 services, rendered by incumbents at the unaided stage has to be clubbed but a condition has been attached that in respect of contributory provident fund, the Managers contribution has to be deposited by Manager/employee along with entire inter est in Contributory Provident Fund account. Qua employees who have been functioning and who have opted for contributory provident fund scheme and have not deposited the contribution qua them time frame fixed earlier for de positing the contribution amount and interest has been extended up to 31.03.1998 and there after again said period has been extended up to 30.06.1999 vide Government Order dated 17.02.1999 Thereafter Government Order dated 15.07.1999 has been issued with clear cut condition providing for to be, adhered in the matter of fixation of salary when the institution in question as included in the grant-in-aid list and entire benefit of increment etc has to be extended to the employee who have been appointed strictly as per Rules. By means of another Government Order dated 26.07.2001 period for depositing amount of managerial contribution had been extended from 30.06.1999 to 31.03.2002 and this much is clear that after the said period in question has been extended employees of various institution whose managerial contribution have not been deposited have rushed to this Court and this Court has proceeded to set aside the cut of date fixed as 31.03.2002 State Government had clarified in the Government dated 22.05.2006, by reiterating paragraph 2 of Government Order dated 29.05.1999 mentioning therein that all those institutions who have been included in the grant-in-aid list there contribution should be deposited within six months from the date institution in question has been taken in the grant-in-aid list.

    25. Fact of the matter is that w.e.f 01.04.2005 new pension scheme has been enforced and prior to it there has been altogether different pension scheme. As far as employees, who have been working in the aided institution prior to 01.04.2005 and who intend to get benefit of old scheme in respect to them, the authority should extend the period to deposit their contribution together with interest as this Court has proceeded to declare the cut of date fixed as 31.03.2002 as irrational and various writ petitions are being filed virtually every day with request that as said cut of date has been declared to be unreasonable and arbitrary, and as such requisite directives be issued for permitting the incumbent to deposit managerial contribution together with interest.

    26. In such a situation question is as to whether said time limit provided for depositing the managerial contribution together with interest should be extended or not. As scheme in question is beneficiary scheme for extending the benefit to teaching and non-teaching staff of the institution and once interest of the State is fully protected as amount of contribution is to be deposited along with interest then in such a situation nothing prevents the State Government to give last opportunity to teaching and non-teaching staff to get benefit of aforesaid scheme by depositing managerial contribution along with interest within time frame provided for specially in the background that cut of date fixed as 31.03.1982 has been struck down, and by the said judgment still holds the field, in view of this qua teaching and non-teaching staff who have been appointed prior to 01.04.2005, as a one time measure, the period for depositing Manage ments contribution with interest, be extended by the State Government. Requisite exercise be undertaken within one month from the date of receipt of certified copy of the order.

    27. Now coming to the second category of cases wherein the staff of institution, who have been appointed in the institution prior to 01.04.2005, when it was unaided but after in stitution has been included in the grant-in-aid w.e.f 01.04.2005, qua them State Govern ment has taken policy decision that those institutions who have been included in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005 they shall be governed by new pension rules. Once State Government has proceeded to take policy decision that teaching and non-teaching staff in the institution in question would be governed by new pension policy after being included in the grant-in-aid list of the State Government, can grievance be raised by the petitioners on the said score that same is arbitrary or unreasonable. Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule, 1964 are not applicable or attracted when the institution in question is not on in the grant-in-aid and the provision of Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund, Insurance Pension Rule, 1964 would be applicable qua the institution from the date when it has been taken into grant-in-aid list of the State Government, as such said rules become applicable in the institution concerned only when it is included in the grant-in-aid list. Admittedly after 01.04.2005, once said group of institution has been included in the grant-in-aid list of the State Government w.e.f 01.12.2006 and a new pension scheme has been there, then petitioners cannot claim as a matter of right that they should be covered by old pension Rules.

    28. This much has been accepted that at the point of time when institution in question has been included in the grant-in-aid list entire benefit of earlier service of unaided stage has been clubbed and benefit of the earlier service rendered has been extended qua grant of pay scale, increment and other benefits etc.

    29. The services rendered at unaided stage has not at all been waste, and due care has been taken to extended the benefits admissible in the lieu of the same. Question is can said service be also included as part of the qualifying service specially when appointment in question has been made prior to 01.04.2005 and admittedly institution in question has been brought into the grant-in-aid list of the State Government w.e.f 01.12.2006

    30. This Court in the case of Chandra Bhushan Bajpai v. Joint Director of Education, Kanpur Mandal, Kanpur (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 32132 of 2001 decided on 21.08.2008), reported in 2008 (3) UPLBEC 2333 : (2009 (1) ALJ (NOC) 15) has taken the view that qualifying service period for pension is to be considered on the parameter as is required under the Rules of 1964. In the said case petitioner was claiming counting of period of service rendered by him in the unaided, Non-Government Junior High School and said claim of the petitioner has not been accepted and service rendered at unaided stage has not at all been counted. Paragraphs 6, 7, 8 and 9 of the said judgment being relevant is extracted below:

    6. For the purpose of qualifying service U.P Contributory Provident Fund Insurance Pension Rules are applicable wherein Rule 19(a) and (b) reads as under:”

    19(a) Service will not count for pension unless the employee holds a substantive post on a permanent establishment.

    (b) Continuous temporary or officiating service followed without interruption by confirmation in the same or another post shall alsocount as qualifying service. (See also C.S.R Para 422).”

    7. The benefit of the aforesaid Rule would have been attracted tothe case in hand pro vided the petitioner would have worked in an istitution which was provided grant in aid. Rule 3 of the aforesaid Rules clearly provides that it is applicable to permanent employees serving in State aided education institutions. Rule 3 reads as under:”

    3. These rules shall apply to permanent employees serving in State aided educational institutions of the following categories run either by a local Body or by a Private management and recognised by a competent authority as such for purposes of payment of grant-in-aid.

    (1) Primary Schools;

    (2) Junior High Schools;

    (3) Higher Secondary Schools;

    (4) Degree Colleges;

    (5) Training Colleges.”

    8. It is clear case of the respondents that the institution inquestion was brought in grant-in-aid list in March 1961 though the petitioner served therein prior thereto. Therefore, U.P Contributory Provident-Insurance-Pension Rules which came into force on 1.10.1964 are not applicable at all. Learned counsel for the petitioner could not place any other provision to substantiate his claim that the said service can be counted. Pension is not a bounty but as a matter; of fact, a right, yet the mode and manner of its payment is governed strictly by relevant Rules. Unless the Rules provide, no person can claim a particular service in a particular employment for counting as qualifying service. The Apex Court, in D.S Nakara v. Union of India, (1983) 1 SCC 305 while holding pension as a right, observed as follows:”

    “Pension is a right and the payment of it does not depend upon the discretion of the Government but is governed by the rules and a Government servant coming within those rules is entitled to claim pension. It was further held that the grant of pension does not depend upon anyone's discretion.” (Para 20)

    9. Learned counsel for the petitioner could not place before the Court any provision under which the services rendered in are cognised but un-aided Non-Government Junior High School could have been counted.

    31. This Court in the case of Kunwar Bahadur Sinha v. Director of Education. U.P Lucknow (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 13741 of 1990 decided on 05.05.1995), reported in 1995 (2) UPLBEC 1264 has proceeded to mention that Rule 19(b) of Rules 1964 has not at all been considered whereas sub-Rule (b) of Rule 19, provides that continuous temporary or officiating service followed without interruption by confirmation in the same or another post shall also count as qualifying service. In the said case it has been mentioned that Regional Deputy Director of Education it seems has not noticed clause (b) of Rule 19 of the Rules and has premised the impugned order solely on Clause (a) of Rule 19 which provides that service will not count for pension unless employee holds a substantive post on a permanent establishment In said case at no point of time issue was raised in respect of institution being grant-in-aid list.

    32. New pension scheme has been effectuated w.e.f 01.04.2005 and it has been mentioned therein that it would be applicable to those set up incumbent who had been appointed after 01.04.2005 and it is true that appointment of petitioners had been made prior to 01.04.2005 but the institution in question has been brought in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005 and benefit of past service when the institution in question was unaided has been extended and the State Government has taken policy decision that new pension scheme shall be applicable qua institutions included in grant-in-aid list w.e.f 01.04.2005 Pension is a right and the payment of it does not depend on the discretion of the Government but is governed by Rules, and once new pension scheme has been enforced w.e.f 01.04.2005, and conscious decision has been taken to include teaching and non-teaching staff under the new pension scheme, wherein institution has been brought on grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005, under the new pension scheme, cannot be faulted, as benefit has to be allowed keeping in view the financial resources of the Government, and coupled with this, the teaching and non-teaching staff of institution included in the grant-in-aid after 01.04.2005, form a different class, as prior to said date the provisions of U.P Contribution Provident-Insurance Pension Rules 1964 was not at all applicable or attracted, and from the date i.e when the provisions of the said Rule have become available i.e after 01.04.2005, new pension scheme has been introduced, in view of this said policy decision cannot be faulted, as same is neither arbitrary nor irrational and there is rational basis for framing such a policy.

    33. Apex Court in the case of Commander HQ v. Capt. Biplavendra Chand, reported in JT 1997 SC 371 : ((1997) 1 SCC 208 : AIR 1997 SC 2607) has taken the view that pension is payable to them who fall within the ambit of Rules. Similar view has been taken in the case of T.N Electricity Board v. Veeraswamy, reported in 1999 (2) ESC (SC) 1036.

    34. Apex Court, in the case of Sudhir Kumar Kansal v. Allahabad Bank, 2011 (2) ESC 243 : (2011 (3) ALJ 262) has, in the matter of grant of pension, either under the old rule or the new rule, proceeded to mention that in society governed by rule of law sympathies cannot override the Rules and Regulations, and in the said case view has been taken accordingly that appellant was hot eligible to claim any benefit under Old Pension Scheme.

    35. Inevitable conclusion is that once institution in question has been included in grant-in-aid list after 01.04.2005 and thereafter new pension scheme has been introduced and it has been stated that the claim of petitioners would be governed under the new scheme then said category of incumbents as matter of right cannot claim to be governed under old scheme, and their claim of pension will fall within the ambit of Rules as has been introduced w.e.f 01.04.2005

    36. In view of this, qua incumbents who have been appointed in the said institution and said institution in question has been included in the grant-in-aid list of the State Government prior to 01.04.2005 qua them last opportunity be given by the State Government for enabling them to deposit managerial contribution along with interest and thereafter whatever benefit of the aforesaid old scheme is liable to be extended, the same be extended to said category of incumbents. In respect of institution who have been included in the grant-in-aid list after 01.04.200S the incumbents working therein their claim would be governed under new pension scheme.

    37. In view of aforesaid discussion, Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 45217 of 2012; 45229 of 2012 are dismissed. Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 47649 of 2012 and Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 44742 of 2012 are allowed. Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 55778 of 2010 and Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 47000 of 2010 are dismissed. Petitioners' whose writ petition has been allowed are permitted to deposit contribution with interest within two months from today, and in the event of deposit being made, then benefit of Government Order be extended to them, subject of fulfillment of other terms and condition.

    38. No orders as to cost.

    39. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Buddhiram v. State Of U.P And Ors.
    (Sep 26, 2012)