AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 22, Rule 4 read with Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provision of Order XXII, Rule 4(4) of the C.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 22, Rule 4 read with Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provision of Order XXII, Rule 4(4) of the C.P.C.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed a writ petition seeking a writ of certiorari to quash two orders: the order dated 26.12.2008 passed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation (S.O.C.) in Appeal No.596 (Vidya Devi Vs. Ram Lolarak and others) and the order dated 17.7.2012 passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation (D.D.C.) in Revision No.1965/2354/4086 (Subhash Chandra Vs. Smt. Vidya Devi and others). The 2008 order allowed the appeal filed by respondent No.4 and remanded the matter to the Consolidation Officer for deciding the question of mutation after hearing and evidence. The subsequent revision filed by the petitioners was dismissed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation, maintaining the remand order.

The land in dispute was purchased by Late Ram Lolarak in 1995 through a registered sale deed, and his name was mutated in the revenue records in 1998. The property was recorded in the name of Ram Lolarak's son, Late Dinesh Pratap Singh, who was a minor at the time of purchase. There had been prior litigation regarding mutation involving Ram Lolarak and Smt. Vidya Devi, wife of Late Dinesh Pratap Singh. Earlier orders involved remands between the Settlement Officer Consolidation and the Deputy Director of Consolidation. Ram Lolarak died in 2003 during the pendency of proceedings, and no substitution of heirs or impleading of petitioners was made thereafter. The appeal was decided against Ram Lolarak in 2008, despite his death in 2003. The petitioners contend that the order is a nullity as it was passed against a deceased person and that they should have been substituted or impleaded as respondents.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order passed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation in 2008, which was decided against a deceased person (Ram Lolarak), is legally valid or a nullity.
  2. Whether the petitioners, being bonafide purchasers and having interest in the land, should have been substituted or impleaded as respondents in the appeal proceedings.
  3. The correctness of maintaining the order of remand by the Deputy Director of Consolidation without addressing the issue of the deceased party and substitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The order dated 26.12.2008 passed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation was against a deceased person (Ram Lolarak) and is therefore a nullity.
  • Precedents from this Court establish that orders passed against dead persons are nullities.
  • The matter should be remanded for fresh decision after substituting or impleading the petitioners as respondents, as they have sufficient interest in the property.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondent No.4 is a lady who has been allegedly harassed by the petitioners for over 32 years.
  • The appeal was decided against a dead person, but this fact was not disputed.
  • The legal position regarding orders against deceased persons, as laid down by this Court, was not disputed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Aziz Mohammad (Dead) through Lrs. and another Vs. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Allahabad and others, 2008 (104) RD 470 Orders passed against dead persons are nullities. Used to establish that the order passed against Ram Lolarak after his death was void.
Raj Narain and others Vs. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Ghazipur and others, 2009 (106) RD 98 Orders passed against dead persons are nullities. Supported the principle that the appeal order was invalid as it was passed against a deceased person.
Leelawati Bai Vs. State of Bombay, A.I.R. 1957, Page 521 Order passed against dead person is a complete nullity. Reinforced the nullity of orders passed against deceased persons.
Amba Bai and others Vs. Gopal and others, A.I.R. 2001 Supreme Court 2003 Judgment passed against a deceased person is a nullity. Affirmed that judgments without knowledge of death of a party are void.
T. Gnanavel and T.S. Kanagaraj and another, 2009 (75) ALR 515 Order XXII, Rule 4(4) of the C.P.C. requires substitution of heirs before judgment if a party dies during pendency. Confirmed that failure to substitute heirs renders the decree a nullity.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the appeal was decided in 2008 against Ram Lolarak, who had died in 2003. There was no effort to substitute his heirs or implead the petitioners, who had purchased the property and had been recorded in the revenue records since 1998. The Court relied on established legal principles and precedents that any order or judgment passed against a deceased person is a nullity. The Court further observed that the Deputy Director of Consolidation dismissed the revision without addressing this crucial issue. Consequently, the Court held that the impugned orders could not be sustained and the matter must be remanded for fresh consideration after proper substitution of the petitioners as respondents in the appeal, in accordance with Order 22, Rule 4 read with Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Court directed that the appeal be decided expeditiously after hearing both sides.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed and the impugned orders dated 26.12.2008 and 17.7.2012 are quashed.

The matter is remitted to the Settlement Officer Consolidation for fresh decision on the appeal after substituting the petitioners as respondents under Order 22, Rule 4 read with Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Court directed that the appeal be decided within six months from the receipt of the certified copy of this order. The parties are free to raise any objections during the fresh proceedings. This decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the prior orders passed against a deceased person and ensuring proper procedural compliance through substitution, but it does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming existing principles.

    Subhash Chandra And Another v. The Deputy Director Of Consolidation, Jaunpur And Others

    Ran Vijai Singh, J.—

    Heard Sri M.D.Singh 'Shekhar', learned Senior counsel assisted Sri R.D. Tiwari, learned counsel for the petitioners, Sri Pradeep Kumar Tiwari, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.4 and learned Standing Counsel for the State respondents.

    2. Counsel for both the parties submits that in this case, at this stage, only a legal question is involved and the same may be decided without inviting any counter affidavit. Therefore, the writ petition is taken up for final disposal with the consent of learned counsel for the parties.

    3. Through this writ petition, petitioners have prayed for issuing a writ of certiorari quashing the order dated 26.12.2008 passed by Settlement Officer Consolidation (in short S.O.C.) in Appeal No.596 (Vidya Devi Vs. Ram Lolarak and others) and order dated 17.7.2012 passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation (in short D.D.C) in Revision No.1965/2354/4086 (Subhash Chandra Vs. Smt. Vidya Devi and others). Vide order dated 26.12.2008, appeal filed by the respondent No.4 was allowed and the matter was remanded back to the Consolidation Officer for deciding the question of mutation after providing opportunity of hearing as well as leading the evidence etc. whereas by the subsequent order, petitioners' revision was dismissed.

    4. It appears that Late Ram Lolarak has purchased the land in dispute through registered sale deed dated 22.2.1995. Name of Ram Lolarak was mutated in the revenue record in the year 1998. The property in dispute was recorded in the name of one Dinesh Pratap Singh S/o Ram Lolarak. It is the case of the petitioners that the property was purchased by Ram Lolarak in the name of his son (namely Late Dinesh Pratap) when he was minor of 15 years. Prior to that there was litigation between Ram Lolarak and Smt. Vidya Devi, W/o Late Dinesh Pratap Singh (S/o Ram Lolarak) regarding mutation for the reasons that after death of Dinesh Pratap Singh, name of Ram Lolarak was recorded in the revenue record on 15.4.1980. Against that order, Smt. Vidya Devi has filed an appeal which was allowed and remanded on 3.11.1981 by the Settlement Officer Consolidation to the Consolidation Officer. Aggrieved by this order, late Ram Lolarak has filed revision before the Deputy Director of Consolidation, which was allowed and the matter was remanded to the Settlement Officer Consolidation instead of Consolidation Officer. When the matter was pending after remand before the Settlement Officer Consolidation, Ram Lolarak died on 15.6.2003. Thereafter, no substitution etc. was filed whereas the petitioners' name was already recorded in the year 1998. The appeal was allowed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation on 26.12.2008. The petitioners herein have filed revision. In the revision, specific ground was taken that the appeal has been decided against dead person, therefore, it is a nullity. It was also contended that the petitioners ought to have been substituted, alternatively, impleaded as respondents in the appeal as they had already purchased the property way back in the year 1995 and have sufficient interest in the land in dispute. The Deputy Director of Consolidation without adverting to this question, has dismissed the revision and maintained the order of Settlement Officer, Consolidation by which the matter was remanded to the Consolidation Officer.

    5. Sri M.D.Singh 'Shekhar', learned Senior Counsel contends that the Deputy Director of Consolidation erred in maintaining the order of Settlement Officer Consolidation whereas the order dated 26.12.2008 passed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation was against the dead person and that was a nullity, in view of the decision of this Court in the cases of Aziz Mohammad (Dead)through Lrs. And another Vs. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Allahabad and others, 2008 (104) RD, 470 and Raj Narain and others Vs. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Ghazipur and others, 2009(106) RD 98. He has further contended that since the order is a nullity, therefore, the matter ought to have been remanded before the Settlement Officer Consolidation for deciding the appeal after substituting/ impleading the petitioners as respondent.

    6. Refuting the submission of learned counsel for the petitioners, learned counsel for the respondents contends that the respondent No.4 is a lady. She is being harassed by the present petitioners for the last 32 years. She at present is about 60 years and petitioners herein are lingering the proceedings. However, he could not dispute this fact that the appeal was decided against a dead person. The legal position as laid down by this Court in the cases of Aziz Mohammad (Dead) (Supra) has also not been disputed by the learned counsel for the respondents.

    7. On the admitted position, the following facts would reveal:

    (1) The present petitioners have purchased the property from Ram Lolarak through registered sale deed in the year 1995 and their names were also mutated in the revenue record in the year 1998.

    (2) In the appeal filed by respondent No.4, Ram Lolarak was contesting respondent and when the appeal was decided in the year 2008, Ram Lolarak was no more in existence as he has already died in the year 2003.

    8. No efforts have been made either to substitute the heirs of Ram Lolarak or to implead the present petitioners who have sufficient interest in the land in dispute being bonafide purchaser and an aggrieved person to contest the case. It is not clear as to whether the validity of the sale deed has ever been challenged before the civil court by filing suit for cancellation of sale deed or it is only to be contested before the Consolidation Courts.

    9. The Apex Court in the case of Leelawati Bai Vs. State of Bombay, A.I.R. 1957, Pae 521 has held that the order passed against the dead person is a complete nullity.

    10. In A.I.R. 2001, Supreme Court, 2003, Amba Bai and others Vs. Gopal and others, the Apex Court has held as under:

    "As the judgment in the Second Appeal was passed without the knowledge that the appellant had died, the same being a judgment passed against the dead person is a nullity."

    11. In T.Gnanavel and T.S.Kanagaraj and another reported in 2009(75) ALR 515, the Apex Court has taken the same view by observing as under:-

    "19. For the reasons aforesaid, we are of the opinion that the High Court had rightly intercepted the provision of Order XXII, Rule 4(4) of the C.P.C. and accordingly held that the decree passed by the Trial Court on20th of December, 2002, in O.S. No.3946 of 1999 was a nullity in the eye of law as the defendant had died during the pendency of the suit for specific performance of the contract for sale and no exemption was sought at the instance of the plaintiff/appellant to bring on record the heirs and legal representatives of the defendant before the judgment was pronounced."

    12. This Court also in the cases of Aziz Mohammad (Dead) through Lrs. And another Vs. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Allahabad and others (Supra) and Raj Narain and others Vs. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Ghazipur and others (Supra) has held that order passed against the dead person is a nullity.

    13. In view of the above legal position, since on the date when appeal was allowed, the respondent Ram Lolarak was dead, therefore, the orders passed by the S.O.C. and Deputy Director of Consolidation cannot be sustained. The writ petition succeeds and is allowed.

    14. The impugned orders passed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation dated 26.12.2008 in Appeal No.596 (Vidya Devi Vs. Ram Lolarak and others) and the order dated 17.7.2012 passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation in Revision No.1965/2354/4086 (Subhash Chandra Vs. Smt. Vidya Devi and others) are hereby quashed. The matter is remitted back before the Settlement Officer Consolidation to decide the appeal. This Court directs that the petitioners be substituted under Order 22, Rule 4 read with Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure in the appeal and fresh decision be taken by the Settlement Officer Consolidation after hearing both sides expeditiously, not later than six months from the date of receipt of certified copy of the order of this Court.

    15. The parties are at liberty to raise their objections which ever they want to raise.

    _____________

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Subhash Chandra And Another v. The Deputy Director Of Consolidation, Jaunpur And Others
    (Aug 24, 2012)