Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 49 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1930 or Rule 2 of the Bihar & Orissa Subordinate Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1935.
  • Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code (Code in short)
  • provisions contained in Rule 97 of the Code
  • Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules.
  • sub-rule (3) or (5) of Rule 97
  • sub-rule (1),
  • Rule 43(b).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 49 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1930 or Rule 2 of the Bihar & Orissa Subordinate Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1935.
  • Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code (Code in short)
  • provisions contained in Rule 97 of the Code
  • Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules.
  • sub-rule (3) or (5) of Rule 97
  • sub-rule (1),
  • Rule 43(b).
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by S.N. Jha, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner sought a writ directing payment of post-retirement benefits including salary for the suspension period, time-bound promotion and consequential benefits, monetary benefits arising from upgradation of post and revision of pay scale.

Key factual chronology provided in the opinion:

  • The petitioner was placed under suspension on 12.1.1978 and faced both departmental proceedings and criminal prosecution.
  • He was acquitted in the criminal case on 9.1.1986.
  • The Enquiry Officer submitted a report exonerating him of the departmental charges on 28.4.1986; suspension was revoked on 21.5.1986 and the petitioner was reinstated.
  • The petitioner retired on superannuation on 31.1.1992. Because the departmental proceeding had not been finally concluded, several post-retirement claims remained outstanding.
  • The writ petition was filed on 11.3.1992. On 12.8.1992 the Registrar, Co-operative Societies (the competent authority), ordered that the petitioner would not be entitled to salary or allowance except subsistence allowance for the suspension period and that the period be treated as absence from duty; the petitioner challenged that order by a supplementary petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after retirement on superannuation, disciplinary proceedings can result in punishment or adverse orders affecting pay/allowances arising from a prior period of suspension.
  2. Whether the competent authority can pass an order disagreeing with an Enquiry Officer's exoneration without assigning cogent reasons and without giving the concerned person further opportunity of hearing.
  3. Whether an order under Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code (concerning reinstatement and treatment of suspension period) can be passed after retirement and what its character (penal or administrative) is.
  4. Whether part or whole of pension may be withheld pursuant to Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, and under what conditions (i.e., requirement of a recorded finding in departmental or judicial proceedings).
  5. What reliefs are appropriate as regards finalisation and payment of pension, gratuity and other post-retirement dues when departmental proceedings remain inconclusive at the time of retirement.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • After retirement of a government servant, pending departmental proceedings come to an end and no punishment can be imposed thereafter.
  • No reason was assigned for imposing an adverse order that is in disagreement with the findings of the Enquiry Officer.
  • No opportunity of hearing was given to the petitioner before passing the adverse order (the order dated 12.8.1992).

The opinion does not set out detailed arguments advanced by the respondent or the competent authority in the same structured manner.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Laxmi Narain Singh v. The State of Bihar, 1989 BBCJ 147 Held that disciplinary action is not permissible after retirement in the absence of a specific rule; Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code permits the competent authority to pass an order on pay/allowances and treatment of suspension period even after retirement; further enquiry may be ordered if reasonable opportunity was denied. The court relied on this decision to conclude that retirement does not materially change the requirement that the competent authority must pass an order under Rule 97 concerning pay/allowances and treatment of the suspension period; the court accepted that such orders can be passed post-retirement and that further enquiry may be required where opportunity was denied.
Narain Misra v. State of Orissa, 1969 S.L.R. 657 Establishes that if an authority intends to take into account charges on which a person was acquitted, it must draw attention to that fact and give the person an opportunity to explain — a principle of fair play and natural justice. The court applied this principle to hold that when the disciplinary authority intends to disagree with an Enquiry Officer's exoneration and impose an adverse consequence under Rule 97(3)/(5), the person must be given explicit notice of disagreement and an opportunity to be heard; lack of such procedure vitiates the order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a stepwise legal analysis based on the statutory provisions and the cited precedents:

  1. Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code was examined in detail. The court quoted and analysed sub-rules (1), (2), (3), (4) and (5), noting:
    • On reinstatement the competent authority must make a specific order about pay/allowances for the period of dismissal, removal or suspension and whether that period shall be treated as spent on duty (Rule 97(1)).
    • Where the authority considers the servant fully exonerated or suspension wholly unjustified, full pay and allowance must be given and the period treated as spent on duty (Rule 97(2) and (4)).
    • In other cases the authority may prescribe a proportion of pay/allowance (Rule 97(3)) and decide whether the period shall be treated as spent on duty for specified purposes (Rule 97(5)).
  2. Applying Dr. Laxmi Narain Singh, the court held that retirement does not materially alter the position: although disciplinary penalties cannot generally be imposed after retirement, the statutory obligation on the competent authority to pass an order under Rule 97 as to pay/allowances and treatment of the suspension period survives retirement. Such an order is not a penalty as enumerated in Rule 49 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1930 or Rule 2 of the Bihar & Orissa Subordinate Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1935.
  3. The court clarified that departmental proceedings cannot be continued post-retirement for imposing service penalties but may be continued for the limited purpose of withholding whole or part of pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, provided a finding of guilt or pecuniary loss is recorded in departmental or judicial proceedings.
  4. On the specific facts, the Enquiry Officer had exonerated the petitioner. The court emphasised the principle from Narain Misra: if a disciplinary authority intends to take into account charges on which a person was acquitted (i.e., to disagree with an exonerating report), it must give explicit notice of disagreement and afford further opportunity to explain. The authority must state cogent reasons for disagreeing with the Enquiry Officer's findings.
  5. The court found the order dated 12.8.1992 to be defective because it showed a lack of awareness that the Enquiry Officer had exonerated the petitioner. Since the authority had not informed the petitioner or given him a chance to meet the grounds of disagreement, the order could not be sustained.
  6. Regarding withholding of pension (an order dated 2.12.1992 was mentioned as having been passed but was not challenged in the writ), the court explained Rule 43(b): withholding or withdrawal of pension is permissible only after a recorded finding in departmental or judicial proceedings that the pensioner is guilty of grave misconduct or caused pecuniary loss. The court did not decide whether such a finding had been recorded in this case because necessary materials were not placed before it.
  7. Remedies and directions: the court quashed the 12.8.1992 order, remitted the matter to the Registrar, Co-operative Societies to reconsider. If the Registrar proposes an adverse order under Rule 97(3) or (5) in disagreement with the Enquiry Officer, he must give a proper show cause notice and pass a reasoned order. If withholding of pension is contemplated under Rule 43(b), a show cause notice must be issued and any concluded finding relied upon must be identified. The court directed that, in any event, the proceedings should be concluded within four months from receipt of the order, given that the petitioner had retired about a year earlier.
  8. The court further directed that all legal dues (pension, gratuity, payment for unutilised leave, provident fund, group insurance, time-bound promotion, upgradation/higher pay arising from pay revision) must be finalised and paid within the same four-month period.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed; the order dated 12.8.1992 is quashed and the matter is remitted to the competent authority for fresh consideration.

Specific operative consequences directed by the court:

  • The Registrar, Co-operative Societies (competent authority) must reconsider the entitlement under Rule 97. If the Registrar intends to pass any adverse order under Rule 97(3) or (5) that disagrees with the Enquiry Officer's exoneration, he must first issue a proper show cause notice and then pass a reasoned order.
  • If the Registrar considers withholding part of the pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, he may do so only if a finding in departmental or judicial proceedings supports such withholding; before doing so the petitioner must be given a show cause notice. If no concluded finding exists, the departmental proceeding may be continued to its logical conclusion, subject to the direction that it should be completed within four months from receipt of this order.
  • All legal dues (post-retirement claims, time-bound promotion, payment resulting from pay revision or upgradation) must be finalised and paid to the petitioner within four months.

Broader implications:

  • The court applied existing statutory provisions and precedent to clarify that Rule 97 obligations survive retirement in the sense that a competent authority must still pass the requisite order regarding pay/allowances and treatment of suspension period; however, the decision does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond the application of existing rules and cited case law.
  • No new legal precedent was created; the judgment applies and explains pre-existing rules (Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code and Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules) and established authorities concerning natural justice (Narain Misra) and Dr. Laxmi Narain Singh.

Disposition

The writ application is allowed with the directions and observations recorded in the opinion. A.N. Chaturvedi, J. concurred.

    Basishtha Prasad Sinha v. The State Of Bihar And Others

    S.N Jha, J.:— This writ application has been filed for direction for payment of post retirement benefits, salary in respect of the suspension period, time bound promotion and its consequential benefits as well as monetary benefits of the upgradation of post and revision of pay scale.

    2. The petitioner was subjected to depart mental proceeding and criminal prosecution. He was placed under suspension on 12.1.78 In the criminal case he was acquitted on 9.1.86 It is stated that in the departmental proceeding also the Enquiry Officer on 28.4.86 submitted report exonerating him of the charges. His suspension was revoked on 21.5.86 and he was reinstated on the post. The petitioner retired from service on reaching the age of superannuation on 31.1.92 However, his claims remained outstanding on account of the pendency of the departmental proceeding as no final decision was taken even after the receipt of the enquiry report. Accordingly, the present writ application was filed on 11.3.92 An order was passed by the competent authority, namely, Registrar, Co-operative Societies on 12.8.92 directing that the petitioner will not be entitled to salary or allowance except subsistence allowance for the suspension period and that the period shall be treated as period of absence from duty. The petitioner has challenged the said order by supplementary petition.

    3. Mr. Prabhat Kumar Varma, learned counsel for the petitioner, raised the following contentions (i) after retirement of the government servant, the pending departmental proceeding comes to an end and no punishment can be imposed on him (ii) no reason has been assigned for imposing punishment in disagreement with the findings of the Enquiry Officer and (iii) no opportunity of hearing was given to the petitioner.

    4. The first contention is squarely covered by the decision in Dr. Laxmi Narain Singh v. The State of Bihar, 1989 BBCJ 147. Therein Mr. Justice L.M Sharma, as he then was, on a reference after difference of opinion between two learned Judges, held that in the absence of specific rule, disciplinary action is not permissible after retirement of the government servant. It was, however, held that Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code (‘Code’ in short) enjoins the competent authority to pass an order at the close of the departmental proceeding as to whether the Government servant is to be paid full pay and allowance for the suspension period in terms of Rule 97(3) and whether, in that situation, the period in question is to be treated as spent on duty or absence from duty. Such an order can be passed even after retirement of the Government servant and where he has been denied reasonable opportunity to place his defence, further enquiry may also be ordered.

    5. At this stage, provisions contained in Rule 97 of the Code may be noticed:

    “97. (1) When a Government servant who has been dismissed, removed, or suspended is reinstated, the authority competent to order the reinstatement shall consider and make specific order—

    (a) regarding the pay and allowance to be paid to the Government servant for the period of his absence from duty, and

    (b) whether or not the said period shall be treated as a period spent on duty.

    (2) Where the authority mentioned in sub-rule (1), is of opinion that the Government servant has been fully exonerated, or in the case of suspension, that it was wholly unjustified, the Government servant shall be given full pay and allowance to which he would have been entitled, had he not been dismissed, removed or suspended, as the case may be.

    (3) In other cases, the Government servant shall be given such proportion of such pay and allowance as such competent authority may prescribe:

    Provided that the payment of allowance under clause (2) or clause (3) shall be subject to all other conditions under which such allowances are admissible.

    (4) In a case falling under clause (2) the period of absence from duty shall be treated as a period spent on duty for all purposes.

    (5) In a case falling under clause (3) the period of absence from duty shall not be treated as a period spent on duty unless such competent authority specifically directs that it shall be so treated for any specified purpose:

    Provided that if the Government servant so desires such authority may direct that the period of absence from duty shall be converted into leave of any kind due and admissible to the Government servant.”

    6. It would appear from bare perusal of the rule that at the time of reinstatement of a Government servant who was dismissed, removed or suspended, the competent authority is required to make specific order as to the entitlement of the person concerned to his pay and allowance with respect to the period of suspension and whether the period is to be treated as spent on duty or not, as per clause (1). Where the delinquent is fully exonerated by the competent authority or where the authority thinks that the suspension was wholly unjustified, he will as of right be entitled to full pay and allowance. However, in all other cases where the person is not fully exonerated or the suspension is not found to be wholly unjustified, the competent authority has to take a decision as to the entitlement of the delinquent to pay and allowance. In other words, in all other cases not covered by clause (2) it is open to the competent authority to direct payment of only part of pay and allowance. Again, in cases covered by clause (2), the period of absence has to be treated as a period spent on duty for all purposes but in cases covered by clause (3), that is in all other cases, a discretion is again vested in the competent authority to decide as to whether the period shall be treated as absence from duty or spent on duty for any specified purpose. An order directing that the Government servant concerned shall not be entitled to pay and allowance save and except the subsistence allowance, and directing that the period in question shall be treated as absence from duty has to be passed by the competent authority in every case at the stage of final conclusion of the departmental proceeding. Where the proceeding is concluded while the Government servant is still in service, there can be hardly any difficulty whatsoever in passing such an order. But whether the same can be done afterwards? According to the learned counsel, this is not permissible after one's retirement. In my opinion, retirement of the person does not materially change the position. Where the person is still in service, the departmental proceeding is concluded by an express order. Where, however, he attains the age of superannuation and retires from service before the proceeding formally concluded, the proceeding will be deemed to have come to an end but only for the purpose of imposing any penalty prescribed in the Service Rules. Nevertheless so far as the period of suspension is concerned, an order as envisaged under sub-rules (3) and (5) has to be passed. It has to be kept in mind that such an order per se is not a penalty as enumerated in Rule 49 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1930 or Rule 2 of the Bihar & Orissa Subordinate Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1935. I am fortified in my view by the observations made in the case of Dr. Laxmi Narain Singh (supra) which decision is based on authorities of the Supreme Court.

    7. On the question of continuance of the departmental proceeding, I hasten to add that although the same cannot be continued for the purpose of imposing any of the penalties mentioned in the service rules, it can be continued for the purpose of withholding whole or part of the pension within the meaning of Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules. On the facts of the case it is necessary to make that clarification since we were informed during the hearing of the case that some order has been passed by the authority on 2.12.92 in regard to withholding of part of the pension.

    8. Although my conclusion on the first question is adverse to the petitioner, he is entitled to succeed on the other two grounds. The Enquiry Officer had exonerated the petitioner of the charges. It is true that the report of the Enguiry Officer is not binding on the disciplinary authority and for cogent reasons, which must appear from the order, the disciplinary authority may take a different view. But in such a case it is necessary that the person concerned is given further opportunity of hearing after stating the grounds of disagreement. Reference in this connection may be made to the following observations of the Supreme Court in the case of Narain Misra v. State of Orissa: 1969 S.L.R 657.

    “Now if the Conservator of Forests intended taking the charges on which he was acquitted into account, it was necessary that the attention of the appellant ought to have been drawn to this fact and his explanation, if any, called for. This does not appear to have been done. In other words, the Conservator of Forests used against him the charges of which he was acquitted without warning him that be was going to use them. This is against all principles of fair play and natural justice. If the Conservator of the Forests wanted to use them, he should have apprised him of his own attitude and given him an adequate opportunity. Since that opportunity was not given, the order of the Conservator of Forests modified by the State Government cannot be upheld.”

    9. An order passed in terms of sub-rule (3) or (5) of Rule 97 is not in the nature of penalty within the meaning of the service rules but nonetheless its effect is penal in naturs since it adversely affects the person concerned. In my opinion, therefore, the same principle should be applicable to cases where the authority, in disagreement with the report of the Enquiry Officer, decides that the persons concerned shall not be entitled to full pay and allowance and that the period in question shall be treated as the period of absence from duty.

    10. A perusal to the order dated 12.8.92 shows complete lack of awareness on the part of the authority that the petitioner had been exonerated of the charges by the Enquiry Officer. In such a situation, the order cannot be sustained. Accordingly, the order, copy whereof has been marked Annexure 1/1 to the supplementary petition and also Annexure-D to the supplementary counter affidavit is quashed. The Registrar, Co-operative Societies, the competent authority, is directed to consider the matter afresh. If he proposes to pass any adverse order in terms of Rule 97(3) and (5) in disagreement with the findings and recommendation of the Enquiry Officer, he shall give a proper show cause notice to the petitioner and pass a fresh reasoned order in accordance with law.

    11. The order dated 2.12.92, referred to above by which the competent authority has taken a decision to withhold part of the pension has not been challenged in this writ petition, perhaps on account of delayed communication to petitioner. Be that as it may, since this is one of the reliefs claimed in this writ petition, the legal position may briefly be stated thus. Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules empowers the State Government to withhold or withdraw whole or part of the pension or to order recovery from pension any amount of pecuniary loss suffered by the Government if the person concerned is found in a departmental or judicial proceeding guilty of grave misconduct or to have caused pecuniary loss to the Government by misconduct or negligence. This, however, can be done only after a finding to Chat effect is recorded in either departmental or judicial proceeding. It is not necessary to advert to the question as to whether the petitioner has been ‘found’ to be guilty of any-such grave misconduct or to have caused pecuniary loss to the Government by his misconduct or negligence within the meaning of Rule 43(b) so as to disentitle him to full pension since full materials have not been placed before us. However since the matter is being remitted back to the Registrar, it would be apt to direct him to consider the matter as to the payment of pension and gratuity in the light of the provisions under Rule 43(b). If, in his opinion, the petitioner has already been found to be guilty of any misconduct etc. he may pass an order withholding part of the pension but before doing so he shall give a show cause notice to the petitioner since the Enquiry Officer had opined otherwise. If, on the other hand, no concluded finding has been recorded in the proceeding as to the misconduct etc. of the petitioner, the proceeding in question may be continued against him to its logical end, However, having regard to the fact that the petitioner retired from service about a year ago, it would be only just and proper that the proceeding is concluded within four months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

    12. In the supplementary counter affidavit, it has been stated that orders have been issued or are being issued in respect of the some of the claims, such as pension and death-cum-retirement gratuity for the duty period, payment of unutilised leave salary, provident fund dues, group insurance dues, time bound promotion etc. I direct that all the legal dues of the petitioner whether in the nature of post retirement claims or claim arising out of the time bound promotion or higher pay as a result of pay revision or upgradation of post must be finalised and necessary payment made to the petitioner within the aforesaid period of four months.

    13. This application, accordingly, is allowed with the observations and directions mentioned above.

    14. A.N Chaturvedi, J.:—I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Basishtha Prasad Sinha v. The State Of Bihar And Others
    (Feb 9, 1993)