AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Mt. Jokhna Tewarin obtained a decree on 28 August 1912 in Suit No. 198 of 1911 from the Court of the Additional Subordinate Judge of Gorakhpur for delivery of possession of a one anna seven pie and 10 chhatak zamindari share of village Kat Kuian against several defendants, including Raja Bahadur Brij Narain Rai and Rai Jagdish Narain Rai. The decree was conditional: possession was contingent on Mt. Jokhna depositing Rs. 2,499-15-0 in Court to the credit of Brij Narain Rai and Jagdish Narain Rai; no date for payment was specified.

Mt. Jokhna died without fulfilling the condition or applying for execution. Her sons and heirs applied for execution on 31 July 1928. The application was initially returned for presentation to the proper Court because the original Court that passed the decree had been abolished. The representatives then presented the application to the Court of the Subordinate Judge of Gorakhpur on 13 September 1928, and money was deposited to the credit of the two defendants on 30 September 1928.

The respondents resisted execution on the ground that the application was barred by limitation. The trial Court held the claim barred under Article 182 of the Limitation Act. The lower appellate Court confirmed the trial Court's decree but held that Article 181, not Article 182, applied. The decree-holders relied on the Divisional Bench decision in Re. Mt. Rukmina Kuar v. Sheo Dat Rai [1919] 51 I.C. 576.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application for execution of the conditional decree is barred by limitation.
  2. Which provision of the Limitation Act governs the execution of this conditional decree — Article 181 or Article 182 — and when does the right to apply for execution accrue?

Arguments of the Parties

Decree-holders' Arguments

  • The application for execution was not time-barred; reliance was placed on the Divisional Bench decision in Re. Mt. Rukmina Kuar v. Sheo Dat Rai [1919] 51 I.C. 576 to support their position.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The application for execution was barred by limitation; at trial this was characterised as falling under Article 182 of the Limitation Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mt. Rukmina Kuar v. Sheo Dat Rai [1919] 51 I.C. 576 Supports the proposition that where a decree is not immediately executable and execution depends on fulfilment of contingencies, Article 182 is inapplicable and the residuary Article 181 governs limitation; and that the decree-holder's right to act may accrue immediately where payment can be made at once. The Court relied on this decision to support its conclusion that Article 182 did not apply to the conditional decree and that Article 181 governed the limitation period.
Rameshwar Singh Bahadur v. Homeshvar Singh A.I.R. 1921 P.C. 31 Holds that where a decree conditions recovery of possession upon payment of money without specifying a date, the decree-holder is entitled to pay at once and claim possession immediately; the right accrues immediately and cannot be prolonged by inaction. The Court cited this Privy Council decision to reinforce that the decree-holder's right to apply accrued from the date the decree was passed (because payment could have been made then) and therefore limitation ran from that date under Article 181.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the nature of the decree and the applicable articles of the Limitation Act. It observed that the decree was conditional and not immediately executable when passed because possession depended upon depositing Rs. 2,499-15-0 to the credit of the two defendants; however, no date for payment was fixed by the decree.

The Court reasoned that Article 182 of the Limitation Act did not apply to decrees that are not immediately executable and whose execution depends on fulfilment of contingencies specified in the decree. Instead, such decrees fall under the residuary Article 181. Under Column 3, Schedule 2 of the Limitation Act, limitation runs from the date on which the right to apply accrues.

The Court distinguished between two related rights: (a) the right to apply for actual possession (which accrues only after the money has been deposited), and (b) the right to apply to have the money deposited to the credit of the defendants (which, the Court held, accrued immediately on the day the decree was passed). Because the decree-holder could have deposited the money on the date of the decree and immediately sought possession, the accrual date for limitation purposes under Article 181 is the date of the decree.

The Court relied on its own Divisional Bench decision in Mt. Rukmina Kuar's case and on the Privy Council decision in Rameshwar Singh Bahadur v. Homeshvar Singh to support the proposition that where no payment date is specified the decree-holder's right accrues immediately and cannot be prolonged by inaction or laches. Applying that principle, the Court concluded that the present execution application, made more than three years after the decree, is time-barred under Article 181.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the application for execution was time-barred under Article 181 of the Limitation Act and accordingly dismissed the appeal.

Implications: The direct effect is that the decree-holders' application for execution is barred by limitation and the appeal is dismissed with costs, including fees on the higher scale in this Court. The opinion applies existing precedent (Mt. Rukmina Kuar and Rameshwar Singh Bahadur) to the facts and does not state that it establishes a new legal rule beyond those authorities.

    (Siri) Narain Tewari And Another v. Brij Narain Rai And Another

    1. This is an appeal by the decree-holders and the only question raised in the appeal is one relating to limitation.

    2. Mt. Jokhna Tewarin obtained a decree against a number of persons from the Court of the Additional Subordinate Judge of Gorakhpur in Suit No. 198 of 1911 on 28th August 1912. Amongst the. defendants to the action were Raja Bahadur Brij Narain Rai and Rai Jagdish Narain Rai. The decree passed against them was for delivery of possession of a one anna seven pie and 10 chhatak zamindari share of a village called Kat Kuian. The decree was not unconditional. It provided that the right to possession was contingent upon Mt. Jokhna depositing in the Court to the credit of Brij Narain Rai and Jagdish Narain Rai a sum of Rs. 2,499-15-0. No date for payment of this sum was specified in the decree.

    3. Mt. Jokhna died. She did not fulfil the condition in her lifetime; nor did she apply for the execution of the decree. The present application for execution was made by her sons and heirs on 31st, July 1928. The application was presented in a certain Court in Gorakhpur. That Court returned the application to the decree-holders for presentation to the proper Court on the ground that the 'original Court which had passed the decree in favour of Mt. Jokhna had been abolished. Thereupon the application was presented by the representatives of the original decree-holder in the Court of the Subordinate Judge of Gorakhpur on 13th September 1928. Money was deposited to the credit of Raja Bahadur Brij Narain Rai and Jagdish Naraia Rai on 30th September 1928.

    4. The application was resisted on the ground that it was barred by limitation. This contention prevailed with the first Court which held that the claim was barred by the application of Article 182, Lim. Act. The lower appellate Court has confirmed the decree of the trial Court, but has differed as regards the specific article which is applicable to the facts of the case. The lower appellate Court came to the conclusion that the article applicable to the case was Article 181 and not Article 182. It has been contended by the learned advocate for the decree-holders that in view of the matter the application for execution is not time-barred, and reliance has been placed upon a ruling of a Divisional Bench of this Court in Re. Mt. Rukmina Kuar v. Sheo Dat Rai [1919] 51 I.C. 576.

    5. We have already noticed that a conditional decree for possession of mauza Kat Kuian was passed in favour of the original decree-holder. This decree for possession however was not capable of execution on the date on which it was passed and required a further application fulfilling the condition contained in the decree. Article 182, Lim. Act, therefore did not apply to a decree of this description. The article applicable was Article 181. Limitation would run from the date on which the right to apply accrued under Col. 3, Schedule 2, Lim. Act. The right to apply for possession did not accrue till the money was paid to the credit of the persons concerned, but the right to apply that the money be deposited to the credit of Brij Narain Rai and Jagdish Narain Rai accrued at once. The decree-holder had the right to apply that the money be deposited to the credit of defendants 8 and 9 on the very day that the decree was passed, and there was nothing to preclude her from depositing the amount and asking for possession. Where a decree is not immediately executable and the right to apply for execution depends upon the fulfilment of certain contingencies provided for in the decree, Article 182 is clearly inapplicable and the only article governing the execution is the residuary Article 181. This view receives support from the decision of this Court in Rukmina Kuer's case [1919] 51 I.C. 576, which has already been adverted to and also from the decision of the Privy Council in Rameshwar Singh Bahadur v. Homeshvar Singh A.I.R. 1921 P.C. 31. Where under the terms of a decree the right of the decree-holder to recover possession of some property in the hands of the defendants is contingent upon the decree-holder paying certain sums of money to the defendants but no date far payment is specified the decree-holder is entitled to pay the money on the date when the decree was passed and to ask for possession immediately after the payment had been made. The right accrues to the decree-holder immediately and at once, and the! decree-holder is not entitled to prolong) the date of payment by his or her in-action or laches. We hold therefore that the application having been made more than three years from the date when the decree was passed is clearly time-barred under Article 181.

    6. We have considered the case in all its aspects, We think that the view taken by the Court below is right. We therefore dismiss this appeal with costs including in this Court fees on the higher scale.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    (Siri) Narain Tewari And Another v. Brij Narain Rai And Another
    (Jan 10, 1931)