Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit for possession of property dedicated to a deity by Pandit Manni Ram through a deed of endowment dated 10th January 1899. Manni Ram appointed himself and Gulab Shankar as sarbarakars (trustees/managers) of the endowed property. After Manni Ram’s death around 1900, Gulab Shankar continued alone as sarbarakar. In 1912, Gulab Shankar appointed the defendant-appellant as trustee and manager by a deed of gift. Gulab Shankar died about three months before the suit was instituted. Subsequently, Udho Ram, heir of Manni Ram, appointed the plaintiff as trustee and sarbarakar in 1922. The plaintiff claimed the defendant was a trespasser, asserting that Gulab Shankar lacked authority to appoint a successor. The defendant contested the suit, arguing, inter alia, that the suit was barred by Section 92 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) and that the defendant’s possession was lawful. The trial court dismissed the plaintiff’s suit, but the appellate court reversed that decision, holding the plaintiff’s appointment valid and the defendant’s possession invalid. The present appeal challenges the appellate court’s ruling.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 92 of the Civil Procedure Code bars the suit claiming possession of the endowed property by a trustee alleging trespass.
  2. Whether Gulab Shankar had the right to appoint the defendant as his successor trustee and manager of the endowed property.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant-Appellant's Arguments

  • The suit was barred by Section 92 of the Civil Procedure Code.
  • Gulab Shankar was competent to appoint the defendant as sarbarakar and trustee.
  • The defendant was rightfully in possession of the endowed property.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • Gulab Shankar had no right to nominate a successor or appoint a trustee of the endowed property.
  • Despite the deed of gift of 1912, Gulab Shankar continued as sarbarakar until his death.
  • After Gulab Shankar’s death, the right to appoint sarbarakar and trustee vested in the heirs of the founder of the trust.
  • The defendant was in unlawful possession and thus a trespasser.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Inayat Husain v. Faiz Mohammad, A.I.R 1923 All. 319 Section 92 CPC does not bar suits where plaintiff claims possession as duly appointed trustee alleging trespass. Supported the court’s conclusion that Section 92 CPC was inapplicable to the present suit.
Mohammad Abdul Majid Khan v. Ahmad Saeed Khan, [1913] 35 All. 459 Same principle as above regarding Section 92 CPC’s inapplicability. Reinforced the view that the suit was not barred under Section 92 CPC.
Puttu Lal v. Daya Nand, A.I.R 1922 All. 499 Section 92 CPC does not apply to suits between individuals claiming right to succeed as trustee. Confirmed that the suit was not within the ambit of Section 92 CPC.
Nilkanta Devrao v. Ram Krishna Vithal Bhat, A.I.R 1923 Bom. 67 Interpretation of Section 92 CPC’s scope in trust administration. Aligned with the court’s reasoning that Section 92 CPC was not applicable here.
Chandra Nath Chakarbarti v. Jadabandra Chakarbarti, [1906] 28 All. 689 Successorship to the office of shebait (trustee) must follow terms of deed or inheritance from founder. Supported the principle that a shebait cannot appoint his own successor absent deed or custom.
Sheo Prasad v. Aya Ram, [1907] 29 All. 663 Same principle on succession to shebait office. Applied to hold that Gulab Shankar had no right to appoint the defendant as successor.
Sheoratan Kunwari v. Ram Pargash, [1896] 18 All. 227 Same principle on succession and appointment of shebait. Used to confirm that succession follows founder’s heirs unless otherwise provided.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined the applicability of Section 92 of the CPC, concluding that it does not bar suits where a plaintiff claims possession as a duly appointed trustee alleging the defendant is a trespasser. The court relied on established precedents to affirm that Section 92 applies only to suits alleging breach of trust for public charitable or religious purposes requiring court administration, which was not the case here.

Next, the court analyzed the nature of the trust and the office of shebait in relation to the endowed property of a temple. It distinguished temples from maths, explaining that the endowed property vests in the presiding deity as a juristic person, with management vested in a trustee or shebait. The court emphasized that succession to the office of shebait depends primarily on the terms of the trust deed. In the absence of any provision or custom, the right to appoint a successor reverts to the heirs of the founder of the trust.

Applying these principles, the court found no provision in the deed allowing Gulab Shankar to appoint a successor. The appointment of the plaintiff by Udho Ram, the heir of the founder Manni Ram, was therefore valid. Consequently, the defendant-appellant had no title to possession and was deemed a trespasser. The court affirmed the appellate court's judgment dismissing the defendant’s claim.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The court dismissed the defendant-appellant's appeal with costs, affirming that the plaintiff was the validly appointed trustee and entitled to possession of the endowed property. The defendant had no lawful title to remain in possession. The decision clarifies that Section 92 of the CPC does not apply to suits between individuals claiming trusteeship rights absent allegations of breach of trust requiring court administration, and that succession to the office of shebait follows the terms of the deed or, in default, the heirs of the founder. No new precedent was set beyond the application of established principles.

    Ganga Charan v. Ram Chandra

    Iqbal Ahmad, J.:— This is a defendants' appeal and arises out of a suit for possession of certain property that was dedicated to a certain deity by one Pandit Manni Ram by a deed of endowment, dated the 10th January 1899. By that deed Manni Ram appointed himself and one Gulab Shankar as sarbarakars of the endowed property. Manni Ram died in or about the year 1900 and Gulab Shankar alone continued to act as sarbarakar of the endowed property.

    2. By a deed styled as a deed of gift dated the 17th December 1912, Gulab Shankar appointed the defendant-appellant as trustee and manager in his place. About three months prior to the institution of the suit giving rise to the present appeal Gulab Shankar died.

    3. Udho Ram, the heir of Manni Ram, on the 15th December 1922, executed a document in favour of the plaintiff by which be appointed the plaintiff as trustee and sarbarakar of the endowed property.

    4. The plaintiff's case was that Gulab Shankar had no right to nominate a successor of his own, or to appoint a trustee of the endowed property, and that, notwithstanding the execution of the deed of gift of 1912, Gulab Shankar continued to act as sarbarakar till the date of his death and that after Gulab Shankar's death the right to appoint a sarbarakar and trustee of the endowed property vested in the heirs of the founder of the trust. The plaintiff maintained that the defendant was in possession of the endowed property as a trespasser and accordingly claimed the relief referred to above.

    5. The suit was contested by the defendant on various grounds, but as only two points have been argued in the present appeal, we need not notice the points other than those argued before us. It was contended by the defendant that the suit was barred by Section 92 of the CPC, and that Gulab Shankar was competent to appoint the defendant as a sarbarakar and trustee and that the defendant-appellant was rightfully in possession of the endowed property.

    6. Both the Courts below overruled the plea based on Section 92 of the CPC. The trial Court accepted the other contention advanced on behalf of the defendant mentioned above and accordingly dismissed the plaintiff's suit. The lower appellate Court came to the conclusion that the defendant Gulab Shankar had no right in preference to the heirs of the founder of the trust to appoint a successor of his own and that the defendant had not been validly appointed and the plaintiff was a duly appointed trustee and was entitled to the relief sought.

    7. In our judgment the decision of the lower appellate Court is perfectly correct and ought to be affirmed. It is well settled that Section 92 of the CPC, has no application to suits where a plaintiff claims possession of the endowed property on the allegation that he is duly appointed trustee and that the defendant is a; trespasser; vide Inayat Husain v. Faiz Mohammad . A.I.R 1923 All. 319 and Mohammad Abdul Majid Khan v. Ahmad Saeed Khan . [1913] 35 All. 459. It has also been decided by this Court in the case of Puttu Lal v. Daya Nand . A.I.R 1922 All. 499 that Section 92 of the CPC does not apply to a suit between persons who individually claim a right to succeed to the office of trustee. In view of these authorities it is impossible to hold that the present suit was a suit of the nature contemplated by Section 92 of the CPC. It is to be noted that S. 92 has reference to those cases and to those cases alone, where there is an allegation of breach of any express or constructive trust created for public purposes of charitable or religious nature, or where the direction of the Court is deemed necessary for the administration of any such trust. In the present case there was no allegation of any breach of the trust nor was it alleged that the direction of the Court was necessary for the administration of the trust and in the absence of any such allegation Section 92 of the CPC, could not apply. The view that we take is in consonance with the view taken in the case of Nilkanta Devrao v. Ram Krishna Vithal Bhat . A.I.R 1923 Bom. 67. We accordingly agree with the Courts below in holding thit S. 92 was not a bar to the suit.

    8. In our judgment there is no substance either in the second point argued by the learned counsel for the appellant. We are in the present case dealing with a temple as distinguished from a math. In the case of a temple the endowed properties are deemed vested in the presiding god treated as a juristic person, the management being vested in a trustee. The manager or trustee of a temple is designated as a shebait.

    The devolution of the office of shebait depends primarily on the terms of the deed by which the trust is created. In the absence of any provision in the deed as to the devolution of the office of shebait the title to the property or to the management and control of the dedicated property, as the case may be, follows the line of inheritance from the founder, in other words, it passes to his heirs unless there has been some usage or course of dealing which points to a different mode of devolution, e.g, devolution on a single heir; vide Mulla's Principles of Hindu Law, 5th edition, page 408 of the cases cited therein.

    9. As already stated in the absence of a provision in the deed prescribing the mode of devolution to the office of shebait and in the absence of a custom to the contrary, the power to appoint a successor to a shebait reverts to the heirs of the founder of the trust and a shebait has no right to appoint a successor to himself, vide the cases of Chandra Nath Chakarbarti v. Jadabandra Chakarbarti . [1906] 28 All. 689, Sheo Prasad v. Aya Ram . [1907] 29 All. 663 and Sheoratan Kunwari v. Ram Pargash . [1896] 18 All. 227. In the present case it has been held by both the Courts below that Udho Ram is the beir of Manni Ram, the founder of the trust. Therefore the appointment of the plaintiff by Udho Ram as a shebait is a valid appointment and the plaintiff has a right to enter into possession of the endowed property as a trustee. The defendant has not a shadow of title to remain in possession and the decree passed against him is perfectly correct. The remaining grounds taken in the memorandum of appeal have not been pressed. Accordingly we dismiss the appeal with costs.

    N.D

    10. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ganga Charan v. Ram Chandra
    (May 25, 1927)