Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 75 of the United Provinces Village Panchayat Act, Act 6
  • provisions of Section 174(4)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 75 of the United Provinces Village Panchayat Act, Act 6
  • provisions of Section 174(4)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by Sheo Dina (also described as Kachhi) who was convicted of murder under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to death by the Sessions Judge of Banda; there was also a reference for confirmation of that sentence. The alleged victim was Mt. Bari Bahu, the accused's mother-in-law. The victim lived at Ajnar; the accused lived at Ari, a village about two miles from Ajnar. On 23 June 1932 the victim and her daughter Mt. Bhaoni travelled from Ari to Ajnar because the daughter was ill. On the night of 23 June, at about 9 p.m., villagers of Khoi took Mt. Bhaoni and the accused out of a well located between the villages; those villagers were told that the persons had accidentally fallen into the well and that the victim had drowned. A report was made to the police (thana) at about 9 p.m. by Ganwa, the chaukidar, stating an accidental drowning and not mentioning the accused.

Because the locality was a panchayat village, a panchayat procedure was followed pursuant to rules under Section 75 of the United Provinces Village Panchayat Act (Act 6 of 1920) (rules of 16 December 1925, Rrs. 34 and 35). The panchayat met next morning; the dead body was recovered from the well and the panchas found seven injuries on the head caused by a hatchet. A report was then made to the thana at about 9 a.m. on 24 June alleging that Sheo Dina had murdered Mt. Bari Bahu. A police inquest was subsequently conducted under Section 174(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code. Mt. Bhaoni's statement was recorded under Section 164 CrPC on 26 June.

Trial evidence included: Mt. Bhaoni's statement that the accused assaulted her mother with a hatchet, inflicted six or seven wounds, threw the deceased into the well and attempted to drown Mt. Bhaoni; corroborating witness evidence about a hatchet found near the well and identification of that hatchet as the accused's; medical evidence (26 June) that the injuries were incised wounds consistent with an axe or similar weapon and not explicable by a single fall; and the testimony of village police personnel (including head constable Uma Shanker) about the well and sequence of events. The Sessions Court convicted the accused under Sections 302 and 307 IPC; the present opinion confirms those convictions and sentences and dismisses the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence established the offence of murder under Section 302, I.P.C., committed by Sheo Dina.
  2. Whether the sentence of death imposed under Section 302, I.P.C., was appropriate and should be confirmed.
  3. Whether the accused was guilty of attempted murder under Section 307, I.P.C., in respect of Mt. Bhaoni and whether the sentence of five years' rigorous imprisonment should be confirmed.

Arguments of the Parties

Defence's Arguments

  • Objection that the initial procedure (panchayat) was not in accordance with Section 174(4) CrPC (learned defence counsel raised this procedural objection).
  • Submission that the injuries to the deceased might have been caused by an accidental fall into the well onto sharp-edged rocks under the water, rather than by an assault with a hatchet.
  • Attempt to point to an ambiguity in Mt. Bhaoni's statement as recorded on 26 June (phrasing such as "those men") and to suggest inconsistency as to whom she told the story and when.

Prosecution's Case / Supporting Evidence

  • Mt. Bhaoni's statement recorded under Section 164 CrPC described a deliberate assault by the accused with a hatchet, throwing the deceased into the well, and an attempt to drown Mt. Bhaoni; this statement was consistent across magistrate and trial proceedings.
  • Corroboration by villagers and police: a hatchet was found near the well and identified as the accused's; a chaukidar (Ram Sahai) testified that the accused left the village on the day with a hatchet.
  • Medical evidence (exam on 26 June) that the head injuries consisted of multiple incised wounds and a fracture, which in the medical opinion could not have been caused all at once by a fall and were consistent with a heavy sharp-edged weapon such as an axe.
  • Evidence about the well (plinth height about two feet) and its likely use for irrigation with a leathern bucket made the defence theory of sharp rocks less plausible.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by examining the admissible evidence and the plausibility of the defence explanations in light of corroborative material:

  1. Procedure: The court addressed the defence objection to the panchayat procedure (rather than immediate police inquest). It found that the procedure complied with the rules of 16 December 1925 (Rules 34 and 35) under Section 75 of the United Provinces Village Panchayat Act (Act 6 of 1920), and therefore the initial panchayat procedure was proper.
  2. Credibility and consistency of the principal witness: Mt. Bhaoni's statement to the magistrate under Section 164 CrPC (26 June) was consistent with her later Court testimony. The court considered minor ambiguities (e.g., the Magistrate's phrasing "those men") and concluded that no contradiction sufficient to impeach the account was established.
  3. Corroboration: Independent witnesses (Ganwa chaukidar, Pula, Tanta, Gaya Prassad sarpanch) and the discovery of a hatchet near the well corroborated parts of Mt. Bhaoni's account. Ram Sahai identified the hatchet as belonging to the accused and testified that the accused had left his village with a hatchet.
  4. Medical evidence: The medical examiner's opinion was that six incised wounds and other injuries were consistent with a heavy sharp-edged weapon (such as an axe) and that all seven injuries could not have been caused simultaneously by a single fall; the doctor rejected the possibility that the pattern of wounds resulted from a fall onto sharp rocks.
  5. Examination of the defence theory: The defence theory that sharp-edged rocks in the well caused the injuries was deemed speculative. The court noted the defence made no attempt to establish the presence of such rocks—by cross-examining prosecution witnesses on the point, calling defence witnesses, or seeking a local inspection—despite the theory being easily provable. The absence of evidence supporting that theory weighed against the defence.
  6. Physical improbability of accidental fall: Evidence about the well's plinth (approximately two feet high) and its use for irrigation (requiring a leathern bucket) made accidental falling onto sharp rocks improbable in the court's view.
  7. On intention and premeditation: The court relied on testimony (Ram Sahai) that the accused left his village about an hour after his wife and mother-in-law with a hatchet in hand. The court concluded this showed deliberation and premeditation, relevant to sentencing.
  8. Attempted murder finding: The court accepted Mt. Bhaoni's consistent Section 164 statement regarding the accused's attempt to drown her, treating it as reliable evidence for conviction under Section 307 IPC.

In sum, the court applied findings on credibility, corroboration, medical opinion, and the absence of defence evidence to reject the defence hypothesis and to uphold the convictions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The convictions and sentences imposed by the Sessions Court were confirmed.

Specific orders and direct consequences:

  • Section 302, I.P.C. (murder): The death sentence imposed on Sheo Dina is confirmed; the court directs that the sentence be carried out according to law.
  • Section 307, I.P.C. (attempt to murder): The conviction and sentence of five years' rigorous imprisonment imposed on Sheo Dina for attempted murder of Mt. Bhaoni are confirmed.
  • The appeal is dismissed.

Broader implications:

The opinion does not articulate any new legal principle or precedent; its consequences are limited to confirmation of conviction and sentence in this case based on the assessment of evidence, medical opinion, corroboration and the absence of defence proof for an alternative theory. No broader precedent is stated to have been established by this decision.

K.S

End of summary. This summary is based exclusively on the contents of the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.

    Sheo Dina v. Emperor Opposite Party.

    1. This is an appeal by Sheo Dina, Kachhi, who has been sentenced to death under S. 302, I.P.C, by the learned Sessions Judge of Banda, and there is also a reference for confirmation of that sentence. The person alleged to have been murdered is Mt. Bari Bahu, the mother-in-law of the accused. She lived at Ajnar where there is a police station and the accused Sheo Dina lives at Ari, a village two miles from Ajnar, with his wife Mt. Bhaoni, daughter of Mt. Bari Bahu. It is common ground that on the 23rd June 1932, Mt. Bari Bahu and her daughter started to go from Ari to Ajnar. The daughter had become ill and had sent for her mother to take her to her mother's house. It is alleged by Mt. Bhaoni that the accused was unwilling to let her go. It is also common ground that on the night of the 23rd of June at 9 p.m, Mt. Bhaoni and Sheo Dina were taken out of a well which is half way between these two villages and is situated in the fields of the village of Khoi. They were taken out by the villagers of Khoi. The representation made to the villagers who took them out was that they had accidentally fallen into the well and it was also stated that Mt. Bari Bahu had fallen in and that she had been drowned. Accordingly at 9 p.m, on that night a report was made at the thana by Ganwa chaukidar, who was the chaukidr both of Ajnar and of Mouza Khoi. His report was in accordance with the information which had been given that Mt. Bari Bahu had been accidentally drowned. In the report he did not make any mention of the accused and his wife having been both taken out of the well and the report indicates that only Mt. Bari Bahu fell into the well and was drowned.

    2. The order given on this report was that as this was a panchayat village the chaukidar was directed to make a report for the completion of a formal panchayatnama. Learned counsel objected to this procedure as not being in accordance with Section 174(4) of the Cr PC, but we have ascertained that the procedure was in accordance with the rules of 16th December 1925, Rr. 34 and 35 of the rules under Section 75 of the United Provinces Village Panchayat Act, Act 6 of 1920.

    3. The procedure, therefore, was perfectly correct. The panchayat took place next morning and the dead body of Mt. Bari Bahu was taken out of the well and the panchas found that there were seven injuries inflicted by a hatchet on the head of the corpse and a report was made in the thana at 9 a.m, on the 24th of June to this effect-stating further that Sheo Dina accused had murdered Mt. Bari Bahu on ac count of her loose character. It also appears that an inquest was held by the police after this under the provisions of Section 174(4) of the Cr PC. This is stated in the evidence of Uma Shanker, head constable, who was then second officer, p. 25, line 41. The statement of Mt. Bhaoni was recorded by a magistrate under Section 164 of the Cr PC, on the 26th of June and the statement which she then made was consistently made by her in the Court of the committing Magistrate and in the Sessions Court. She stated that, her husband overtook her and her mother and suggested that they should have a drink of water at the well in question. Mt. Bhaoni refused saying she was not thristy. The accused then said, “Draw water and give me to drink”. The accused had a hatchet in his hand and he assaulted Mt. Bari Bahu and inflicted six or seven wounds with hatchet. He then threw the deceased into the well, and pushed Mt. Bhaoni into the well also and said. “You also go and the with our mother.” Mt. Bhaoni clung on to the side of the well and her husband got into the well and proceeded to push her down under the water intending to drown her. She said to her husband that there would be no one to look after her small daughter if she had been drowned and her husband then said that he would not kill her if she would swear on the head of her daughter that she would not tell what happened, and say that they had fallen into the well accidentally while drawing water. At this stage people came up and she and her husband shouted out and they were taken out of the well.

    4. Her story has not been taken down very clearly by the Magistrate on 26th June as he records. “1 told those men the whole story of killing my mother”. Learned Counsel for defence has argued that the words “those men” refer to those men who took her out of the well, but she also states in the line below. “Then those persons took both of us to Ajnar police station”. The taking to the police station was on the morning of the 24th of June and the Magistrate has not clearly recorded whether the witness meant to refer to the persons who took her on the morning of the 24th or persons who took her on the evening of the 23rd, when she says that she told, certain person the whole story of killing her mother. We do not think that there is any contradiction established by learned Counsel on this point. The story of Mt. Bhaoni is corroborated in certain details by the evidence of the witnesses Ganwa chaulddar, Pula, Tanta and Gaya Prassad sarpanch who said that next morning there was a hatchet found close to the well, and this hatchet has been identified as the hatchet of accused by Ram Sahai, the chaukidar of the village of the accused. This witness states that the accused left the village with the hatchet in his hand on the day in question. The statement of Mt. Bhaoni was made on the 26th of June under Section 164 of the Cr PC, in which she described the injuries as having been inflicted by a hatchet or axe. The medical examination was made on the same day, 26th June, and the medical examination also confirms the evidence of Mt. Bhaoni, as the medical witness states in his deposition on p. 15 that in his opinion the six incised wounds could have been caused by some blunt and heavy sharp-edged weapon such as an axe. There was also a contusion in the middle of the forehead and a fracture of the right temporal bone. This was under one of the external injuries which was an incised wound. The medical witness was cross-examined with a view to show that the injuries might have been caused “if the well had sharp-edged rocks under the water” and the deceased fell into it. The medical witness stated:

    “All the seven injuries could not be caused all at once by one fall as they are situated in different parts of the head. In my opinion looking at the nature of all the injuries I can say that it; is not possible to have such injuries by a fall. I say so because the injuries are incised wounds.”

    5. It is obvious that although sharp rocks might cause an incised wound, a fall on such a rock would produce not only an incised wound but a contusion, and there are no contusions connected with the six incised wounds mentioned in the medical report. Now the cross-examination of the doctor took place on the 11th of August 1932, in the Court of the committing Magistrate. Therefore on that date the defence had formed the theory that the injuries might have been caused by a fall into the well where there were sharp-edged rocks under water. A necessary part of proving the case for the defence would have been evidence to show that there were sharp-edged rocks in that well under the water. This is a matter which could have been quite easily established either by cross-examination of the prosecution witnesses or by calling witnesses for the defence or by asking for a local inspection by the Court. The defence did not attempt to show the existence of any sharp-edged rocks in this well by any of those methods. Not one single question was asked in cross-examination of any prosecution witnesses as to the existence of sharp-edged rocks, although witnesses gave evidence who stated that the persons had been taken out of the well in their presence and the head constable, Uma Shanker, gave evidence that he made a sketch of the well Ex. 30 and gave a description of the well. The defence called some witnesses but they did not ask any of their witnesses as to whether there were any sharp-edged rocks in this well. It is obvious, therefore, that the defence have entirely failed to prove that there were sharp-edged rocks in that well, and that this part of the defence is a mere theory founded on the imagination of the defence counsel. We cannot accept such a theory which could easily have been supported by evidence for defence, which defence have deliberately failed to produce. As to the story of falling into the well the evidence of Uma Shanker, head constable, is that the plinth of the well is about two feet high. It is, therefore, extremely improbable that people would fall into such a well accidentally. Further, as regards sharp-edged rocks in the well it should be noted that this is, according to Mt. Bhaoni, a well in the fields presumably used for purposes of irrigation. Irrigation in this country is conducted by means of a leathern bucket and it would not be possible to use a leathern bucket in a well in which there were sharp rocks. The medical evidence, therefore, confirms the evidence of Mt. Bhaoni very strongly. It is, therefore, established that the accused and his wife and his mother-in-law were all in a well, that the accused and his wife came out of that well and the accused represented that his mother-in-law had been drowned. Subsequently it was found that his mother-in-law had died from injuries inflicted on her by an axe. There is the evidence of Mt. Bhaoni that the accused caused those injuries to his mother-in-law. The case for the prosecution is in our opinion overwhelming and we hold that the accused was rightly convicted under S. 302, I.P.C

    6. There remains the question of sentence. It is urged that the accused is young man of twenty two years of age. But he is shown to have acted with deliberation because the evidence of the chaukidar of his village, Ram Sahai, shows that an hour after his wife and her mother-in-law left, be started after them with an axe in his hand. He must, therefore, have premeditated this murder. Under these circumstajices we do not consider that we can reduce the sentence. Accordingly, we confirm the sentience of death passed on Sheo Dina and we direct that the sentence be carried out according to law. There is also a charge under S. 307 for the attempted murder of Mt. Bhaoni. The evidence of the attempted murder consists of the statement of Mt. Bhaoni. We see no reason why that statement should not be accepted. She made her statement to the magistrate under Section 164 of the Cr PC without any undue delay on the 26th of June and her statement has been consistently put forward by her before the Committing Magistrate and before the Sessions Court. Accordingly, we also confirm the finding of the lower Court and the conviction and sentence of five years' rigorous imprisonment under S. 307, I.P.C, passed on Sheo Dina, and we dismiss the appeal.

    K.S

    7. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sheo Dina v. Emperor Opposite Party.
    (Feb 27, 1933)