Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion by S.K. Jain, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners sought a writ of mandamus directing the respondents (Union of India, State of Uttar Pradesh and the Superintendent of Police, Ballia) not to arrest or deport them on the ground that they were allegedly citizens of another country. The petitioners are residents (by birth or long residence) of village Baheri, district Ballia. The petition recounts the family relationship among petitioners Nos. 1 to 6, certain episodes of cross-border movement between India and East Pakistan/Bangladesh (including short visits and prolonged residence), voting and tax records for some petitioners, and an incident where local police informed the family on 30-4-1983 that a report had been made against them alleging they should be arrested and deported to Bangladesh.

The respondents filed a counter-affidavit in which they set out factual contentions that various petitioners had lived in or traveled to Pakistan/East Pakistan/Bangladesh at different times, including that petitioner No.1 had entered and left India multiple times on Pakistani passports between the 1950s and 1961 and had served in the railway service in East Pakistan; that petitioner No.2 accompanied parents to Pakistan and married there; and that petitioners Nos.4 and 5 were born in Narainganj (Dhaka) in 1970 and 1973. The petitioners filed a rejoinder denying abandonment of Indian citizenship or acquisition of Pakistani citizenship during the relevant periods.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents could arrest or deport the petitioners on the basis of allegations that they were citizens of another country without first obtaining a decision from the Central Government under Section 9(2) of the Citizenship Act, 1955 read with the Citizenship Rules, 1956 (Rule 30).
  2. Whether the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution is an appropriate forum to determine the factual question of whether particular petitioners are foreigners, or whether such questions must be determined under the statutory scheme (notably Section 9 of the Citizenship Act) by the Central Government.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The petitioners argued that the question whether a person had acquired the citizenship of another country is to be determined by the Central Government under Section 9(2) of the Citizenship Act, 1955 read with the Citizenship Rules, 1956; therefore the respondents could not arrest or deport the petitioners without obtaining a determination under those provisions.
  • The petitioners relied on several precedents (listed below) to support the proposition that the Central Government has the authority to determine acquisition of foreign nationality and that actions of arrest/deportation should await that determination.
  • In a rejoinder, the petitioners (through Nizamuddin) contended that petitioner No.1 did not abandon Indian citizenship and did not acquire Pakistani citizenship during his service period.

Respondents' Case (as set out in the counter-affidavit)

  • The respondents (by affidavit of Sub-Inspector Lallan Prasad Singh) provided a factual narrative asserting that petitioner No.1 had gone to East Pakistan, served there in the railways after 1947, travelled with his family between India and Pakistan on Pakistani passports/visas at various dates in the 1950s and 1960s, and that members of the family had lived in Narainganj (Dhaka), where births and a death had occurred.
  • The respondents alleged that certain petitioners had returned to India illegally and therefore implied they were not entitled to resist arrest/deportation on the ground asserted in the petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P. v. Rahmat Ullah, AIR 1971 SC 1182 (also cited in the text as AIR 1971 SG 1382) That where an individual had a Pakistani passport/visa and the question arose whether he had lost Indian citizenship after the commencement of the Constitution, the Central Government must determine the question under Section 9 of the Citizenship Act. The court summarized the case to show that on its facts the Supreme Court held the Central Government had to determine the question under Section 9; it used this to consider whether the instant matter was analogous.
State of U.P. v. Shah Mohammad and another, AIR 1969 SC 1234 That issues about acquisition of foreign citizenship during the pendency of earlier proceedings should be determined by the Central Government under Section 9 and Rule 30 (the High Court should not remit such issue to lower courts but order determination by the Central Government). The court cited the case to emphasize the proper forum for deciding acquisition of foreign nationality (Central Government under Section 9) and to distinguish factual circumstances in the present case.
Kulathil Mammu v. State of Kerala and others, AIR 1966 SC 1614 That Article 9 (sic: likely meaning Article 7 in context) deals with pre-Constitution voluntary acquisition of foreign nationality, and voluntary acquisition after the Constitution's commencement must be dealt with under the Citizenship Act, 1955. Quoted to support the proposition that post-commencement questions of acquisition of foreign citizenship fall within the Citizenship Act and the Government of India's domain; used to show difference in legal posture from the present facts.
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Peer Mohammad, AIR 1963 SC 645 (i) That loss of Indian citizenship under Section 9(1) by acquiring a Pakistan passport must be decided by the Central Government, not the Court; (ii) Article 7 refers only to migration between 1 March 1947 and 26 January 1950, and migration after 26 January 1950 is to be determined under the Citizenship Act, 1955. The court relied on these principles to frame which petitioners' cases fall within Section 9 and which are to be viewed under constitutional provisions; it used the case to support limitation on Article 7's temporal scope.
Union of India v. Gkaus Mohammad, (1962) 1 SCR 1; AIR 1961 SC 1526 Ratio used to support the proposition that Article 226 proceedings are not appropriate for resolving complex factual disputes about foreign nationality. The court cited this authority to support its view that the question whether certain petitioners were foreigners involved disputed facts that required detailed evidence and were not suitable for disposal in writ proceedings.
Akbar Khan v. Union of India and others, (1962) 1 SCR 779 Held that Section 9(2) does not prevent a Civil Court from determining the question concerning the nationality of a person. The court referred to this case to note that although civil courts can determine nationality in some circumstances, the present factual disputes would require detailed evidence, making Article 226 proceedings unsuitable for most petitioners here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the factual material on record for each petitioner and applying the statutory and constitutional provisions and the authorities cited.

- Petitioner No.1: The court accepted that petitioner No.1 was employed in the Railways from 1943 and was later posted to Maiman Singh (East Pakistan) and continued serving there until retirement in 1977. Except for three short visits to India in 1954, 1958 and 1961, he did not live in India prior to 1977; his wife died in Dhaka in 1970. On these facts the court concluded petitioner No.1 could not be held to have acquired Indian citizenship under Sections 3, 4, 5 or 6 of the Citizenship Act, 1955.

- Petitioner No.2 (Nizamuddin): Documentary records put his birth around 1942–1944. He accompanied his parents to Pakistan and thus his case likewise did not fall within Sections 3–6 of the Act; the court treated his case as not covered by Section 9(2).

- Petitioner No.3 (Smt. Nabuat/ Rahman Bibi): She was married to Nizamuddin between 4-6-1961 and 25-6-1961 and lived in Pakistan thereafter until 1977 when she returned clandestinely with family. The court concluded that the question whether and when she acquired the citizenship of Pakistan is properly a matter to be decided under Section 9(2) of the Citizenship Act, 1955 by the Central Government (and governed by Rule 30 of the Rules).

- Petitioners Nos.4 and 5: Born in 1973 and 1970 respectively at Narainganj (Dhaka) and having returned to India in 1977, the question for them was whether they had acquired Indian citizenship; the court held their cases were not covered by Section 9(2).

- Petitioner No.6 (Km. Naseem): Born in India in 1975 or 1978, the question was whether she had acquired Indian citizenship; her case was likewise not covered by Section 9(2).

The court also addressed the procedural appropriateness of Article 226 writ proceedings for deciding nationality. It observed that determination of whether petitioners Nos.2, 4, 5 and 6 were foreigners involved disputed questions of fact requiring detailed examination of evidence. It relied upon Union of India v. Gkaus Mohammad and Akbar Khan to support the view that Article 226 is not an appropriate proceeding to resolve such contested factual issues in many circumstances. The authorities cited were used to delineate when the Central Government's decision under Section 9 is required and when civil courts might or might not be appropriate forums.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • The writ petition is DISMISSED insofar as it relates to petitioners Nos. 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6.
  • The writ petition is ALLOWED insofar as it relates to petitioner No. 3 (Smt. Nabuat @ Rahman Bibi). A writ of mandamus is issued directing the respondents not to arrest or deport her without having recourse to the provisions referred to in the opinion (Section 9(2) of the Citizenship Act, 1955 and Rule 30 of the Citizenship Rules, 1956).
  • There shall be no order as to costs. The order concludes with the brief statement "Writ party allowed."

Implications: The direct legal consequence is that petitioner No.3 is protected from arrest or deportation until the respondents proceed under the statutory mechanism (Section 9(2) and Rule 30) contemplated for determining acquisition of foreign nationality by the Central Government. For petitioners Nos.1, 2, 4, 5 and 6 the writ relief is denied; the opinion does not itself order deportation or arrest but dismisses the petition as to them. The court did not purport to lay down any novel precedent; rather it applied existing authorities to allocate which cases fell within the Central Government's statutory domain and which raised factual disputes unsuitable for disposal in Article 226 proceedings.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

    Committee Of Management, Shri Chitragupta Inter College, Mainpuri v. District Inspector Of Schools, Mainpuri

    S.K.Jain, J.-

    Through this petition the petitioners have sought writ of mandamus directing the respondents, namely, Union of India, State of Uttar Pradesh and the Superintendent of Police, Ballia not to arrest them or deport them on the vague charges of their being citizens of another country.

    2. The petitioners were born in village Baheri of district Ballia and have been living there since their birth. Petitioner Nos. 2 to 6 belong to one family headed by Nizamuddin, petitioner No. 2. Petitioner No. 3 is the daughter of Majid Mian, resident of village Tapani, P. O. Janaupur, district Ballia. She was married to petitioner No. 2 Nizamuddin. Petitioner Nos. 1 to 3 were voters in the Gram Sabha Baheri in the voter list of 1979 and they had also cast their votes in Assembly elections on several occasions. Petitioner No. 1 had a house in the village and he paid house-tax for the years 1971-1972 to 1977-78. Prior to the partition of the country in the year 1947 petitioner No. 1 was employed in Indian Railways and was serving in East Pakistan, presently known as Bangla Desh. In 1947 he could not cross over to India as he was in illegal confinement of the nationals of Pakistan, although his entire family was in India. He managed to come to India in 1950 and since then he was residing in village Baheri. Petitioner No. 2 never left the country. He was married to petitioner No. 3 and out of their wedlock petitioners Nos. 4 to 6 were born. He was running a watch repairing shop since 1970. The Police Inspector of Kotwali Ballia came to the house of petitioner on the night of 30-4-1983 and informed them that Smt. Alima Bibi had made a report against them and, therefore, they were to be arrested and deported to Bangladesh.

    3. On being served, the respondents filed a reply in the form of counter-affidavit of Sri Lallan Prasad Singh, Sub-Inspector, Local Intelligence Unit, Ballia. The case of respondents is that petitioner No. 1 Akbar Ali @ Babar Ali, son of Khushal was born in 1917 and was a resident of village Baheri, district Ballia. Prior to 1947 he was married to Shariffan Bibi, daughter of Asgar Ali of village Janaupr, district Ballia. He was serving in Indian Railways in 1943. In 1947 he went to East Pakistan (now known as Bangla­desh) and joined the Railway service there. After sometime he came to India and took his wife Smt. Sharifan Bibi and son Nizamuddin, petitioner No. 2 to Pakistan. Petitioner No. 1 along with his wife came to India on a Pakistani Passport on 1-9-1954 and returned back on 16-9-1954. He again came to India on 22-4-58 and returned back on 3-5-1958. He alongwith his wife and son came to India on 4-6-1961 and returned back on 25-6-1961. During this period petitioner No. 2 Nizamuddin was married to Rahman Bibi, petitioner No. 3 and she also accompanied her husband and parents in-law to Pakistan on 25-5-1961. Smt Sharifan Bibi, wife of petitioner No. 1 died at Narainganj, Dhaka in 1970.

    4. In 1947 petitioner No. 1 along with petitioner No. 2 to 6 came to India illegally from Narainganj, Dhaka and started living with Qayum Uddin, son of Abdul Rahman, husband of Smt. Atiman Bibi, daughter of Khushal, at village Baheri.

    5. Petitioner No. 2 Nizamuddin was born out of the wedlock of peti­tioner No. 1 and his wife Smt. Sharifan in 1942 in India. During 1947 he accompanied his parents to Pakistan. He came to India with his parents on 4-6-1961, married Smt. Rahiman Bibi, petitioner No. 3 and returned to Pakistan along with his parents and wife. Petitioners Nos. 4 and 5 (minors) were born at Narainganj, Dhaka (Bangladesh) during 1973 and 1970 res­pectively. Km. Nasim, petitioner No. 6 (minor) was born in India in the year 1975/80. Petitioners Nos. 1 to 5 came to India in 1970 and started living in village Baheri illegally as mentioned earlier.

    6. A rejoinder affidavit was filed by Nizamuddin, wherein it was aver­red that petitioner No. 1 was employed in Railways in 1943 and was posted at Dhanbad (India). Thereafter he was transferred to Maiman Singh (East Pakistan), now Bangladesh. In para 8 of the rejoinder affidavit it is contended that the petitioners did not abandon the citizenship of India and had not acquired the citizenship of Pakistan during the service period of petitioner No. 1.

    7. Learned counsel for the petitioners has relied upon State of U.P. v. Rahmat Ullah, AIR 1971 SG 1382 ; State of U.P. and others v. Shah Mohd. and another, AIR 1969 SC 1234 ; Kulathil Mammu v. State of Kerala and others, AIR 1966 SC 1614 ; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Peer Mohd., AIR 1963 SC 645. He has vehemently argued that the question as to whether, when or how any person had acquired citizenship of another country, the authority to determine such question under Section 9(2) of the Citizenship Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), read with the Citizenship Rules, 1956, (hereinafter referred to as the Rules), was the Central Government, and, therefore, the respondents could neither arrest nor deport the petitioners out of India before getting such question decided under the above provisions of the Act and the Rules by the Central Government.

    8. This argument attractive at first sight is, in our opinion, not tenable on the sound appreciation of the facts and law involved in the present case.

    9. Admittedly petitioner No. 1 was employed in Railways Department in 1943 at Dhanbad, but was later on transferred to Maiman Singh (East Pakistan). He continued serving there till his retirement in the year 1977. At no point of time prior to 1977, except for three short visits, namely, from 1-9-1954 to 16-9-1954, from 22-4-1958 to 1-5-1958 and from 4-6-1961 to 25-6-1961 either of the petitioners lived in India, Smt. Sharifan had died in Narainganj, Dhaka sometime in 1970. Therefore, petitioner No. 1 could not be said to have acquired Indian citizenship under any of the Section 3, 4, 5 or 6 of the Citizenship Act, 1955.

    10. In order to ascertain the age of petitioner No. 2 Nizamuddin, docu­ments placed on the record of this case, have been taken into consideration. On the basis of these documents it can be concluded that he was born some­where in 1942 to 1944. Admittedly he had accompanied his parents to Pakistan as his father, petitioner No. 1 was employed there. His case is also not covered under any of the above provisions.

    11. Petitioner No. 3 Smt. Nabuat (sic) @ Rahman Bibi is the daughter of Majid Mian, resident of village Tapan, district Ballia. Her marriage with Nizamuddin was performed somewhere between 4-6-1961 to 25-6-1961 whereafter she had lived in Pakistan with her husband and stayed there till 1977 when she returned to India clandestinely with her in-laws, husband and children. It is in her case that a question is posed as to whether, when or how she has acquired the citizenship of Pakistan. This question is certainly to be decided under Section 9 (2) of the Citizenship Act, 1955 by the Central Government.

    12. Admittedly petitioners No. 4 and 5 were born in the year 1973 and 1970 respectively at Narainganj, Dhaka, East Parkistan and in their cases the question is as to whether they having returned to India in 1977, had acquired Indian citizenship. Their case is, therefore, not covered under Sec­tion 9 (2) of the Act.

    13. Petitioner No. 6 Km. Naseem (minor) was admittedly born in India in 1975 or 1978. In her case the question is as to whether she had acquired Indian citizenship, and therefore, her case is also not covered under Section 9 (2) of the Act.

    14. A proceeding under Articles 226 of the Constitution of India would not be appropriate for a decision of the question as to whether petitioners Nos. 2, 4, 5 and 6 were foreigners which is a question of fact on which there is a great deal of dispute which would require a detailed examination of evi­dence. In holding this view we are fortified by the ratio laid down in the Union of India v. Gkaus Mohammad, (1962)1 SCR 1 ; AIR 1961 SC 1526, Moreover in Akbar Khan v. Union of India and others, (1962)1 SCR 779, their Lordships of the Supreme Court have been pleased to hold that Section 9(2) does not prevent the Civil Court from determining the question concerning the nationality of a person.

    15. Part II of the Constitution deals with citizenship. It is comprised of Articles 5 to 11. Learned counsel for the petitioners has urged that where the Constitution wanted to limit the scope of the Article by reference to the date of the commencement of the Constitution, it has used appropriate words in that behalf, and in that connection he relies on the use of words 'at the commencement of the Constitution' which occur in Articles 5 and 6. Article 7 does not include such a clause, and so the migration from the territory of India to the territory included in Pakistan to which it refers should not be construed to be limited to migration prior to the commencement of the Constitution. Just as a person who has migrated to Pakistan from India prior to January 26, 1950 shall not be deemed to be a citizen of India by virtue of such migration, so should a person who has migrated from India to Pakistan even after the commencement of the Constitution be denied the right of citizenship. That is the case of petitioners and it is based substantially on the ground that the clause 'at the commencement of the Constitution, is not used by Article 7.

    16. This argument attractive at first sight is, in our opinion, not tenable because it is plainly inconsistent with the material words used in the Article. It will be noticed that a person who shall not be deemed to be a citizen of India is one who has after the first day of March, 1947 migrated from the territory of India to the territory of Pakistan.

    17. In the above factual and legal view or the matter, we feel that the writ petition on behalf of petitioner Nos. 1, 2, 4, 5, and 6 is not competent. However, the case of petitioner No. 3 is covered under Section 9(2) of the Act and Rule 30 of the Rules.

    18. Now on the rulings cited at the Bar on behalf of the petitioners.

    19. In State of Uttar Pradesh v. Rahmat Ullah, AIR 1971 SC 1182, the respondent had entered into India on April 1, 1955 and was in possession of a Pakistani Passport and Visa to which no objection was taken by the Indian authorities. He did not enter India clandestinely and he was not to be tried for having entered India in violation of any law of India. His Visa was admittedly extended by the appropriate authority upto May 22, 1965. He was a citizen of India on the commencement of the Constitution and the ques­tion arose as to whether he had lost the Indian citizenship thereafter. On the facts and circumstances of that case it was held by their Lordships of the Supreme Court that the Central Government had to determine under Section 9 of the Act the question of acquisition of Pakistani nationality by him.

    20. In State of Uttar Pradesh v. Shah Mohammad and another, AIR 1969 SC 1234, the plaintiff who had gone to Pakistan after 26th January, 1950 and before the commencement of the Act had returned to India on a Visa issued by the Indian High Commission, Pakistan. He instituted a suit before the commencement of the Act for declaration that under the circumstances of the case his nationality never changed even though he had gone to Pakistan and that he continued to remain a citizen of India and for a decree of perma­nent injunction restraining the authorities from deporting him. In the High Court in appeal against the decision of the lower appellate court in favour of the plaintiff the Government contended that the Civil Court had no jurisdic­tion to decide the question arising in the suit in view of Section 9 of the Citizenship Act, which had been passed during the pendency of the proceedings read with Rule 30 of the Citizenship Rules, 1956. The High Court rejecting the objection framed the issue on the question whether the plaintiff had or not acquired the citizenship of Pakistan during his stay there and remitted the case to the lower appellate court for a finding on that issue. Under the circumstances it was held by their Lordships of the Supreme Court that the High Court should not have called for a decision on that issue by the lower appellate court, but should have ordered the determination of the question by the Central Government.

    21. In Kulathil Mammu v. State of Kerala and others, AIR 1966 SC 1614, it was held by their Lordships of the Supreme Court that Article 9 does not use the word 'migration' and deals only with voluntary acquisition of citizenship of a foreign State before the Constitution came into force. Cases of voluntary acquisition of foreign citizenship after the commencement of the Constitution have to be dealt with the Government of India under the Citizenship Act, 1955. In this case the ratio laid down in 'AIR 1963 SC 645 has been relied upon.

    22. In State of Madhya Pradesh v. Peer Mohammad, AIR 1963 SC 645, it was held : (i) that the question whether persons lost citizenship of India under Section 9(1) having acquired passport from Pakistan Government has to be decided by the Central Government and not by the Court ; and (ii) that Article 7 of the Constitution of India refers to migration which had taken place between the first day of March, 1947 and January 26, 1950. The question about the citizenship of persons migrating to Pakistan from India after January 26, 1950 will have to be determined under the provisions of the Citizenship Act, 1955.

    23. Thus it is evident that the question involved in the above cases which were cited at the Bar by the learned counsel for the petitioners is alto­gether different than the one involved in the case in hand.

    24. Resultantly this petition, so far as the petitioner Nos. 1, 2, 4 to 6 are concerned, is dismissed, whereas it is allowed with regard to petitioner No. 3. A writ of mandamus is, therefore, issued in her case directing the respondents not to arrest or deport her without having recourse to the above said provisions. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Writ party allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Committee Of Managem... v. District Inspector O...
    (Sep 27, 1994)