Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Constitution (Eighty-first Amendment) Act, 2000 added Article 16 (4B)
  • Section 16-G of the U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921,
  • ARTICLE 16 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 3(7) of the U.P Act
  • Classes) Act, 1994,
  • Section 2(c),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Constitution (Eighty-first Amendment) Act, 2000 added Article 16 (4B)
  • Section 16-G of the U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921,
  • ARTICLE 16 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 3(7) of the U.P Act
  • Classes) Act, 1994,
  • Section 2(c),
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The present special appeal was preferred under Rule 5 Chapter VIII of the Allahabad High Court Rules by the party described in the opinion as “Respondent no. 5-appellant,” who was aggrieved by the order dated 29.6.2009 passed by a Single Judge in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 4380 of 2007.

The core factual matrix is as follows: the writ petitioner (identified in the opinion as respondent no. 5) is a Class-IV employee of Moti Lal Nehru Smarak Inter College, a grant-in-aid institution. On 28.2.2003 a Clerk vacancy arose on retirement. There are three Clerk posts (including Head Clerk), two of which were occupied by General category employees. Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III of the relevant Regulations (made under Section 16-G of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921) provides that 50% of sanctioned posts of Head Clerk and Clerk shall be filled by promotion from Class IV employees.

Because no candidate of the Scheduled Caste (SC) was available for promotion, the District Inspector of Schools relied on a Government Order dated 18.12.1990 and decided to fill the vacancy by direct recruitment from among members of the Scheduled Caste. An advertisement was published, the appellant (a member of the Scheduled Caste) applied and was selected; the selection was pending consideration by the Regional Committee.

The writ petitioner (a non-SC Class IV employee) filed a writ petition (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 69585 of 2005: Vinod Kumar Singh v. District Inspector of Schools), which by order dated 9.11.2006 was disposed of with a direction to consider his claim. The District Inspector rejected his representation by order dated 4.12.2006. The writ petition challenging that decision gave rise to the proceedings before the Single Judge. The Single Judge set aside the order impugned in the writ petition and the appointment of the appellant and directed that the vacant Class III post be filled by promotion from among Class IV employees of the College.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a vacancy of a Class III post (Clerk) that is subject to a promotion quota under Regulation 2(2) (50% by promotion) may be filled by direct recruitment from the Scheduled Caste when no SC candidate is available for promotion, in light of the Government Order dated 18.12.1990 and Section 3(7) of the U.P. Public Services (Reservation...) Act, 1994.
  2. Whether there is a conflict between the Regulation (requiring 50% promotion) and the Government Order (permitting direct recruitment among the reserved category where no reserved candidate is available for promotion), and if so, which provision prevails.
  3. Whether filling the vacancy by appointment of a Scheduled Caste candidate by direct recruitment in the recruitment year would result in impermissible “100% reservation” or otherwise violate Article 16 of the Constitution (as contended with reference to M. Nagaraj and related authorities).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (represented by Mr. Ranjit Asthana)

  • The Government Order dated 18.12.1990 is saved by Section 3(7) of the U.P. Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes/Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994, and thus remains applicable.
  • The Government Order provides that where promotion posts reserved for SC/ST remain unfilled due to unavailability of candidates, those posts shall be filled by direct recruitment from among that reserved category; consequently, the District Inspector's decision to fill the Clerk post by direct recruitment for the Scheduled Caste was lawful and the appellant's selection was valid.

Respondent no. 5's Arguments (represented by Mr. Indra Raj Singh)

  • Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III mandates that 50% of Class III posts be filled by promotion and, if there is a conflict between the Regulation and the Government Order, the Regulation must prevail; hence the post should have been filled by promotion from Class IV employees, not by direct recruitment.
  • Filling the vacancy in the recruitment year by a Scheduled Caste candidate could amount to 100% reservation for that year, which would be impermissible under Article 16 of the Constitution; reliance placed on M. Nagaraj v. Union of India (AIR 2007 SC 71) particularly paragraph 67.
  • He also challenged the appointment/selection process of the appellant, though the selection was then under consideration by the Regional Committee.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M. Nagaraj v. Union of India, AIR 2007 SC 71 Principles concerning reservation and promotional roster operation; paragraph 67 and especially paragraph 68 discussing how roster operation and consideration of entire cadre strength ensure reservation remains within limits (and interaction with earlier cases). The court relied on paragraph 68 of M. Nagaraj to reject the contention that appointment of an SC candidate in the recruitment year would necessarily violate Article 16. The opinion held that use of the roster system permits such an appointment without exceeding reservation limits.
R.K. Sabharwal (1995 AIR SCW 1371) Authority on operation of the roster system for promotions and the need to consider entire cadre strength to determine whether reservation limits have been reached. Cited (via paragraph 68 of M. Nagaraj) to explain that the roster system, when operating for filling cadre strength, ensures reservation remains within the 50% limit and that marking of posts by category governs subsequent vacancies.
Indra Sawhney (reference in the opinion) Principle that reservation in a particular year should not exceed 50% (as applied to initial appointments); used as background in the analysis of reservation limits. Referenced to contrast the rule applicable to initial appointments with the roster operation in promotions; used in the chain of authorities (via M. Nagaraj and R.K. Sabharwal) to conclude the roster operation was permissible in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a structured analysis grounded in the relevant Regulation, the Government Order (18.12.1990) and the statutory saving provision in the U.P. Public Services (Reservation...) Act, 1994.

First, the court acknowledged that Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III requires that 50% of Clerk (Class III) posts be filled by promotion from Class IV employees. It was also accepted that the Government Order addresses the contingency where reserved-category candidates are not available for promotion and prescribes filling such posts by direct recruitment from among the reserved category.

Second, the court observed that the Government Order is saved by Section 3(7) of the U.P. Act (1994), which preserves existing Government Orders providing for reservation in promotion. The court therefore treated the Government Order as continuing to have operative effect unless modified or revoked.

Third, the court considered whether there was any conflict between the Regulation and the Government Order. The court concluded there was no conflict: the Regulation mandates promotion but is silent on the specific contingency where a reserved-category Class IV employee is not available for promotion. The Government Order supplements the Regulation by specifying the course of action in that contingency (direct recruitment among the reserved category). Because the Regulation does not address the unavailability scenario, the Government Order does not supplant the Regulation but supplements it.

Fourth, on the submission that appointment by direct recruitment of an SC candidate in the recruitment year would amount to impermissible excess reservation under Article 16, the court relied on M. Nagaraj and R.K. Sabharwal to explain that when a roster system governs promotions, the reservation remains within the permissible limits — the roster marks posts for categories and those marks apply when vacancies occur. The court held that the roster operation here permitted filling the vacancy by an SC candidate without transgressing Article 16.

Finally, although the court rejected the Single Judge's reasoning that the Government Order had not been produced and therefore could not be relied upon, it refrained from expressing any view on the merits of the appellant's selection because the selection was pending consideration by the Regional Committee.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed and the impugned order dated 29.6.2009 passed by the learned Single Judge is set aside. There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The direction of the Single Judge setting aside the appointment of the appellant and directing that the vacancy be filled by promotion is reversed by this court.
  • The court held that the Government Order dated 18.12.1990 (saved by Section 3(7) of the U.P. Act, 1994) legitimately supplements Regulation 2(2) where reserved-category candidates are not available for promotion; consequently, filling the vacancy by direct recruitment from the Scheduled Caste was lawful in principle.
  • The writ petitioner (respondent no. 5) is not eligible for the promotion in question because the post was reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate; this formed part of the court's reasoning for not entertaining the writ petitioner’s claim to promotion.
  • The court expressly declined to adjudicate upon the correctness of the appellant's selection, since that matter was under consideration by the Regional Committee.
  • No new precedent was laid down; the court resolved the dispute by applying existing regulations, the Government Order, and settled principles from the cited authorities (M. Nagaraj, R.K. Sabharwal and related jurisprudence).

    Mahendra Kumar Gond v. Inspector Of Schools

    Hon'ble C.K Prasad, CJ

    Hon'ble A.P Sahi, J

    Respondent no. 5-appellant, aggrieved by order dated 29.6.2009 passed by a learned Single Judge in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 4380 of 2007, has preferred this special appeal under Rule 5 Chapter VIII of the Allahabad High Court Rules.

    Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts giving rise to the present appeal are that the writ petitioner-respondent no. 5, is a Class-IV employee of Moti Lal Nehru Smarak Inter College (hereinafter referred to as ‘the College’), which receives grant-in-aid. On 28.2.2003, a vacancy of Clerk in the College occurred due to the retirement of the incumbent. There are three posts of Clerks including the post of Head Clerk out of which two are occupied by the members of the General category.

    Regulation 2 of Chapter III of the Regulations made in exercise of the power under Section 16-G of the U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921, inter alia, provides that 50% of the sanctioned posts of Head Clerk and Clerk shall be filled up by promotion from Class IV employees. Undisputedly, respondent no. 5 does not belong to the reserved category. As no candidate of the Scheduled Caste was available, the District Inspector of Schools by order dated 15.4.2005 took a decision to fill up the post by direct recruitment from amongst the members of the Scheduled Caste and in the light of the aforesaid, an advertisement was published in the Newspaper. The appellant, herein, who happens to be a member of the Scheduled Caste, offered his candidature and was selected for the appointment. After the said selection, matter is under consideration of the Regional Committee. Writ Petitioner-respondent no. 5, herein, filed a writ application, inter alia, praying for a direction for his promotion to the post of Clerk. Said writ application was registered as Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 69585 of 2005 (Vinod Kumar Singh v. District Inspector of Schools) and by order dated 9.11.2006, this writ application was disposed of with a direction to consider his claim. In the light of the aforesaid order, the District Inspector of Schools, considered his claim and by order dated 4.12.2006, rejected his representation. He challenged the aforesaid order in the writ application, which has given rise to the present appeal.

    It was contended before the learned Single Judge that in view of Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III of the Regulations, 50% of Class III post is to be filled up by promotion and filling up the said post by direct recruitment in the light of the Government Order dated 18.12.1990 is illegal. The aforesaid submission found favour with the learned Single Judge and the learned Single Judge has held that in view of the aforesaid Regulation, 50% of the posts have to be filled up by promotion and the same cannot be filled up by direct recruitment. The observation of the learned Single Judge in this connection reads as follows:-

    “It is not in dispute that the third vacant Class III post was required to be filled up by promotion in accordance with Regulation 2(2) contained in Chapter III of the Act. What is, however, contended by the respondents is that this vacant post should be filled up by a Scheduled Caste candidate and since no Scheduled Caste candidate was available, the said post was required to be filled by direct recruitment. Regulation 2(2) contained in Chapter III of the Act clearly provides that 50% of the Class III posts have to be filled up by promotion and indeed even the respondents do not dispute this position. The Government Order dated 18th December, 1990 which has been referred in the impugned order has not been filed either by the State or by the contesting respondents and nor was it produced before the Court at the time of hearing of the petition. Even otherwise, it is not possible to accept the contention advanced by respondents as under the relevant Regulation 2(2) contained in Chapter III of the Act at least one post has necessarily to be filled up by promotion and if this is not done, the said provision would be rendered futile.”

    As would be evident from the aforesaid passage of the judgment of the learned Single Judge, the Government Order dated 18.12.1990 was not produced before him. Accordingly, the learned Single Judge set aside the order impugned in the writ application as also the appointment of the appellant herein. The learned Single Judge further directed the Committee of Management to fill up the vacant Class III post by promotion from amongst the Class IV employees working in the College.

    Before we enter into the merit of the case, it is expedient to consider the reservation policy of the State Government in regard to promotion. It is relevant here to state that the U.P Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes/Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994, provides for reservation in the public services and the post, and by virtue of its definition under Section 2(c), it applies to educational institutions owned and controlled by the State Government or which receive grant-in-aid. Section 3 thereof provides for reservation at the stage of direct recruitment and sub-section (7) thereof makes applicable such prevalent Government Orders that provide for reservation against posts to be filled up by promotion. In view of the aforesaid provisions, all Government Orders providing for reservation in promotion continue to be applicable till they are modified or revoked.

    It is relevant here to state that the Government Order dated 18.12.1990 considered the issue of filling up such vacancies reserved for the members of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe, which remain unfilled due to their unavailability. The aforesaid Government Order, inter alia, provides that against such posts where appointment is to be made by promotion, and for which reservation is provided, if the candidates of the reserved category are not available, same shall be filled up by direct recruitment from amongst the members of the said category. In the light thereof, the District Inspector of Schools had taken a decision to fill up the vacancy of the Clerk by direct recruitment reserved for the member of the Scheduled Caste and in fact, an advertisement to that effect was issued and in response thereof, the appellant herein had offered his candidature. Writ petitioner-respondent no. 5, neither challenged the said decision of the District Inspector of Schools nor the advertisement nor for that matter the selection of the appellant herein. It is only when the matter of his appointment was before the Regional Committee, he chose to file the writ application.

    While assailing the judgment of the learned Single Judge, Mr. Ranjit Asthana, appearing on behalf of the appellant, submits that in view of the Government Order, which is saved by Section 3(7) of the U.P Act No. 4 of 1994, all the Government Orders regarding promotion shall continue to be applicable. He submits that the Government Order dated 18.12.1990 clearly provides that when a candidate of the reserved category is not available for promotion, such post shall be filled up by direct recruitment from amongst the members of the said category. He submits that in the light thereof, the decision was taken to fill up the post of Clerk by direct recruitment from amongst the members of the Scheduled Caste and the appellant was duly selected for appointment.

    Mr. Indra Raj Singh, however, appearing on behalf of respondent no. 5, submits that in view of Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III of the Regulations referred to above, the post has to be filled up by promotion from amongst the Class IV employees. He submits that in case of conflict between the Regulation and the Government Order, Regulation will prevail and as such the post of Clerk falling vacant on retirement of the incumbent is to be filled up by promotion and not by direct recruitment.

    Having appreciated the rival submissions, we find substance in the submission of Mr. Asthana. Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III of the Regulations provides for filling up 50% of the post of Clerk by promotion. It is not in dispute that the Government Order provides for reservation in promotion and in the light thereof, the post which had fallen vacant, is to be filled up by the member of the Scheduled Caste category. Undisputedly, the writ petitioner, who claims promotion to Class III post does not belong to the Scheduled Caste category. In view of the aforesaid, the post of Clerk has to be filled up by promotion from amongst the members of the Scheduled Caste category. Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III of the Regulations provides for promotion to a Class III post of such Class IV employees, who are eligible. Undisputedly, the post of Clerk was to be filled up by way of promotion of a Scheduled Caste employee and the writ petitioner being not its member, was not eligible to be considered for such promotion. True it is that in case of conflict between the provisions of Regulation and the Government Order, the former will prevail. However, in the present case, we do not find any conflict between the Regulation and the Government Order providing for filling up the post by direct recruitment due to non-availability of the candidate of the reserved category for promotion. Regulation 2(2) of Chapter III of the Regulations does provide for promotion of Class IV employees and the Government Order provides for reservation in promotion. The Regulation is silent as to what would happen, if a Class IV employee of the reserved category is not available for promotion and then how it is to be filled up. This is supplemented by the Government Order dated 18.2.1990, and hence it cannot be said that the Government Order had supplanted the Regulation, and shall not hold the field.

    While defending the impugned order, Mr. Indra Raj Singh, further submits that one post had fallen vacant in the recruitment year and in case it is filled up by a member of the Scheduled Caste, it shall tantamount to 100% reservation, which is not permissible under Article 16 of the Constitution of India. In support of the submission, reliance has been placed on a judgment of the Apex Court in the case of M. Nagaraj v. Union of India, reported in AIR 2007 SC 71, and our attention has been drawn to paragraph 67 of the judgment.

    We do not find any substance in the submission of Mr. Singh and the decision relied on, instead of supporting his contention, goes against him. Here, in matter of promotion roster is followed and undisputedly, two posts having been occupied by the members of General category, it was to be filled up by a member of the Scheduled Caste category. This is permissible in view of the judgment of M. Nagaraj (supra) relied on by Mr. Singh itself. Paragraph 68 of the judgment, which is relevant, reads as follows:-

    “68. However, in R.K Sabharwal (1995 AIR SCW 1371) which was a case of promotion and the issue in this case was operation of roster system, the Court stated that entire cadre strength should be taken into account to determine whether reservation up to the required limit has been reached. With regard to ruling in Indra Sawhney case that reservation in a year should not go beyond 50% the Court held that it applied to initial appointments. The operation of a roster, for filling the cadre strength, by itself ensures that the reservation remains within the 50% limit. In substance the court said that presuming that 100% of the vacancies have been filled, each post gets marked for the particular category of candidate to be appointed against it and any subsequent vacancy has to be filled by that category candidate. The Court was concerned with the possibility that reservation in entire cadre may exceed 50% limit if every year half of the seats are reserved. The Constitution (Eighty-first Amendment) Act, 2000 added Article 16 (4B) which in substance gives legislative assent to the judgement in R.K Sabharwal.”

    Therefore, we do not find any substance in the submission of Mr. Singh.

    Mr. Singh, lastly attempted to assail the appointment of the appellant. As the selection of the appellant is under consideration of the Regional Committee, we do not want to express any opinion in this regard. However, we hasten to add that the writ petitioner-respondent no. 5, is not a member of the Scheduled Caste category and, therefore, is not eligible to be promoted to the post, which has been reserved for the Scheduled Caste category. This is an additional reason why we are not inclined to entertain the said submission.

    In the result, the appeal is allowed, the impugned order dated 29.6.2009 passed by the learned Single Judge is set aside. However, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mahendra Kumar Gond v. Inspector Of Schools
    (Aug 6, 2009)