Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order V, Rule 17
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order V, Rule 17
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a second appeal against the judgment and decree dated August 26, 1966, passed by Sri Madan Lal Gupta, III Additional Civil Judge, Agra, which allowed the appeal of the respondents after setting aside the decree of the trial Court.

The defendant respondent had obtained an ex parte decree from the Judge, Small Causes, Agra in Suit No. 959 of 1962 for recovery of arrears of rent. The decree was executed resulting in the arrest of the plaintiff appellant.

The plaintiff appellant then filed a suit alleging that he was never a tenant of the defendant respondent and that the decree obtained was vitiated by fraud, specifically claiming collusive and fictitious service of summons. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the decree was void and ineffective against him.

The defendant respondent contested the suit denying fraud and pleaded that the decree was res judicata between the parties.

The trial Court, after hearing evidence, found that the service of summons was fictitious and collusive and that the decree was obtained by fraud, and accordingly decreed the plaintiff's suit and granted an injunction.

The defendant respondent appealed, and the lower appellate court reversed the trial court's decree and dismissed the plaintiff's suit.

The plaintiff appellant then filed the present second appeal challenging the appellate court's decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decree obtained by the defendant respondent in Suit No. 959 of 1962 was obtained by fraud and collusive service of summons on the plaintiff appellant.
  2. Whether non-service or fictitious service of summons can vitiate the decree and render it void and ineffective against the plaintiff appellant.
  3. Whether the principle of res judicata applies to the decree obtained by the defendant respondent.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff Appellant's Arguments

  • The plaintiff appellant was never a tenant of the defendant respondent.
  • The decree was obtained by fraud through collusive and fictitious service of summons.
  • No process server ever personally served the summons on the plaintiff appellant.
  • The summons were not served in accordance with the legal requirements under Order V, Rule 17, as the process server did not affix the summons on the premises after refusal to accept it.
  • The plaintiff appellant denied receiving any summons or notices in the case.

Defendant Respondent's Arguments

  • Repudiated allegations of fraud in obtaining the decree.
  • Asserted that the decree obtained in Suit No. 959 of 1962 stands as res judicata between the parties.
  • Claimed that the plaintiff appellant was duly served with summons, supported by a report of service by the process server.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the evidence concerning service of summons. The plaintiff appellant testified that no process server ever came to serve him in Suit No. 959 of 1962. The defendant respondent relied on a report by the process server stating that the plaintiff appellant met him and took the summons but refused to sign the acknowledgment.

The court held that such a report does not amount to valid service in law because, under Order V, Rule 17, if the summons is refused to be accepted or acknowledged, the process server must affix a copy of the summons on the outer door or some conspicuous part of the plaintiff’s residence or place of business, which was not done here.

The defendant respondent failed to produce the process server or the witnesses who allegedly saw the service, thereby failing to discharge the burden of proof. The plaintiff appellant’s denial of service was credible and supported by the absence of affirmative evidence from the defendant respondent.

The lower appellate court agreed that the plaintiff was not duly served but held that mere non-service does not constitute fraud. The court disagreed with this view, stating that non-service in these circumstances must be presumed to have been effected by fraud and deception.

Accordingly, the court found the appellate court’s view perverse and set it aside, restoring the trial court’s decree.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The decree of the lower appellate court is set aside and the decree of the trial court is restored with costs throughout.

This decision directly affects the parties by reinstating the trial court’s finding that the decree obtained by the defendant respondent was procured by fraud through collusive and fictitious service and is therefore void against the plaintiff appellant. No new precedent beyond the facts of the case was established.

    Mohan Dhobi v. Smt. Kastoori Devi

    Chandra Prakash, J.:— This is a second appeal against the judgment and decree dated August 26, 1966 passed by Sri Madan Lal Gupta, III Additional Civil Judge, Agra allowing the appeal of the respondents after setting aside the decree of the trial Court.

    2. The defence respondent obtained an ex parte decree from Judge, Small Causes, Agra in suit No. 959 of 1962 for the recovery of some money as arrears of rent.

    3. He put that decree into execution and the plaintiff appellant was arrested.

    4. Thereafter the plaintiff filed suit giving rise to this appeal on the allegations that the plaintiff appellant was never a tenant of the defendant respondent and the decree obtained by the defendant respondent was vitiated by fraud. Collusive and fictitious service was obtained against the plaintiff appellant on the summons of that case. On these allegations plaintiff wants a declaration that the aforesaid decree was void and ineffective against the plaintiff appellant.

    5. The suit was resisted by the defendant respondent by repudiating fraud. It was also pleaded that the decree obtained by the defendant respondent in the court of Judge, Small Causes, Agra stood as res judicata between the parties.

    6. The trial Court after taking evidence of parties came to the conclusion that fictitious and collusive service was made against the plaintiff appellant in S.C.C Suit No. 959 of 1962 and the decree was obtained against plaintiff after practising fraud. On the above findings the trial court decreed the plaintiff's suit and granted the injunction prayed.

    7. Against the above decree the respondent filed appeal in the court below and the court below after hearing the parties reversed the decree of the trial court and dismissed the plaintiff's suit.

    8. Feeling aggrieved the plaintiff has come up in second appeal.

    9. I have heard learned counsel for the appellant alone as the respondent has not been represented in this court. After going through the record of the case I have come to the conclusion that the view taken by the court below is perverse and cannot be allowed to stand. The oral evidence produced by the parties consisted of the parties themselves. Mohan plaintiff appeared in the witness box and stated that no process server ever came to him and he was not served in the case No. 959 of 1962 at all. On the other hand Smt. Kastoori Devi respondent stated that the plaintiff appellant was duly served in the case. The paper Exh. 1 is the copy of the report of the summons alleged to have been served on the plaintiff appellant in S.C.C suit No. 959 of 1962. According to this report the process server reported that Mohan Lal appellant met him and the latter took up the summons and copy of the plaint but refused to sign the counter part of the summons. The above report is no service in law. Either the appellant had to be served personally or if the appellant refused to sign the acknowledgment then under Order V, Rule 17 the proper course on the part of the process server was to affix a copy of the summons on the outer door or on some conspicuous part of the house in which the plaintiff appellant originally resided or carried on business. This was not done. As a matter of fact as a prudent man the process server should not have parted with the summons and notices before obtaining signatures of the plaintiff appellant on the counter part.

    10. The plaintiff appellant is alleged to have been served by the process server Sumer Singh in the presence of two witnesses namely Qazi Iqbal Ahmad and Narain. The defendant respondent did not produce either Sumer Singh or Qazi Iqbal Ahmad or Narain. The plaintiff appellant had to give evidence of a negative character. If in fact he had not been served with any summons in Suit No. 959 of 1962 he could do no better than to state on oath that he never received any summons and notices in the case and nobody came to serve summons and notices on him and it was for the defendant respondent to prove by positive affirmative evidence by producing the process server and the witnesses to show that in fact the plaintiff appellant refused to accept the summons and notices. When the plaintiff appellant was denying the service of the summons the burden of proof lay on the defendant respondent decreeholder to establish by cogent evidence that plaintiff appellant was duly served. This was not done in this case. Even lower appellate court has not disagreed with the finding of the trial court that the plaintiff appellant was not duly served. But it has held that merely non service does not amount to fraud or deception. The view does not seem to be correct. When the plaintiff appellant was not served in that case at all it will have to be presumed that service was got effected on the plaintiff appellant by practising fraud and deception on him. The view taken by the court below cannot be allowed to a stand and must be set aside.

    11. For the reasons given above the appeal is allowed, the decree of the lower appellate court is set aside and the decree of the trial court is restored with costs throughout.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohan Dhobi v. Smt. Kastoori Devi
    (Aug 19, 1975)