AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • 25, 1974.3. Section 16-F of the U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Institution sub-section (3) of Section 16-F
  • sub-section (3) of Section 16-F
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • 25, 1974.3. Section 16-F of the U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Institution sub-section (3) of Section 16-F
  • sub-section (3) of Section 16-F
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — K.N. Singh, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed initially in the C.T. Grade and later promoted to the L.T. Grade at Patel Memorial Intermediate College, Atraulia, Azamgarh, an institution aided and recognised by the Board of High School and Intermediate Education. In 1973 a vacancy arose for Lecturer in Economics. The Managing Committee filled the vacancy by promotion and forwarded names in order of preference to the District Inspector of Schools (DIS). The Committee placed Surya Narain Dhar Dwivedi at serial No. 1 and the petitioner at serial No. 2.

The DIS by order dated 25 January 1974 held that Surya Narain Dwivedi did not fulfil the requisite qualifications and accorded approval to the petitioner's appointment. The Committee then appointed the petitioner and he began functioning as lecturer.

Aggrieved, Surya Narain Dwivedi and another candidate made representations to the Regional Deputy Director of Education (Deputy Director). The Deputy Director, after obtaining the DIS report, by order dated 20 July 1974 directed the DIS to review and recall his approval and instructed the Managing Committee to hold a fresh selection. Pursuant to that direction, the DIS wrote on 16 January 1975 setting aside his earlier order and directing fresh selection; he later wrote on 3 May 1975 about compliance with salary paid to the petitioner.

The Managing Committee did not act further, the petitioner challenged the orders of the Deputy Director and the DIS by filing the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Regional Deputy Director of Education had jurisdiction to set aside the District Inspector of Schools' approval of the petitioner's promotion in the absence of a representation by the Managing Committee as contemplated by sub‑section (3) of Section 16‑F of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921.
  2. Whether the District Inspector of Schools had power under the Act or Regulations to review or recall his own order granting approval to the petitioner's appointment, in the absence of statutory authority or fraud/misrepresentation.
  3. Whether the DIS lawfully exercised independent judgment when recalling his approval, or whether he acted mechanically because of the Deputy Director's direction.
  4. Whether the setting aside of the DIS's approval without hearing the petitioner violated the principles of natural justice and thereby vitiated the impugned orders.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the Deputy Director of Education lacked jurisdiction to direct the recall of the DIS's approval because the Managing Committee had not preferred any representation against the DIS's order dated 25 January 1974, as required by sub‑section (3) of Section 16‑F of the Act.

The opinion does not present a detailed, separate account of the respondents' legal submissions within the text.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds from the statutory scheme in Section 16‑F of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921, which requires that appointments be made only of persons with prescribed qualifications and who are recommended by the Selection Committee, with approval by the District Inspector of Schools in the case of teachers. Sub‑section (3) creates a right of representation by the Managing Committee against disapproval by the DIS; for teachers the representation lies to the Regional Deputy Director and his decision is final. Sub‑section (4) allows the Selection Committee or Managing Committee, where representation is rejected, to recommend another name.

Applying those provisions to the facts, the court found:

  • The Managing Committee followed the prescribed selection procedure and presented its recommendation in order of preference. It placed Surya Narain Dwivedi at serial No. 1 and the petitioner at serial No. 2.
  • The DIS examined the matter and, finding Dwivedi unqualified (he had not completed the five years' service required by the Regulations), approved the petitioner's appointment by order dated 25 January 1974. The Managing Committee did not make any representation against that disapproval but proceeded to appoint the petitioner and continued to be satisfied with his work.
  • Because the Managing Committee did not make any representation as envisaged by sub‑section (3) of Section 16‑F, the Deputy Director of Education had no authority under the Act to set aside the DIS's approval or to issue directions to recall it. While the Deputy Director is a higher administrative authority and may issue administrative directions to a subordinate, that administrative superintendence does not authorize the Deputy Director to overturn a statutory approval process in the absence of the specific representation procedure provided by the Act.
  • Regarding the DIS's later action to review and recall his own order, the court observed that neither the Act nor the Regulations confer on the DIS a power to review or recall an approval once given, except under the general law permitting review where an order was obtained by fraud or misrepresentation. Because there was no allegation or finding of fraud or misrepresentation, and because all relevant facts had been placed before the DIS when he decided on 25 January 1974, the DIS had no jurisdiction to review his order on any other basis.
  • Even if the DIS had possessed some power to review, the court found that he did not exercise independent judgment: the DIS's counter‑affidavit did not show any valid ground for recalling the approval, and it was conceded that the DIS recalled his order only because the Deputy Director had directed him to do so. Thus the DIS acted mechanically, without applying his own mind.
  • Further, when the DIS set aside the approval after the petitioner had been appointed and had begun functioning as lecturer, the petitioner had acquired a right to hold the post. The DIS did not afford the petitioner an opportunity to be heard before setting aside the approval. The court held that this omission violated the principles of natural justice and vitiated the impugned orders.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed and the impugned orders are quashed. Specifically, the court quashed the order of the Regional Deputy Director of Education dated 20 July 1974 and the orders of the District Inspector of Schools dated 16 January 1975 and 3 May 1975.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The court's decision restores the effect of the DIS's original approval of 25 January 1974 by quashing the orders that purported to set it aside (the opinion does not state additional relief beyond quashing those impugned orders).
  • The petitioner is awarded his costs.

Broader implications: The opinion applied existing statutory interpretation and general principles of administrative law (limits of subordinate review, requirement of statutory procedure for representation, the narrow scope for review absent fraud, the duty to exercise independent judgment, and the requirements of natural justice). The court did not state that it was laying down a novel precedent beyond application of these principles to the facts; no new statutory construction beyond the immediate statutory provisions was announced in broader terms.

    Rajendra Tripathi v. Deputy Director Of Education, Gorakhpur And Others

    K.N Singh, J.:— The petitioner was appointed as teacher in the C.T Grade in the Patel Memorial Intermediate College, Atraulia, Azamgarh an institution aided and recognised by the Board of High School and Intermediate Education. He was later on promoted to the L.T Grade. In 1973, there was a vacancy in the higher grade of lecturer in the subject of economics. The petitioner as well as certain other teachers applied for the same. The Committee of Management decided to fill up this vacancy by promotion. After selection the name of Surya Narain Dhar Dwivedi, another teacher of the College and the petitioners name was forwarded to the District Inspector of Schools for his approval. The recommendation was made in the order of preference. The District Inspector of Schools by his order dated January 25, 1974 held that Surya Narain Dhar Dwivedi was not entitled to promotion as he did not fulfil the requisite qualifications laid down in the Regulations, he accorded approval to the petitioners appointment. The Committee of Management thereafter appointed the petitioner and he commenced functioning as lecturer. Thereupon Surya Narain Dhar Dwivedi and one Shyam Narain Singh, another teacher who was a candidate for promotion to the lecturers grade made representation before the Regional Deputy Director of Education. After obtaining report from the District Inspector of Schools, the Deputy Director of Education by his order dated July 20, 1974 directed the District Inspector of School to review and recall his order granting approval to the petitioners promotion in the lecturers grade and issued directions to the Managing Committee to hold fresh selection. In pursuance of the direction issued by the Deputy Director of Education, the District Inspector of Schools by his letter dated January 16, 1975 informed the Managing Committee that the order dated January 25, 1974 granting approval for the petitioner's promotion to the lecturer's grade is set aside and the Managing Committee is directed to hold fresh selection. It appears that since the Managing Committee was satisfied with the petitioner's work it did not take any action in the matter. The District Inspector of Schools thereupon addressed another letter to the Managing Committee on May 3, 1975 directing it to comply with his salary already paid to the petitioner in the lecturer's grade. Aggrieved the petitioner filed this petition challenging the validity of the orders of the Deputy Director of Education as well as that of the District Inspector of Schools.

    2. Learned counsel for the petitioner urged that the Deputy Director of Education has no jurisdiction to issue directions to the District Inspector of Schools for recalling his orders granting approval to the petitioner's promotion to the lecturer's grade, as no appeal had been preferred by the Managing Committee against the orders of the District Inspector of Schools dated January 25, 1974.

    3. Section 16-F of the U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) lays down that no person shall be appointed as a Principal, Headmaster or teacher in a recognised institution unless he possesses the prescribed qualifications and he is recommended by the Selection Committee constituted under the Act and his appointment is approved by the District Inspector of Schools in the case of a teacher and the Deputy Director of Education in the case of Headmaster and Principal of the Institution sub-section (3) of Section 16-F provides that where the Regional Deputy Director of Education or the District Inspector of Schools as the case may be disapproved any name proposed by the management for appointment as Principal, Headmaster or teacher, the management may within three weeks of the receipt of the disapproval make a representation against it to the Director, in the case of disapproval being given by the Deputy Director of Education, but in the case of teacher the representation may be made before the Regional Deputy Director of Education and his decision is final in the matter. Sub-section (4) further provides that if the recommendations made by the Selection Committee or the Managing Committee is disapproved and the representation of the management is rejected either by the Deputy Director or Director of Education, the Selection Committee or the Managing Committee may proceed to recommend another name for approval as provided under Section 16-F of the Act.

    4. There is no dispute that selection for appointment to the post of Lecturer in Economics was made by the Managing Committee in accordance with the provisions contained in the Act and the Regulations framed thereunder and all the requisite procedure was followed. There is further no dispute that the Committee of Management made its recommendation to the District Inspector of Schools in order of preference. It placed Surya Narain Dhar Dwivedi a teacher of the College at serial No. 1 while the petitioner's name was placed at serial No. 2. There is further no dispute that Surya Narain Dhar Dwivedi who was recommended at serial No. 1 was not qualified for promotion to the lecturer's post as he had not completed 5 years of service as required by the Regulations. The District Inspector of Schools accorded approval to the petitioner's appointment. Admittedly the Committee of Management was satisfied with the order of the District Inspector of Schools as it did not prefer any representation against the disapproval of its proposal in respect of Surya Narain Dhar Dwivedi, instead the Committee of Management appointed the petitioner as lecturer in Economic and it appears to be fully satisfied with his work. In the absence of any representation as contemplated by sub-section (3) of Section 16-F of the Act, the Deputy Director of Education had no authority or jurisdiction to set aside the order of District Inspector of Schools. The Act and the Regulations framed thereunder do not contain any provision conferring any right of representation to a rival candidate to challenge the order of the District Inspector of Schools granting approval. While granting approval or disapproval the Deputy Director of Education as well as the District Inspector of Schools exercised statutory functions in accordance with the provisions conferred in the Act and Regulation. They are not entitled to exercise any power which is not conferred on them by the statutory provisions in matters relating to the grant of approval. The Deputy Director of Education is a higher authority and in administrative matters he is entitled to issue directions to the District Inspector of Schools who is a subordinate authority, but in matter relating to grant of approval the Deputy Director of Education has jurisdiction to issue direction or set aside the order of approval only when a representation as contemplated by sub-section (3) of Section 16-F is made before him. In the absence of any representation of the Managing Committee the Deputy Director has no jurisdiction to set aside the order of the District Inspector of Schools granting approval or to issue directions to him to review or recall his order.

    5. It is urged that the District Inspector of Schools has no jurisdiction to review or recall any order granting approval for the appointment of a teacher. The Act and the Regulations do not confer power on the District Inspector of Schools to review or recall his order suo motu or on the application made by any aggrieved party. In the absence of any statutory provisions, once the District Inspector of Schools accords approval or disapproves the proposed appointment of a teacher, he is not empowered to review his order, but there is exception to this rule well recognised by the general law of review. It is well settled principal that a public authority while exercising statutory powers is entitled to review its orders if it is satisfied that the order was obtained by fraud or misrepresentation. If an order is obtained by practising fraud or misrepresentation, the order is nullity and as such the authority concerned is empowered to review its order and pass a fresh order. But in a case where the order is not obtained by fraud or misrepresentation the statutory authority has no jurisdiction to review its order unless provision to that effect is contained in the Act or the Rules. In the instant case there is no statutory provision either under the Act or under the Regulations conferring power on the District Inspector of Schools to review his order granting approval. There is further no dispute that the order of approval was not obtained by fraud or misrepresentation. All the necessary papers and facts were placed by the Managing Committee before the District Inspector of Schools and he passed the order on merits. The District Inspector of Schools had no jurisdiction to review his order.

    6. But assuming that the District Inspector of Schools could review his order dated January 25, 1974 granting approval to the petitioner's appointment as lecturer, he could not do so, on the mere direction of the Deputy Director of Education without applying his own mind. The counter affidavit filed on behalf of the District Inspector of Schools does not show that there was any valid ground or reason for recalling his order granting approval to the petitioner's appointment. On the other hand it is conceded that since the Deputy Director of Education directed him to withdraw his order, he complied with that direction by recalling his order dated January 25, 1974 granting approval to the petitioner's appointment and issued direction to the Managing Committee for holding fresh selection. It is thus clear that the District Inspector of Schools failed to exercise his own discretion, instead he acted in a mechanical manner to give effect to the order of the Deputy Director of Education.

    7. There is yet another infirmity in the impugned order of the District Inspector of Schools.’ Admittedly the petitioner was appointed and he had been working on the post of lecturer after approval was accorded by the District Inspector of Schools. He thus acquired a right to hold the post of teacher in the lecturer's grade. But he was not heard or given any opportunity by the District Inspector of Schools before setting aside the order of approval. The impugned orders were passed in violation of the principles of natural justice. The order of the District Inspector of Schools is vitiated on this ground also.

    8. In the result I allow the petition and quash the impugned orders of the Deputy Director of Education dated July 20, 1975 and the two orders of the District Inspector of Schools dated January 16, 1975 and May 3, 1975. The petitioner is entitled to his costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajendra Tripathi v. Deputy Director Of Education, Gorakhpur And Others
    (Apr 12, 1976)