AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Ministerial Manual Establishment Rule 154(a)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Ministerial Manual Establishment Rule 154(a)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — P.K.S. Baghel, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Union of India, through the Ministry of Communication, Department of Post, filed a writ petition challenging the judgment and order dated 28 July 2009 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (Allahabad Bench) in Original Application No. 1626 of 2005 filed by respondent no. 1, Shyam Lal Shukla.

Relevant facts as stated in the opinion:

  • Respondent no. 1 (Shyam Lal Shukla) was engaged as a contingency paid Chowkidar at Sahson Sub Post Office, district Allahabad in 1982. The initial engagement document dated 10.4.1982 (issued under Rule 267 of the Posts & Telegraph Financial Handbook) is on record as Annexure-1 to his Original Application.
  • By a communication dated 2.1.1992 (Annexure-2), respondent no. 1 was treated as a “full time C.P Employee of Postal Department” and was conferred temporary status with effect from 29.11.1989; in compliance of a Director's letter dated 12.4.1991 he was extended benefits akin to regular employees (DA, ADA, leave, maternity leave, HRA, bonus, medical facility, insurance scheme and GPF).
  • The Department of Posts formulated a "Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status in Regularization) Scheme" (communication dated 12.4.1991) in compliance with a Supreme Court order arising from Writ Petition No. 1276 of 1986. The Scheme was put into operation from 1/10/1989 and specified, inter alia, conferment of temporary status and benefits and contained paragraph 17 which precluded recruitment from the open market for Group D posts so long as casual labourers with requisite qualifications were available.
  • Respondent no. 1 reached superannuation on 30 June 2003. He made representations seeking pensionary benefits which elicited no response; consequently he filed Original Application before the Tribunal seeking directions to grant pension, commutation, gratuity, encashment of unavailed leave, medical facilities, and payment of arrears with interest.
  • The Tribunal allowed the Original Application and directed that respondent no. 1 be treated as a regular employee and be entitled to post-retiral benefits as per relevant statutory rules; the Tribunal also awarded interest at 9% per annum from the date the amounts became due.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether respondent no. 1 should be treated as a regular employee and thereby entitled to pension and other post-retiral benefits despite the absence of a formal order of regularization.
  2. Whether the Department of Posts' actions (including any recruitment or failure to regularize) were inconsistent with the Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status in Regularization) Scheme, particularly paragraph 17 prohibiting open-market recruitment while casual labourers were available to fill Group D posts.
  3. Whether Rule 154(a) of the Post & Telegraphs Ministerial Manual (Establishment Rule 154(a)) and the approved Scheme require conferment of pensionary benefits to classes of contingency-paid staff who worked alongside regular employees, even in the absence of formal regularization.
  4. Whether precedent authorities relied upon by the petitioner (including Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi) are applicable to deny the respondent the relief granted by the Tribunal.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Union of India / Department of Posts)

  • The Department's principal defence before the Tribunal (and thus before the High Court) was that respondent no. 1 was not regularized because there was no vacancy available, and therefore he was not entitled to pension.
  • The petitioner relied on judgments including Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi to support the contention that the relief sought should not be accorded; the petitioner also relied on other decisions and argued that some Tribunal decisions (e.g., Lucknow Bench OA No. 509/2004) supported its stance.

Respondent's Arguments (Shyam Lal Shukla)

  • The respondent claimed engagement as contingency paid Chowkidar from 10.4.1982 and asserted that the engagement was against a vacant post; he relied on the communication dated 2.1.1992 treating him as a full-time contingency-paid employee and conferring temporary status effective 29.11.1989 along with benefits.
  • He sought pensionary and other retirement benefits (pension, commutation, gratuity, encashment of leave, medical facilities and arrears) on the basis of his continuous service, the Scheme framed by the Department in compliance with the Supreme Court order, and Rule 154(a) of the Manual which treats certain contingency paid staff as "regular" employees for present purposes.
  • The respondent contended (and the Tribunal accepted) that he had qualifying service (calculated in the judgment) and that departmental practice and the Scheme required that he be treated as regular for pensionary benefits even in the absence of a separate formal regularization order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order of the Supreme Court in Writ Petition No. 1276 of 1986 (Reserved Trained Pool Telephone Operators of Bombay and others) Ground for formulation and approval of the Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status in Regularization) Scheme and the requirement to finalize a Scheme for postal employees; expectation of parity of service conditions between temporary and regular employees. The Court relied on the fact that the Scheme was formulated in compliance with and approved by the Supreme Court; this supported the conclusion that the Scheme's terms (including conferment of temporary status and benefits) must be given effect.
Ram Lakhan v. Union of India (Special Leave to Appeal dated 13.1.1997 arising out of OA No. 159/93) Authority relied upon by the Tribunal in similar factual contexts concerning regularization/benefits of casual/temporary employees. The Court noted this order was on the Tribunal's record (Annexure-AR-2) and treated it as part of the supporting authorities which the Tribunal had considered; it contributed to the conclusion that the Tribunal's decision was not erroneous.
Chandi Lal v. Union of India (order dated 2 September 2005 in OA No. 917 of 2004) Another tribunal/Supreme Court-connected order on the record dealing with similar facts of casual labourers/temporary status and benefits. The order (on record as Annexure-AR-3) was regarded by the Court as one of the authorities relied upon by the Tribunal to support its conclusion; the High Court treated these authorities as consistent with granting relief to the respondent.
Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (reported in 2006 (2) UPLBEC 1880) Principles regarding regularization and legitimate expectations in public employment (relied upon by the petitioner). The High Court found Umadevi inapplicable to the facts because here a specific Scheme had been framed by the Postal Department in compliance with a Supreme Court order and the Scheme had the imprimatur of the Supreme Court; therefore the Department could not resile from implementing the Scheme.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court's analysis proceeded by reference to the statutory/scheme framework and to the factual record admitted before the Tribunal and this Court:

  1. Scheme and Supreme Court Approval: The Court emphasized that the Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status in Regularization) Scheme was formulated by the Department of Posts in consultation with Ministries of Law, Finance & Personnel and was put into operation in compliance with the Supreme Court's directions in Writ Petition No. 1276 of 1986. The Scheme specified conferment of temporary status from 1/10/1989 and detailed benefits that should follow.
  2. Paragraph 17 of the Scheme: The Court highlighted paragraph 17 which prohibits open-market recruitment for Group D posts (except compassionate appointments) so long as casual labourers with requisite qualifications are available to fill the posts. The Court observed that it was neither the case of the petitioner nor believable that no post was available for regularization from 1992 until the respondent's superannuation, and therefore the Department's action was contrary to paragraph 17.
  3. Rule 154(a) of the Post & Telegraphs Ministerial Manual: The Court quoted Rule 154(a), which states that selected categories of whole-time contingency paid staff (including chowkidars) who work side by side with regular employees "should ... be brought on to regular establishments ... and should be treated as 'regular' employees." The Court treated this Rule as expressing the essential purpose of granting pensionary benefits to such employees notwithstanding the lack of a formal order of regularization.
  4. Service and Qualification: The Court relied on admitted facts about the respondent's uninterrupted service. It set out the periods of service as recorded in the opinion (contingent fund from 10.4.1982 to 26.11.1989; consolidated fund from 26.11.1989 to 29.11.1992; temporary Group D service from 30.11.1992 to 30.6.2003) and calculated total qualifying service as 17 years, 4 months and 10 days.
  5. Reliance on Precedents and Tribunal Orders: The Court recorded that the Tribunal had relied upon earlier orders (e.g., Ram Lakhan and Chandi Lal) which were placed on record. It examined a contrary Tribunal decision from Lucknow (OA No. 509/2004) relied upon by the petitioner and concluded that that Tribunal had failed to take proper account of the Department's Scheme and paragraph 17 and had misconceived Rule 154(a).
  6. Inapplicability of Umadevi to the Present Facts: The Court considered the petitioner's reliance on Umadevi and concluded that it did not apply because, in contrast to the facts of Umadevi, here there was a specific Scheme framed by the Postal Department approved by the Supreme Court which created obligations the Department was required to implement.
  7. Conclusion from Analysis: On the combined effect of the Scheme, Rule 154(a), the admitted facts of continuous satisfactory service, and the Tribunal's reasoning supported by relevant authorities on record, the High Court found no error in the Tribunal's judgment and concluded that it did not call for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

DISMISSED — The writ petition filed by the Union of India was dismissed. The High Court upheld the Tribunal's direction to treat respondent no. 1 as a regular employee and to grant post-retiral benefits as per the relevant statutory rules; the Tribunal's award of interest (as recorded in the impugned order) was not disturbed by the High Court.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Tribunal's order treating Shyam Lal Shukla as a regular employee and entitling him to pensionary and other post-retiral benefits stands affirmed by the High Court. The writ petition challenging that order was dismissed. The opinion also records that no order is passed as to costs.
  • Broader precedent: The Court did not state that it was laying down a new legal principle; rather it applied the existing Scheme (approved by the Supreme Court) and Rule 154(a) to the facts. The opinion emphasizes that where a Scheme approved by the Supreme Court and a manual rule (Rule 154(a)) require treatment as regular employees and confer pensionary benefits, the Department is bound to implement them. The judgment does not purport to expand or overrule Supreme Court authority; it treats existing scheme- and rule-based obligations as determinative in the present fact situation.

No other costs order was made: "However, no order is passed as to costs." (as recorded in the opinion)

    Union Of India And Others Petitioners v. Shyam Lal Shukla

    P.K.S Baghel, J.:— The Union of India through the Ministry of Communication, Department of Post has filed the present writ petition against the judgment and order dated 28th July, 2009 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad Bench, Allahabad (hereinafter referred to as Tribunal) in Original Application No. 1626 of 2005 filed by the respondent no. 1, Shyam Lal Shukla.

    2. The brief facts leading to the instant petition are that the respondent no. 1 was engaged as Contingency Paid Chowkidar “Sahson” Sub. Post Office district Allahabad in the year 1982.

    3. The initial engagement of respondent no. 1 is on the record as Annexure-1 to his Original Application filed before the Tribunal and it has been issued in terms of Rule 267 of Posts and Telegraph Financial Hand Book, Volume-1, Second Edition. It is dated 10.4.1982 and bears signature of respondent no. 1 as Relieving Officer. Respondent no. 1 asserts that the engagement was against a vacant post. Annexure-2 of Original Application is communication dated 2.1.1992 wherein respondent no. 1 has been treated to be “full time C.P Employee of Postal Department” and has been conferred temporary status w.e.f 29.11.1989 It goes on to say that respondent no. 1 and some other similarly situated Employees will get all the benefits mentioned in the Director's letter dated 12.4.1991 In compliance thereof the respondent no. 1 was extended all the benefits of regular employee such as DA, ADA, Leave entitlement, Maternity Leave, HRA, Bonus, Medical facility, Insurance Scheme and G.P.F

    4. It is noteworthy that temporary status to the respondent no. 1 has been granted in pursuance of a Scheme known as Casual Labours (Grant of Temporary Status in Regularization) Scheme. The said Scheme was formulated by the Department of Post, Government of India vide communication dated 12.4.1991 issued by the Director General, Department of Post, New Delhi in compliance of the order of Supreme Court in Writ Petition No. 1276 of 1986 filed by the Reserved Trained Pool Telephone Operators of Bombay and others connected with other writ petitions. The said Scheme has been annexed as Annexure-1 to the writ petition. Relevant protion of the order of the Supreme Court in the said writ petition is quoted here in under:—

    “learned counsel for the petitioners concedes that the regularization of 21,000.00 employees in the Department of Telecommunications has been effected but complains that no such proceeding has taken place in respect of the postal employees. He states that there is pressing need for a parity of service conditions including pay, house rent allowance and other allowances between the temporary employees and the regular employees covered by this category. The learned Additional Solicitor General of India assures us that the scheme will be finalised latest by first week of April, 1989 and that complete position will be placed before the court at that stage….”

    The scheme known as Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status in Regularisation) Scheme has been formulated and put into operation from 1/10/1989 and a copy thereof has been placed for our consideration. We find that the scheme is comprehensive and apart from provision for conferment of temporary status, it also specifies the benefits available on conferment of such status. Counsel for the respondent-Nigams have told us that the scheme will be given full effect and other benefits contemplated by the scheme shall be worked out. In these circumstances, no further specific direction is necessary in the two applications relating to the two Nigams of Bombay and Delhi except calling upon the respondents to implement every term of the scheme at an early date.”

    5. The respondent no. 1 was given temporary status in terms of the said Scheme w.e.f 25.11.1989 The Suprintendent of Post Office, Allahabad extended the emoluments of monthly salary such as DA and ADA, HRA as revised from time to time and granted privileges as provided to other regular employees. The petitioner reached to his age of superannuation on 30 June, 2003. Before his superannuation he made several representation for the benefit of pension. However, his representation failed to elicit any response from the authorities. Having, no option left he filed the Original Application before the Tribunal for the following relief:—

    1. To direct the respondents to take due and appropriate actions into the matters and arrange payments of all retiring and pensionary benefits as admissible to other Deptt. Group D employees w.e.f 1.3.2003 within stipulated period:-

    2. Pension and commotation,

    3. Gratuity,

    4. Un-availed earned to be encashed,

    5. Medical treatment facilities,

    6. To pay arrears of the benefits with 12% interest w.e.f 1.7.2003 to the date actual period within stipulated period.”

    6. The petitioner's main defence before the Tribunal was that the respondent no. 1 was not regularized as there was no vacancy and as such he is not entitled for the pension. The Tribunal by its impugned judgment and order has allowed the Original Application with a direction to treat the respondent no. 1 as regular employee and also that he is entitle to all post retiral benefits as per relevant statutory Rules in force. The respondent no. 1 was also held to be entitled to 9% annual interest from the date it becomes due.

    7. As noticed earlier the Supreme Court had approved a Scheme for casual labours namely (Grant of Temporary Status in Regularization) Scheme. The said Scheme was drawn up by the Postal Department in consultation with the Ministries of Law, Finance & Personnel. The Scheme provides inter alia ‘temporary status’ should be conferred on casual labours in employment as on 29.11.1989 and continued to be employed on the said date and have rendered continuous service of at least one year. If an employee get the temporary status he should be entitled for minimum of the pay scale for a regular Group D including DA/HRA and CCA. One of the important feature of the Scheme which has relevance for the present controversy is that no recruitment from open market will be done till the casual labours were available to fill up the posts. The paragraph 17 of the Scheme is extracted hereunder below:—

    “17. No recruitment from open market for group ‘D’ posts except compassionate appointments will be done till casual labourers with the requisite qualification are available to fill up the posts in question.”

    8. It is admitted fact that the Senior Superintendent of Post Office, Allahabad had issued a communication dated 2.1.92 and granted ‘temporary status’ to the respondent no. 1 w.e.f 29.11.1989 and his name was placed at Serial No. 11 in the list. It is neither the case of the petitioner nor is it believable that from the year 1992 till the date of superannuation of respondent no. 1 no post was available for his regularization. The action of the Department/Petitioner was in the teeth of paragraph 17 of the Scheme approved by the Apex Court mentioned herein above.

    9. Apart from the aforesaid fact the respondent no. 1 was entitled for the pension in term of the Post & Telegraphs Ministerial Manual Establishment Rule 154(a) which is quoted herein below:—

    “154.(a) Selected categories of whole time contingency paid staff, such as Sweepers, Bhisties, Chowkidars, Chobdars, Malis or Gardeners, Khalassis and such other categories as are expected to work side by side with regular employees or with employees in work charged establishment, should, for the present, be brought on to regular establishments of which they form adjuncts and should be treated as “regular” employees.”

    10. From the perusal of Rule 154 A of Manual it is manifestly clear that the Chowkidar, Sweeper, Malis, Khalassis who worked side by side with regular or with employees in Work Charge Establishment should be brought on regular Establishment and should be treated ‘regular employees’. The Rule itself has used the word ‘regular employee’ without any reference to formal order of regularization. The Tribunal has relied on Rule 154 A of the Manual of appointment and allowances of the Officers of the Indian Post & Telegraphs Department. It is, undisputed fact that the respondent no. 1 has worked and has received the payment from contingent fund w.e.f 10.4.1982 to 26.11.1989 i.e Seven Years Six Months and Nineteen days, thereafter from the consolidated fund of Central Government from 26.11.1989 to 29.11.1992 three years and then from 30.11.1992 till the date of retirement i.e 30.6.2003 as temporary Government Employee of Group D, for ten years Seven months and One day. The total qualifying service for pension comes to 17 years, four months and 10 days.

    11. It is admitted case that the respondent no. 1 from his initial engagement i.e 10.4.1982 till his date of superannuation i.e 30.6.2003 has worked uninterruptedly and to the entire satisfaction of the Department as has been stated in the Counter Affidavit, Supplementary Counter Affidavit before the Tribunal and in the Writ Petition before this Court and there is no mention that the work of the respondent no. 1 was unsatisfactory.

    12. The Tribunal has also relied on the order of the Supreme Court in Special Leave to Appeal dated 13.1.1997 arising out of the Original Application No. 159/93 of Tribunal, in the case of (Ram Lakhan v. Union of India) as well as order dated 2nd September, 2005 in Original Application No. 917 of 2004, (Chandi Lal v. Union of India). The aforesaid orders were on the record of the Tribunal as Annexure-AR-2 and AR-3 with affidavit filed on 26.8.2008 in similar facts.

    13. In our view the said Rule clearly spells out its essential purpose, to give pensionary benefit to certain class of employees as ‘regular employee’, notwithstanding the fact that no formal order of regularization was passed.

    14. Sri Singhal has relied on the judgment of Central Administrative Tribunal, Lucknow Bench, Lucknow passed in Original Application No. 509 of 2004. We have perused the said judgment. In the said case, the learned Tribunal has not taken note of the Scheme framed by the Department dated 12.4.2001 and paragraph 17 of the Scheme wherein it is clearly provided that no recruitment will made from open market for Group D posts (except on compassionate appointment) till casual labours with requisite qualifications are available to fill up the posts in question. Moreover, the Tribunal has also mis-construed Rule 154(a) as it has not appreciated the said Rule in correct prospective. It appears, the relevant part of the said Rule wherein it is provided that the Chowkidars etc. should be treated as “regular employee” subject to completion of conditions mentioned therein, has escaped the notice of the learned Tribunal.

    15. Sri Singhal has also relied on the judgment of the Supreme Court passed in the case of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi reported in 2006 (2) UPLBEC 1880. The said judgement has no application in the present case as in the present matter the Scheme has been framed by the Postal Department in compliance of the order of the Supreme Court and the said Scheme has been approved by the Supreme Court. Thus the Postal Department/Petitioner herein cannot resile from its obligation to implement the said Scheme in letter and spirit.

    16. In the background of the aforesaid facts we are satisfied that there is no error in the impugned judgment of the Tribunal and it does not call for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.

    17. Hence, the writ petition is dismissed.

    18. However, no order is passed as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others Petitioners v. Shyam Lal Shukla
    (Dec 23, 2011)