Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act read with clause 9(1) of the Haryana Prevention
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act read with clause 9(1) of the Haryana Prevention
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Dharampal (appellant) was convicted by the Special Judge, Bhiwani by judgment dated 18.9.1996/20.9.96 under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act read with clause 9(1) of the Haryana Prevention of Hoarding and Maintenance of Quality Order, 1977 and clauses 3 and 4 of the Haryana Commodities Price Marketing and Display Order, 1975. He was sentenced to undergo RI for two years and to pay a fine of Rs. 5,000/-, with a default sentence of six months RI. The prosecution case was that SI Mahender Singh received secret information that the appellant was keeping a large quantity of kerosene; a raid on 28.6.1994 discovered 760 litres while records showed nil stock; appellant could not explain and was charged. The appellant appealed against the conviction/sentence; this opinion records the appellate court's consideration.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sentence awarded to the appellant should be reduced and the appellant released on probation in view of the protracted trial and the authorities cited in support.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Conviction not challenged on merits; primary prayer is reduction of sentence.
  • Case relates to 1994 and the appellant has endured a protracted trial of about nine years; therefore he deserves leniency and the benefit of probation.
  • Relied upon the judgments: Sant Lal… v. State Of Haryana…. 1999 (2) All India Criminal Law Reporter 652 : 1999 (2) RCR (Cr.) 563 and Niranjan v. State Of Haryana, 1992 (3) Crimes 1069 : 1994 (2) RCR (Cr.) 620 (P&H).

State's Arguments

  • The appellant does not deserve leniency because he was found in possession of a large quantity of kerosene without any record; the sentence awarded by the trial court should be maintained.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sant Lal… v. State Of Haryana…. 1999 (2) All India Criminal Law Reporter 652 : 1999 (2) RCR (Cr.) 563 Authority relied upon to seek benefit of probation/reduction of sentence. The court held this judgment to be fully applicable to the facts and circumstances and relied on it in deciding to modify the sentence and release the appellant on probation.
Niranjan v. State Of Haryana, 1992 (3) Crimes 1069 : 1994 (2) RCR (Cr.) 620 (P&H) Authority relied upon to seek benefit of probation/reduction of sentence. The court treated this decision as applicable and supportive of granting probation in view of the protracted trial, contributing to the decision to modify the sentence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the record and evidence and found no infirmity in the conviction; the conviction was therefore upheld. On quantum of sentence the court accepted the appellant's submission that the proceedings dated from 1994 and the appellant had endured a protracted trial of about nine years. The court found merit in the authorities cited by the appellant and concluded that, in all the facts and circumstances, the ends of justice would be met by releasing the appellant on probation rather than imposing the substantive sentence. The court therefore modified the sentence while preserving the conviction, specifying conditions for probation and procedural steps if bonds are not furnished.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Conviction of the appellant is UPHELD, but the sentence is modified: the appellant is to be released on probation of good conduct on furnishing personal bonds of Rs. 20,000 with one surety in like amount for one year, without supervision of a Probation Officer; failure to furnish bonds within one month of receipt of certified copy will result in execution of the original sentence. The appeal is dismissed with this modification.

Implications: The direct effect is that the appellant remains convicted but will be released on probation subject to the stated conditions; the opinion applies cited authorities to justify leniency due to trial delay. The opinion contains no discussion of broader precedent-setting implications beyond its application to the present case.

    Dharam Pal v. State Of Haryana

    Virender Singh, J. — Dharampal appellant herein has been convicted by learned Special Judge, Bhiwani vide judgment dated 18.9.1996/20.9.96 under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act read with clause 9(1) of the Haryana Prevention of Hoarding and Maintenance of Quality Order, 1977 and clauses 3 and 4 of the Haryana Commodities Price Marketing and Display Order, 1975 and has been sentenced to undergo RI for two years and to pay a fine of Rs. 5000/-, in default of payment of fine of further undergo RI for six months.

    2. In short the case of the prosecution is that SI Mahender Singh, who was posted as In-charge of Police Post, Dinod Gate, Bhiwani received a secret information against the appellant to the effect that he was keeping kerosene oil to the extent of large quantity. A raid was conducted with the officials of the Food & Civil Supplies department on the shop of the appellant on 28.6.1994 and kerosene to the extent of 760 litres was found in possession of the appellant whereas his relevant record in this connection was showing nil stock. Since the appellant could not furnish any explanation for it, he was booked in the present case. After completion of the entire investigation, the appellant was challaned to face trial. On appreciation of the entire evidence, the learned Judge, Special Court, has convicted and sentenced him as stated above. Hence, this appeal.

    3. I have heard Mr. R.S Kundu, learned counsel for the appellant and Mrs. Geeta Mathuria, learned Assistant Advocate General, representing the State of Haryana. With their assistance I have also gone through the entire records of the case.

    4. Mr. Kundu does not assail the impugned judgment of conviction on merits and instead prayed for reduction in the quantum of sentence. In support of his arguments, it has been submitted that the present case relates to the year 1994 and by now the appellant has already faced the rigour of protracted trial of about 9 years and as such he deserves a lenient view so far as quantum of sentence is concerned. In support of his arguments, he has relied upon two judgments of this Court rendered in Sant Lal… v. State Of Haryana…., 1999 (2) All India Criminal Law Reporter 652 : 1999 (2) RCR (Cr.) 563 (Niranjan v. State Of Haryana, 1992 (3) Crimes 1069 : 1994 (2) RCR (Cr.) 620 (P&H) and prayed for the benefit of probation.

    On the other hand Ms. Mathuria vehemently contends that the appellant does not deserve any leniency as he was found in possession of large quantity of kerosene oil without any record and the sentence as awarded by the trial court deserves to be maintained.

    5. So far as the merits of the case of concerned, although the learned counsel has not assailed the conviction of the appellant on merits, yet I have scanned the entire evidence minutely and do not find any infirmity in this regard. Conviction of the appellant is, thus, maintained.

    6. On quantum of sentence 1 find that there is substance in the arguments advanced by learned counsel for the appellant. Admittedly, the present case relates to the year 1994. He has already suffered the agony of protracted trial of about 9 years. The judgments rendered in Sant Lal's case and Niranjan & another's case (supra) cited by the learned counsel for the appellant are fully applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case as well.

    7. Taking into consideration all the facts and circumstances of the present case, I am of the considered view that the ends of justice would be adequately met if the appellant is ordered to be released on probation instead of awarding substantive sentence. Accordingly, upholding the conviction of the appellant for the charge framed against him it is directed that he shall be released on probation of good conduct on his furnishing personal bonds in the sum of Rs. 20,000/- with one surety in the like amount to keep peace and be of good behaviour for a period of one year and to receive the sentence as and when called upon to do so during the said period of one year. It is however made clear that releasing of the appellant on probation would be without the supervision of Probation Officer. The requisite bonds shall be furnished before the trial court within one month after the receipt of certified copy of the order, failing which the appellant shall undergo the sentence imposed upon him by the learned trial court. With the modification in the quantum of sentence, as referred to above, the present appeal is dismissed. Let intimation of this judgment be sent to the trial court.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dharam Pal v. State Of Haryana
    (Oct 8, 2003)