Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 33-C of the U.P Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 (hereinafter referred to as the Act, 1982).4.
  • Uttar Pradesh Secondary Education Services Commission (Amendment) Act, 1998;(d)
  • INTERMEDIATE EDUCATION ACT 1921
  • provisions of Section 33-C,
  • clause (c) of sub-section (1)
  • Section 18;(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 33-C of the U.P Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 (hereinafter referred to as the Act, 1982).4.
  • Uttar Pradesh Secondary Education Services Commission (Amendment) Act, 1998;(d)
  • INTERMEDIATE EDUCATION ACT 1921
  • provisions of Section 33-C,
  • clause (c) of sub-section (1)
  • Section 18;(b)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was selected by the District Inspector of Schools in a selection held on 05.01.1993 and a selection/appointment order was issued on 18.01.1993. Under the relevant provisions the District Inspector was empowered to hold such selections and the appointment was to be on ad hoc basis against a substantive vacancy, to continue until a regularly selected candidate joined.

The Management (respondent) refused to perform the ministerial act of issuing the letter of appointment and thereby did not allow the appellant to join the institution despite the selection/appointment order. The appellant made repeated representations dated 16.02.1993, 18.02.1993, 23.02.1993 and others up to 13.08.1993. Ultimately, the Management issued the letter of appointment on 25.08.1993 and the appellant joined on 26.08.1993 and thereafter has been continuously functioning in the institution.

The Uttar Pradesh Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 (the Act, 1982) was amended effective 20.04.1998 to introduce Section 33-C, which provided for regularisation of certain ad hoc appointees appointed on or after 14.05.1991 but not later than 06.08.1993 (subject to other conditions including continuous service up to commencement of the amendment and suitability by a Selection Committee).

Claiming benefit under Section 33-C, the appellant made representations for regularisation and, failing to obtain relief, filed a writ petition. The State filed a counter-affidavit asserting that the appellant was appointed only on 25.08.1993 (i.e., after 06.08.1993) and therefore not entitled to regularisation under Section 33-C. The learned Single Judge refused the mandamus sought by the appellant on the basis that the appointment was after 06.08.1993 but permitted the appellant to seek representation before the State Government for a reasoned order. The present special appeal challenges that judgment of the Single Judge dated 02.04.2010.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant is entitled to regularisation under Section 33-C of the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 despite the formal letter of appointment being issued on 25.08.1993, which is after the cut-off date of 06.08.1993.
  2. Whether the learned Single Judge erred in declining the writ (mandamus) on the basis that the selection order in favour of the appellant was stayed or rescinded (an assumption of fact that the Court below recorded).
  3. Whether, in circumstances where a candidate was prevented from joining through no fault of his own by the Management's inaction, the appointment/letter of appointment should be treated as relating back for purposes of eligibility under Section 33-C.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant (through Mr. Vivek Prasad Mathur) submitted that the appellant was appointed on 18.01.1993 pursuant to the selection and that the Single Judge's finding that an order dated 05.02.1993 stayed the selection in relation to the appellant (continuing until 05.11.1993) was erroneous and unrelated to the appellant.
  • It was argued that the stay order dated 05.02.1993 related to another teacher (Km. Jyoti Daniel) and not to the appellant, and therefore the Single Judge proceeded on a mistaken factual basis.
  • The appellant relied on facts that the District Inspector of Schools had dispatched the selection order dated 18.01.1993 and that the Manager's refusal to issue the appointment letter was an inaction preventing the appellant from joining through no fault of his own; the manager eventually issued the letter on 25.08.1993 after repeated representations.

Respondent / State's Arguments

  • The State, in its counter-affidavit, disputed the appellant's entitlement to regularisation on the ground that the appellant came to be appointed only on 25.08.1993, which is 19 days after the cut-off date 06.08.1993 specified in Section 33-C, and therefore he was not eligible for the benefit.
  • The counter-affidavit did not dispute that the appellant had been denied the letter of appointment by the Management despite repeated representations and despite the selection order dated 18.01.1993 being issued by the District Inspector of Schools.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by addressing the factual findings and legal consequence of the Management's inaction. The analysis unfolded along these lines:

  1. The Court examined the Single Judge's basis for refusing the mandamus and found that the Single Judge had recorded a finding that the selection order in favour of the appellant was stayed or rescinded (a stay dated 05.02.1993 continuing till 05.11.1993). The Court held that this finding was erroneous because there was no such order in relation to the appellant; the stay related to a different teacher (Km. Jyoti Daniel).
  2. The Court noted that the State, in its counter-affidavit before the Single Judge, did not dispute that the District Inspector of Schools had issued the selection order dated 18.01.1993 nor dispute that the Management had not issued the appointment letter despite repeated representations. Subsequent clarification from the Standing Counsel confirmed there was no order dated 05.02.1993 in relation to the appellant.
  3. On the substantive issue under Section 33-C, the Court observed the statutory scheme introduced on 20.04.1998: Section 33-C regularised ad hoc appointees appointed on or after 14.05.1991 but not later than 06.08.1993 against substantive vacancies, provided the teacher was continuously serving up to commencement of the amendment and was found suitable by a Selection Committee.
  4. The Court distinguished the appellant as belonging to a class of candidates who were wrongfully prevented, through no fault of their own, from joining the institution because the Management failed to perform a ministerial act (i.e., issuance of the appointment letter) despite the District Inspector's selection order.
  5. The Court reasoned that where the Management's inaction wrongfully prevents a selected candidate from joining, that inaction cannot be allowed to defeat the candidate's legitimate entitlement. The Manager's failure to issue the letter — an act apparently ministerial and commanded by the District Inspector of Schools — could not be visited upon the appellant.
  6. Accordingly, the Court held that the letter of appointment in such circumstances must be treated as relating back prior to the statutory cut-off date (06.08.1993) for the purposes of Section 33-C, thereby making the appellant eligible for regularisation if otherwise qualified.

The Court's reasoning was tightly tethered to the facts on record (selection order dated 18.01.1993; Management's refusal to issue appointment letter until 25.08.1993; lack of any stay order relating to the appellant) and the statutory scheme of Section 33-C as introduced by the 1998 amendment.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 02.04.2010 is set aside; the writ petition and the appeal are allowed; the appellant is entitled to the benefit of regularisation under Section 33-C in the circumstances narrated.

Direct consequences and directions issued by the Court:

  • Respondent No. 2 (Regional Joint Director of Education, Basti) is directed to proceed to consider the appellant's claim for regularisation in light of the Court's observations and to issue appropriate orders not later than six weeks from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order, provided the appellant is otherwise eligible and qualified.
  • The Court held that, in these circumstances, the letter of appointment will be treated as relating back prior to the cut-off date of 06.08.1993 for purposes of Section 33-C.
  • No order as to costs was made by the Court.

Broader implications: The opinion confines its relief to the factual class of candidates who were wrongfully prevented from receiving letters of appointment through no fault of their own and directs administrative reconsideration. The opinion does not purport to establish a general novel precedent beyond the facts before the Court; it applies the statutory scheme of Section 33-C to the appellant's factual situation.

    Firangi Prasad v. State Of U.P & Others

    Ferdino I. Rebello, C.J and A.P Sahi, J.:— Heard Sri Vivek Prasad Mathur, learned counsel for the appellant and the learned Standing Counsel for respondents 1 to 4.

    2. Respondent no. 5 is the District Inspector of Schools, Basti, functioning as Prabandh Sanchalak of the Institution, who is already arrayed as respondent no. 3.

    3. This special appeal relates to the dispute of a claim by the appellant for his regularization under the provisions of Section 33-C of the U.P Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act, 1982’).

    4. The admitted facts are that the appellant was appointed in a selection held by the District Inspector of Schools on 05.01.1993 Under the relevant provisions, it was the District Inspector of Schools, who was empowered to get the selection held for appointment of the teacher on ad hoc basis. There is also no dispute that the appellant was appointed against a substantive vacancy on ad hoc basis in terms of the relevant provisions and his selection and appointment was duly notified to respondent no. 5-Management, vide order dated 18.1.1993

    5. The Management was called upon to allow the appellant to join as teacher on ad hoc basis within ten days and the appellant was also to accordingly join the Institution. It is to be noted that the said appointment was on ad hoc basis to continue till a candidate regularly selected joined the post.

    6. The appellant appears to have approached the Management along with order dated 18.01.1993, but the Management refused to perform the said ministerial act of issuing the letter of appointment and did not allow the appellant to join in the Institution, about which complaints were made by the appellant through representations dated 16.02.1993, 18.02.1993, 23.02.1993 and several other repeated representations up to 13.08.1993 The Management ultimately on 25.08.1993 issued a letter of appointment allowing the appellant to join on 26.08.1993, whereafter he has been continuously functioning in the Institution.

    7. The order of appointment has also been brought on record, which demonstrates that the same was being issued pursuant to the selection order dated 18.01.1993 and the oral discussion in the meeting held with the District Inspector of Schools.

    8. The Act, 1982 was amended w.e.f 20.04.1998 by introducing certain amendments including the provisions of Section 33-C, which is quoted herein below:—

    “33-C. Regularisation of certain more appointments.-- (1) Any teacher who--

    (a)(i) was appointed by promotion or by direct recruitment on or after May 14, 1991 but not later than August 6, 1993 on ad hoc basis against substantive vacancy in accordance with section 18, in the Lecturer grade or the Trained Graduate grade;

    (ii) was appointed by promotion on or after July 31, 1988 but not later than August 6, 1993 on ad hoc basis against a substantive vacancy in the post of a Principal or Head Master in accordance with Section 18;

    (b) possesses the qualification prescribed under, or is exempted from such qualification in accordance with, the provisions of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921;

    (c) has been continuously serving the Institution from the date of such appointment up to the date of the commencement of the Uttar Pradesh Secondary Education Services Commission (Amendment) Act, 1998;

    (d) has been found suitable for appointment in a substantive capacity by a Selection Committee constituted under sub-section

    9. shall be given substantive appointment by the Management.

    (2)(a) For each region, there shall be a Selection Committee comprising,-

    (i) Regional Joint Director of Education of that region, who shall be the Chairman;

    (ii) Regional Deputy Director of Education (Secondary) who shall be member;

    (iii) Regional Assistant Director of Education (Basic) who shall be a member.

    10. In addition to above members, the District Inspector of Schools of the concerned district shall be co-opted as member while considering the cases for regularisation of that district.

    (b) The Procedure of selection for substantive appointment under sub-section (1) shall be such as may be prescribed.

    (3)(a) The names of the teachers shall be recommended for substantive appointment in order of seniority as determined from the date of their appointment.

    (b) If two or more such teachers are appointed on the same date, the teacher who is elder in age shall be recommended first.

    (4) Every teacher appointed in a substantive capacity under sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be on probation from the date of such substantive appointment.

    (5) A teacher who is not found suitable under sub-section (1) and a teacher who is not eligible to get a substantive appointment under that sub-section shall cease to hold the appointment on such date as the State Government may by order specify.

    (6) Nothing in this Section shall be construed to entitle any teacher to substantive appointment, if on the date of commencement of the Ordinance referred to in clause (c) of sub-section (1) such vacancy had already been filled or selection for such vacancy has already been made in accordance with this Act.”

    11. By virtue of the said amendment, all ad hoc appointees either by way of promotion or direct recruitment against a substantive vacancy, not appointed later than 06.08.1993, were entitled to be regularised and placed on probation. The aforesaid provision as noted above was introduced w.e.f 20.04.1998 and it further provides that in order to obtain the benefit of regularisation, the concerned teacher should have been appointed prior to 06.08.1993 and should have been continuing upto the date of introduction of the said provision in the year 1998.

    12. Claiming benefit under the aforesaid provision, the appellant made representations for regularisation before the competent authority and having failed to get any benefit, filed the writ petition, which has given rise to the present appeal.

    13. The respondent-State appears to have filed a counter affidavit in the writ petition disputing the claim of the appellant on the ground that the appellant came to be appointed only on 25.08.1993, which is 19 days after the cut-off date mentioned in Section 33-C of the Act, 1982 and, therefore, the appellant was not entitled to the benefit of the said provision.

    14. Counter affidavit filed on behalf of the State did not dispute the allegation contained in the writ petition that the appellant had been denied the letter of appointment by the Management in spite of repeated representations after his selection and the order of the District Inspector of Schools dated 18.01.1993 A supplementary affidavit has been filed by the appellant bringing on record certain facts to dispute the correctness of the facts, which have been made basis by the learned Single Judge to refuse the mandamus as prayed for.

    15. The learned Single Judge after having assessed the claim of the appellant held that in view of the fact that the appellant had been appointed after 06.08.1993, is not entitled to claim any such regularisation, but allowed the appellant to approach the State Government for representing his case and the State Government was called upon to pass a reasoned and speaking order accordingly.

    16. Mr. Mathur, learned counsel for the appellant submits that the appellant had been appointed on 18.01.1993 and that the finding recorded by the learned Single Judge, that the District Inspector of Schools himself had stayed the order of selection on 05.02.1993, which continued till 05.11.1993, is absolutely erroneous inasmuch as there was neither any such order, nor any such continuance in relation to the appellant. He submits that the stay order dated 05.02.1993 was in relation to some other teacher, namely Km. Jyoti Daniel in the same Institution, which has got nothing to do with the appointment and selection of the appellant. This aspect of the matter was sought to be clarified from the learned Standing Counsel, who has produced the instructions and Sri Dwivedi, learned Standing Counsel states, on the basis of such instructions, that there was no such order dated 05.02.1993 in relation to the appellant.

    17. Having considered the aforesaid submissions, it is, therefore, clear that the learned Single Judge proceeded to decline the mandamus as prayed for on a clear erroneous assumption of fact. The order in favour of the appellant dated 18.01.1993 was neither stayed nor rescinded. This is also corroborated by a perusal of the counter affidavit that was filed before the learned Single Judge where also the State did not dispute the aforesaid position. Accordingly, the finding recorded by the learned Single Judge on the strength of such facts cannot be sustained.

    18. The second contention needs to be examined in the light of the facts that have emerged from the record, namely that the appellant for no fault on his part was kept out of the Institution by the inaction of the Management in spite of the District Inspector of Schools having despatched the selection order on 18.01.1993 From the facts on record, it is evident that the Manager of the Institution had to perform the ministerial act of issuing a letter of appointment to the appellant in terms of the selection order dated 18.01.1993 The Management admittedly complied with it after much persuasion on 25.08.1993, for which the appellant is nowhere at fault. On the contrary, the appellant had been continuously approaching the Management time and again expressing his willingness to join the Institution.

    19. In these circumstances, teachers like the appellant fall within an altogether different class of candidates, who have been wrongfully prevented by the inaction of the Management in joining the Institution. The Management has to perform only a ministerial act and by its inaction, it cannot defeat the legitimate claim of a teacher like appellant.

    20. The direction contained in the order dated 18.01.1993 was categorical to allow the appellant to join within ten days, which admittedly was scuttled by the Manager for reasons best known to him.

    21. The Manager is obliged to issue a letter of appointment under the direction of the District Inspector of Schools, who is the competent authority under the Rules. Any unwarranted defiance and in the absence of any infirmity in the selection of the appellant, such inaction of the Management cannot be of any disadvantage to the appellant or to any such teacher belonging to this class.

    22. The respondents cannot by their inaction, therefore, deprive a candidate of his or her legitimate right to claim continuance in service. It is, therefore, clear that there was a deliberate delay on the part of the Management in issuing the letter of appointment in the present case and accordingly, the right of the appellant to claim continuance under the selection order dated 18.01.1993 cannot be denied. The appellant will, therefore, be entitled to the benefits flowing out of the order dated 18.01.1993 and in such a situation, the letter of appointment will relate back prior to the cut-off date i.e 06.08.1993

    23. This, in our opinion, would be the correct interpretation of law in relation to the candidates who have been wrongfully prevented from receiving their letters of appointment for no fault of theirs.

    24. Having concluded so, we, therefore, hold that the appellant was entitled for the benefit of regularisation in the circumstances narrated above and accordingly, the conclusion drawn by the learned Single Judge to refuse the mandamus cannot be sustained.

    25. In view of that, the judgement and order of the learned Single Judge dated 02.04.2010 is set aside. The writ petition as well as the appeal are allowed. Respondent no. 2-Regional Joint Director of Education, Basti, shall proceed to consider the claim of regularisation of the appellant in the light of the observations made hereinabove and issue appropriate orders, not later than six weeks from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order before him, if the appellant is otherwise eligible and qualified.

    26. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Firangi Prasad v. State Of U.P & Others
    (Nov 11, 2010)