Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case involves a dispute over inheritance and partition of a 9.88-acre property jointly owned by two brothers, Jhangal and Dakhal, members of the Gond caste, a Scheduled Tribe. Plaintiffs Sawango and Jaituniya are daughters of Jhangal, while defendant Urchamahin is the daughter-in-law of Dakhal, and Kismat Singh is likely an illegitimate grandson of Balam Singh, son of Dakhal. The plaintiffs claimed succession according to Hindu law, while respondents contended that their own customary law applied. The trial court decreed a partition in favor of the plaintiffs for half the property, but this was reversed by the lower appellate court, which dismissed the suit. The present second appeal challenges this reversal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in view of Section 6 of the Central Provinces Laws Act, 1875, the Court can apply the principles of the Hindu Succession Act to members of Scheduled Tribes.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The plaintiffs specifically pleaded and deposed that they adopted Hindu law for succession purposes.
  • The respondents failed to prove any custom contrary to Hindu law.
  • Therefore, the suit for partition should have been decreed under Section 6 of the Central Provinces Laws Act, 1875.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The parties are members of the Scheduled Tribes, specifically the Gond caste, where daughters are not entitled to inherit property.
  • Defendant Urchamahin deposed that Jhangal died without issue and Dakhal left only one son, Balam Singh, who inherited the property.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that both parties failed to prove any customary law governing succession within their Gond caste. The Central Provinces Laws Act, 1875, particularly Sections 5 and 6, regulates inheritance and provides that in absence of any specific law or custom, courts must decide cases according to justice, equity, and good conscience. Since no applicable custom or law was established, the Court held that the rights of inheritance must be decided under Section 6 of the Act. The daughters of Jhangal, plaintiffs Sawango and Jaituniya, being the nearest relatives, are entitled to inherit their father's share. The appellate court erred in dismissing the suit without applying Section 6. Hence, the trial court's judgment favoring the plaintiffs was restored.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is ALLOWED. The judgment and decree of the lower appellate court are set aside, and the trial court's judgment and decree are restored. The parties shall bear their own costs. This decision directs that in the absence of any proven customary law governing inheritance among Scheduled Tribes, courts must apply the principles of justice, equity, and good conscience under Section 6 of the Central Provinces Laws Act, 1875. No new precedent beyond this specific application was established.

    Sarwango v. Urchamahin

    JUDGMENT

    1. The present second appeal has been admitted for consideration on the following substantial question of law:-

    “Whether in view of Section 6 of Central Provinces Laws Act, 1875 the Court can apply the principles of Hindu Succession Act to the members of Scheduled Tribes ?

    2. Vide judgment & decree dated 2.5.1994 the Additional District Judge, Surajpur, in Civil Appeal No. 52A/92 allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit by reversing the judgment & decree dated 10.3.92 passed by the Civil Judge Class-ll, Surajpur, in Civil Suit No. 9A/88.

    3. Undisputed facts of the case, Jhangal and Dakhal were two brothers. Plaintiffs Sawango and Jaituniya are daughters of Jhangal, defendant Urchamahin was daughter-in-law of Dakhal, brother of Jhangal and Kismat Singh was probably illegitimate grandson of Balam Singh i.e son of Dakhal. Both brothers Jhangal and Dakhal were joint owner of the property situated at village Kurwa, tahsil Surajpur i.e.9.88 acres, they were by caste Gond. As per plaint allegation, they follow the Hindu law for their succession, but as per respondents allegation, they were having their own custom for succession.

    4. After providing opportunity of hearing to the parties, the trial Court has decreed the suit for partition to the extent of half share in favour of the plaintiffs, but same has been reversed by the lower appellate Court.

    5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the judgment & decree impugned, judgment & decree of the trial Court and records of the Courts below.

    6. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the plaintiffs have specifically pleaded and deposed that they have adopted the Hindu law, especially for the purpose of succession, but the respondents have failed to prove the custom contrary to the Hindu law, therefore, suit ought to have decreed even in terms of Section 6 of the Central Provinces Laws Act, 1875 (for short ‘the Act’).

    7. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No. 2 opposes the appeal and submits that the parties are members of Scheduled Tribes and in their caste Gond i.e Gond caste, daughters are not entitled to inherit the property left by their father. Defendant No. 1 Urchamahin has specifically deposed that Jhangal died issueless, Dakhal died leaving only son Balam Singh who has inherited the property left by both brothers.

    8. Indisputably, it was joint property of Jhangal and Dakhal. Defendants are heirs of Dakhal and the plaintiffs are heirs of Jhangal. Both the parties have failed to prove any custom governing succession in their caste.

    9. The Central Provinces Laws Act, 1875 has been enacted to regulate the inheritance, special property of females, betrothal, marriage, dower, adoption and other system and customs. Sections 5 and 6 of the Act reads thus:

    “5. Rule of decision in cases of certain classes.- In questions regarding inheritance, special property of females, betrothal, marriage, dower, adoption, guardianship, minority, bastardy, family relations, wills, legacies, gifts, partitions or any religious usage or institution, the rule of decision shall be the Muhammadan Law in cases where the parties are Muhammadans, and the Hindu Law in cases where the parties are Hindus, except in so far as such law has been by the legislative enactment altered or abolished, or is opposed to the provisions of this Act:

    Provided that when among any class or body of persons or among the members of any family any custom prevails which is inconsistent with the law applicable between such persons under this section, and which if not inconsistent with such law, would have been given effect to as legally binding, such custom shall, notwithstanding anything herein contained, be given effect to.

    6. Rules in cases not expressly provided for.- In cases not provided for by section 5, or by any law for the time being in force, the Courts shall act according to justice, equity and good conscience.”

    10. In the present case, both the parties have failed to prove any law of inheritance or custom prevailing in their Gond caste i.e member of Scheduled Caste whom Hindu law or other law governing inheritance is not applicable. In absence of any law of inheritance or custom prevailing in their caste governing the inheritance the Courts are required to decide the rights according to justice, equity and good conscience in term of Section 6 of the Act. Plaintiffs Sawango and Jaituniya are daughters of Jhangal, nearest relative rather the respondents, who were daughter-in-law of brother of Jhangal and legitimate or illegitimate son of Balam Singh, son of Dakhal.

    11. In these circumstances, plaintiffs Sawango and Jaituniya would be the persons' best entitlement to inherit the property left by their father. The Courts below ought to have decreed the suit for partition to the extent of share of Jhangal, but the Court below i.e the lower appellate Court has allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit in absence of any law or custom for inheritance for a member of Schedule Tribe. The Courts below are required to decide their rights of inheritance in accordance with the provisions of Section 6 of the Act applicable to the State of Chhattisgarh and undivided State of Madhya Pradesh.

    12. Consequently, substantial question of law formulated for the decision of this appeal is decided as positive with a modification that in absence of any such law of inheritance the Courts are required to decide the question of inheritance according to justice, equity and good conscience.

    13. On the basis of finding on substantial question of law, the appeal deserves to be allowed and is hereby allowed. Judgment & decree of the lower appellate Court are hereby set aside and judgment & decree of the trial Court are hereby restored.

    14. Parties shall bear the cost of the appeal.

    15. Advocate fees as per schedule.

    16. Decree be drawn up accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sarwango v. Urchamahin
    (Jan 4, 2013)