Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Municipal Rules and Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act.
  • Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act (Bom. 3 of 1901),
  • Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act. Although S. 73 of that Act
  • provisions of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act
  • Section 59 of the Bombay District Municipal Act,
  • Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act,
  • Section 60 of the Bombay District Municipal Act,
  • SECTION 100 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1908,
  • Article 132 of the Limitation Act,
  • Bombay District Municipal Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Municipal Rules and Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act.
  • Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act (Bom. 3 of 1901),
  • Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act. Although S. 73 of that Act
  • provisions of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act
  • Section 59 of the Bombay District Municipal Act,
  • Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act,
  • Section 60 of the Bombay District Municipal Act,
  • SECTION 100 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1908,
  • Article 132 of the Limitation Act,
  • Bombay District Municipal Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Municipality of Athni (plaintiff) sued the defendant, owner of certain properties within the municipal district, to recover arrears of house-tax and a general sanitary cess for a period extending over twelve years prior to the suit, together with interest. The defendant pleaded, inter alia, that the claim was barred by limitation.

At trial the court held the claim to the general sanitary cess barred by limitation but allowed the claim to the house-tax, passing a decree for Rs. 332 with interest and directing recovery by sale of the properties described in the plaint. Both parties appealed: the plaintiff appealed the rejection of the sanitary cess claim; the defendant appealed the decree against him.

The first appellate court (learned Assistant Judge) disallowed the claim to interest but allowed the municipality's claims to both house-tax and general sanitary cess, holding they were not barred by limitation. The defendant (appellant) then appealed to the court that produced the present opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the municipality's claim for arrears of house-tax and general sanitary cess is governed by Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1908 (action for money charged on immovable property?) or by Article 132 of the Limitation Act (actions to enforce a charge on immovable property), i.e., whether Article 132 applies making the claims subject to the 12-year period applicable to charges on immovable property.
  2. Whether sums due by way of general sanitary cess (as imposed under the municipal rules) constitute a "tax imposed in the form of a rate on lands or buildings" within the meaning of Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act, and therefore form a first charge on the land or building.
  3. Whether the levy of the general sanitary cess in the form adopted by the Athni Municipality was ultra vires the municipality's powers under Sections 59 and 60 of the Bombay District Municipal Act and the municipality's rules (Schedule E to R. 232 of the Athni Municipality Rules).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Defendant's) Arguments — Mr. Jahagirdar

  • The municipality's claim is a claim for money payable by the defendant and therefore governed by Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1908, not Article 132.
  • Article 132, as applied by the lower appellate court, applies only to claims to enforce payment of money which are charged on immovable property by agreement of the parties; it does not apply to charges not created by agreement.
  • Section 87 should be read as applying only to house-tax (the tax specified in Section 59(a)(i)), and not to other taxes such as the general sanitary cess; thus the general sanitary cess is not a rate on buildings and cannot be a first charge under Section 87.
  • The appellant relied (by reference) to a decision reported at 35 Bom. L.R. 599 for the proposition that the general sanitary cess cannot be made a charge on property.

Respondent's (Municipality / Lower Courts') Position

  • The lower courts treated both the house-tax and the general sanitary cess as taxes imposed in the form of a rate on lands or buildings and therefore as sums that form a first charge on the land or building under Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act.
  • The municipality made rules under Section 60 (Schedule E to R. 232 of the Athni Municipality Rules) selecting the general sanitary cess (Section 59(vii)) and specifying the class of property and the rate/amount (e.g., houses assessed at house-tax of Rs. 3 or more pay Rs. 1-8-0 per annum), thereby manifesting an intention to impose the cess in the form of a rate assessed on buildings.
  • By reason of the municipal rules and Section 87, sums due on account of taxes imposed in the form of a rate are first charges on the property and therefore Article 132 of the Limitation Act applies, making the claim within time (12 years).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Reported at 35 Bom. L.R. 599 Cited for the view that a general sanitary cess cannot be made a charge on property (decision based on provisions of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act and Bandra Municipality rules). The court distinguished this authority: it noted the decision rested on the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act and the Bandra rules, which differ from the Bombay District Municipal Act and the Athni rules under consideration here; therefore the case was not treated as binding authority governing the present dispute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining statutory provisions and the municipal rules actually framed by the Athni Municipality, without expanding beyond the materials in the record.

  1. The court accepted that the house-tax clearly falls within the description "a rate on lands or buildings or both" and that under Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act all sums due on account of any tax imposed in that form are a first charge upon the building or land in respect of which such tax is leviable. Consequently, sums due as house-tax are within the class of charges contemplated by Section 87.
  2. The appellant contended that Article 132 should not apply because it is limited to charges created by agreement. The court rejected this narrow construction: it noted Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act recognises that a "charge" may arise by operation of law and is not restricted to charges by agreement; similarly, the charge in respect of house-tax arises by municipal rules together with Section 87.
  3. Turning to the general sanitary cess, the court reviewed Section 59 of the Bombay District Municipal Act which enumerates several types of taxes the municipality may impose, including (vii) a general sanitary cess for public latrines and refuse removal. Section 60 prescribes the procedure and empowers the municipality to select a tax and frame rules specifying the class of property liable and the rate or amount.
  4. The Athni Municipality, exercising the power in Section 60, framed rules (Schedule E to R. 232) selecting the general sanitary cess and specifying the class ("All buildings and houses") and the basis for computing the amount (linked to house-tax assessment). Prima facie that method of computation makes the cess take the form of a rate on buildings within the meaning of Section 87.
  5. The court addressed the appellant's argument that Section 87 and related provisions were intended to apply only to the tax expressly described in Section 59(a)(i) (a rate on buildings or lands) and not to other taxes. The court distinguished the textual phrases in Sections 68 and 87, noting they speak of "any tax imposed in the form of a rate on buildings or lands or on both" and thus are not restricted to the first class alone; accordingly, where another tax (such as the general sanitary cess) is in fact imposed in the form of a rate on buildings, Sections 68 and 87 apply.
  6. The court considered the cited authority (35 Bom. L.R. 599) which supported the contrary view but concluded that that decision turned on different statutory provisions (the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act) and the specific rules of the Bandra Municipality, facts which differ from the present case; therefore it did not control the present controversy.
  7. The appellant also argued that where the legislature expressly permitted certain taxes to be imposed as rates (e.g., water-rates) but omitted such express provision for the general sanitary cess, the omission should imply denial of the power. The court rejected a strict application of expressio unius, explaining that Section 60 gives broad rule-making powers to the municipality to specify rates or bases for computation and that the enumerations referred to in other clauses are not intended to limit the general power. The court held the power under Section 60(a)(iv) was sufficiently wide to permit the municipality to impose the general sanitary cess in the form of a rate on buildings or lands.
  8. Having concluded the general sanitary cess as levied was lawfully imposed in the form of a rate on buildings or lands, the court held it is a first charge under Section 87 and therefore the municipality's claim to recover arrears of that tax within twelve years is timely under Article 132 of the Limitation Act.
  9. The court further corrected an aspect of the decree: since the tax is recoverable from the particular properties in respect of which it is levied, the decree should direct sales of the different properties of the defendant corresponding to the sums due on each; the decree was to be amended accordingly.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The court held that both the house-tax and the general sanitary cess, as imposed by the Athni Municipality rules and within the framework of the Bombay District Municipal Act, are taxes imposed in the form of a rate on buildings or lands and therefore constitute a first charge on the respective properties under Section 87. Consequently, the municipality's claims to recover arrears of these taxes for twelve years are within time under Article 132 of the Limitation Act, 1908.

Implications:

  • The municipality may recover arrears of both house-tax and the general sanitary cess as claimed; the claims are not barred by limitation because Article 132 applies.
  • The decree will be amended to direct sale of the specific properties in respect of which the various sums are due (i.e., separate realization from the respective properties), and the appeal is dismissed with costs.
  • The court distinguished an earlier decision (35 Bom. L.R. 599) and based its conclusion on the particular statutory scheme and municipal rules before it; the opinion does not expressly state that it establishes a novel binding precedent beyond its application to the facts and legal provisions considered.

    Shidrao Narayanrao Gumaste Patil v. Municipality Of Athni

    1. This is a second appeal from a decision of the learned Assistant Judge of Belgaum. The plaintiff, the Municipality of Athni, instituted this action against the defendant, who is an owner of certain properties situated within the municipal district, to recover arrears of house-tax and general sanitary cess due from him for a period extending over 12 years before the suit and also interest on those arrears. The defendant contended inter alia that the claim was barred by limitation. The trial Court thought that the claim to the general sanitary cess was so barred, but allowed the claim to the house-tax and passed a decree for the said tax in the amount of Rs. 332 with interest thereon. It directed that the tax should be recovered by sale of the properties described in the plaint belonging to the defendant. Against that decree both parties appealed. The plaintiff appealed against the rejection of the claim to the general sanitary cess, while the defendant appealed against the decree against him. The learned Assistant Judge in first appeal disallowed the claim to interest but allowed the claim of the municipality to the house-tax and general sanitary cess holding that it was not barred by limitation. Against that decree the defendant has appealed. Mr. Jahagirdar for the appellant in view of the written statement has not questioned the legality of the imposition. But he maintains that the claim of the municipality being for money payable by the defendant, is governed by Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1908, and not by Article 132 of the of that Act which has been applied by the lower appellate Court. The learned Assistant Judge thought that Art. 132 applied as the sums claimed were a first charge on the properties in respect of which they were levied. In his opinion, both the house-tax and the general sanitary cess were taxes imposed in the form of a rate on lands or buildings or on both within the meaning of Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act (Bom. 3 of 1901), which regulates the recovery of taxes by the municipality and therefore by virtue of the rules of the municipality were a first charge upon the building or land, in respect of which the taxes were levied. The question with regard to the claim for house-tax presents no difficulty, for, it is conceded before me that it is a rate on lands or buildings or on both and therefore under Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act, the sums due on account of the house-tax is a first charge upon the building or land in respect of which it is leviable. Section 87 provides as follows:

    All sums due on account of any tax imposed in the form of a rate on lands or buildings or on both, mentioned in S. 68, shall…. be a first charge upon the building or land, in respect of which such tax is leviable.

    2. Mr. Jahagirdar contends that even if house-tax is a rate on lands or buildings Article 132 of the Limitation Act, will not apply, because, he says, that article applies to a claim to enforce payment of money which is by agreement of parties charged upon immovable property. There is no such qualification in the article itself and under Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, a “charge” is not restricted to a charge created by the agreement of parties. That section applies also to charges arising by the operation of law. The charge relating to a sum of money due on account of house-tax is such a charge by reason of the Municipal Rules and Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act. Therefore the claim to the house-tax is clearly in time being instituted within twelve years when it became recoverable. The claim with regard to the levy of the general sanitary cess is not so easy to determine. Section 59 of the Bombay District Municipal Act, gives the municipality the right to impose certain taxes indicated therein. Those are so far as their enumeration is material:

    (i) a rate on buildings or lands or both, situate within the municipal district;

    (vi) a special sanitary cess upon private latrines, premises or compounds cleansed by municipal agency, after notice given as hereinafter required;

    (vii) a general sanitary cess for the construction or maintenance, or both construction and maintenance, of public latrines, and for the removal and disposal of refuse.

    3. Under section 60 of the Act before imposing a tax the municipality has to observe certain preliminary procedure. It has under cl. (a)(i) to select for the purpose one or other of the taxes specified in S. 59; and under cl. (ii) to prepare rules for the purposes of cl. (i) of S. 46 prescribing the tax selected; and to specify according to cl. (iv) the amount for which, or the rate at which, it is desired to make the class or classes of persons or of property, or of both, liable. The municipality has made its choice by selecting the tax described in S. 59(vii) namely “the general sanitary cess” and under the powers conferred on it by sub-cl. (iv) of cl. (a) of s. 60 it has fixed the amount for or the rate at which the class of property of the tax-payer is liable. It has also prescribed rules under sub-cl. (ii) in accordance with cl. (i) of S. 46. That rule is in Sch. E to R. 232 of the Athni Municipality Rules. Serial No. 4 of the Schedule deals with the general sanitary cess. The class of property made liable is stated in col. 3 as follows: — “All buildings and houses”. Then follows in col. 4 the amount for and the rate at which such class of property is made liable and it provides that houses which are assessed at house tax of Rs. 3 or more are liable to pay a tax of Rs. 1-8-0 per annum (see col. 5) and houses assessed at less than Rs. 3, half the amount of house tax.

    4. Apparently according to that rule the amount of the tax is to be computed according to the annual rental or rate at which the building is assessed. That is the basis for fixing the tax. Prima facie, therefore, the tax assumes the form of a rate on building within Section 87 of the Act. Mr. Jahagirdar contends that the imposition of this tax is not a rate on building, and that S. 87 applies only to house-tax or in other words tax mentioned in S. 59(a)(i), that is, “a rate on buildings or lands or both, situate within the municipal district” and not to any other tax in whatever form it may be imposed. That is his first line of argument. The legislature in dealing with the first class of taxes in S. 59 has described it as “a rate on buildings or lands.” Section 63 which deals with assessment of liability for rates says:

    (1) When a rate on buildings or lands or both is imposed, the municipality shall cause an assessment list of all buildings, or lands, or buildings and lands in the municipal district to be prepared containing [several particulars].

    5. It evidently deals with the first class of taxes, namely, “the rate on buildings or lands.” But the language of S. 68, to which reference is made in S. 87, recognizes a distinction between “a rate on buildings or lands” and “a tax imposed in the form of a rate on lands or buildings or on both.” Section 68 says:

    Every tax imposed in the form of a rate on buildings or lands or on both, shall be leviable primarily from the actual occupier of the property upon which the said taxes are assessed, if he is the owner of the buildings or land, etc.

    6. The phraseology in S. 87 follows s. 68 for it says: “All sums due on account of any tax imposed in the form of a rate on lands or buildings or on both.” Mr. Jahagirdar contends that both Ss. 68 and 87 are intended to deal with the tax specified in S. 59(a)(i) that is, a rate or tax on buildings or lands and therefore may well apply to house-tax alone. It is difficult to agree with that view, for the language is intended to cover any other tax which is imposed in the form of a rate on buildings or lands. I was referred to the case in 35 Bom. L.R 5991 for the view that the general sanitary cess cannot be made a charge on property. That case was decided by reference to certain provisions of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act (Bom. 18 of 1925) and the rules of the Bandra Municipality. Here we are not dealing with the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act. Although S. 73 of that Act is in pari materia with Section 59 of the Bombay District Municipal Act, we do not know in what form the rules were framed by the Bandra Municipality. I do not think in the view I take of the Bombay District Municipal Act and the rules of the Athni Municipality that decision would been authority governing the present case. The question as to the legality of the imposition was never directly raised in the lower Courts. If the imposition is legal, then undoubtedly under Section 87 of the Bombay District Municipal Act, it would be a first charge on the building or land and therefore Article 132 of the Limitation Act, would apply.

    7. In my opinion, the form in which the tax is imposed is legal. As I have said, Section 60 of the Bombay District Municipal Act, gives the power to the municipality to frame rules specifying the amount for which, or the rate at which, it is desired to make the classes of property referred to in cl. (iii) liable. Clause (iii) of that section confers the power on the municipality to make rules specifying the class or classes of persons or of property, or of both, which the municipality desires to make liable. The municipality having made its selection of the tax under S. 60(a)(i), it has to say under cl. (iv) at what rate it shall be recovered, and for that purpose it can specify the manner in which that rate can be fixed or lay down the basis for computing the amount of the tax. In so doing, the municipality may say that the rate shall take the form of a rate assessed on buildings. Prima facie, a rule of that kind is therefore within its powers. But it is pointed out that wherever the Legislature contemplated that the municipality after selecting a tax specified in S. 59 should have the power to impose that tax in the form of a rate assessed on buildings or lands, it has conferred that power expressly, and that having omitted to do so in the case of the “general sanitary cess” it must be deemed to have denied such power to the municipality. In support of that view, I was referred to S. 59(b)(viii) which says as follows:

    a water-rate or water-rates, for water supplied by the municipality, which may be imposed in the form of a rate assessed on buildings and lands.

    8. Similarly clause (c) of the proviso to that section says:

    the municipality in lieu of imposing separately any two or more of the taxes described in cls. (i), (vii), (viii) and (ix) may impose a consolidated tax assessed as a rate on buildings or lands, or both situate within the municipal district.

    9. The rule expressio unius est exclusio alterius has to be applied with great caution, for, it is not of universal application and it cannot be applied unless the statute by its language shows that all things different in genus and description from those which are enumerated are intended to be excluded. The above clauses are in my opinion merely enumerative. When the Act gives general powers to the municipality to fix the amount or rate at which it desires to make the class or classes of persons or property liable, it is not proper to suggest that, because some specific instances are enumerated wherein it is said that the municipality can impose rates upon certain basis, such enumeration has the effect of limiting the municipality's choice of the bases upon which the taxes can be levied. The powers conferred on the municipality by S. 60(a)(iv) are, in my opinion, sufficiently wide to permit it to impose the general sanitary cess in the form of a rate on building or land, and there is no inconsistency in the rules framed by the municipality.

    10. Therefore, I do not think that the levy is ultra vires of the municipality. Consequently, the tax selected being in the form of a rate assessed on buildings or lands or on both, is a first charge on the building under Section 87 of the Act, and therefore the claim of the municipality to recover the arrears of that tax for twelve years is within time under Article 132 of the Limitation Act. Consequently this appeal fails and will be dismissed with costs. It is said that as the tax is recoverable from the property in respect of which it is levied, the decree should have directed the sales of the different properties of the plaintiff in respect of which the various sums are due. That is correct and the decree shall be amended accordingly. In other respects it is maintained.

    11. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shidrao Narayanrao Gumaste Patil v. Municipality Of Athni
    (Mar 6, 1942)