Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On 24 March 1930 R.E. Thompson applied for a United Kingdom patent for improvements in thin flexible safety razor blades intended to be bent transversely and maintained in a curved position during use. A UK patent issued on 24 September 1931 (specification and Controller's certificate are Ex. D). Thompson claimed priority from the UK application and applied in India on 19 May 1930. An Indian patent was granted on 4 June 1931 for 16 years from 7 September 1933 (Ex. A). On 23 October 1931 Thompson assigned the Indian patent to the plaintiffs (assignment and registration certificate Ex. B). The plaintiffs sought and obtained leave to amend the Indian specification to conform with the English patent (leave granted 7 September 1933; amended specification Ex. C).

The plaintiffs sued the defendants for infringement of the Indian patent (Ex. A), alleging that since amendment the defendants had been importing, offering for sale and selling safety razor blades called "Navy Blade" or "Navy Blue Razor Blade" constructed so as to infringe the first claim of the plaintiffs' specification. A particular sale on 22 October 1936 to J.C. Santos of Bandra (six cartons, each containing five blades) was pleaded. The plaintiffs sought an injunction and damages.

In their written statement the defendants admitted acting as selling agents in India for the Triangle Mechanical Laboratories Corporation (U.S.) and admitted importing and selling "Navy" blades, but raised multiple defenses: denial that Thompson was the first and true inventor; denial that the alleged improvements constituted patentable invention; assertions of lack of novelty and lack of utility; allegation that the amendment was unauthorized and obtained by misrepresentation; denial of assignment; contention that the plaintiffs' blades were manufactured exclusively outside British India and that the patent should be revoked; and a counterclaim for Rs. 5,000 for threats to the defendants and their customers. The defendants later abandoned their counterclaim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Ralph Emerson Thompson was the first and true inventor of the improvements in or relating to blades for safety razors?
  2. Whether the alleged improvements were inventions which could be the subject matter of a valid grant of Letters Patent?
  3. Whether there was any novelty in the alleged invention at the date of the grant?
  4. Whether the alleged invention had any utility?
  5. Whether the alleged amendment of the specification was authorized and valid in law?
  6. Whether the specification and claims are vague and ambiguous?
  7. Whether the specification is insufficient?
  8. Whether the grant was obtained by misrepresentation?
  9. Whether the grant of Letters Patent is valid?
  10. Whether there was a valid assignment?
  11. Whether there was any infringement or threatened infringement?
  12. Whether the plaintiffs' safety razor blades are manufactured exclusively outside British India, and whether the plaintiffs' patent is liable to be revoked?
  13. Whether the plaintiffs have suffered any damages or loss of profits or are exposed to further loss or damage?
  14. Whether the defendants are liable for the said loss or damage?
  15. Whether the plaintiffs threatened the defendants and their customers by circulars, advertisements and notices with legal proceedings?
  16. What damage did the defendants suffer and whether the plaintiffs are liable to pay the same?
  17. Generally.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Claims

  • The plaintiffs allege that the defendants have been importing, offering for sale and selling razor blades ("Navy Blade"/"Navy Blue Razor Blade") constructed so as to infringe the first claim of the (amended) Indian patent (Ex. A).
  • The plaintiffs relied on their registered patent (assignment from Thompson recorded) and the leave to amend the specification to bring the Indian patent into conformity with the English patent.
  • The plaintiffs sought an injunction and damages for infringement; they indicated willingness to accept nominal damages (assessed at Re. 1) in the proceedings before the court.

Defendants' Defences

  • Admitted they were selling agents in India for the U.S. manufacturer and that they imported and sold the named blades.
  • Denied that Thompson was the first and true inventor of the improvements.
  • Denied that the alleged improvements constituted patentable invention, asserting lack of novelty and lack of utility.
  • Alleged that the amendment of the specification was unauthorized, invalid and obtained by misrepresentation (fraud).
  • Denied the alleged assignment to the plaintiffs.
  • Asserted the plaintiffs' blades were manufactured exclusively outside British India and submitted that the patent was liable to be revoked under the statute.
  • Counterclaimed Rs. 5,000 for alleged threats to defendants and their customers (this counterclaim was later abandoned).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(1906) 24 RPC 1411 at p. 151 Requirement that particulars be given as to whom the defendant alleges to be the true and first inventor—so as to inform the plaintiff and remove ambiguity in the objection. The court noted this authority in relation to Issue 1 and observed that the defendants had given no particulars as to whom they alleged to be the true and first inventor; the citation supported the court's expectation of particularisation by the defendants.
(1888) 5 RPC 198 (Kekewich J.) Commercial success and rapid sale of an article shortly after manufacture and sale is cogent evidence of novelty (and of utility)—it may be evidence that prior knowledge did not give an obvious clue to the invention. The court cited this passage when discussing novelty (Issues 3 and 4) to explain that practical utility and commercial success are relevant factors when assessing whether an asserted invention was obvious.
(1885) 2 RPC 1553 (Kay J.) The fact that a patent has been infringed is strong evidence of the utility of the invention. The court relied on this authority when discussing utility, noting that attempted infringement can be regarded as evidence of utility in assessing Issue 4.
(1893) 10 RPC 1064 (Lord Justice Bowen) Remarks on imitation and the inference that imitation or infringement is an indicator of utility and commercial worth. The court referenced Bowen LJ's remarks (and an accompanying quotation from Swan) in the general discussion supporting the proposition that imitation/infringement may be relevant evidence of an invention's utility and worth.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by addressing specific legal points raised by the pleadings and statutory provisions, applying authorities cited in the opinion and the statutory framework of the Patents and Designs Act, 1911.

On procedural and evidentiary matters relating to Issue 1 (first and true inventor), the court relied on the authority that defendants should particularise whom they allege to be the true and first inventor; the defendants failed to provide any such particulars and the court recorded that omission.

On novelty and utility (Issues 3 and 4) the court recounted principles from treatises and cases: if the new result was long sought after or solved a longstanding problem, that tends to show the prior art did not render the result obvious; mere simplicity is not necessarily fatal; a "scintilla" of invention may suffice; and commercial success or prompt imitation can be cogent evidence of novelty and utility. The court referenced Kekewich J.'s observation that quick commercial acceptance is cogent evidence of novelty, and Kay J.'s remark that attempted infringement is strong evidence of utility. The court also cited observations about imitation from Bowen LJ and a passage from Swan to reinforce that inference.

On Issue 5 (amendment of the specification), the court applied Section 17 of the Patents and Designs Act, 1911, observing that sub-section (8) provides that leave to amend is conclusive as to the right to make the amendment except in cases of fraud, and that the amendment, once advertised, is deemed to form part of the specification. The defendants had alleged the amendment was obtained by misrepresentation but produced no evidence of fraud. Given the certificate evidencing grant of leave to amend, the court held the granting of leave to amend was conclusive on that point.

On Issue 10 (assignment), the court observed that S.63(3) permits assignment by the person registered as proprietor and S.2(12) defines "patentee" by reference to registration. The assignment and the Controller's certificate of registration were produced; therefore the plaintiffs were the registered assignees and entitled to enforce the patent.

On Issue 12 (manufacture outside British India and revocation), the court analysed Section 23 of the Act. That section permits an application to the Governor-General in Council for revocation on the ground of exclusive or main manufacture outside British India, not earlier than four years after the patent date, but requires the applicant to show readiness to manufacture locally and to have applied for a license from the patentee; if the Governor-General, after inquiry, is satisfied and the patentee refuses reasonable terms, revocation may follow. The defendants conceded they had made no application to the plaintiffs for a license and had made no application to the Governor-General under S.23. Consequently, the court held the defendants could not invoke S.23 to seek revocation. The court also noted S.29 entitles the patentee to sue anyone who makes, sells or uses the invention without license during the patent's term, supporting plaintiffs' right to sue despite manufacture abroad.

After consideration of the evidence (the opinion states "After discussing evidence the judgment proceeded further"), the court concluded the plaintiffs had established the validity of their patent and had made out a case of infringement. The fact that the plaintiffs' blades were manufactured exclusively outside British India was deemed immaterial in the circumstances of this case and did not render the patent liable to revocation.

On damages (Issues 13 and 14) the plaintiffs' counsel informed the court the plaintiffs would accept nominal damages; the court assessed damages at Re. 1 and answered Issues 13 and 14 in the affirmative (i.e., those matters resolved in plaintiffs' favour). Issues 15 and 16 (relating to the defendants' counterclaim) were no longer live because the counterclaim was abandoned; the court therefore dismissed the counterclaim with costs.

The court certified under Section 32 of the Act that the validity of the patent came in question in the suit (entitling the plaintiff, in a subsequent suit in that Court on the same patent, to recover full costs if the plaintiff again succeeds, subject to the court's direction). The court directed the Prothonotary and Senior Master to send a copy of the decree to the Controller for entry in the register of patents and ordered the exhibits to be returned to the parties subject to an order in that behalf.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court entered a decree in favour of the plaintiffs: it held the plaintiffs' patent valid, found that the defendants had infringed the patent, granted an injunction in terms of the plaint, awarded nominal damages of Re. 1, and awarded costs to the plaintiffs. The defendants' counterclaim was dismissed with costs.

Implications:

  • The plaintiffs are entitled to enforce the Indian patent despite the plaintiffs' blades being manufactured exclusively outside British India; the defendants' failure to pursue the statutory remedy under S.23 or to seek a license from the patentee precluded revocation on that ground in this litigation.
  • The leave to amend the specification (granted and evidenced by the Controller's certificate) was held conclusive in the absence of proof of fraud; the amendment was therefore valid for all courts and purposes (per S.17, as applied).
  • The assignment to the plaintiffs was treated as valid and registered (per S.63(3) and S.2(12)), enabling the plaintiffs to sue as proprietors of the patent.
  • The decision gave the plaintiffs injunctive relief, a nominal damages award (Re. 1), costs, and a certificate under S.32 that the patent's validity was in question in the suit (relevant to costs in subsequent suits on the same patent).
  • No broader or novel legal precedent is stated to have been created by the judgment; the court applied established statutory provisions and cited established authorities in reaching its conclusions. The direct effect is the relief awarded to the plaintiffs and the dismissal of the defendants' counterclaim.

Order: Decree for plaintiffs in terms described above; exhibits to be returned subject to order; Prothonotary and Senior Master to notify the Controller for register entry; certificate under S.32 granted.

    Gillette Industries Ltd. v. Yeshwant Brothers

    1. On 24th March 1930, R.E Thompson applied for a patent in the United Kingdom relating to improvements in safety razor blades of the thin flexible type having external cutting edges and a medial slot and which were intended to be bent transversely and maintained in a position of curvature during use. A patent was granted to him in the United Kingdom on 24th September 1931. The specification and the certificate of the Controller relating to the granting of that patent are Ex. D. On 19th May 1930 R.E Thompson made an application for a similar patent in India and he claimed the priority date of the United Kingdom patent. On 4th June 1931 a patent was granted to him in India for 16 years from 7th September 1933 and the certificate of the Controller and the patent specification are Ex. A. On 23rd October 1931 the Indian patent was assigned by Thompson to the plaintiffs. The assignment and the certificate of the Controller as to registration thereof are Ex. B (collectively). On 10th September 1932 the plaintiffs applied for leave to amend the Indian patent in order to bring that patent into conformity with the English patent. Leave to amend was granted on 7th September 1933 and the certificate of the Controller and the patent specification as amended are Ex. C. The plaintiffs bring this action against the defendants for infringement of the patent, Ex. A. They allege that the defendants since the patent was amended have infringe ed and threatened and intend to infringe their patent in that they have been importing into British India offering for sale and selling safety razor blades bearing the name “Navy Blade” or “Navy Blue Razor Blade” so constructed as to infringe the first claim in their specification. They allege that on 22nd October 1936 the defendants sold to J.C Santos of Bandra six cartons of “Navy Blue Razor Blades” or “Navy Blades,” each carton containing five “Blades” so constructed as to infringe their patent. The plaintiffs accordingly claim an injunction and damages.

    2. The defendants in their written statement admit that they are the selling agents in India of the “Navy Blade” and the “Navy Blue” razor blade manufactured by the Triangle Mechanical Laboratories Corporation of the United States of America and admit that they have been importing into and selling in India “Navy Blades” and “Navy Blue Blades.” Among other defences however they deny that Thompson was the first and true inventor of any improvements in or relating to blades for safety razors, and they deny that the alleged improvements were an invention which could be the subject-matter of a valid grant of Letters Patent. They say further that there was no novelty in the alleged invention at the date of the grant, and no utility therein. They also say that the amendment of the specification was unauthorized and invalid in law and was obtained by misrepresentation. They deny the alleged assignment. They say further that the plaintiffs' razor blades are manufactured exclusively outside British India and that the plaintiffs' patent is liable to be revoked and they submit that it should be revoked. They allege further that the plaintiffs have threatened them and their customers by circulars, advertisements and notices with legal proceedings and they counterclaim Rs. 5000 damages therefor. Such a claim is contemplated by Section 36 of the Patent and Designs Act, 1911, though that section provides that it is not applicable if an action for infringement of the patent is commenced and prosecuted with due diligence as has been the fact in the present case. The issues raised are as follows:

    (1) Whether Ralph Emerson Thompson was the first and true inventor of the improvements in or relating to blades for safety razor? (2) Whether the alleged improvements were inventions which could be the subject matter of a valid grant of the Letters Patent? (3) Whether there was any novelty in the alleged invention at the date of the grant? (4) Whether the alleged Invention had any utility? (5) Whether the alleged amendment of the specification was authorized and valid in law? (6) Whether the specification and claims are vague and ambiguous? (7) Whether the specification is insufficient? (8) Whether the grant was obtained by misrepresentation? (9) Whether the grant of Letters Patent is valid? (10) Whether there was a valid assignment? (11) Whether there was any infringement or threatened infringement? (12) Whether the plaintiffs' safety razor blades are manufactured exclusively outside British India, and whether the plaintiffs' patent is liable to be revoked? (13) Whether the plaintiffs have Buffered any damages or loss of profits or whether the plaintiffs are exposed to further loss or damage? (14) Whether the defendants are liable for the said loss or damage? (15) Whether the plaintiffs threatened the defendants and their customers by circulars, advertisements and notices with legal proceedings? (16) What damage did the defendants suffer and whether the plaintiffs are liable to pay the same, and (17) Generally.

    3. It will be convenient briefly to refer to certain matters of law arising in connexion with some of these issues. Issue 1 raises the question whether Thompson was the first and true inventor of the improvements. In Edn. 8 of Terrell on Patents at p. 396 it is stated that particulars should be given as to whom the defendant alleges to be the true and first inventor. It is pointed out that this has the effect both of informing the plaintiff of the case he has to meet and of removing any ambiguity which might arise from the bare statement of this objection, and (1906) 24 RPC 1411 at p. 151 is cited. In this connexion it may be here pointed out that the defendants have given no particulars whatever an to whom they allege to be the true and first inventor. Issues 3 and 4 deal with questions of novelty and utility. The question of novelty is dealt with at some length at p. 66 and the following pages of Terrell on Patents. It is there pointed out that if it can be shown that the new result was long sought for, that persons skilled in the art had been working without success to attain it, and had long regarded it as a problem, and that the invention of the patentee successfully solved the problem—then such a state of affairs constitutes evidence of the strongest kind that the prior knowledge did not in fact give an obvious clue to the solution and ought not to be considered as destroying “subject-matter.” It is further pointed out that mere simplicity is not necessarily an objection, that a mere scintilla of invention is sufficient, especially where the appreciation of a desideratum is one of the important features of the invention and that there may be invention in improvements in what is merely simplification, though matters of ordinary skilled designing or mere workshop improvements cannot be considered as requiring the exercise of invention. It is further pointed out that the practical utility and commercial success of the invention may be a material factor in determining whether the new result was obvious or not. In his judgment in (1888) 5 RPC 198,2 Kekewich J. stated as follows (p. 205):

    If within a short time of the first manufacture and sale an article of commerce commands a ready and extensive sale, that feet, which is proof of utility, must also be accepted as evidence, not conclusive but cogent of novelty.

    4. As to utility it is stated at page 111 of Terrell's work that the fact that the patent has been infringed is evidence of utility. (1885) 2 RPC 1553 is cited, where Kay J. said (p. 160):

    Better evidence of the utility of an invention cannot possibly be had than the fact that the defendant has attempted to infringe it,

    5. And a reference is made to the remarks of Lord Justice Bowen in (1893) 10 RPC 1064 at p. 111. In Swan's Patents, Designs and Trade Marks the author says as follows (p. 126):

    There is one form of flattery which even the vanity of an inventor does not relish, and that is the flattery of imitation. It is however the inevitable reward of a successful invention and the most signal mark of admiration that the public are wont to pay to inventive achievement. One might almost say ‘Happy the inventor whose patent is infringed’ for that is the surest sign that he has devised something of utility and worth.

    6. Issue 5 raises the question whether the amendment of the specification was authorized and valid in law. Section 17 of the Patents and Designs Act, 1911, deals with applications to amend patents, and sub-s. (8) provides that leave to amend shall be conclusive as to the right of the party to make the amendment allowed, except in case of fraud; and the amendment shall be advertised in the prescribed manner, and shall in all Courts and for all purposes be deemed to form part of the application or specification. The defendants, although they allege in their written statement that the amendment was obtained by misrepresentation, have offered no evidence whatever of fraud in connexion with the obtaining of the amendment and it is, in my opinion, perfectly plain that the granting of leave to amend which is established by the certificate put in this case is conclusive upon that matter. Issue 10 questions the validity of the assignment. S. 63(3) of the Act permits the person registered as the proprietor of a patent to assign the patent, and S. 2(12) defines ‘patentee’ as the person for the time being entered on the register of patents kept under the Act as the grantee or proprietor of the patent. The assignment has been produced and there is a certificate of the Controller of the registration of that assignment. The plaintiffs therefore are clearly assignees of the patent, and as such are entitled to enforce it.

    7. Issue 12 raises the question whether the plaintiffs' safety razor blades are manufactured exclusively outside British India, and whether the plaintiffs' patent is liable to be revoked. It is admitted that the plaintiffs' razor blades are manufactured exclusively outside British India, but in my opinion, for reasons which I will mention that fact is entirely irrelevant. S. 23 of the Act deals with this question.

    8. It provides that at any time not less than four years after the date of a patent granted under the Act, any person may apply to the Governor-General in Council for relief under the section on the ground that the patented article or process is manufactured or carried on exclusively or mainly outside British India. Sub-s. (2) provides that if the Governor-General in Council after inquiry is satisfied that the allegations are correct and that the applicant is prepared and is in a position to manufacture or carry on the patented article or process in British India, and that the patentee refuses to grant a license on reasonable terms, then he may make an order revoking the patent. It is conceded by the defendants that they made no application to the plaintiffs for a license, and further that they made no application to the Governor-General under S. 23 of the Act. Consequently they are not in a position to ask the Court to revoke the patent granted to the plaintiffs as not having complied with R. 23. It is however to be pointed out that although the blades are not manufactured here the business of selling them is carried on a very extensive scale in British India by the plaintiffs. It is provided by S. 29 of the Act that the patentee may institute a suit against any person who, during the continuance of the patent acquired by him, makes, sells or uses the invention without his license. That section clearly entitles the plaintiffs to maintain this action. (After discussing evidence the judgment proceeded further.) On this evidence I have no hesitation whatever in holding that the plaintiffs have established the validity of their patent, and have made out a case of infringement and are entitled to succeed. As to Issue 12 the plaintiffs' razor blades are manufactured exclusively outside British India, but in the circumstances of this case this is immaterial and the plaintiffs' patent is not liable to be revoked.

    9. As regards Issues 13 and 14, Sir Jamshedji Kanga for the plaintiffs informed me that the plaintiffs would be content with nominal damages which I assess at Re. 1. I answer Issues 13 and 14 in the affirmative. Issues 15 and 16 relate to the defendants' counter-claim. As this was abandoned by the defendants those issues no longer arise. There will be a decree in favour of the plaintiffs granting them an injunction in terms of the prayer (a) of the plaint, and damages Be. 1. The plaintiffs will also get the costs of the suit. The counter-claim is dismissed with costs. The plaintiffs ask me to grant a certificate under S. 32 of the Act, which provides that in a suit for infringement of a patent the Court may certify that the validity of the patent came in question, and if the Court so certifies, then in any subsequent suit in that Court for infringement of the same patent the plaintiff, on obtaining a final order or judgment in his favour, shall, unless the Court trying the suit otherwise directs, have his full costs, charges and expenses of and incidental to the said suit properly incurred. Accordingly I certify that the validity of the patent came in question in this suit, and I have already held that the plaintiffs' patent is a valid patent. The Prothonotary and Senior Master will send to the Controller a copy of the decree in this case in order that he may cause an entry thereof and reference thereto to be made in the register of patents. The parties have agreed that the exhibits in this case should be returned to them subject to an order in that behalf. That order I make accordingly.

    D.S/R.K

    10. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gillette Industries Ltd. v. Yeshwant Brothers
    (Dec 9, 1937)