Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1972
  • s. 47 read with Order 21 Rule 97
  • Order 21 Rule 101
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1972
  • s. 47 read with Order 21 Rule 97
  • Order 21 Rule 101
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a judgement-debtor tenant, was subject to an eviction suit instituted by the successor-in-interest of the opposite parties, the landlords. The predecessor-in-interest of the opposite parties filed Title Suit No. 327 of 1976 for the petitioner's eviction, which was decreed up to the Supreme Court, resulting in the petitioner's loss. Subsequently, the opposite parties initiated Title Execution Case No. 50 of 1986 to execute the decree from the Title Suit. The petitioner filed a petition under section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure, registered as Misc. Case No. 48 of 1990, and sought permission to produce a xerox copy of a certified copy of a document as evidence. This application was rejected by the learned Munsif by order No. 83 dated October 4, 1991, leading to the present revisional application under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the question of title can be examined in execution proceedings.
  2. Whether a xerox copy of a certified copy of an original document is admissible as evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner sought to admit a xerox copy of a certified copy of a document as evidence in the execution proceedings.
  • Reference was made to several precedents, including AIR 1944 PC 11, AIR 1980 Cal. 90, AIR 1981 Cal. 219, and AIR 1968 SC 938, to support the admissibility of such evidence.
  • It was argued that such copies may be admissible in evidence based on these cases.

Respondent’s Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1944 PC 11 Admissibility of evidence of copies of documents. Considered but not specifically applied; part of cited authorities on admissibility issues.
AIR 1980 Cal. 90 Raising question of title in execution proceedings. Supported the settled law that title can be questioned in execution proceedings.
AIR 1981 Cal. 219 Raising question of title in execution proceedings. Reinforced the principle that title issues may be examined in execution proceedings.
AIR 1968 SC 938 (Lakshmipat Choraria v. State of Maharashtra) Admissibility of secondary evidence (photographs) under special circumstances. Distinguished by the court as not applicable due to different factual circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court recognized two main issues: the examination of title in execution proceedings and the admissibility of a xerox copy of a certified copy as evidence. It affirmed the settled legal principle, supported by section 47 read with Order 21 Rules 97 and 101 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that questions of title may indeed be raised in execution proceedings to challenge the decree's validity.

Regarding the admissibility of the xerox copy, the court clarified the distinction between relevancy and admissibility of evidence, emphasizing that admissibility is a prerequisite to considering relevancy or probative value. The court analyzed section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1972, which defines secondary evidence and its illustrations. It noted that a xerox copy of a certified copy, which was not compared with the original document, falls under illustration (c) and is inadmissible as secondary evidence.

The court distinguished the cited Supreme Court decision in Lakshmipat Choraria v. State of Maharashtra (AIR 1968 SC 938), which allowed photographic evidence under special circumstances, as the facts of the present case were materially different. Consequently, the court upheld the rejection of the petitioner's application to admit the xerox copy.

Holding and Implications

The court rejected the revisional application challenging the order rejecting the petitioner's application to admit a xerox copy of a certified copy of a document in the execution proceedings.

The direct effect is that the petitioner’s application to admit such secondary evidence was properly refused, and all interim orders were vacated. There was no order as to costs. The decision does not establish new precedent but affirms established principles regarding the examination of title in execution proceedings and the strict admissibility criteria for secondary evidence under the Indian Evidence Act.

    In Re v. Kabita Bose

    1. This application under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is directed against order No. 83 passed on October 4, 1991 by the learned Munsif, 5th Court, Alipore in Misc. Case No. 48 of 1990 arising out of Title Execution Case No. 50 of 1986.

    2. The petitioner was the judgement-debtor tenant in an eviction suit instituted by the successor-in-interest of the opposite parties landlords.

    3. The predecessor in interest of the opposite parties filed in a Title Suit being No. 327 of 1976 in the 5th Court of Munsif at Alipore for the eviction of the petitioner. The Title Suit was decreed upto the stage of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the petitioner lost although out.

    4. Thereafter the opposite parties initiated a Title Execution case No. 50 of 1986 for execution of the decree obtained in the said Title Suit No. 327 of 1976.

    5. In the said Title Execution case, the petitioner filed a petition under s. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure which was registered as Misc. Case No. 48 of 1990 and in connection with the said Misc. case, the petitioner filed an application for being allowed to produce a xerox copy of the certified copy of a document. The said application of the petitioner was rejected by the impugned order against which the present revisional application has been made before this court.

    6. It is not necessary to go into all the facts raised and contended by the parties in this revisional application. It is true that the learned Munsif in the impugned order has made certain remarks which may not be tenable in law but the main question centers round two points namely, whether the question of title can be gone into in execution proceedings and whether a xerox copy of a certified copy of an original document can be admitted into evidence.

    7. So far as the first point is concerned it is now settled law that the question of title, in order to prove that the decree is a nullity, can be gone into even in execution proceedings and it is not necessary to discuss the case laws on this point as the section itself namely, s. 47 read with Order 21 Rule 97 and specially Order 21 Rule 101 clinch the issue.

    8. It is the second point which needs some consideration. It was sought to be argued, on a citation of a few cases at the bar, that such evidence may be admissible in evidence.

    9. Mr. Shyamaprasanna Roychoudhury, learned advocate appearing for the petitioner cited a number of decisions including the decision reported in AIR 1944 PC 11, AIR 1980 Cal. 90, AIR 1981 Cal. 219 and AIR 1968 SC 938. Of these decisions reported in AIR 1980 Cal. 90 and AIR 1981 Cal. 219 deal with the raising of question of title in the execution proceeding regarding which it has already been cited hereinbefore that the law is now settled that such question can be raised in execution proceedings.

    10. The other two cases deal with the admissibility of evidence of copies of documents.

    11. The learned court below was wrong in holding that before considering the admissibility of evidence the court's duty is first to consider the relevancy of the evidence concerned, I am afraid that the reverse is the proposition of law namely, the admissibility of a document has nothing to do with the relevancy of the document. If a document is not admissible in law its relevancy is immaterial. On the contrary if a document is admissible only then the question of relevancy of such evidence or the probative value of such evidence will be taken into consideration.

    12. Be that as it may, in this revisional application we are to consider as to whether a xerox copy of the certified copy of a document can be admitted in evidence.

    13. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Lakshmipat Choraria v. State of Maharashtra reported in AIR 1968 SC 938 on a consideration of a large number of cases, held that in the circumstances of that particular case a photograph, though not a primary evidence, is admissible in evidence. The said case is not of much help to the petitioner as the circumstances of the said case were entirely different. In the said case the photograph concerned were of parties who were co-conspirators in a crime and the photographs were sought to be exhibited for the purpose of identification of the accused concerned.

    14. Here in the instant case the facts are entirely different. Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1972 defines secondary evidence. The analogy of a xerox copy does not find place in any of the illustrations appended to the said section. Illustration (b) provides that a copy compared with a copy of a letter made by a copying machine is secondary evidence of the contents of the letter if it is shown that the copy made by the copying machine was made from the original. Illustration (c) provides that a copy transcribed from a copy but afterwards compared with the original is secondary evidence; but the copy not so compared is not secondary evidence of the original, although the copy from which it was transcribed was compared with the original.

    15. In the instant case the xerox copy which was obtained from a certified copy was not compared with the original and as such under illustration (c) it is expressly said to be inadmissible as secondary evidence.

    16. For the reasons stated above, it is to be held that the learned court below was justified in rejecting the application for allowing the petitioner's application for introducing the said xerox copy of a certified copy of a document of transfer in the Misc. Case concerned in connection with the Title Execution case referred to above.

    In the circumstances, the application has no merit and fails. As such the application is rejected, all in terim orders if any, are vacated.

    There will, however, be no order as to costs.

    Application rejected.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    In Re v. Kabita Bose
    (Nov 20, 1991)