Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 47 of the Code
  • provisions of Order XXI, Rule 55,
  • Order XXI, Rule 55,
  • Rule 55, Order
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 47 of the Code
  • provisions of Order XXI, Rule 55,
  • Order XXI, Rule 55,
  • Rule 55, Order
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the appellant from a judgment passed by the District Judge in respect of execution proceedings against him. Two creditors had obtained decrees and attached certain immoveable property of the appellant. Other creditors had obtained decrees but had only put in applications for execution without issuing attachment. The Court fixed 22 September 1909 for the sale of the attached property. On that date, at the appellant's instance, a third person brought sufficient monies to satisfy in full the decretal claims of the two attaching creditors; the Nazir accepted the money and gave a receipt. The payment was made under the provisions of Order XXI, Rule 55 (which provides that payment into Court of the amount decreed with costs and attachment-related charges shall be deemed to withdraw the attachment).

On 23 September 1909 an ex parte application was made to the Court seeking distribution of the monies paid into Court on the basis that they were assets distributable rateably among all creditors who had applied for execution. On 27 September 1909 the Judge ordered rateable distribution of those monies and ordered sale of further properties which had been attached. The appellant appealed to the District Court; before the appeal was heard a sale of the other attached properties was held on 26 January 1910. The appellant applied on 21 February 1910 that the sale should not be confirmed; that application was dismissed on 14 April 1910. The appellant appealed, and the District Judge dismissed that appeal on 30 June 1910.

In June 1911 an appeal against the order of 27 September 1909 came before the District Court, but because the confirmation of the sale had already been decided adversely to the appellant, no further proceedings were taken on that appeal. The appellant then appealed to the present Court against the order of 30 June 1910.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the matter was appealable to this Court (i.e., whether a second appeal lay), specifically whether the question falls under Section 47 of the Code.
  2. Whether payment into Court under Order XXI, Rule 55 has the effect of withdrawing attachment so that property is no longer duly attached and cannot be sold in execution.
  3. Whether money paid into Court for the purpose of satisfying particular attaching creditors (under Rule 55) constitutes "assets" held by the Court within the meaning of Section 73 of the Code and therefore is distributable rateably among other judgment-creditors who had applied for execution.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The payment made into Court on 22 September 1909 (under Order XXI, Rule 55) operated to withdraw the attachments on the appellant's property; consequently, at the time of the sale in January 1910 there was no attachment authorizing sale.
  • The monies paid into Court for the purpose of satisfying the attaching creditors' decrees (and thereby raising the attachment) could not be treated as assets of the Court distributable rateably among other judgment-creditors who had merely applied for execution.

Applicants / Other Creditors' Arguments

  • They contended that the money paid into Court were assets which were distributable rateably among all the creditors who had applied for execution (i.e., that Section 73 applied to those monies).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vibudhapriya Tirthaswami v. Yusuf Sahib (1905) I.L.R. 28 Mad. 380 As authority supporting the proposition that payment into Court under the relevant rule causes the attachment to be treated as withdrawn (i.e., that attachment ends upon payment). Referred to as further authority for the view that if attachment ended on the payment into Court, the property was not duly attached at the time of the later sale.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Jurisdiction: The Court addressed an initial objection that no second appeal lay and concluded that the matter falls under the provisions of Section 47 of the Code and is therefore appealable to this Court.

On the effect of payment under Order XXI, Rule 55: The Court examined the consequence of the payment into Court on 22 September 1909. It treated Rule 55 (Order XXI) as establishing that where the amount decreed with costs and all charges and expenses resulting from the attachment are paid into Court, the attachment shall be deemed to be withdrawn. The Court stated that property can only be sold if it has been duly attached; if the attachment was terminated by the payment into Court, the property was not duly attached at the time of the sale in January 1910. The Court cited Rule 55 directly and also referred to the Madras High Court decision in Vibudhapriya Tirthaswami v. Yusuf Sahib as further authority for this interpretation.

On whether payment under Rule 55 becomes "assets" under Section 73: The Court considered Section 73, which provides for rateable distribution of assets held by the Court among multiple judgment-creditors who had applied for execution before receipt of such assets, after deducting "costs of realization." The Court read the reference to "costs of realization" as indicating that Section 73 contemplates assets held in the process of execution. It reasoned that treating money paid into Court under Order XXI, Rule 55 as assets within Section 73 would nullify the effect of Rule 55: if such payments could immediately be absorbed by rateable distribution among multiple creditors, a judgment-debtor would have no inducement to procure payment into Court to raise an attachment. On that basis the Court concluded that the monies paid into Court for the particular purpose of satisfying the attaching creditors were not to be treated as distributable assets under Section 73.

On the combined application of these principles to the facts, the Court determined that the order of the lower appellate Court (which had ordered rateable distribution and sale of further properties) was incorrect in the respects identified and required reversal and remedial measures.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court REVERSED the order of the lower appellate Court, SET ASIDE the sale of the properties that had been confirmed below, and REMANDED the Darkhast (application) to the lower Court for disposal according to law.

Consequences for the parties: The immediate effect is that the sale confirmed below has been set aside and the matter is returned to the lower Court for further proceedings consistent with the Court's reasoning. The appellant was awarded his costs in this Court and in the two lower Courts.

Broader implications: The opinion rests on an interpretation of the interaction between Order XXI, Rule 55 and Section 73 of the Code. The Court's decision applies those statutory provisions to the facts and reverses the lower Court for treating Rule 55 payments as distributable assets under Section 73. The opinion does not state that it is laying down a new binding precedent beyond the disposition in this case.

    Sorabji Coovarji v. Kala Raghunath

    1. This is an appeal by the appellant from a judgment passed by the District Judge with reference to certain execution proceedings against him.

    2. Two creditors had obtained decrees and attached certain immoveable property of the appellant, and other creditors had obtained decrees but had merely put in applications for execution without issuing attachment. The 22nd of September 1909 was the date fixed by the Court for the sale of the attached property, and upon that date a third person, at the instance of the appellant, came to the Court with sufficient monies to satisfy in full the decretal claims of the two attaching creditors. The money was accepted by the Nazir of the Court and a receipt therefore was given to the person making the payment. The payment so made was made according to the provisions of Order XXI, Rule 55, which says that where the amount decreed with costs and all charges and expenses resulting from the attachment of any property are paid into Court the attachment shall be deemed to be withdrawn.

    3. Upon this payment being made the appellant considered himself free from any danger, for the moment, of the sale in execution of his immoveable property, but on the following day the 23rd of September, an ex parte application was made to the Court for distribution of the money paid for the purpose of satisfying the claims of the attaching creditors, and it was urged that the money was assets which were distributable rateably among all the creditors who had applied for execution.

    4. On the 27th of September 1909, the Judge assented to the contention of the applicants and ordered rateable distribution of the monies so paid into Court and sale of further properties which had been attached towards further satisfaction of the claims of the judgment-creditors.

    5. Against this order an appeal was preferred to the District Court by the appellant, but long before it came on for hearing the sale of the other properties had taken place. That sale was held on the 26th of January 1910.

    6. On the 21st of February 1910, the appellant applied that the sale should not be confirmed but his application was dismissed on the 14th of April 1910.

    7. From that order of dismissal the appellant appealed to the District Judge who, on the 30th of June 1910, dismissed the appeal.

    8. In June 1911, the appeal against the order of the 27th of September 1909 came on before the District Court, but, as the question of the confirmation of the sale had already been decided by that Court adversely to the appellant, no further proceedings were taken on the appeal against the order of 27th of September; and the appellant comes to this Court in appeal against the order of the 30th of June 1910.

    9. It was objected at the outset that this was a case in respect of which no second appeal lay.

    10. We are of opinion; however, that it is a question in execution between the parties to decrees and therefore falls under the provisions of Section 47 of the Code and is appealable to this Court.

    11. The main ground upon which the pleader for the appellant has based his argument is that by virtue of the payment on the 22nd of September 1909 the attachments upon the property must be deemed to be withdrawn, and that if there was no attachment upon the property the Court was not justified in ordering a further sale of the properties, nor was it justified in treating the monies which had been paid in for the purpose of satisfying the attaching creditors' decrees and raising the attachment as assets held by the Court which were distributable among other judgment-creditors who had merely applied for execution.

    12. We think that the appellant is light in both contentions. Property can only be brought to sale after it has been duly attached, and if the attachment came to an end upon the payment into Court on the 22nd of September 1909, the property was not duly attached at the time of the sale in January 1910. We think this is clear from the terms of Rule 55, Order XXI; but if further authority is required we may refer to the judgment of the Madras High Court in Vibudhapriya Tirthaswami v. Yusuf Sahib (1905) I.L.R. 28 Mad. 380.

    13. The question remains whether the money paid into Court for a particular purpose can be treated as assets distributable under section 73 of the code. That section provides that "where assets are held by a Court and more persons than one have, before the receipt of such assets, made application to the Court for the execution of decrees for the payment of money passed against the same judgment-debtor and have not obtained satisfaction thereof, the assets, after deducting the costs of realization, shall be rateably distributed among all such persons." In the reference to "the costs of realization" we have an indication that the legislature contemplated that the assets referred to should be assets held in the process of execution. If we were to hold that money paid into Court under Order XXI, Rule 55, was assets held by the Court within the meaning of Section 73, we should be only nullifying the provisions of rule 55; for, there would be no inducement to any judgment-debtor to procure a payment into Court of the amount of the claim of his attaching creditor if the money could at once be absorbed by rateable distribution amongst a number of other creditors.

    14. For these reasons, we reverse the order of the lower appellate Court, set aside the sale, and remand the Darkhast to the lower Court for disposal according to law.

    15. The appellant will have his costs in this Court and the two lower Courts.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sorabji Coovarji v. Kala Raghunath
    (Sep 11, 1911)