Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Parmar Gogji Kana v. Parmar Ganesh Moti .

    Judgement

    JUDGEMENT :- The suit from which this second appeal arises was instituted by the plaintiff-respondent in the Court of the Civil Judge (J.D.) at Limbdi against the defendant-appellant for a permanent injunction restraining the defendant from tethering cattle in his Pali and keeping utensils and agricultural implements and also for a permanent injunction restraining him from causing obstruction to him in tethering cattle or using the Pali in any way he liked and for other incidental reliefs in the suit, inter alia alleging that the suit Pali belongs to him and that the defendant has no right to tether cattle or keep any such implements so as to obstruct him in enjoyment thereof.

    2. The defendant-appellant resisted the suit inter alia contending that the Pali in front of his house belongs to him and not to the plaintiff as alleged; that he had allowed the plaintiff to construct a Ganmn as he was his neighbour and he had to remove the same when called upon to do so, that he has a right to use and enjoy the Pali in front of his house in any manner he liked and that, therefore, the suit was liable to he dismissed.

    3. The trial Court raised the issuer and in its opinion the Pali in front of the houses of the parties extending to the wall of Thaker Mandir on the East and between the two Kodyas of the plaintiff belongs to the plaintiff and that the defendant has no right to tether cattle or put any utensils and implements on the Pali in front of his house In the result therefore, he directed the defendant to remove the wooden heep from near the southern kodya and also all other utensils and implements if any, from the Gaman. The defendant is further restrained from doing any act that would interfere with the plaintiffs reasonable enjoyment of the disputed Pali Feeling dissatisfied with that order passed on 30th November 1957 by Mr. J.S. Bhatt Civil Judge (J D) Limbdi, the defendant preferred Civil Appeal No. 40 of 1958 in the Court of the District Judge, Zalawad Division. The same issue regarding the ownership in respect of the disputed Pali was raised and he found that it belonged to the plaintiff. In the result the appeal was dismissed with costs Aggrieved by that derision passed on 30th April 1959 by Mr. V.M. Solanki, District Judge. Zalawad Division Surendranagar, the defendant has come in appeal.

    4. Mr. Shah, the learned advocate for the appellant, contends that while he can have no objection to the finding about the ownership of the Pali which is in front of the plaintiffs house, the ownership of the Pali in front of the defendants house belongs to the defendant. All that the plaintiff can claim in respect of that portion of the Pali would by his right of passage for going on the southern side and for that purpose, he would no doubt have to keep that land open so that there would not be any obstruction or interference with the right of the plaintiff to pass by that side. Reliance was placed on a case of Mahamedsaheb Ibrahimsaheb v. Tilokchand Abheerchand Marwadi, 24 Bom LR 373 : (AIR 1922 Bom 243). Now this aspect of the case does not appear to have been properly considered by the learned appellate Judge. What the plaintiff is required to establish is his title over the Augan space in front of defendants house. There is no document showing any such title over that open space. There can hardly arise any question of his claim by adverse possession of that space, which is obviously in front of defendants own house and is being used by him. On the other hand, it appears prima facie evident that open site in front of a house goes with the ownership of the house itself and he becomes the owner thereof. Similarly possession thereof can as well go with the possession of the house to which it appertains. In the case of 24 Bom LR 373 : (AIR 1922 Bom 243), it has been so held and the following pertinent observations c an well hold good in the present case :-

    " Possession of open sites goes naturally with the possession of the property to which they adjoin. If the defendant asserts his rights over those sites, he must show, in the absence of any evidence, that the sites ceased to be appurtenant to the property and that he has been in possession adversely against the owner of the property. In such a case, the fact of the plaintiffs title comes to his aid with greater force; and unless the defendant can show that he has been in possession adversely to the plaintiff for more than twelve years, the plaintiff will be entitled to a decree."

    5. The plaintiff has not been able to show any such ownership over that open space, and the only thing which he can claim is to have right of passage through that open space. That has no doubt to be protected. The defendant has to use it subject to that right of the plaintiff in that respect. It was, however, said that on two occasions the plaintiff had protested against the defendant who was tethering a mare in that space and he had removed the same and had even discontinued such user through the intervention of the leading persons of the village. But that evidence does not establish his having agreed or conceded to the ownership of that open space as of the plaintiff. He may have reasonably conceded to discontinue tethering of his mare as that would cause obstruction to the passage of the plaintiff or even may amount to a nuisance which the plaintiff would be entitled to have it r emoved from nea rby his house and from where he has to pass by. The plaintiff has no document of title to show ownership over the open space in front of the defendants house. The user of the defendant of that space shows his ownership over the same and there can be no claim of plaintiffs adversely holding it. But as observed in the case referred to hereabove, the possession of open sites naturally goes with the possession of the property to which they appertain. No other person can have ownership over the front portion of somebodys house. That onus of proof was on the plaintiff and the Courts below have ignored this aspect of the matter and that justifies interference by this Court in second appeal though the finding is one of fact. In fact, it has resulted in gross injustice in the circumstances of the case. The finding recorded by both the Courts below in respect of the open Fali in front of the defendants house cannot be sustained.

    6. That however does not mean that the defendant can make use of that open space in any manner he likes He has to keep it open for reasonable enjoyment which the plaintiff and persons living in his house together with cattle etc. have a right to for passing through that open space. He cannot put materials or tether cattle as to cause obstruction to the plaintiffs passage. The direction to remove the wooden hoop from near the southern Kodya shall, therefore, stand as that would obviously obstruct the passage of the people living in the house of the plaintiff. The defendant shall also be restrained from doing any act that would interfere with the plaintiffs reasonable enjoyment on account of his right of passage through that portion in dispute viz. the Fali portion in front of the defendants house.

    7. The decree shall stand modified as stated hereabove. The order directing the defendant to remove the wooden hoop from near the southern Kodya shall stand. He shall further be restrained from doing any act that would interfere with the plaintiffs reasonable enjoyment as a passage for the inmates etc. living in the house of the plaintiff on the northern side. That open site shall, however, remain open. Parties shall bear their own costs throughout.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Parmar Gogji Kana v. Parmar Ganesh Moti .
    (Jun 20, 1967)