AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 51 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 51 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959.

    Ganpat Singh Jalamsingh And Others v. State Of M.P.

    On 31-7-1958 the Sub-Divisional Officer, Khurai, passed an order allotting land to 22 persons. This order was passed after an enquiry had been made by the Tahsildar. Thereafter on 31-1-1960 the successor in office of the Sub-Divisional Officer, who passed the order of 31-7-1958, reopened the order of allotment and on 10-2-1960 set aside his predecessor's order so far as the thirteen petitioners are concerned. Appeals against this order of 10-2-1960 to the Collector and the Commissioner were unsuccessful. The thirteen persons adversely affected by the Sub-Divisional Officer's order of 10-2-1960 have filed the present revision petition. The grounds on which revision of the orders of the lower Courts is sought are: the same as those which were urged before the Collector and the Commissioner in the first and second appeals and are the following-

    (1) The Sub-Divisional Officer, who passed the order of 10-2-1960, had no jurisdiction to review his predecessor's order because he had not obtained the sanction of the Collector for such review;

    (2) The Sub-Divisional Officer did not follow the procedure prescribed for reviewing the previous order passed in the case since he did not issue individual notices to the persons interested;

    (3) the grounds on which the Sub-Divisional Officer reviewed the order of his predecessor so far as the present petitioners are concerned are not the grounds recognised by the Land Revenue Code and therefore the review order was not proper; and,

    (4) even on merits, the Sub-Divisional Officer's order of 10-2-1960 is not sustainable as it is contrary to the evidence on record.

    2. The first ground of objection to the Sub-Divisional Officer's order is without force. It is only, if the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1954, applied, that it was necessary for the Sub-Divisional Officer to obtain the sanction of the Collector for reviewing the order passed by his predecessor. In the instant case the Sub-Divisional Officer took up the question of review of his predecessor's order on 31-1-1960 i.e. after the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, had come into force. section 51 of this code, which deals with review, does not require that a revenue officer should obtain the sanction of his official superior before reviewing his predecessor's order.

    3. So far as the second ground is concerned the objection of the petitioners is well founded. On 31-1-1960, the Sub-Divisional Officer decided to take up the question of reviewing the order passed by his predecessor. He directed a notice to be issued to the Patwari, the Patel and the Kotwar of the village and further directed that the Patwari should inform the persons to whom land was allotted to appear before the Sub-Divisional Officer on 8-2-1960. He also directed that a proclamation should be made in the village by the Patwari that an enquiry regarding the allotment of Kabil Kashta land in the village was to be made afresh and those who had anything to say in the matter should appear before the Sub-Divisional Officer. As alleged by the petitioners no individual notices were served on the petitioners. On 8-2-1960, the next date of hearing, the Sub-Divisional Officer took up the case in the village. Among the persons who appeared before him were 14 of the persons to whom land had been allotted by his predecessor. The Sub-Divisional Officer recorded what he termed a “Note of spot enquiry”, in which indicated whether any of the 22 persons to whom land had been previously allotted, were landless persons or already had land in their possession. It is not clear what evidence was taken by the Sub-Divisional Officer before he came to the conclusions recorded in this note. After recording this note he passed the impugned order on 10-2-1960, in which he stated that 17 of the persons to whom land had been previously allotted should not have been allotted land as they were not landless persons and therefore, set aside the order of his predecessor allotting land to them.

    4. From the above recital of facts it is obvious that the procedure followed by the Sub-Divisional Officer was not the procedure prescribed by section 51 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959. The first proviso to this section states that no order shall be varied or reversed unless notice has been given to the parties interested to appear and be heard in support of such order. What this proviso requires is that an individual notice should be served on each of the persons who would have been affected by the proposed review. The notice should have specified the grounds on which it was proposed to review the previous order so that the persons could have had adequate opportunity to counter those grounds and make their submission why the previous order should not be varied or reversed. A general notice in the village without indicating the grounds on which it was proposed to review the previous order cannot be said to be a proper compliance with the requirements of the above proviso. If in a review preceding the previous order is reversed or varied without proper notice to the parties interested, the order is vitiated by a grave irregularity of procedure and cannot be sustained. On this ground alone, therefore, the revision petition of these 13 persons is entitled to succeed.

    5. The third ground urged for interfering in revision is also well founded. An order can be reviewed only on the grounds provided for such review in the Civil Procedure Code. These grounds are :-

    (1) The discovery of new and important matter or evidence;

    (2) mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; and,

    (3) any other sufficient reason.

    The first ground is not available in this case since there is nothing to indicate that any new or important matter or evidence was discovered by the Sub-Divisional Officer which was not within the knowledge of his predecessor in spite of the exercise of due diligence. There is nothing in the order to indicate that there was any mistake or error apparent on the face of the record which would justify the review of the previous order and, therefore, the second ground was also not available. If the review can be justified at all it can be justified only on the ground that there was other sufficient reason for it. The words “other sufficient reason” have been held to mean

    "reasons sufficient on grounds at least analogous to those specified in the other two grounds for review"
    in Chhaju Ram v. Neki AIR 1922 PC 112. In the instant case it cannot be said that the ground on which the review was made, namely, that the 13 petitioners were not landless persons constitutes “other sufficient reason” within the meaning of those words as defined in the above ruling. Therefore, on this ground also the Sub-Divisional Officer's order is liable to be set aside.

    6. In view of my conclusions on grounds Nos. 2 and 3 above, it is not necessary to go into the merits of the case as to whether the Sub-Divisional Officer was right in his conclusions that these petitioners were not landless persons at the time of the original order of 31-7-1958.

    7. The result is that the revision petition succeeds and is allowed. The order of the Sub-Divisional Officer dated 10-2-1960, so far as it relates to these 13 petitioners, is set aside and the order of his predecessor dated 31-7-1958 is restored.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ganpat Singh Jalamsingh And Others v. State Of M.P.
    (Jan 20, 1962)