Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent instituted a suit in July 1987 as an indigent person under Order 33 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code, registered as Miscellaneous Case No. 6/1988. The trial Court conducted an enquiry under Order 33 which concluded on 2-5-1989 by refusing the respondent's prayer to sue as an indigent person and directed payment of Court-fees. The respondent failed to pay the Court-fees and challenged this order by way of revision in the High Court. The High Court quashed the trial Court’s order on 10-1-1990 and remanded the matter for rehearing. On 18-1-1990, the trial Court permitted the respondent to sue as an indigent person, but the suit was not registered as a regular suit at that time. On 18-1-1990, the Court allowed the appellants time to file their written-statement by 23-1-1990. The appellants did not file the written-statement by that date, resulting in the trial Court forfeiting their right to file it. The appellants filed a written-statement on 23-3-1990, which the trial Court refused to take on record. The trial Court subsequently decreed the respondent’s suit for damages on 16-10-1990. The appellants appealed against this judgment and decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court erred in refusing to permit the appellants to file their written-statement under Order 8, Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Code, thereby depriving them of the right to defend their case.
  2. Whether the findings on merit by the trial Court were based on legal evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The trial Court committed illegality by not properly exercising its power under Order 8, Rule 10, CPC by refusing to permit the appellants to file their written-statement.
  • The appellants were deprived of the opportunity to properly defend the suit.
  • The findings on merit were not based on any legal evidence.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1971 Punjab 435 Order 8, Rule 1, CPC must be applied to advance justice and not to punish a defaulting defendant. The Court relied on this principle to hold that the trial Court did not exercise its discretion judiciously in forfeiting the right to file written-statement.
AIR 1982 Patna 136 Same principle as above regarding the exercise of discretion under Order 8, Rule 1, CPC. Reinforced the Court’s view that the trial Court’s refusal to allow filing of written-statement was manifestly illegal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the procedural history and noted that the trial Court was under a wrong impression that multiple opportunities had been granted to the appellants to file their written-statement prior to 18-1-1990. The Court emphasized that there was no legal requirement for the appellants to file a written-statement during the pendency of the enquiry under Order 33, CPC, as the suit was not yet registered as a regular suit. Since the trial Court refused to register the suit due to non-payment of Court-fees, the appellants were not obliged to file a written-statement until the suit was properly registered after the High Court’s order on 10-1-1990. The appellants were effectively given only five days (from 18-1-1990 to 23-1-1990) to file their written-statement. The Court found that this short time was insufficient and the trial Court’s forfeiture of the right to file the written-statement was an improper exercise of discretion. The Court held that the trial Court’s refusal to admit the written-statement filed on 23-3-1990 was also unjustified. Consequently, the appellants were deprived of their fundamental right to defend the suit, which prejudiced their case.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed, the impugned judgment and decree are set aside, and the matter is remanded for a fresh trial.

The trial Court is directed to take the appellant-defendants' written-statement on record and decide the suit in accordance with law. Court-fees paid by the respondent shall be refunded. This decision directly affects the parties by providing the appellants a fair opportunity to defend the suit, but it does not establish any new precedent beyond the proper exercise of discretion under Order 8, Rule 10, CPC.

    State Of M.P. v. Madan Singh

    N. G. Karambelkar, J. :-

    Appellant/defendants have preferred this appeal against the judgment and decree dated 16-10-1990 passed in Civil Suit No. 37-A/1990 by Fourth Additional District Judge, Gwalior, decreeing respondent-plaintiffs suit for damages.

    2. The respondent did not appear in this Court despite service of notice by publication.

    3. In appeal, the impugned judgment and decree has been assailed mainly on the ground that the learned trial Court committed illegality by not properly exercising its power under Order 8, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code in not permitting the appellants to file written-statement and thereby forfeiting their right to file written-statement, and thereby deprived the appellants from properly defending their claim. The findings on merit have also been assailed on the ground that those are not based on any legal evidence.

    4. We have heard learned counsel for appellants and perused the record.

    5. Briefly stated, it is borne out from the record that respondent instituted his suit in July 1987 as an indigent person under Order 33 Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, which was registered as Miscellaneous Case No. 6/1988. The enquiry under Order 33, Civil Procedure Code continued till 2-5-1989 when by its order learned trial Court refused respondent-plaintiffs prayer for permission to sue as an indigent person and directed him to pay Court-fees. Respondent-plaintiff was allowed time to pay Court-fees till 10-7-1989. It is found that Court-fees was not paid and instead the respondent-plaintiff challenged trial Court's order by way of revision in the Hon'ble High Court. The High Court vide its order dated 10-1-1990 passed in Misc. Appeal No. 56/1990 quashed trial Court's order and remanded the matter back for rehearing and disposal afresh. It is found that order of the High Court and the original record were received in the trial Court on 18-1-1990. On that day itself, the matter was taken up for hearing when the two sides made statement that they did not want to produce any further evidence and after hearing the two sides application was allowed permitting the respondent-plaintiff to sue as indigent person. It is to be noted that even after this, the suit was not registered as a regular suit. This mistake was noticed by learned trial Court on 16-10-1990 while delivering the judgment. Assuming for arguments sake that regular suit was registered on 18-1-1990, it would appear that the Court on 18-1-1990 allowed time to appellants to file written-statement till 23-1-1990. It would be proper to reproduce order sheet dated 18-1-1990 :

    @ Hindi @

    6. On 23-1-1990, the appellant-defendants did not file written-statement, and therefore, the Court forfeited their right to file written-statement on the ground that they failed to file written-statement despite a number of opportunities having been given in the past.

    7. It is found that the trial Court while passing orders on 21-1-1990, was misled and acted on a wrong impression that many opportunities were granted for filing written-statement. It is true that the Court below right from 3-11-1989 asked the appellant-defendants to file written-statement and it continued till 18-1-1990. This important legal aspect appears to have been missed by learned trial Court that the defendants were not required to file written-statement till there was a regular suit in existence. There was no legal propriety in asking the defendants to file written-statement during the pendency of enquiry under Order 33, Civil Procedure Code. The enquiry concluded on 2-5-1989 when the Court refused permission to sue as an indigent person. The plaintiff having not paid Court-fees in compliance of the order dated 2-5-1989, regular suit was not registered and could not have been registered. This position continued till 10-1-1990 when trial Court's order was quashed by High Court and till 18-1-1990 when trial Court permitted plaintiff to sue as indigent person. In this view of the matter, there was no occasion for defendants to file written-statement nor the trial Court was legally competent to ask them to file written-statement, and therefore, their failure to file written-statement prior to 18-1-1990 was insignificant in the eyes of law. It is, thus, evident that virtually defendants were allowed hardly five days' time to file written-statement after 18-1-1990 and the right to file written-statement was forfeited on 23-1-990 under the impression that much time has already been allowed in the past for the same purpose. It is to be noted that provision of sub-rule (1) of Order 8, Civil Procedure Code has to be worked in a manner so as to advance justice. It is not intended to be so operated as to punish the defaulting defendant for his omission. AIR 1971 Punjab 435 and AIR 1982 Patna 136. In the facts and circumstances of the instant case, we do not find that learned trial Court exercised its discretion in a judicious manner in refusing the time to file written-statement and in forfeiting defendant's right to file written-statement. It is again to be noted that the appellant-defendants did file written-statement on 23-3-1990 and requested the Court that it be taken on record. However, learned Court rejected defendant's application vide its detailed order dated 11-5-1990. A perusal of the order shows that the trial Court took it seriously that a number of opportunities were granted to file written-statement in the past before forfeiting their right on 23-1-1990. It appears that the learned trial Court again failed to notice that the suit was at initial stage on 23-3-1990 because till then plaintiff-respondent had produced no evidence and in that circumstances the written-statement could have been taken on record keeping in mind the explanation given by defendants for the delay in filing written-statement.'

    8. As discussed above, we find that the approach of learned trial Court in exercising its power under Rules 1 and 10 of Order 8, Civil Procedure Code was manifestly illegal. It is found that in the facts and circumstances of the case, only one opportunity of 5 days was afforded to appellant-defendants to file written-statement, which in our considered opinion was not sufficient. We are, therefore, of the opinion that learned trial Court deprived appellant-defendants from properly defending their case by illegally forfeiting their right to file written-statement and further by refusing to take written-statement on record and this has certainly prejudiced the case of the defendants. The defendants having not been allowed to file written-statement and have virtually been denied the right to defend the case and on this count alone, the judgment and decree under challenge deserves to be set aside. The defendants ought to be allowed and afforded reasonable opportunity to defend their case after filing written-statement.

    9. In the result, impugned judgment and decree of the learned trial Court is set aside and matter is remanded for fresh trial. The learned trial Court shall now take written-statement on record and decide the suit in accordance with law.

    10. The Court-fees be refunded.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of M.P. v. Madan Singh
    (Aug 28, 2000)