Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act, 1959
  • The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act, 1959
  • The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On the night of 20-2-1984, deceased Firozbhai Abdul Latif set out with Accused 1 (Asaf Afkhan Kalandarkhan) and Accused 3 (Vora Ismailbhai Daudbhai) in a Fiat car allegedly to collect outstanding dues at Savarkundla. En route they decided to stop at Nal Sarovar for hunting and picked up Accused 2 (Mahamadkhan Nathekhan) along with his gun. While nearing Nal Sarovar, Firozbhai sustained a gun-shot wound to the right side of his chest and later died in V.S. Hospital, Ahmedabad.

• The police initially treated the shooting as an attack by unknown assailants based on a complaint lodged by Accused 3. Subsequent investigation led to the filing of a charge-sheet against all three accused for offences under Sections 302, 120-B and 201 IPC and Section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act.

• In Sessions Case No. 44 of 1985 the Additional Sessions Judge, Ahmedabad (Rural) acquitted all the accused.

• The State of Gujarat appealed. On 26-12-2006 the High Court of Gujarat partly reversed the acquittal: it convicted Accused 1 and 3 under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC, Accused 2 under Section 302 read with Section 114 IPC, and Accused 1 & 2 under Section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act, while affirming acquittal on the conspiracy charge.

• The present three criminal appeals before the Supreme Court challenge that High Court judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in overturning the trial court’s acquittal on a case resting solely on circumstantial evidence.
  2. Whether the evidence on record proved homicidal death and the appellants’ guilt beyond reasonable doubt, or whether the possibility of accidental firing remained.
  3. Whether the High Court erred in treating the statement of Accused 3 under Section 313 CrPC as substantive evidence against him.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The High Court impermissibly substituted its own view for that of the trial court without identifying any compelling error, contrary to settled principles governing interference with acquittals.
  • The prosecution case is founded on circumstantial evidence that does not exclude the reasonable possibility of accidental firing; hence conviction is unsustainable.

Respondent State's Arguments

  • The High Court undertook a detailed re-appraisal of evidence and correctly concluded that the chain of circumstances established the appellants’ guilt.
  • The presence of nitrate on Accused 1’s hand wash and other forensic material corroborate the prosecution story of homicidal shooting.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka, (2007) 4 SCC 415 Scope of appellate powers against an order of acquittal; need for caution and the “double presumption” of innocence. Relied on to emphasise that the High Court must pinpoint significant errors before reversing an acquittal and should not merely substitute its opinion.
Sujit Biswas v. State of Assam, (2013) 12 SCC 406 Statements under Section 313 CrPC are not evidence and circumstances not put to the accused cannot be used against him. Cited to hold that the High Court erred in treating Accused 3’s Section 313 statement as incriminating evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook an independent scrutiny of the circumstantial evidence:

  • Possibility of accidental firing: Medical testimony (PW 1 Dr Kothari) and ballistic expert evidence (PW 7) indicated that an accidental discharge was possible if the gun rested vertically between the rear-seat occupants on a bumpy road. The entry wound direction (right-to-left, down-to-up) was consistent with this scenario.
  • Nitrate traces: The presence of nitrate on Accused 1’s hands was deemed a natural consequence of his proximity to the discharged firearm, not proof that he pulled the trigger.
  • Absence of motive: Alleged financial disputes were unsupported by account books; even PW 3 conceded no dues from Accused 3. Motive, an important factor in circumstantial cases, was therefore lacking.
  • Misapplication of Section 313 statement: The High Court’s use of Accused 3’s answers as substantive evidence contravened Sujit Biswas.
  • Standard for reversing acquittal: Guided by Chandrappa, the Court stressed that unless the trial court’s view is perverse, an acquittal should stand. Here, the trial court’s conclusion of accidental death was a plausible view.

On cumulative assessment, the Supreme Court found the prosecution failed to prove homicidal death beyond reasonable doubt; the trial court’s view remained a reasonable one, warranting restoration of the acquittal.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; Conviction and Sentence Set Aside; Trial Court Acquittal Restored.

Immediate effect: all three appellants stand acquitted of the charges and are released from the sentences imposed by the High Court. Broader implication: the judgment reinforces the stringent threshold for appellate interference with acquittals, especially in cases hinging on circumstantial evidence, and reiterates that Section 313 statements cannot be treated as substantive evidence.

    Mahamadkhan Nathekhan v. State Of Gujarat .

    Chockalingam Nagappan, J.— All three appeals are preferred against the judgment dated 26-12-2006 in State of Gujarat v. Asafafkhan Kalandarkhan Criminal Appeal No. 865 of 1986 passed by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad.

    2. Accused 1 Asaf Afkhan Kalandarkhan, Accused 2 Mahamadkhan Nathekhan and Accused 3 Vora Ismailbhai Daudbhai were tried for the charge under Sections 302, 120-B and 201 IPC and Section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act, 1959 for committing the murder of Firozbhai Abdul Latif by firing gunshot on the right side of his chest, when he was in the motor car of Accused 3 in the early hours on 21-2-1984 in Sessions Case No. 44 of 1985 on the file of the Additional Sessions Judge, Ahmedabad (Rural) at Narol. The trial court acquitted the accused from all the charges levelled against them. Challenging the same the State of Gujarat preferred appeal in Criminal Appeal No. 865 of 1986 on the file of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad and the High Court held that the charge of criminal conspiracy against Accused 1 to 3 has not been proved by the prosecution and the offence under Section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act is not proved as against Accused 3 and acquitted them of the said charges. At the same time, the High Court found Accused 1 and 3 guilty of the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and Accused 2 guilty for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 114 IPC and further held Accused 1 and 2 guilty of the offence punishable under Section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act. Accordingly, the High Court sentenced all the three accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life for the charge of murder and sentenced Accused 1 and 2 to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three years and to pay a fine of Rs 5000, in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months for the offence under the Arms Act. Challenging their conviction and sentence all the three accused have preferred three independent appeals before this Court.

    3. Briefly the prosecution case is as follows: Accused 1 and 3 were friends of deceased Firozbhai and their relationship was cordial. Accused 2 was also a common friend of them. Firozbhai was in the business of selling tyres of four-wheelers and two-wheelers and Accused 3 was in the business of sale and purchase of motor trucks and was a broker in that field and he was helping Firozbhai to sell tyres to the traders at Savarkundla, a town under District Bhavnagar. There were outstandings to be recovered from customers at Savarkundla and Firozbhai was interested in early recovery and at his instance Accused 1 and 3 on 20-2-1984 agreed to accompany Firozbhai to Savarkundla sometime during afternoon hours. Firozbhai sold the tyres at Savarkundla on credit basis at the instance of Accused 3 by taking only token amount and hence Firozbhai was keen that Accused 3 should accompany him. The brother of deceased Firozbhai, Mohammed Usman was working in a Cooperative Bank in the same place and during the spare hours he was helping Firozbhai in his business. On 20-2-1984, Firozbhai told his brother Mohammed Usman of his plan to go to Savarkundla with Accused 1 and 3 for collecting dues from his customers and requested him not to go to the bank on the next day so that he can attend to the business at the shop. Both the brothers took dinner in the night and at that time Firozbhai informed his wife Banu Bibi about his programme to go to Savarkundla and further told her that he was to go in the car with Accused 1 and 3 and she need not worry because of severe cold. After dinner he left the home with a suitcase and went to the shop of Accused 3.

    4. Accused 3 at that time was reluctant to go with Firozbhai and finally Accused 1 and 3 agreed and they started in the Fiat car driven by Accused 3. On their way, they put petrol from the petrol pump of Lalitkumar and proceeded towards Bagodara. Suddenly, they decided to go to Nal Sarovar for hunting and they went to Village Gangad and took Accused 2 with his gun. It was decided that firstly they would go for hunting at Nal Sarovar and then they would proceed to Savarkundla. They took petrol from Bagodara petrol pump and started their journey towards Nal Sarovar. When they were nearing Nal Sarovar, Firozbhai received gunshot injury from the gun and the accused returned towards city to take injured Firozbhai to the hospital. On the way Accused 2 got down with his gun. Accused 1 and 3 took injured Firozbhai to V.S Hospital and told the hospital authority that some unknown persons injured Firozbhai when they were proceeding towards Savarkundla. Firozbhai succumbed to the gunshot injury and the police from Ellisbridge Police Station recorded the complaint of Accused 3 and the case was registered. Inquest was held and articles were recovered and the Fiat car belonging to Accused 3 was seized in the presence of panchas under a mahazar. The body was sent to post-mortem.

    5. PW 4 Dr Pratima Mahendra Desai conducted autopsy under the supervision of PW 1 Dr Kothari and they found the following injuries:

    “1. Wound on right side of chest just lateral and slightly below right nipple. Its margin just touching the areola. It was 12 cm away from the midline of chest and 16 cm below right clavicle. It was 3 cm × 2 cm × chest cavity-deep. Margin was abraded as shown in diagram, the lower border showing bevelling and it was red and upper border is overlapping. The fourth, fifth right ribs were fractured. The direction was from right to left anteroposteriorly and below upwards. Margins inverted. No visible marks of burning, tattooing and blackening. Blood was coming out from this wound, these injuries were ante-mortem.”

    Ext. 15 is the post-mortem certificate issued by them and the cause of death was due to shock and haemorrhage resulting from firearm wound.

    6. The Forensic Science Laboratory experts collected the chance-prints on the handle of the motor car and took specimen of blood from the bloodstains found in the car. They took hand wash of Accused 1 and 3. On investigation the police found that Accused 3 has given false information and the case was transferred to Umrala Police Station and thereafter the investigation was handed over to the State Crime Branch. The witnesses were examined and on completion of the investigation final report came to be filed against the accused. During the trial the prosecution examined number of witnesses and marked documents. The trial court acquitted the accused of the charges. However, on the appeal by the State, the High Court set aside the judgment of the trial court and convicted and sentenced the accused as stated supra. The accused have challenged the same in the present appeals.

    7. The primary submission made on behalf of the appellants is that the High Court in the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 865 of 1986 had merely substituted its view to the one taken by the trial court which is impermissible in law and it ought not to have interfered with the judgment of acquittal made by the trial court, particularly in a case of circumstantial evidence. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent State contended that the High Court has elaborately considered the evidence on record and came to the conclusion that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the accused persons and the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellants are sustainable.

    8. The crucial issue for consideration, therefore, relates to interference by the High Court in an acquittal rendered by the trial court. The entire case law on the subject was discussed by this Court in the decision in Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka (2007) 4 SCC 415 wherein it was held as follows:

    “(1) An appellate court has full power to review, reappreciate and reconsider the evidence upon which the order of acquittal is founded.
    (2) The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 puts no limitation, restriction or condition on exercise of such power and an appellate court on the evidence before it may reach its own conclusion, both on questions of fact and of law.
    (3) Various expressions, such as, ‘substantial and compelling reasons’, ‘good and sufficient grounds’, ‘very strong circumstances’, ‘distorted conclusions’, ‘glaring mistakes’, etc. are not intended to curtail extensive powers of an appellate court in an appeal against acquittal. Such phraseologies are more in the nature of ‘flourishes of language’ to emphasise the reluctance of an appellate court to interfere with acquittal than to curtail the power of the court to review the evidence and to come to its own conclusion.
    (4) An appellate court, however, must bear in mind that in case of acquittal, there is double presumption in favour of the accused. Firstly, the presumption of innocence is available to him under the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that every person shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved guilty by a competent court of law. Secondly, the accused having secured his acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is further reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial court.
    (5) If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis of the evidence on record, the appellate court should not disturb the finding of acquittal recorded by the trial court.”

    It is the obligation of the High Court to consider and identify the error in the decision of the trial court and then decide whether the error is gross enough to warrant interference. The High Court is not expected to merely substitute its opinion for that of the trial court only because of the first two principles in the decision referred to above permit it to do so and because it has the power to do so — it has to correct an error of law or fact significant enough to necessitate overturning the verdict of the trial court. The High Court has to exercise its discretion very cautiously, keeping in mind the acquittal of the accused and the rights of the victim.

    9. The case of the prosecution rests on circumstantial evidence. Though the appellants herein were charged for the offence of criminal conspiracy to commit the murder of Firozbhai, the trial court as well as the High Court held that the said charge has not been proved by the prosecution. Insofar as the charge of murder is concerned, the High Court reversed the judgment of the acquittal of the trial court and found the appellants guilty and that is under challenge in these appeals.

    10. For better appreciation, in this judgment, the accused are referred to by their original rankings before the trial court. Firozbhai was in the business of selling tyres of four-wheelers and two-wheelers and Accused 3 was in the business of sale and purchase of motor trucks and he was helping Firozbhai to sell tyres to the traders at Savarkundla. Accused 1 was also a friend of Firozbhai and Accused 2 was a common friend to all of them. At the instance of Accused 3, Firozbhai sold tyres to the customers at Savarkundla on credit basis and there were outstandings to be recovered and on 20-2-1984, Firozbhai asked Accused 3 to accompany him to collect the dues. Accused 3 was reluctant to proceed to Savarkundla in the night on 20-2-1984 because of the cold climate but on the compulsion of Firozbhai both Accused 1 and 3 agreed to the trip. Firozbhai directed his younger brother to look after the business in the shop the next day and convinced his wife that he is proceeding in the car driven by Accused 3 and hence she need not worry about the cold climate. Accordingly, they left at about 10.00 p.m on 20-2-1984 in the Fiat car driven by Accused 3 and on the way they put petrol from the petrol pump of Lalit Kumar. Out of 12 circumstances enumerated by the trial court in its judgment the above constitute first four of them and the trial court found that the prosecution has satisfactorily established the same.

    11. In this context it has to be borne in mind that the relationship Firozbhai had with Accused 1 and 3 was very cordial. It is in evidence that Accused 3 would frequently visit the shop of Firozbhai and was helping Firozbhai in improving his tyre business. In fact, Accused 3 was reluctant to go to Savarkundla in the night on 20-2-1984 on account of cold climate and suggested to leave the next day morning. Firozbhai having come fully prepared for the trip with his suitcase, compelled Accused 1 and 3 to leave the same night by car to Savarkundla. While proceeding to Bagodara they decided to go Nal Sarovar for hunting and they took Accused 2 with his gun and when they were nearing Nal Sarovar Firozbhai received the gunshot injury from the gun. Both the wife and younger brother of Firozbhai have testified that Firozbhai was fond of hunting and on earlier occasion he had gone for hunting along with his friends. Hence, there is no surprise that they took a decision while midway to go for hunting at Nal Sarovar and then proceed to Savarkundla. Only for that purpose they picked up Accused 2, a common acquaintance, from his village.

    12. As per the prosecution case, Accused 3 was driving the Fiat car and Accused 2 was seated at his left side in the front seat and Firozbhai and Accused 1 were seated on the back seat and the gun resting between them vertically. Ext. 48 is the panchnama dated 19-5-1984 prepared during test and it states that the gun was placed on rear seat of the Fiat car and the butt of the gun moved towards the down side of the seat of the driver at 14 inches below the seat and the person was made to sit on the left side of the rear seat looking at the pipe of the gun and the pipe remain at 5 inches from the chest. PW 1 Dr Kothari under whose supervision the autopsy was conducted has testified that he saw wound on the right side of chest slightly below right nipple and the direction was from right to left anteroposteriorly and below upwards. It is his further testimony that if the deceased is sitting in motor car and if nozzle of gun is within distance of 1 ft and it is in the direction of injury and there is accidental firing the said injury is possible. The ballistic expert PW 7, in his testimony given on 10-12-1985 in the trial has stated that it is possible that if there are jerks and the road is bumpy there is a possibility that the trigger could be pressed and the gun be fired accidently. He further categorically opined that the direction of the injury is from down to up and hence there is every possibility that the gun injury is due to an accident.

    13. Much reliance was placed by the High Court on the information of the FSL expert about the presence of nitrate in the hand wash of Accused 1. In fact, the High Court in para 24 of the judgment has observed thus:

    “The presence of nitrate in the hand wash of this accused establishes that at the time of sustaining gunshot injury by deceased Firozbhai Accused 1 Ashrafkhan must be very close to him or he must be responsible for the injury.”

    Accused 1 was seated in the back seat along with Firozbhai when the gun fired. PW 7 Jayprakash, ballistic expert has testified that on the back seat of the car and on the doors of the left side glass pane nitrate was found. Having seated in the back seat it is but natural that nitrate was found in the hands of Accused 1 but from that no inference can be drawn that he used the gun and was responsible for the injury.

    14. The High Court treated the statement of Accused 3 given under Section 313 CrPC as evidence against him. This is clearly impermissible in law. This Court in the recent decision in Sujit Biswas v. State of Assam (2013) 12 SCC 406 held thus:

    “20. … The circumstances which are not put to the accused in his examination under Section 313 CrPC, cannot be used against him and must be excluded from consideration. The said statement cannot be treated as evidence within the meaning of Section 3 of the Evidence Act, as the accused cannot be cross-examined with reference to such statement.”
    (emphasis in original)

    15. Firozbhai died of gunshot injury is established by the medical evidence. The trial court elaborately considered the evidence and held that there was possibility of accidental death rather than homicidal death. In our view the homicidal death has not been established in the facts of the case.

    16. There was no motive for the occurrence. Though large amounts are said to be due from the customers at Savarkundla, there is no evidence on record in the form of books of accounts. Practically, there is no evidence on this aspect. In fact, according to PW 3 Mohammed Usman as per Ext. 19 a sum of Rs 35,640 was due from Accused 3 and a sum of Rs 18,240 was due from Accused 1. In the cross-examination he has stated that the said amount is due from the clients of Savarkundla and not from Accused 3 Ismailbhai and there are no dues from him. The law is well settled that when the prosecution case rests purely on circumstantial evidence, motive plays an important part in order to tilt the scale against the accused. In our view the High Court misread the material evidence and reversed the decision of the trial court by convicting the accused. The conviction and sentence are liable to be set aside.

    17. In the result all the appeals are allowed and the conviction and sentence imposed by the High Court on the appellants in the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 865 of 1986 are set aside and the judgment of acquittal rendered by the trial court is restored.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mahamadkhan Nathekhan v. State Of Gujarat .
    (Sep 10, 2014)