Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT 2002
  • Rules 8-A, 9 and 10 in the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
  • Order VIII, Rule 1 CPC as amended by Act 22 of 2002
  • Rule 1 of Order VIII as amended by Act 22 of 2002.
  • Order VIII, Rule 10 read with Section 151, CPC 1908
  • Order VIII, Rule 1, CPC as amended by Act 46
  • Act 22 of 2002. Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • Rules 1, 1(a) and 10 of Order VIII
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC
  • Rule 1 of Order VIII, CPC
  • Order VIII, Rule 1, CPC,
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT 2002
  • Rules 8-A, 9 and 10 in the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
  • Order VIII, Rule 1 CPC as amended by Act 22 of 2002
  • Rule 1 of Order VIII as amended by Act 22 of 2002.
  • Order VIII, Rule 10 read with Section 151, CPC 1908
  • Order VIII, Rule 1, CPC as amended by Act 46
  • Act 22 of 2002. Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • Rules 1, 1(a) and 10 of Order VIII
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC
  • Rule 1 of Order VIII, CPC
  • Order VIII, Rule 1, CPC,
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, plaintiff in O.S. No. 27 of 2002 before the Junior Civil Judge, Kalwakurthy, filed a suit for recovery of money. The suit summons were served on the sole defendant on 10-5-2002. The defendant appeared through counsel on 13-6-2002 and was granted time to file a written statement. The defendant ultimately filed the written statement on 9-10-2002, which was accepted by the Court. Despite this, the petitioner filed an application (I.A. No. 390 of 2002) under Order VIII, Rule 10 read with Section 151, CPC, praying that the written statement be rejected and judgment pronounced against the defendant. The trial Court dismissed this application by order dated 3-3-2003, holding that since the written statement was filed within the time permitted, judgment could not be pronounced under Rule 10 of Order VIII, CPC. The petitioner then filed this revision petition under Section 115, CPC challenging the trial Court's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Order VIII, Rule 1 CPC as amended by Act 46 of 1999 must be strictly interpreted to disallow any extension beyond 30 days for filing a written statement by the defendant.
  2. Whether the trial Court acted within its jurisdiction in refusing to pronounce judgment despite the defendant filing the written statement beyond 90 days from service of summons.
  3. Whether the lower Court's refusal to reject the written statement and pronounce judgment caused a miscarriage of justice to the petitioner.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Order VIII, Rule 1 CPC as amended by Act 46 of 1999 must be strictly interpreted in line with the legislative intent behind the amendments.
  • The Civil Court is not entitled to extend the time beyond 30 days from the date of service of summons for filing the written statement.
  • Since the defendant did not file the written statement within 90 days as required under the amended Rule 1 of Order VIII CPC, the trial Court ought to have pronounced judgment against the defendant or made an appropriate order.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the text of Rule 1 of Order VIII CPC as it existed before and after the amendments by Acts 46 of 1999 and 22 of 2002. The Court noted that while the normal requirement is for the defendant to file a written statement within 30 days of service of summons, this rule is not rigid or inflexible. The proviso to Rule 1 as amended by Act 22 of 2002 allows the Court to extend the time up to 90 days. Furthermore, Rules 8-A, 9, and 10 of Order VIII, which were omitted by Act 46 of 1999 and later reintroduced by Act 22 of 2002, provide that if a party fails to file a written statement within the time fixed by the Court, the Court shall pronounce judgment or make an appropriate order.

The Court interpreted the reintroduction of Rule 10 as evidence that Parliament did not intend for the Civil Court to pronounce judgment immediately upon failure to file the written statement within 90 days. Additionally, Section 148 CPC empowers the Court to enlarge time, and inherent powers under Section 151 CPC allow the Court to prevent miscarriage of justice. The Court concluded that the trial Court had sound discretion in refusing the interlocutory application and did not err in its decision.

Holding and Implications

The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed.

The Court upheld the trial Court's discretion in allowing the defendant's written statement filed within the time permitted by the Court. The decision confirms that the amended provisions of Order VIII, Rules 1 and 10 CPC, read with Sections 148 and 151 CPC, permit flexibility and judicial discretion in extending time for filing written statements and in deciding whether to pronounce judgment for failure to file within prescribed periods. No new precedent was established; the direct effect is that the petitioner’s application to reject the written statement and pronounce judgment was rightly refused.

    Nachipeddi Ramaswamy v. P. Buchi Reddy .

    Judgement

    The petitioner is the plaintiff in O.S. No. 27 of 2002 on the file of the Court of the Junior Civil Judge, Kalwakurthy. The suit was filed for recovery of money. According to the petitioner, the suit summons were served on the sole defendant/respondent herein on 10-5-2002. The defendant appeared through counsel before the Court on 13-6-2002 and the Court granted time for filing written statement from time to time. Ultimately on 9-10-2002, the defendant filed a written statement and the Court accepted the same. None the less, the petitioner filed an application being I.A. No. 390 of 2002 under Order VIII, Rule 10 read with Section 151, CPC 1908 as amended by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act 1999 (Act 46 of 1999) and the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act 2002 (Act 22 of 2002). The petitioner prayed the trial Court to pronounce the judgment by rejecting the written statement filed by the defendant. The trial Court by the impugned order dated 3-3-2003 dismissed the petitioners application holding that the defendant filed the written statement within the time permitted by the Court and therefore a judgment cannot be pronounced as per Rule 10 of Order VIII, CPC.

    2. The learned counsel for the petitioner Sri K. Srinivas submits that Order VIII, Rule 1, CPC as amended by Act 46 of 1999 has to be strictly interpreted having regard to the spirit with which the amendments were brought into force. According to the learned counsel, the Civil Court is not entitled to extend time beyond 30 days from the date of service of summons on the defendant/defendants for filing written statement and as the defendant has not filed the written statement within 90 days as required under Order VIII, Rule 1, CPC, the lower Court ought to have pronounced the judgment or order.

    3. This revision petition is filed under Section 115, CPC. As per the said section as amendment by act 46 of 1999, the petitioner has to show that if his I.A. had been allowed, the same would have resulted in the disposal of the suit itself. As the petitioner prayed for pronouncement of the judgment and had it been allowed, it would have resulted in the disposal of the suit itself, the Civil Revision Petition is maintainable.

    4. The next question is whether the Court below has acted within the jurisdiction conferred on it and whether the alleged improper exercise of jurisdiction by the lower Court has resulted in miscarriage of justice to the petitioner?

    5. Rule 1 of Order VIII, CPC as it existed prior to Act 46 of 1999 and as it existed after amendment act 22 of 2002 reads as under :

    (See Table on next page)

    6. A reading of Rule 1 of Order VIII, CPC does not support the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner. The normal requirement of law is that the defendant shall within 30 days from the date of service of summons, present the written statement of his defence subject to other Rules contained in Order VIII. This Rule is not inflexible or rigid. This is made clear by the proviso to Rule 1 of Order VIII as amended by Act 22 of 2002. It stipulates that it is competent for the Court to specify the time beyond 30 days and in any case the same shall not be later than 90 days from the date of service of summons. It is also interesting to note that Rules 8-A, 9 and 10 in the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 were omitted by Act 46 of 1999 but again they were reintroduced after Act 22 of 2002. Rule 10 of Order VIII reads as under : Procedure when party fails to present written statement called for by Court :- Where any party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up.

    7. A plain reading of the above would show that if a defendant fails to present the written statement within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, the Court has to pronounce judgment and make such order relating to the suit as it thinks fit. The very fact that the Parliament which chose to delete Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC again decided to reintroduce it by act 22 of 2002 would show that Order VIII, Rule 1 CPC as amended by Act 22 of 2002 cannot be interpreted in strict terms. Further, to my mind, Rules 1, 1(a) and 10 of Order VIII together would show that though a defendant is required to file written statement within 30 days after receipt of summons and though the Court can extend the time till 90 days, the Court is not divested of power to fix further time for filing the written statement. It is well settled that this cardinal principle of interpretation of law with an enactment has to be read as a whole and then the entire section has to be read and thereafter the Act has to be interpreted section by section. One Rule or one Section in the enactment cannot be a guiding factor for arriving at the intendment of the legislature. The very fact that Rule 10 is reintroduced by act 22 of 2002 by the Parliament would show that the Parliament never intended the Civil Court to pronounce judgment immediately after the failure on the part of the defendant to file written statement within 90 days.

    8. Further, Section 148, CPC empowers the Court to enlarge the time. In addition to this, we must not forget that the Civil Court being a Court of equity, justice and good conscience is also vested with inherent powers under Section 151 CPC to avoid miscarriage of justice. It is always open to the Civil Court to exercise inherent powers provided such exercise is not totally derogatory to the main provisions of the Act and the Rules made thereunder.

    9. In refusing the interlocutory application filed by the petitioner, the lower Court has exercised sound discretion and the same does not warrant any interference under Section 115, CPC.

    10. The Civil Revision Petition is accordingly dismissed.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nachipeddi Ramaswamy v. P. Buchi Reddy .
    (Apr 17, 2003)