Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • (3) Rule 17 of civil rules
  • 6, rule 14 of the code
  • 6, rule 14 and rule 17
  • Order 6, rule 14,
  • Order 29, rule 1,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • (3) Rule 17 of civil rules
  • 6, rule 14 of the code
  • 6, rule 14 and rule 17
  • Order 6, rule 14,
  • Order 29, rule 1,

    K.A.Mangatayaramma v. Indian Bank, Madras

    (1) The petitioner is the defendant. He raised the plea that the person who signed on behalf of the respondent - bank did not file into court the authorisation to verify the pleadings and that therefore, the plaint shall be rejected. The lower court has not considered that ground, but held that this ground can be raised by filing an additional written statement and it would be considered at the time of trial. Assailing the said order, the revision has been filed.

    (2) Sri t. Veerabhadrayya, learned counsel for the petitioner relying upon rule 17 of civil rules of practice read with order 6, rule 14 of the code of civil procedure, has contended that rule. 17, civil rules of practice, has not been complied with.

    (3) Rule 17 of civil rules of practice reads thus:

    "if any pleading which, under any " provision of law or these rules, is required to be signed or verified by a party, is signed or verified by any person on his behalf of a written authority in this behalf signed by the authority shall be filed in court", together with an affidavit verifying the signature of the party, and stating the reason of his inability to sign or verify the proceeding, and proving the means of knowledge of the facts set out. In the proceeding of the person signing or verifying the same. "

    No doubt. Order 6, rule 14, civil procedure code, postulates that every pleading shall be signed by the party and his pleader. Where by reason of absence or for other good cause the party is unable to sign the pleading, any person duly authorised by him may sign the pleading. The object, thereby is that the suit was instituted with the knowledge of the suitor and that he award of the contents of the pleading since he is bound thereby. Admittedly, the respondent is a nationalised bank, and therefore, it is signed by the officer appointed by the bank, since the bank as such cannot sign the pleadings being an incorporated body. Order 29, rule 1, c. P. C. Provides that in a suit by or against a corporation, a pleading may be signed and verified on behalf of the corporation by the secretary or by any director or other principal officer of the corporation who is able to depose to the facts of the case. This rule is permissible but not mandatory. This rule is subject to the rule laid down in order 6, rule 14 and rule 17 operates in that area. Therefore, the officer authorised on behalf of the bank has to sign the pleading and has to verify its contents. Rule 17 of the civil rules of practice is to be read subject to the above rules. A written authorisation in this behalf signed by the party shall be filed in court together with an affidavit verifying the signature of the competent officer of the bank stating the reason of his inability to sign or verify the. Pleading proving the means of knowledge of the facts set out in the pleadings. Though the language couched appears to be mandatory regarding filing of the authorisation, it is not an inflexible rule. The word "shall" is not always a prescriptive of mandatory character. The object and purpose of the statute has to be kept in view. When a duty is imposed by a statute requiring that it shall be performed in a certain manner, such prescription may well be regarded to be directory only in cases where no injustice is caused to others or public have no control over the performance of duty by the officer entrusted. To hold such acts as null and void would work serious injustice or inconvenience and at the same time it would not promote the main object of the statute. In this perspective it must be held that rule 17 is only directory. On establishing that the person that signed and verified the pleading is authorised or conpetent to sign on behalf - of a corporation it would be unreasonable to call upon to file the authorisation along with the plaint or written statement. It could be filed later. It is a question of fact in each case. The plaint is not to be rejected outright on that score. Sufficient time may be given to file the same. In this case, since the verification was made by a competent person on behalf of an incorporated body, i. E. The bank, though authorised, the authorisation has not been filed into court. It is common knowledge that an incorporated body would file the plaint or the written statement as the case may be, only on authority. Keeping the internment of the rule and the purpose of which it is being done, it mus be held that the filing of the authorisation shall be treated to be only directory. Accordingly, i hold the infirmity crept in the case is not so vital as to vitiate the initiation of the proceedings in the suit. Accordingly the order of the lower court is not required to be revised in this revision. The civil revision petition is dismissed,but in the circumstances, without costs.

    (4) The respondent - bank is directed to file the authorisation together with an affidavit as provided under rule 17 of the civil rules of. Practice, within a period of one month from today. C. R. P. Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.A.Mangatayaramma v. Indian Bank, Madras
    (Feb 28, 1984)