Seetharem Reddy, J.:-
(1) This petition seeks to issue a writ of mandamus declaring various provisions of the andhra pradesh educational institutions (regulation of admissions and prohibition of capitation fee) act 1983 (hereinafter referred to as'the act') as ultra vires of articles 26, 29 and 30 of the constitution of india, and consequently directing the respondents to forbear from implementing the same.
(2) During the time when the case was heard; including not only the day when the arguments came to an end but also later, employees of this high court were on strike. Therefore, the detailed reasoning for the judgment was postponed, though the operative portion of the judgment was pronounced on that day hence these reasons.
(3) Relevant format of the case is: the petitioner - society styled - 'sultan - ui - uloom education society, hyderabad', was registered in the year 1980 under the a. P. (telangana area) public societies regulation act, 1350 fasti. It is, as per the affidavit filed in support of the petition, a muslim minority institution set up to promote modern and scientific education and to help, develop the character of the younger generation of all castes communities and religions in general and of muslims in particular. One of the aims and objects is to establish technical, scientific and educational institutions. All the members of the society and office bearers are muslims. The society decided to establish a college of engineering and technology commencing from the academic year 1981 - 82 and so on request, the state government accorded permission through its letter dated 4 - 9 - 1980 on ceitairt conditions rh petitioner society was also permitted to levy capitation fee on students seeking admission. It was, however, made clear that no financial aid, recurring, and non - recurring shall be made available. On certain conditions being fulfilled an inspection commission appointed by the osmania university, to which this institution was seeking affiliation, afier spot inspection of the college, submitted its recommendations inter alia, to grant provisional affiliation to the college for two years. Ovie of the conditions imposed by the state government was that the petitioner - society is to fill up 70% of the seats strictly in accordance with merit - cum - capitation fee, and the rest of 30%seats will be filled up by the management at their discretion, however, subject to rules and procedure of admission. The college, therefore, came into being on 1 - 12 - 1980 and commenced courses with an intake of 150 students in three disciplines - civil, mechanical and electronics communications. The provisional affiliation granted earlier was further extended. Out of 14 private engineering colleges, the petitioner - society is the only one which is run by the muslim minority community.
(4) While so, the government of andhra pradesh promulgated ordinance 3 of 1983 on 30 - 1 - 1983, which sought to regulate admission to educational institutions and to prohibit the collection of capitation fee. The ordinance however, was not applicable to the institution run by the petitioner - society. Subsequently, the state legislature enacted the impugned act and brought it into force with effect from 30 - 1 - 1983 the date on which the ordinance was brought into force. It received the assent of the governor on 6 - 4 - 1983. In the act, however, the provision contained in the ordinance, which saved minority educational institutions from its operation, has been omitted thereby making it applicable to the minority institutions as well. The act, therefore, makes drastic inroads into the rights of the minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The provisions of the act obligate the management to a particular method of admission, which violate the constitutional guarantees provided to minority communities under articles 26, 29 and 30 of the constitution of india. Hence this writ petition.
(5) The affidavit in opposition fited on behalf of the state government avers inter alia that the letter dated 4 - 9 - 1880, through which permission is said to have been accorded to the petitioner - society the government have informed the vice chancellor, osmania university, of the fact that they have recommended to the deputy educational officer (technical). Government of india. Ministry of education, southern regional office, madras, that an engineering college might be started at hyderabad under the management of sultan - ui - uloom education society. It is further averred that the petitioner - society has started muffakham jah college of engineering at hyderabad from the year 1980 - 81 even before the permission was accorded by the deputy educational adviser. As per the terms and conditions, the society has to deposit an amount of rs. 30 lakhs in a joint account of the institution and the director of technical education and also to provide a land of 30 acres. The society has not so far produced the title deeds regarding the land. Even the deposit of an amount of rs. 30 lakhs in the grindlays bank, hyderabad, is not in a joint account of the society and the director of technical education and so, the society has not fulfilled the conditions. These conditions were also enclosed to the letter addressed to the vice - chancellor, osmania university.
(6) The college started functioning with effect from 1 - 12 - 1980 with an intake of 150 students, it is further stated that the college has not been registered under the societies registration act. It has not also adopted the rule of reservation for purposes of admission and thus violated the rules and procedure for admission. It is also stated that the society did not seek any clarification at any time as to the quantum of capitation fee that they would collect from the students for admission. So according of permission for collection of capitation fee by the state government does not arise at all.
(7) Further, the institution cannot be classified as a minority institution as majority of the students belonged to other communities. Though it is a fact that the college is run by the muslim minority in the sense that all the members of the governing body belong to the muslim community, but it is in no way advancing the cause of the minority community there is no concession shown in collecting capitation fee to the students belonging to the minority community. Further, from the memorandum of association it is evident that the institution was started to promote modern and scientific education and to help, develop the character of the younger generation of all castes, communities and religions. Hence it cannot be treated as a minority institution" established and administered for the benefit of the muslim minority. "
(8) The management collected capitation fee of rs. 25,000/ - in general from each candidate; rs. 35,000/ - each from candidates belonging to other states and rs. 50,000/ - each from candidates coming from outside the country. The provisions of the act by prohibiting the collection of capitation fees, by regulating collection of donations and the tuitions fees, neither prevent the management from formulating any alternate sources of finances, nor violate the constitutional protections. The provisions of the act, inter alia, regulate admissions based on merit. They seek to do away wjth the unhealthy and evil practice of admission to educational institutions the basis of paying capacity of the students, rather than merit, which alone should be the criterion for pursuing professional or higher education. It is also averred that though the collection of capitation fee is abolished, yet receipt or donations is not prohibited. What is prohibited is the price of admission. Further the government by its letter dt: 3 - 6 - 1983 assured non - recurring and recurring grants to the petitioner and also indicated the tuition fees of rs. 3. 000/ - to be collected from each student. These measures are assured on the basis of the recommendation of a/i expert committee to make up the deficit of the institution for abolition of capitation fees contentions; - the contentions of sri v. Venkataramanayya learned counsel for the petitioner in the main are:
(1) the petitioner institution which is being run and administered by the muslim minority is entitled to the protection and benefits conferred under article 30 of the constitution of india. (2) the various provisions enacted in the impugned act. Are ultravires and violative of the various provisions of the constitution of india.
(9) Preliminary objection - petitioner institution whether a minority one ? the learned advocate general raised a preliminary point contending that the petitioner - institution cannot be reckoned as a minority institution, as this institution has neither been established nor administered by a minority community further, the memorandum of association must show that it is for the benefit of the minority. Therefore, the question of claiming protection under article 30 of the constitution does not arise.
(10) Chiefly, therefore, the argument of the learned advocate general rests on (1) the proper meaning of the words 'establish' and 'administer' and (2) whether the institution should subserve the minority.
(11) The learned advocate general placed reliance, in support of this argument, on the memorandum of associa - tion of the petitioner - society. We may at once, therefore turn to thft relevant portions of the memorandum. Para 3 which sets out the aims and objects, runs as under:
"3 aims and objects: this is a muslim minority institution envisaged under articles 25 to 30 of the constitution of india set up to promote modern and scientific education and to help develop the character of the younger generation of all castes communities and religions in general and of muslims in particular."
(12) Annexed to the memorandum of association are the 'rules and regulations of the society' the relevant portions may be set out;
"i. Membership: - membership of the society shall comprise of the following categories of individuals/institutions - (a) promoter members listed in annexure - i (b) founder members listed in annexure - ii (c) life members whose applications for membership have been approved by the board of governors and who have paid a fee of rs. 500/ -. (d) institutional members whose applications have been accepted. "iii. Mode of enrolment : - any person/institution desirous of becoming a member shall submit his/its application in writing on the printed form of the society together with membership fee. The board of governors shall have the - discretion to accept or reject an application without assigning reasons for its - decision. "
"vii. General body: - the general body shall consist of (1) promoter members, (2) founder members (3) lifa members and (4) institutional members a meeting of the general body shall be held annually in the months of april to july. It shall - (a) review the working of the society and its subordinate bodies, if any (b) consider such matters as are; referred to it by the board of governors; (c) confirm minutes of the previous meeting; (d) adopt the annual report of the board of governors; (e) adopt the statement of account prepared by the auditors of the society."
Viii "board of governors (a) the affairs of the society shall be managed by a board of governors of not less than five and not more than seven members. (b) the board of governors shall comprise of: i, the four promoter members named in annexure - l , who shall be permanent. Ii. Two founder members nominated by promoter members from those named in annexure - ii. Iii. One member nominated by promoter members from the categories of life members and institutional members. Iv. Not more than three co - opted members. (c) every board of governors shall elect its chairman. Secretary and treasurer in its first meeting. It shall have the powers to create additional posts of office bearers if required and to elect such additional office bearers. The chairman and secretary as also vice - chairman and joint - secretary, if and when such posts are created shall be elected from the list of promoter members only. (d) the board of governors shall be competent to co - opt not more than 3 members in addition to its approved strength. (e) the day - to - day affairs of the society shall be managed by the board of governors and it shall meet once a month if not oftener. (f) meetings of the board of governors shall be called by the secretary with the concurrence of the chairman. (g) full names, addresses, designations and occupations of the members of the board of governors to whom, by the rules and regulations of the society, the management of its affairs is entrusted:
'width:53. 1%; border - collapse:collapse;border:none;mso - border - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - padding - alt:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'>
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> si. No. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - left:none;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> name |
top style='width:29. 16%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - left:none;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> office |
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> mr. K a siddique |
top style='width:29. 16%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> chairman |
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 2. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> mr. Ghulam ahmed |
top style='width:29. 16%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> member |
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 3. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> mr. S m amjad ali khan |
top style='width:29. 16%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> member |
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 4. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> mr. M waliullah |
top style='width:29. 16%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> member |
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 5. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> mr. Mohd ikramullah khan |
top style='width:29. 16%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> member |
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 6. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> prof manzoor alam |
top style='width:29. 16%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> member |
| top style='width:17. 32%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 7. |
top style='width:53. 52%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> mr. Nizamuddin ahmed |
top style='width:29. 16%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> secretary |
the persons named above shall constitute the society's board of governors and shall hold office for a period of five years from the date of registration.
(13) Insofar as the aims and objects clause as laid down in the memorandum of association, is concerned, the very first words are "this is a musiim minority institution" , then followed up by the words - 'envisaged under articles 25 to 30 of the constitution of india". But when it comes to the main object, it reads: "to help, develop the character of the younger, generation of all castes, communities and religions in general and of muslims in particular". The emphasis, therefore being on muslims to begin with, but latei in general terms in respect of other castes, communities and religions also. It is equally evident from the rules and regulations of the society, annexed to the memorandum of association, that all the members of the board of governors, comprising 7 members, belong to the muslim community. The promoter members, as per annexure - l, comprises all muslims; so also, the founder members listed in annexure - ll.
(14) Now before adjudicating, while bearing in mind the ingredients as brought out from the memorandum of association, the position in this behalf as brought out by the ease may be noticed
(15) Meaning of establishment and administer's whethef to bi used conjuctively in azeez basha v. Union of india (1) a i r 1968 s c 662 (aligarh muslim university case for short) the supreme court while dealing with the word "establish" as employed in article 30 (1) of the constitution, held:
"it will be seen that here also founding is not the only meaning; and the word also means "to bring into existence. " we are of opinion that for the purpose of art 30 (1) the word means" to bring in to existence and so the right given by article 30 (1) to the minority is to bring into - existence an educational institution, and if they do so to administer it. "
Further held:
"the 1920 - act was then passed by the central legislature and the university of the type that was established thereunder, namely, one whose degrees would be recognised by government, came to be established. It was clearly brought into existence by the 1920 - act for it could not have been brought into existence otherwise. It was thus the central legislature which brought into existence the aligarh university and must be held to have established it. It would not be possible for the muslim minority to establish a university of the kind whose degrees were bou,nd to be recognised by government and therefore it must be he'd that the aligarh university was brought into existence by the central legislature and the government of india. If that is so, the muslim minority cannot claim to administer it, for it was not brought into existence by it. The aligarh university not having been established by the muslim minority, no amendment of the act can be struck down as unconstitutional under article 30 (1)."
(16) Further, while dealing with the membership and nature of the court, it was observed;
"it is true that the proviso to section 23 (1) of the 1920 - act said that" no person other than a muslim shall be a member of the court", which was declared to be the supreme governing body of the aligarh university and was to exercise all the powers of the university, not otherwise provided for by that act. It appears from paragraph 8 of the schedule that even though the members of the court had to be muslims, the electorates were not exclusively muslims. Besides there were other bodies like the executive council and the academic council which were concerned with the administration of the aligarh university and there was no provision in the constitution of these bodies which confined their members only to muslims. It will thus be seen that" besides the fact that the members of the court had to be all muslims, there was nothing in the act to suggest that the administration of the aligarh university was in the muslim minority as such. We are therefore of opinion that the aligarh university was neither established nor administered by the muslim minority and therefore, there is no question of any amendment to the 1920 - act being unconstitutional under article 30 (1) for that article does not apply at all to the aligarh university. "
(17) In state of kerala vs. Mother provincial (2) air 1970 s. C. 2079. The supreme court held: "article 30 (1) has been construed
Before by this court. Without referring to those cases it is sufficient to say that the clause contemplates two rights which are separated in point of time. The first right is the initial right to establish institutions of the minority's choice. Establishment here means the bringing into being of an institution and it must be by a minority community it matters not if a single philanthropic individual with his own means, founds the institution or the community, at large contributes the funds. The position in law is the same and the intention in either case must be to found an institution for the benefit of a minority community by a member of that community. It equally irrelavent that in addition to the minority community others from other minority communities or even from the majority community can take advantage of these institutions such other communities bring in income and they do not have to be turned away to enjoy the protection the next part of the right relates to the administration of such institutions. Administration means 'managment of the affairs' of the institution. This management must be free of control 60 that the founders or their nominees can mould the institution as they think fit, and in accordance with their ideas of how the interests of the community in general and the institution in particular will be best served, no part of this management can be taken away and vested in another body without an encroachment upon the guaranteed right. "
(18) In s. K. Patro vs state of bihar (3) air 1970 sc 259 the supreme court while faced with the question,' whether the church missionary society higher secondary school was established and administered by the christian mis - sionaries or not held:
"the extracts from the record book clearly showed that the local residents of bhagalpur had taken a leading role in establishing and maintaining the school; assistance was undoubtedly obtained from other bodies including the church missionary society london, but the school was set up by the christian mis - sionaries and the local christian residents of bhagalpur with the aid of funds part of which was contributed by them."
(19) It is categorically asserted in the affidavit of the petitioner that the entire initial investment at the time of establishment of the college, was received by way of donation and benefaca - tions from the muslim community. It is also clear from the memorandum of association that all the bodies, including the governing body are composed of members from muslim community only. So, the muslim minority community has brought the college into being and so should be held as established by the said minority within the meaning of article 30 (1) of the constitution. It is equally to be held that right from the inception i. E. From 1980 - 81, the affairs of the institution are being managed by the muslim community only. Therefore it has undoubtedly to be held that the college is being administered by the muslim minority community within the meaning of the said article. So even reading disjunctively, the twin ingredients establish' and administer' envisaged under article 30 (1) of the constitution are to be held satisfied therefore we have no hesitation in holding that the institution has to be reckoned as a minority institution. The cases referred to above, cited for the resoondent - state can be of little or no assistance. Petitioner - institution whether subserve the interest of the minority exclusively:
(20) Now coming to the second aspect, the argument of the learned advocate general is that admittedly the management has to fill up 70% of the seats strictly in accordance with merit cum capitation fee. However, the management has been permitted to fill up the remainder 30% at their discretion which of course again is subject to the rules and procedure of admission. So there is nothing in the memorandum of association to show that the 70% of seats so reserved is totally restricted to muslims. Therefore it cannot be said that the institution is serving the muslim minority. Reliance was placed on the following case law.
(21) In in re kerala eduction bill 1957 air 1958 sc 956 the supreme court held:
"it is therefore that art. 30 (1) confers on all minorities whether based on religion or language the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice the minorities evidently desire that education should be imparted to the children of their community in an atmosphere congenial to the growth of their culture. Our constitution makers recognised the validity of their claim and to allay their fears conferred on them the fundamental rights referred to above. Without recognition therefore the educational institutions established or to be established by the minority con. Munities cannot fulfil the real objects of their choice and the rights under art. 30 (1) cannot be effectively exercised. The right to establish educational institutions of their choice must therefore mean the right to establish real institutions which will effectively serve the needs of their community and the scholars who resort to the educational institutions."
In samuel v dist, educational officer (5) air 1982 a. P 64 this court held :
"it is necessary to reiterate that the right guaranteed by art. 30 of the constitution is the right given to the minority as such, and not to an individual member, or individual members of the minority and that the right is moant to benefit the minority by protecting and promoting its interests where an educational institution is established and maintained exclusively or predominantly for leeching or promoting the religious tenets of a given religious minority, or for promoting and developing the language and literature of a given linguistic minority, there can be little doubt that it is an educational institution serving and promoting the interests of such minority, and hence a 'minority institution' but, where an educational institution is established and maintained for imparting general secular education where admission is not restricted to the members of that minority alone, (where a particular minority institution does not want any aid from the government, it would not be bound by the restriction in art. 29 (2) , the question arises whether merely because the person or persons who establish it belong to a minority community (whether or not they form into a committee or a society registered under the societies registration act) , can the institution itself be treated as a "minority institution"? on this aspect, it should be remembered that it is not necessary that the minority community as such should establish the institution; it is open to a single member of a minority community to establish end maintain an educational institution. (see: state of kerala vs. Mother provincial, air 1970 s c 2079 (at p 2082) , but it should not be forgotten that such educational institution must, in some manner, serve or promote the interests of the minority. It should be shown that the minority concerned, or a considerable section thereof/ is benefited by that institution. Otherwise, there would be no nexus between the institution and the minority as such. Take the case of an educational institution established by en individual 'a' belonging to a minority community, in the sta te. The institution established by him imparts purely secular education as seems to be the position today generally. The institution is not meant to preserve and promote the religion or language of the minority. The person runs the institution for his own private benefit and promotion. The majority of the students do not belong to the minority community to which the person establishing it, belongs. What is the conceivable connection, in such a case, between the institution and the minority community; and what is the basis for calling it a 'minority institutioji? it is not a'minority institution', but an institution belonging to an individual who happens to belong to a minority community. "
Further held :
"therefore, it cannot be said that, merely because the members of a society which establishes an educational institution belong to a particular minority, community the institution established by them automatically becomes a minority institution. In each, case, the same test must be applied, viz whether the institution does in any manner serve or promote the interests of the minority to which it claims to belong."
In st. J. T. College for women' ernakulam vs. Uni. App. Tribunal (6) 1980 lab. I. C. Page 47, it was held :
"regulations made in the true interests of efficiency of instruction discipline, health, sanitation morality, public order and the like may undoubtedly be imposed. Such regulations are not restrictions on the substance of the right which is guaranteed : they secure the proper functioning of the institutions, in matters educational. The freedom guaranteed by art. 30 (1) is intended to be a real and effective right for the protection of the minorities in the matter of setting up of educational institutions of their choice and administering them in the manner they consider best for promoting the ideas and ideals underlying the founding of the institution. The right cannot be whittled down by so - called regulative measures conceived in the interest not of the minority educational institutions but of the public or of the nation as a whole. Regulations which may lawfully be imposed either by legislative or executive action must be directed to making the institution effective as an educational institution while retaining its character as a minority institution. Such regulation must satisfy a dual test the test of reasonableness and the test that it is regulative of the educational character of the institution and is conducive to making the institution an effective vehicle of education for the minority community as well as other persons who resort to it"
.
(22) The learned counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the following decisions. W proost vs state of bihar (7) air1969sc465 in this case the supreme court held :
"the argument on behalf of the state there appears to be that there are three conditions before the protection and privileges of article 30 (1) may be clai - med : - (1) there must be a minority community, (2) one or more of the members of that community should after the commencement of the constitution, seek to exercise the right to establish an educational institution of his or their, choice, and (3) the educational institution must be established for the members of his or their own community"
.
Dealing with the third aspect, their lordships held :
"the emphasis here was rightly placed not upon the needs of the community exclusively but upon the educational needs of the citizens or sections thereof. In other words, the suggestion that art. 30 (1) is limited to the needs of a single community or that only its own culture, language or script need to be provided for is not the right approach". Here too, if we may say so, the point decided was different but the observation does make article 30 (1) much wider than the learned attorney general would have us hold"
(23) Before adjudicating, the statistical data regarding the admittees for 3 years, as provided for in the additional affidavit filed on behalf of the petitioners, may be noticed.
'width:87. 16%; border - collapse:collapse;border:none;mso - border - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - padding - alt:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'>
| 5 valign=top style='width:100. 0%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> annexure - 'b' number of candidates admitted at reduced or nil donation |
| top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> si. No. |
top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> year |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> muslims |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> non muslims |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> total |
| top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1. |
top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1980 - 81 |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 24 |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 2 |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 26 |
| top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 2. |
top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1981 - 82 |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 14 |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 2 |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 16 |
| top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 3. |
top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1982 - 83 |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 28 |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 5 |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 33 |
" colspan=5 valign=top style='width:100. 0%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> annexure - 'a' |
| colspan=5 valign=top style='width:100. 0%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> statement showing the number of ? muslims and non - muslims admitted in the college. |
| " valign=top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> ? |
" valign=top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> ? |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> muslims |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> non - muslims |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> total |
| top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> batch? 1 |
top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1980 - 81 |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 64 |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 76 |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 140 |
| top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> batch? 2 |
top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1981 - 82 |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 110 |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 60 |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 170 |
| top style='width:16. 56%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> batch? 3 |
top style='width:31. 04%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 1982 - 83 |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 95 |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 94 |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 189 |
| top style='width:47. 6%;border:solid windowtext. 75pt; border - top:none;mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;background:white; padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> total percentage of muslims 54% |
top style='width:14. 4%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 269 |
top style='width:20. 78%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 230 |
top style='width:17. 22%;border - top:none;border - left: none;border - bottom:solid windowtext. 75pt;border - right:solid windowtext. 75pt; mso - border - top - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt;mso - border - left - alt:solid windowtext. 75pt; background:white;padding:0in 2. 0pt 0in 2. 0pt'> 499 |
(24) This aspect of the case is assuming very great importance, as of late, there has bsen a growing tendency to establish an educational institution by a single individual or a few members of a family or two or three families of a minority community with the dominant idea of making money out of it by admitting predominantly students from other communities and only a marginal number from the minority community, in order to just give it a colour that it is a minority institution, claiming thereby all the possible protection under articles 29 and 30 of the constitution of india.
(25) True, a minority institution could be established even by a single member of that community or few members thereof. But, the benefit of imparting education must go, if not exclusively but predominantly to the members beloging to that minority community. If it does not, then it would defeat the raison - d - etre of the institution established for minorities. The observations of s r das, c j in in re kerala education bill' 1957 (4) (supra) are in fact quite apposite and the same may be seen.
"the real import of art. 29 (2) and art. 30 (1) seems to us to be that they clearly contemplate a minority institution with a sprinkling of outsiders admitted into it. By admitting a non - member into it, the minority institution does not shed its character and cease to be a minority institution -"
Observations of the in w proost vs state of
(26) The supreme court bihar (7 supra)
"in other words, the suggestion that article 30 (1) is limited to the needs of a single community or that only its own culture, language or script need to be provided for is not the right approach. ' will not, however, militate against the adjudication to which we have arrived at."
(27) Coming to the case on hand, even on the principle evolved by us, the institution cannot be reckoned as a non - minority institution the statistics furnished demonstrate that the admittees belonging to the minority community viz , muslim community; vastly predominate. Therefore, it is hard to accede to the submission of the learned advocate general that it should be reckoned as a minority - institution. Sections 3and4 of the act - whether constitute restrictions or permissible measures of regulation:
(28) The next limb of the contention of the learned advocate, - general, is that even assuming that it is a minority institution, the measures contained in sections 3 and 4 of the act are merely regulatory in nature, which are reasonable and that the same have been enacted for promoting the standards of education. Secondly, the standards of education are not part of management and therefore, any change affecting the mode and nature of admission, cannot be called restrictions, but permissible regulations.
(29) The argument in opposition is that admissions through common entrance test may be good, but there may not be adequate candidates from that minority community, who would have got through the said entrance test, and therefore, the institution might be compelled to admit non - minority students as well, affecting thereby the rights of ths institution.
(30) In order to appreciate the rival contentions, relevant provisions of sec -. Tions 3 and 4 of the impugned act may now be set out; section 3 of the act reads thus: -
"3 (1) subject to such rules as may be made in this behalf admission into educational institutions shall be made either on the basis of the marks obtained in the qualifying examination or on the basis of the ranking assigned in the entrance test conducted by such authority and in such manner as may be prescribed : provided that admission into medical and engineering colleges shall be made only on the basis of the ranking assigned in the common entrance test conducted as aforesaid. (2) the admission into educational institutions under sub - section (1) shall be subject to such rules as may be made by the government in regard to reservation of seats to the members belonging to scheduled castes, scheduled, tribes and backward classes and the andhra pradesh educational institution (regulation of admission) order, 1974"
.
Section 4 of the act runs as under: -
"section 4 (1) notwithstanding anything in section 3 it shall be lawful for any minority educational institution to admit students belonging to the concerned minority whether based on religion or language, on the basis of the marks obtained by them in the qualifying examination or as the case may be, on the basis of the ranking assigned to them in the entrance test conducted in the prescribed manner. (2) where any minority educational institution intends to admit students not belonging to the concerned minority, such admission shall be only on the basis of the maiks obtained in the qualifying examination or as the case may be, on the basis of the ranking assigned in the entrance test conducted in the prescribed manner."
(31) It is quite manifest from the proviso to section 3 (1) that admisssion to the engineering colleges, petitioner institution being one, shall be made only on the basis of the ranking secured in the common entrance test conducted as per the rules prescribed. As per rule 6, the government has constituted a common entrance test commmittee. In fact this year as many as 32,700 candidates appeared for the common entrance test out of whom 9,727 have been successful in securing the minimum marks laid down thereunder. Out of these, there are as many as 125 candidates, who belong to muslim community.
(32) Now, under section 4 (1) a minority inatitutipn is entitled to admit students belonging to the concerned minority community, on the basis of the ranking assigned in the common entrance test. In fact, under sub - section (2) of section 4, the minority institution is empowered to admit, if they so desire, some of thenon minority students as well. We do not find any fetter, from these provisions, on the powers of the management of a minority institution to admit majority of students belonging to that minority community. If that be so, we fail to see how these provisions trench upon their right to admit students belonging to their community.
(33) We dp not propose to deal with the hypothetical proposition, which the learned counsel at one stage attempted to advance, that if out of the successful candidates in the common entrance test, there cannot be adequate number to fulfil the aspiration of the management to admit all or predominantly students belonging to the muslim minority, then this provision envisaged under the proviso to section 3 (1) would seek to place restriction on their power to manage the institution. In state of kerala v. Mother provincial (2) supra it has been held by the supreme court that - " standards of education are not part of management". Therefoie, if the students belonging to muslim minority are not in a position to secure even the minimum percentage of marks, as prescribed by the rules in the common entrance test conducted, then certainly the management cannot be allowed to stifle the standards of education by admitting students belonging to that minority community, who could not secure even the minimum percentage of marks. So, as we have stated at the out set that this is purely hypothetical, the principles evolved do not admit of any such argument being advanced on behalf of the institution. So, from amongst the successful list of candidates, the minority institution will be quite at liberty to select candidates belonging to that minority community, though not quite in accordance with the general ranking assigned, which would otherwise be applicable to the other non - minority institutions. But, however, they would be constrained to accord admission to the members belonging to the minority community as per the ranking assigned in the common entrance test, in deviation of the general ranking assigned. Law for state
(34) Sidhrajbhai v. State of gujarat (8) a. I. R. 1963 s. C. 540 in this case the supreme court held:
"the state could not disregard of override the fundamental right by employ ing indirect methods of achieving exactly the same result. Even the legislature could not do indirectly what it certainly could not do directly"
.
Further held:
"it was therefore held that notwithstanding the absolute terms in which the fundamental freedom under art. 30 (1) was guaranteed, it was open to the state by legislation or by executive direction to impose reasonable regulations"
Also held:
"regulations which may lawfully be imposed either by legislative or executive action as a condition of receiving grant or of recognition must be directed to making the institution while retaining its character as a minority institution effective as an educational institution. Such regulation must satisfy a dual test the test of reasonableness and the test that it is regulative of the educational character of the institution and is conducive to making the institution an effective vehicle of education for the minority community or other persons who resort to it"
.
(35) In state of kerala. Vs. Mother provincial (2). Supra it was held: -
"administration means 'management of the affairs' of the institution. This management must be free of control so that the founders or their nominees can mould the institution as they think fit, and in accordance with their ideas of how the interests of the community in general and the institution in particular will'be best served. No part of this management can be taken away and vested in another body without an encroach ment upon the guaranteed right"
.
Also held:
"there is, however, an exception to this and it is that the standards of education are not a part of management as such. These standards concern the body politic and are dictated by considerations of the advancement of the country and its people. Therefore, if universities establish the sylabi for examinations, they must be followed subject however, to special subjects which the institutions may seek to teach, and to a certain extent the state may also regulate the conditions of employment of teachers and the health and hygiene of students. Such regulations do not bear directly upon management as such although they may indirectly affect it. Yet the right of the state to regulate education, educational standards and allied matters cannot be denied. The minority institutions cannot be allowed to fall below the standards of excellence expected of educational institutions or under the guise of exclusive right of management to decline to follow the general pattern"
.
(36) In all saints high school v govt. Of a p (9). A i r 1980 s c 1042 chandrachud c j speaking for the majority held: -
"these decisions show that while the riyht of the religious and linguistic minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice cannot be interfered with, restrictions by way of regulations for the purpose of ensuring educational standards and maintaining the excellence thereof can be validly prescribed. As observed by das, c j. , in re; kerala education bill, "right to administer cannot obviously include the right to mal - administer" and in the words of shah j. , in rev. Sidhrajbhai, "the right is subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of efficiency of instruction, discipline, health, sanitation morality, public order and tha like. " hidayatullah c j. Said in veiy rev. Mother provincial that "standards of education are not a part of management as such ", that the '. Minority institutions cannot be permitted to fall below the standard of excellence expected of educational institutions "and that " the right of the state to regulate education, educational standards and the allied matters cannot be denied. "
Further held: -
"no institution, minority or majority, has a fundamental right to recognition by the state or affiliation to the university, but since recognr and affilition are indispensable for affectective and fruitful exercise of the funda right of minorities to establish and adri,,nister educational institutions of their choice, they are entitled to recognition and affiliation if they agree to accept and comply with regulatory measures which are relevant for granting recognition and affiliation, which are directed to ensuring educational excellence of the institution concerned and which largely and substantially, leave unimpaired the right of administration in regard to internal affairs of the institution."
Fazal am, j. , on an exhaustive analysis of the case law summarised the principles and propositions, as under:
"1. Article 30 (1) enshrines a fundamental right of the minority institutions to manage and administer their educational institutions which is completely in consonance with the secular nature of democracy and the directives in the constitution itself. 2. Although unlike article 19 the right conferred on the minorities is absolute, unfettered and unconditional but this does not mean that this right gives a free licence for mal - administration so as to defeat the avowed object of the article, namely, to advance excellence and perfection in the field of education. 3. While the state or any other statutory authority has no right to interfere with the internal administration or management of the minority institution, the state can take regulatory measures to promote the efficiency and excellence of educational standards and issue guidelines for the purpose of ensuring the security of the services of the teachers or other employees of the institution. 4. At the same time, the state or any university authority cannot under the cover or garb of adopting regulatory measures tend to destroy the administrative autonomy of the institution or start interfering whilly nilly with the core of the management of the institution so as to render the right of the administration of the management of the institution concerned nugatory or illusory. Such a blatant interference is violative of article 30 (1) an iuld be wholly inapplicable to the insti n concerned. 5. ,. Icle 30 by its vary nature implies that where an affiliation is asked for, the university concerned cannot refuse the same without sufficient reason or try to impose such conditions as would completely destroy the autonomous administration of the educational institution"
.
In st. Xviers college vs state of gujarat (12) a i r 1974sc 1389 it was held :
"the entire controversy centres round the extent of the right of the religious and linguistic minorities to administer their educational institutions. The right to administer is said to consist of four principal matters. First is the right to. Choose its managing or governing body it is said that the founders of the minority, institution have faith and confidence in their own committee or body consisting of persons selected by them. Second is the right to choose its teachers. It is said that minority institutions want teachers to have compatibility with the ideals, aims and aspirations of the institution. Third is the right not to be compelled to refuse admission to students in other words, the minority institutions want to have the right to admit students of their choice subject to reasonable regulations about academic qualifications. Fourth is the right to use its properties and assets for the benefit of its own institution"
Further held:
"we may now deal with the scope and ambit of the right guaranted by clause (1) of article 30. The clause confers a right on all minorities, whether they are based on religion, or language to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The right conferred by the clause is in absolute terms and is not subject to restrictions, as in the case of rights conferred by article 19 of the constitution the right of the minorities to administer educational institutions does not however prevent the making of reasonable regulations in respect of those institutions. The regulations have necessarily to be made in the interest of the institution as a minority educational institution. They have to be so designed as to make it an effective vehicle for imparting education. The right to administer educational institutions can plainly not include the right to maladminister. Regulations can be made to prevent the housing of an educational institution in unhealthy surroundings as also to prevent the setting up or continuation of an educational institution without qualified teachers. The state can prescribe regulations to ensure the excellence of the institution. Prescription of standards for educational institutions does rot militate against the right of the minority to administer the institutions. Regulations made in the true interests of efficiency of instruction discipline health sanitation morality public order and the like may undoubtedly be imposed such regulations are not restrictions on the substance of the right which is guaranteed they secure the proper functioning of the institution in matters educational (see observations of shah j in rev. Sidhar jabhai sabhai (1963) 3 scr 837 at p. 850= (air 1963 sc 540) (supra). Further as observed by hidayatullah c. J in the case of very rev. Mother provincial (suprd) the standards concern the body politic and are dictated by considerations of tho advancement of the country and its people. Therefore , if universities establish syllabi for examinations they must be followed subject however to special subjects which the institutions may seek to teach and to a certain extent the state may also regulate tha conditions of employment of teachers and the health and hygiene of students. Such regulations do not bear directly upon management as such although they may indirectly affect it. Yet the right of the state to regulate education educational standards and allied matters cannot be denied. The minority institutions cannot be allowed to fall below the standards of excellence expected of educational institutions or under the guise of exclusive right of management to decline to follow the general pattern. While the management must be left to them, they may be compelled to keep in step with others'"
In g. F. College, shahjahanpur v. Agra university (10) air. 1975 s. C. 1821, the supreme court, after referring to the following observations viz. , "the right of a linguistic or religious minority to administer educational institutions of their choice, though couched in absolute terms had been held by this court to be subject to regulation measures which the state might impose for furthering the excellence of the standards of education. ' (mr, justice jaganmohan reddy in st. Xaviers college v. State of gujarat (air 1974 s. C. 1389) and.
"it is an illusion for a minority to claim absolute immunity. The thrust of the case is that real regulations are desirable, necessary and constitutional but, when they operate on the 'administration' part of the right, must be confined to chiselling into shape, not cutting down out of shape, the individual personality of minority"
(tier beg and dwivedi jj) , further held :
"the discussion throws us back to a closer study of statute 14 - a to see if it cuts into the flesh of the managements' right or merely tones up its health and habits. The two requirements the university asks for are that the managing body (whatever its name) must take in (a) the principal of the college; (b) its senior most teacher. Is this desideratum dismissible as biting into the autonomy of management or tenable as ensuring the excellence of the institution without injuring the essence of the right? on a careful reflection and conscious of the constitutional dilemma, we are inclined to the view that this case falls on the valid side of the delicate line. Regulation which resticts is bad; but regulation which facilitates is good. Where does this fine distinction lie? no rigid formula is possible but a flexible test is feasible. Where the object and effect is to improve the tone and temper of the administration without forcing on it a stranger, however, superb his virtues be, where the directive is not to restructure the governing body but to better its performance by a marginal catalytic induction, where no external authority's fiat or approval or outside nominee is made compulsory to validate the management board but inclusion of an internal key functionary appointed by the autonomous management alone is asked for, the provision is salutary and saved, being not a diktat eroding the freedom of the freedom."
(37) Director of s. E. T. N. Govt. V. G. Arogiasamy (11) air 1971 madras 441, in this case, admissions to basic and non - basic training schools was sought to be controlled by the government by amending the previous order to the effect that the list of candidates to be admitted by the aided, including the minority institutions will be subject to final approval of a committee constituted by the government comprising the chief educational officer and a non - official member. This was challenged as making inroads into the rights of the minorities to run their institution. On that, the court held: "what is the effect of the impugned order? in our opinion, it places serious restrictions on the freedom of the minority institutions to make admissions of students according to their choice. It throws the students of the minority community into a competition with the generality of students belonging to that and all other communities. The applications for admission to any institution cannot be restricted to a particular community because of articles 15 (1) and 29 (2). The result is the students of the roman catholic community, which is said to represent less than ten per cent of the total population, when in competition with students of the other communities who have all applied for admission, obviously will have but slender chances of admission contrary to the protection afforded by article 30 (1) , it is true the impugned order is conceived in public interest to ensure proper standards in the matter of admission to basic and non - basic training schools. That is good by itself. But when applied to a minority institution, its effect is not to its benefit from its own point of view. Thai is forbidden by article 30 (1)
(38) The learned counsel also referred to the decisions in lillykurian v. S r. Lewina (13) a i r. 1979 s c 53 and indulal hiralal shah vs. S s salgaonker, (14) air 1983 bom 193. On the above conspectus, the emerging principles are :
1) right to administer a minority institution cannot obviously include the right to mal - administer; 2) stands of education are not part of manegemint as such; 3) minority institutions cannot be permitted to fall below the standard of excellence expected of educational institutions and the right of the state to regulate education, educational standards and the allied matters cannot be denied; 4) no institution, minority or majority, has a fundamental right to recognition by the state or affiliation to the university; but since they are indispensable, they are entitled to recognition and affiliation, if they agree to accept and comply with regulatory measures, provided they are directed to ensuring educational excellence of the institution, without impairing the right of administration in regard to the internal affairs of the institution, 5) the right of a minority institution to admit students of their choice is subject to reasonable regulations about academic qualifications. 6) regulations made in the interest of efficiency of institution, discipline, health, sanitation, morality, public order and the like, may undoubtedly be imposed. Such regulations are not restrictions on the substance of the right which ie guaranteed.
(39) Bearing in mind the above, if we examine the impact of the provisions enacted in sections 3 and 4 of the act, which have been already analysed, we have no hesitation in concluding that the mode of common entrance test for the! purpose of admission of students to all the colleges in the state, including the mino - rity institution, is not only proper but even essential in the circumstances, the object being sustenance of standards of excellence in the institutions imparting education in 'professional courses'. This mode of common entrance test has been upheld as proper and feasible measure by this court as well as by the supreme court. Further, the provisions under section 4 do not in any way forbid the management from admitting students belonging to the minority community to which it belongs on the contrary, sec - r tion 4, as is conspicuous, it a provision which is special and singular as well. Enabling the minority institutions to admit of course, within contours laid down by the act and the rules prescribed thereunder, which neither restrains nor curtails their liberty to manage internal affairs.
(40) Hence in our judgment, the provisions enacted both in section 3 as well as section 4. Do not constitute restrictions; they are permissible measures of regulation, and so, are perfectly legal and constitutional.
(41) The other contentions and counter contentions, viz. ,
1) section 3 of the act totally takes away the right of admissions thereby causing complete eclipse of the powers of the management and thus imposing unreasonable restriction on the fundamental right of the petitioners: 2) section 5, which abolishes capitation fee, is annihilative of the very basis of the institution as it is one of the chief sources of collecting funds from the admittees which is not at all unhealthy practice and so. Deprives the management of its fundamental right to run the educational institutions. 3) section 6 of the act imposes unreasonable restriction on the collection of donations when it purports to lay down the manner of collection of the same delegating to the rule making authority, to prescribe the mode and method and therefore, the provision which is oppressive, should be struck down. 4) section? empowers the government to regulate the tuition fee by way of a noification without giving any guidelines what soever and therefore, is arbitrary apart from being unreasonable. 5) sections 8 to 10 are penal in nature, which confer excessive powers on the government to take over the management in case the institutions contravene the provisions of the act. 6.) section 11 is highly arbitrary and excessive as it empowers any gazetted office'r, authorised by the government to enter at any time during the normal working hours of an educational institution, to search and inspect any record and to seize the. Same only for the purpose of ascertaining whether there is or has been any contravention of the provisions, irrespective of the fact whether the said officer had any reason, information or suspicion or not, and therefore, the provision must be struck down as draconion. 7) the government having permitted the institutions to run the same by collecting the capitation fee, is estopped from enforcing the abolition of capitation fee by enacting the impugned act. Under article 19 (1) (g) of4he constitution the private institution has every right to carry on its business or occupation either by collecting capitation fee or by collecting donations or by both, and the government seeking to prevent the same by legislation, is imposing unreasonable restriction falling outside the ganut of article 19 (6) of the constitution. 8) the provisions of the act impose complete embargo on the management of the institution and so, destroy the very existence of the private institutions which curtails liberty resulting in deprivation of personal liberty, in contravention of article 21 of the constitution. 9) the collection of capitation fee from the willing students for admittance to the institution, cannot be reckoned as an evil equating either with the act of illicit manufacture of liquor, or immoral trafficking and so on, so as to constitute reasonable constriction. , have also been raised in w. P. No. 3492/83 and batch and so, our adjudication on those will hold good herein as well.
(42) In the result, the writ petition is dismissed. No costs. Advocate's fee rs. 250/ -.