AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, (Act VI of 1957),
  • provisions of section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, (Act VI of 1957),
  • provisions of section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion (Order pronounced by Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are hotel proprietors running three establishments in Vijayawada (Welcome Hotel at Gandhinagar, Welcome Hotel at Samarangam chowk, and Welcome Coffee Club at Gandhinagar). They filed the petition challenging actions of officers of the Sales Tax Department (Special Evasions circle) who, according to the petitioners, conducted a continuous and intensive supervision of the hotels' business operations.

The petitioners alleged that on 22-11-1960 respondents visited early in the morning, went through rooms including kitchens, placed officers at the cashier's counter for prolonged periods, questioned customers about items consumed, recorded bill amounts, retained bills until closing time, prepared statements of daily bills, and coerced cashiers/accountants to sign those statements. The petitioners also alleged earlier incidents of similar "shop watch" in 1958 and extended periods in 1959, and that they were not furnished copies of statements signed by their representatives.

In their counter, the Special Commercial Tax Officer (Evasions), Vijayawada, admitted that sales were intensively watched on 22-11-1960 pursuant to a programme issued by the Special A.C.T.O. (E) for shop watch. The counter denied coercion in obtaining signatures, asserting the statements were given voluntarily, and explained the shop watch was undertaken under the authority of section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act to determine correct turnover; it described the manner and timing of watch (admitting watches from about 4:30 A.M. to 10 P.M. in relays).

The Sales Tax Department also referred to disputed assessments and alleged suppression of sales, with one assessment enhanced and another pending finalisation after cross-check verification.

The petition sought issuance of writ(s) (mandamus or other appropriate relief) directing respondents to forbear from continuous supervision of the petitioners' hotel businesses. The Court heard the matter and allowed the petition, making no order as to costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Sales Tax Authorities are justified, under the provisions of section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act (Act VI of 1957), to keep a continuous watch on the petitioners' hotels and to supervise their business operations throughout the day for several days.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contended that section 28(2) authorises inspection of accounts, registers and documents and of "the goods in his possession" and of offices, shops or godowns — but that this authorisation is limited to inspection and does not permit continuous surveillance or "watch" of business activities.
  • They alleged the Sales Tax officers engaged in continual surveillance (including early-morning visits, constant presence at counters, questioning customers, retaining bills, preparing statements and coercing signatures), which interfered with their business, caused harassment and loss, and was repeated across several dates in 1958, 1959 and again in 1960.
  • They sought writ relief (mandamus or other) to restrain respondents from such continuous supervision of the hotels.

Respondents' (Sales Tax Department / Government) Arguments

  • The Special Commercial Tax Officer admitted an intensive "shop watch" took place on 22-11-1960 pursuant to an internal programme for shop watch issued by the Special A.C.T.O. (E).
  • The Department maintained that the shop watch was authorised by section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act and was undertaken to obtain an accurate assessment of turnover (alleging suppression of sales and purchases by the dealer in audits of 1958–59 and 1959–60).
  • The respondents denied allegations of coercion and of creating a scene; they stated that statements by cashiers were given voluntarily after verification of cash, and they denied the specific factual details of coercion and of the exact procedures alleged by the petitioners (for example, that an inspector took bills and read them aloud while others noted amounts).
  • The Department described the shop watch practice as involving visits at different days and seasons, sometimes for a whole day, sometimes part, and asserted that the results of such shop watches had been effective in revealing higher turnover in hotels.
  • It was admitted that watch activity involved personnel remaining at the counter and that watch periods extended from early morning (the counter claims 4:30 A.M.) until closing (10 P.M.), with officers working in relays.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed the decisive question as whether section 28(2) authorised the Sales Tax Authorities to keep a continuous watch and supervise the petitioners' hotel businesses.

The Court analysed the statute's language. Section 28(2) reads (quoted in the opinion): “All accounts, registers and other documents maintained by a dealer in the course of his business the goods in his possession, and his offices, shops, godowns, vessels or vehicles shall be open for inspection at all reasonable times by such officer.”

The Court rejected the petitioners' narrow reading that the provision authorised inspection only of goods in the dealer's possession. The Court observed that the statute uses the conjunction "and" (not "or") and therefore authorises inspection of both documents/goods and of the offices/shops/godowns themselves. The Court concluded inspection of premises is independent of inspection of goods and that the legislature intended power to inspect the premises (offices, shops, godowns, vessels, vehicles) apart from the goods.

However, the Court also rejected the Government Pleader's argument that "inspection" equates to continuous "watch" throughout the entire day. The Court focused on two textual and semantic points:

  • Temporal limitation: The statutory phrase "at all reasonable times" implies inspections at reasonable times (related to the nature of the business and working hours) and does not authorise a continuous process of surveillance from opening to closing every day. The Court reasoned that "reasonable times" must relate to the character and working hours of the business and permit inspections for periods convenient in the circumstances, rather than perpetual observation.
  • Conceptual distinction: The Court distinguished the concepts of "inspection" and "watch." By reference to dictionary meanings (as quoted), "inspection" involves careful scrutiny or close examination, while "watch" implies constant observation or vigilance. The Court held that the admitted conduct of the respondents — continual and close observation for extended periods (from about 4:30 A.M. to 10 P.M. and over several days) and in relays — amounted to surveillance and harassment, not mere inspection.

Applying these principles to the factual record, the Court found that the Sales Tax officers had, on their own admission, engaged in continual surveillance of the hotels for extended periods and that almost all the petitioners' factual allegations about the intensity and duration of the watch were accepted by the respondents (except in respect of coercion in obtaining signatures and alleged disturbance). The Court concluded that while the Department has the right to enter and inspect kitchens and other branches during reasonable times, it does not have a statutory licence to keep a continuous watch of the hotel business from early morning till night for several days.

Holding and Implications

PETITION ALLOWED

Holding: The Court allowed the petition and restrained the Sales Tax Authorities from keeping a continuous, day-long watch or exercising continuous supervision over the petitioners' hotel businesses as described in the petition. The Court clarified that inspections at reasonable times related to the nature and working hours of the business are permissible, but continual surveillance as admitted in this case is not authorised by section 28(2).

Direct consequences for the parties: The respondents are not permitted to continue the intensive, continuous surveillance practice in the manner found by the Court. The Court expressly allowed the petition and made no order as to costs.

Broader implications: The opinion confines itself to statutory interpretation of section 28(2) and the facts of the case; it does not spell out any extended precedent beyond the immediate ruling. The text does not claim to establish any new general legal doctrine beyond its reading of the statute and the distinction between inspection and continual surveillance.

End of summary — based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion.

    P. Lakshman Rao & Sons v. Ebnazer, Special Commercial Tax Officer, (Evasion), Vijayawada & Others

    (Order of the Court pronounced by Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)

    1. This petition is directed against the action of the Sales Tax Department in keeping a continuous watch over the business of the hotels of the petitioner. The petitioners who are carrying on business of running hotels in the town of Vijayawada complain that the respondents who belong to the Special Evasions circle of the Sales Tax Department embarked upon a whole time super-vision of the actual business activity of the hotel. It is said that the respondents 3 to 5 visited the hotels in the early hours of the morning on 22-11-1960 and went round all the rooms in the hotel including the kitchen and directed two of the respondents to sit at the counter by the side of the cashier while the other respondents were going round all the rooms and keeping watch and enquiring about the articles of food supplied to the customers) that when the customers came to pay the bill, one of the respondents takes the bill, inquires the customer what articles were consumed by him and then reads out the bill and directs the other to note down the amount of the bill on a paper, and that thereafter the respondents would keep the bill in their custody till the close of the day. This process would continue until the closure of the hotel at 10 P.M After the end of the day, the respondents would prepare a statement of the amounts of the bills and would coerce the cashier or the accountant whoever is at the counter to sign the statement, threatening and intimidating them, in spite of protests by them. It was further stated that, while the customers were taking tiffin or meals, the respondents also keep going round the rooms inquiring the customers as to what menu they were being supplied. The petitioners contend that, in spite of portests in 1958, be came procedure was continued in 1959 from 11-4-1959 to 17-4-1959 and from 27-4-1959 to 7-5-1959, and that the statements signed by the representatives of the petitioners were got signed by them and were taken away and they would not even furnish copies thereof to them. It is stated that just before the filing of the petition the respondents have again started this method of supervision by visiting at 5 A.M and sitting the whole day. In the circumstances, it is prayed that a writ of mandamus, or any other appropriate writ, direction or order be issued to the respondents to forbear from carrying on the continuous supervision of the sales and supplies or other business activities of the petitioners in the three hotels, viz., Welcome Hotel at Gandhinagar, Welcome Hotel at Samarangam chowk and Welcome Coffee Club at Gandhinagar, Vijayawada town.

    2. In the counter filed by the Special Commercial Tax Officer (Evasions) Vijayawada, it was admitted that the sales of these hotels were ‘intensively’ watched on 22-11-1960 by the Inspectors named therein in obedience to the programme issued by the Special A.C.T.O (E) for shop Watch, Sri J.B Rajarao.

    3. It is stated that the turnover returned by the dealer for 1958-59 was not accepted and the assessment was enhanced, and similarly suppression by way of not accounting certain purchases was noticed for the year 1959-60, during cross check verification and the assessment for the year is pending finalisation. It was stated that the dealer suppressed his sales during the days of shop watch, by reducing the preparations and canvassing against customers entering the hotel, and that if this was taken into consideration the turnover of the dealer would be far more than the sales noticed during the shop watch. It is contended that this intensive watch or shop watch was undertaken “in consonance with the provisions of section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act and in order to have effective watch over sales in hotels, shops etc., watch the sales in them with a view to arrive at the correct turnover of the dealers. The present practice is to watch the sales of the shops and hotels during different days and in different seasons, sometimes for the whole day and at other times for a part of a day. The results achieved so far as a result of shop watch in respect of Hotels are spectacularly high when compared with the sales that were being recorded by the dealers.” Again it is stated that respondents 3 to 5 who were allotted to Welcome Hotel started watching the shop at 4-30 A.M and not from 5 A.M as stated in the affidavit of the petitioners, and that as the watch of the hotels have to be conducted from 5 A.M to 10 P.M (i.e for a Continuous period of 17 hours in a day,) only two of them watched the hotel and adjusted their timings according to their convenience and allowed one man to go out for food, coffee and to take rest. It is, therefore, seen that virtually two of the C.T, Inspectors were watching the shop through cut she day. With respect to the allegation that the C.T Inspectors remained at the counter, the deponent admitted the C.T Inspectors remained at the counter, but stated that they caused no hindrance to the customers. But the allegation that the C.T Inspector takes the bill, enquires the customers as to what articles they have consumed and then reads out the bills and directs the other to note down the amount of the bill on a paper, has been denied. So was the allegation that the statements were taken from the petitioners forcibly. It was contended that these statements were given voluntarily by the petitioners. To quote the words in the counter, “In the present instance, the C.T Inspectors obtained a statement from the cashiers of all the four hotels who were managing the hotels at that time in their own hand duly appending their signature voluntarily after verification of the cash. The version of the petitioner that the respondents prepared a statement of the amount of the bills and coerced the cashier or accountant to sign the statement in spite of protests by them in their own hand is not correct.” The respondents also denied the allegation that their shop watch interfered with the business or that it created a scene.

    4. It is clear from the affidavit of the petitioners and the counter that the respondent-officers of the Sales Tax Department, were keeping a continual, intensive watch over these hotels for several days, that this watch continued from 4— 30 in the morning to 10 in the night and was undertaken in relays by the respondents. Almost all the allegations made in the petition were accepted except those relating to the statements of the petitioners being taken under coercion or threat and the allegation that their inspection caused a scene or disturbance in the conduct of the business. The Sale Tax Officer also claimed relief to superivse the business of the hotels.

    5. The short question which falls for determination is, whether the Sales Tax Authorities are justified under the provisions of section 28(2) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, (Act VI of 1957), to keep a continuous watch on the hotels of the petitioners, and to super vise the same. Section 28(2) is in the following terms:—

    “All accounts, registers and other documents maintained by a dealer in the course of his business the goods in his possession, and his offices, shops, godowns, vessels or vehicles shall be open for inspection at all reasonable times by such officer.”

    6. It is contended on behalf of the petitioners that this Section merely authorises the Sales Tax Authorities to inspect all accounts, registers and documents maintained by the dealer in the course of his business and the goods in his possession his offices shops or godowns; and secondly they are only authorised to inspect and not to keep watch. The Government Pleader, however, submits that the Department is entitled to inspect not merely the goods in the offices, shops and godowns but the offices, shops and godowns them selves, and to observe the manner in which business is being conducted provided the same is done at a reasonable time during the day, and that what was in fact done by the Sales Tax authorities was only an inspection and nothing more. It appears to us that the first contention of the learned advocate for the petitioners that the section merely authorises the inspection of the goods in possession of the dealer or in his offices, Shops and godowns is untenable because the word used is not “or” but “and”. Consequently, not only have the Sales-Tax authorities power to inspect all accounts and registers and other documents and goods in the possession of the dealer, but also inspect his offices, shops, godowns, vessels and vehicles. The inspection of offices, shops, and godowns etc. is quite independent from the inspection of goods in his possession. The goods in his offices, shops and godowns are certainly goods in his possesssion and if the legislature merely wanted to confine the inspection only to the inspection of goods, there was no necessity to indicate inspection of offices, shops and godowns, nor would the addition of vessels or vehicles relevant in the contest of the contention of the learned Advocate. What was intended was to give power to inspect offices, shops, godowns vessels and vehicles apart from the goods in the possession of the dealer. We have no hesitation in rejecting that contention of the learned advocate. But at the same time we cannot accepet the contention of the learned Government Pleader that there is no difference between inspection and keeping a watch, and that the section authorises the continuous watching of the business on the premisses of the dealer from the time the business commences to the time it ends. Apart from the question that the words “inspection” and “watch” connote different meanings, the words” at all reasonable times”, would indicate not a continuous process throughout the entire day, but only at certain times which, in the circumstances of the particular case, are reasonable. The antithesis of reasonable time would be unreasonable time. So that, if “at all reasonable times” comprehends the period from 4-30 in the morning to 10 in the night, the unreasonable time would only be confined to the period between 10 P.M and 4-30 P.M when the establishment is closed. To our mind “reasonable time, must have some relation to the nature of the business, and to the time of the day in relation to the working hours, as to enable an inspection to be made for such pried or periods during the day conveniently as the circumstances will permit.

    7. Secondly, the words ‘inspection’ and ‘watch’ connote two different meanings. A reference to the Oxford dictionary would show that “inspection” means the action of inspecting; looking narrowly into, careful scrutiny or survey, close or criticl examination; while “watch” would indicate that it is an alert state, being on the look out, vigilant, constant observation, attention to what may come, “inspection” and “watch” connote two different ideas. A scrutiny for the purpose of inspection may require a reasonable or sufficient time, while a watch would indicate a constant observation irrespective of the time required for careful scrutiny of the particular object to be achieved. What the Sales Tax authorities had undertaken, on their own admission, is not an inspection, but a continual and close watch, as would amount to survelliance and harassment of the hotels. It is not denied that the Sales Tax authorities have every right to go into the kitchen and other branches of the hotel and inspect the same at reasonable time or times, but not to be continually watching the hotel and its business from the moment it starts early morning till the whole day for several days. If this course of conduct is permitted, it would seriously interfere with the business of the petitioners and is calculated to cause them loss. The Department has every right to visit the premises for such period or periods as the circumstances would permit during the day but not to keep a continual watch as is being done or to exercise supervision over their business.

    8. We accordingly allow the petition with the aforesaid directions but, in the circumstances make no order as to coats.

    9. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Lakshman Rao & Sons v. Ebnazer, Special Commercial Tax Officer, (Evasion), Vijayawada & Others
    (Oct 31, 1961)